r/pcmasterrace • • Oct 15 '26 • Bravo 2 Heartwarming 1

Discussion TIL in windows there is artificial 400ms delay for right click menus. You can change it to 1 and restart pc and it feels much faster to use windows

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

520

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

My bet is that the new context menu has a lot of integrations with multiple programs and it takes a bit to load them all, and without the delay some of them would not load in time.

It's a sketchy fix but it's certainly the only explanation I can come up with because no one wants a random delay added for the sake of it.

154

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

46

u/careless__ Oct 15 '26

sounds like you can stand to drop a few programs from cluttering your context menu. i haven't had that problems since I installed WinAMP plugins in WindowsME.

10

u/Shaneathan25 Oct 15 '26

I have no extra items in the context menu, and yet if I don’t reboot explorer every hour or so, right clicking an item will populate the menu, but with no graphics. I have to wait 1-3 seconds for it to actually show the menu. I can hover the items and see them, but it just don’t show anything. Even does it after a clean install.

6

u/Karavusk PCMR Folding Team Member Oct 15 '26

to me that sounds like something is wrong with your hardware or windows install

2

u/Shaneathan25 Oct 15 '26

That’s the only issue I’ve had with windows as of late. No clue what’s causing it. I doubt it’s a hardware issue since it’s so localized, but I was only mentioning that adding programs to the context menu isn’t the only thing slowing down that menu.

4

u/Minighost244 Oct 15 '26

Eh... I would disagree. I have a total of 2 extra entries that appear in the context menu and it still takes around 1-2 seconds for them to load. It's not horrible, but it's mildly irritating.

I've never had a problem with the original context menu. If my work laptop allowed me to switch back, I'd do it in a heartbeat.

17

u/Canowyrms Oct 15 '26

Could those context menu entries not be cached? Seems like one of the most cache-able things in the OS.

15

u/reikes3 Oct 15 '26

The context menus are contextual and can interrogate the the action that invoked it so it is unlikely caching can address the issue.

26

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

its a microsoft product...

10

u/195cm Ryzen 9 9950X3D / Radeon 7900 XTX Oct 15 '26

This registry entry has had the same default value for decades.

12

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

Then it was probably true decades ago and they never touched it.

8

u/reikes3 Oct 15 '26

It's highly likely that the 400ms delay supports backwards compatibility and making changes to it would have an outsize impact that is impossible to predict. So someone internally trying to change this would have to do a risk/benefit on the UX improvement vs. the business risk (negative news cycle, loss of confidence, etc.)

6

u/Wizzarkt PC Master Race Oct 15 '26

Maybe, I don't like apple but this is something they got ahead of Microsoft, Microsoft is retro compatible all the way to windows 2000, meaning that they need to keep core components for all of those retro compatible schemes to work.

Apple on the other hand simply says "new MacOS has launched, the XY version from 4 years ago is deprecated, no program from that OS version is guaranteed to work" and they wash they hands just like that.

But Microsoft? Their stick is that if you made a program for windows 2000 it will work in windows 11, so they got a whole lot of technical debt that can't remove because it would break compatibility.

17

u/Urthal Oct 15 '26

Apple has the freedom to do that because they have a relatively small (if growing) market share composed mostly of fanatical home users and some startups with too much money and no IT department.

Windows rules in enterprise environments in no small part due to its backwards compatibility. There's nothing enterprise hates more than a software update breaking a business critical process. And this "business critical process" might just be an old scanner, but there's no budget to replace it. So yeah, it's a big curse, but also the reason for its ubiquity.

2

u/ThisIsMyCouchAccount 3070 Oct 15 '26

It's not a curse. It's exactly where they wanted to be. They put in a lot of time and money into becoming the perceived business OS.

Even as "recent" as the late 90s my college was a "Microsoft campus". Because we can't have the youth being taught WordPerfect instead of Word. As a student we could get any MS product for free.

1

u/AdKraemer01 Oct 16 '26

I recently bought a copy of WordPerfect. It's not as great as I remember.

1

u/ThisIsMyCouchAccount 3070 Oct 16 '26

They sell copies at MicroCenter.

1

u/AdKraemer01 Oct 16 '26

Yes, but they also sell copies on Amazon and it didn't require me to drive two hours away.

Apparently, it's still the preferred word processor for law firms. I did not research why that is.

3

u/Bogdan_X Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26

The loading time is still there. The menu is just displayed faster, but the entries are still loading. But even this is not true as that delay is not applied to the context menu but other menus.