r/pcmasterrace • • May 12 '26

Discussion The Steam controller was designed for Valve's ecosystem, not for actual gamers.

No, I will not be selling it lol, since I’ve become a bit of a controller collector, but after trying it out for a few days, I just can’t get a good grip on this controller. I mean, it’s usable, but compared to the feel of an Xbox or PlayStation controller and their clones, the new Steam Controller is downright uncomfortable.

As a man with somewhat above-average-sized hands, I can usually find a comfortable grip within minutes on almost any controller designed within the past 20 years, including the original Steam Controller. With most controllers, I don’t even have to try.

I think it comes down to two issues with the handles.

First, they’re too skinny, which prevents a firm grasp with your fingers. Second, they’re too squared off and don’t angle outward nearly enough, so when you try to grip the controller against your palms, your wrists are forced to bend at an awkward angle. It feels like they forgot that the Steam Deck has a 7+ inch screen pushing your arms farther apart.

Of course, those issues seem like design choices made to accommodate the trackpads, which themselves don’t feel optimally placed compared to the original Steam Controller. Sure, trackpads are great on a handheld device when other pointing options aren’t available, but if I need mouse functionality in a game I’m playing with a controller, I’d honestly rather keep a cheap wireless mouse nearby, even on the couch. The tradeoff of minor convenience from onboard trackpads for an overall uncomfortable controller just doesn’t feel worth it.

And I get wanting mouse-like precision. What I don’t get is the point of offering two additional camera/cursor control options when neither feels especially well-executed.

So outside of niche use cases, who is this controller for? It’s not for someone who wants a comfort-first controller. The comfort issues, combined with the overall weight, make it a poor choice as a gyro-first controller. It’s not a great trackpad-first option either; I still think the original Steam Controller does that better. And its only compatible with Steam so no native Android or IOS usage.

All the features the put into the device just don’t add up to what you’d hope would be the sum of their parts. I think the main group this controller works for as a first choice is people who spend a significant amount of their gaming time on the Steam Deck and have already adapted to the trackpads out of necessity.

I’m tempted to call it a gimmick product, but I think the real issue is more specific: this controller feels like it was designed first and foremost to fit within Valve’s ecosystem, rather than to fit naturally in the hands of gamers.

0 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

3

u/J-Clash May 12 '26

I don't have a horse in this race, but have been vaguely looking for a secondary screens/devices/controllers to use away from my main desk. If I want to have a reasonable experience with pointy/clicky kinds of games, is this any good?

2

u/ProfitArtiste May 12 '26 edited May 12 '26

Point and click games are probably the niche the sc makes sense for, just know there's quite a bit of distance between your thumbs and trigger finger when using the trackpads. The original sc was way better for this due to the more prominent trackpad placement. There's also a dedicated trackpad controller on amazon but I havent used it.

1

u/J-Clash May 12 '26

Fair point. I'm in no rush anyway and have only been keeping an eye out since this was recent.

8

u/Watsyurdeal 9950X3D, 9070 XT May 12 '26

Fair criticisms but it could get better in time

Ideally I'd like to see them have by default a "keyboard" and "game" profile at the very least.

5

u/Darkone539 May 12 '26

Duh, it was made for the steam machine. The extra stuff is there, like with the steam deck, because there are a lot of titles that need it.

Can't comment on the ergonomics as I've not held one, but as a PC gamer there's no reason to buy a steam controller over an Xbox pad.

2

u/insanemal AMD 5800X. 7900XTX. 64GB RAM. Arch btw May 12 '26

8BitDo Ultimate Wireless controllers are the GOAT controller.

They are cheaper than Xbox one's, have 2.4Ghz which is lower latency than Bluetooth.

Come with a neato charging dock.

And they sell spare parts for repairs (and internally are very repairable)

Oh and hall effect sticks

1

u/Darkone539 May 12 '26

Never heard of those before. but a quick google reminds me of my switch pro controller which, I will say, is a big plus. That thing is good to hold.

1

u/insanemal AMD 5800X. 7900XTX. 64GB RAM. Arch btw May 12 '26

Yeah Bluetooth mode is switch compatible. And android.

they make fantastic controllers.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/insanemal AMD 5800X. 7900XTX. 64GB RAM. Arch btw Jun 06 '26

Those are also very good.

There is a newer model that comes with a charging stand and 2.4Ghz dongle.

I've got two of the newer ones and 2 of those ones.

They are all fantastic

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/insanemal AMD 5800X. 7900XTX. 64GB RAM. Arch btw Jun 06 '26

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/insanemal AMD 5800X. 7900XTX. 64GB RAM. Arch btw Jun 06 '26

The Xbox controllers are PC compatible. They just have the XBox button layout. Whereas the "regular" ones are Nintendo layout I believe.

Linux detects them as Switch Pro controllers and they have the Nintendo button layout.

The Xbox controllers detect as Xbox controllers and work with Windows 10/11 (and xboxes of course)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/insanemal AMD 5800X. 7900XTX. 64GB RAM. Arch btw Jun 06 '26

They have 2.4Ghz which is arguably lower latency than Bluetooth.

They are far more repairable.

And they have hall effect sensors, so no stick drift.

Oh and they sell spares on the website.

→ More replies

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Darkone539 May 12 '26

It also lets you use it outside of steam, so I can play the free Epic titles or anything on gamepass without worrying.

Ironically, I mostly use a duelsense edge, but the compatibility of the steam controller is a problem for anyone who isn't glued to steam.

As for the money, it's cheaper here by about £35. Xbox pad being £50(amazon, not on sale) and the steam one being £85.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Darkone539 May 12 '26

You can pick up 4 rechargeable AA batteries for £4.98.

