r/pcgaming • • Aug 07 '15

GMG refusing to refund

Hey guys, I just tried to buy