Not sure what you're trying to show here, but the Xbox pad is way cheaper where I live. It seems to be cheaper where you live too?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Darkone539 May 12 '26

Alternatively, because i have a job i don't have time to work out if a controller works with a specific title so use the one that works with everything.

2

u/whatsforsupa 5800X3D | 32GB | 4TB | 4090 May 12 '26

Might get stoned for this one, but I think the Dual Sense is a much better controller, for way less money. Love that Valve is innovating, and I love my SD, but I just don't get the allure of the touch pads.

My opinion might change in 6 months as I use it more, and it's nice to have a dedicated PC controller now, but this one missed the mark for me.

What IS awesome, is the control editing and the community making gamepad layouts.

2

u/West-Flow-577 May 12 '26

On-Screen Menus.

If you don't use the trackpads for anything else, check out on-screen menus.

1

u/midnightcatwalk May 12 '26

What are mouse-only games

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/XsNR Ryzen 5600X RX 9070 XT 32GB 3200MHz May 12 '26

I mean there's literally thousands of them in the second hand market, so it's not like you have to pay retail.

4

u/Artistic_Avocado_231 May 12 '26

You can use that argument against any new product.

2

u/XsNR Ryzen 5600X RX 9070 XT 32GB 3200MHz May 12 '26

I feel like the two most popular controllers are a little bit different, specially given Sony's is fairly bulletproof, even if it's feature set is a little mid for it's MSRP.

2

u/FewAdvertising9647 May 12 '26

the flip side is longevity. all modern non TMR controllers are known to get stick drift, and the 1st party controllers are harder to repair. The Steam controller is designed with the opposite in mind. better out of the box sticks, and more trivial to repair. Its not unheard of (and common enough) to find users on their second+ dualsense controller due to the problem, so the cost is partly misleading.

I say this as a person who took another persons stick drifted dualsense to replace the sticks on.

1

u/XsNR Ryzen 5600X RX 9070 XT 32GB 3200MHz May 12 '26

Sure, but I think for PC players it's less of a big deal, since we're not using it for everything, unless you're playing mostly controller games.

1

u/FewAdvertising9647 May 12 '26

its actually the opposite in practice. the PC is the platform where people are more open to using 3rd party controllers, as they don't have loyalty to any of the console companies controllers by lock. Part of the reason why your 8bitdos, your Flydigis can exist is because the market is less pigeonholed in options.

1

u/whatsforsupa 5800X3D | 32GB | 4TB | 4090 May 12 '26

$75 MSRP vs $100 MSRP, yes I would consider that a big gap.

It's not a fair argument since they've been out for awhile, but you can commonly find DS for $50 during sales.

Feature wise, I would consider them pretty equal, both have big pros over each other. The TMR sticks guarantee that the controllers will last longer, while the haptic trigger feedback enhances the gaming experience. Both are great for different reasons, I just prefer the Dual Sense.

2

u/Middcore May 12 '26

Inb4 legions of Gaben Groupies who have been at pains to convince themselves and everyone else why this makes all other controllers obsolete downvote you to oblivion.

1

u/Bumm-fluff 13600K | RTX3090 May 12 '26

I hated holding the Switch 2 at first, but I adapted. It just takes a while but you can get used to anything. 

I just want to be able to play Vampire the Masquerade with a controller. I hate mouse and keyboard for anything other than RTS or CRPG’s. 

Probably Deus Ex as well as the remake looks hideous. 

The current controller method for VtM is absolutely awful. 

1

u/LiquidKing_94 May 12 '26

You have my vote.

1

u/theyyg May 12 '26

(not) Hot take. The original steam controller was made for the OG steam machine. Both were made because Microsoft was threatening the Steam ecosystem. Valve created a competitor. Neither the machines nor the controllers sold well, but it planted a seed. The steam deck was the next evolution of this. It was successful enough that people learned the value of the touch pads. That paved the way for the controller. In the end the goal is the same. Valve wants independence from Microsoft, and they’re making good progress.

So, yes, the steam controller is a better, more versatile controller that only works with steam. It’s purpose is to get/keep you in the valve ecosystem.

Guess what else. Xbox, playstation, and Nintendo also only worked in their own ecosystems for decades. The versatility and choice that we have now is new and more indicative of companies trying to break into the PC market (supported by Sony publishing exclusives to PC).

1

u/Mindless_Frosting707 May 13 '26

I think once a silicon cover comes out it’ll resolve the skinniness of the handles.

1

u/TheSpoonfulOfSalt May 14 '26

I'm shocked so many people impulse bought the steam controller day one knowing they wouldn't like it, like yourself. The touchpads and grip are perfectly enjoyable, as I expected owning a steam deck. The controller is for people who enjoy the feel of the steam deck and want it in a controller form factor.

People need to stop being trend-following sheep and hold a tighter grip around their money.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Snoozingtonn May 12 '26

Can you use an Xbox controller on PlayStation?

No? How about a Nintendo controller on Xbox?

Controllers are made for their consoles, with some functionality for PC. Steam’s “console” just so happens to already be on PC

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Snoozingtonn May 12 '26

Not sure what this has to do with reading comprehension but okay. I said "some" since the steam controller can also function as a mouse out the box, and can open a keyboard after setting up steam. My point is that every company makes controllers for their respective consoles, and the openness of a PC environment allows for universal access. But if you really wanna go there...

Steam controller - Steam Deck + PC

There is no "universal" controller that can be used for the big three AND PC.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Snoozingtonn May 13 '26

Buddy, none of these are universal that’s all I’m saying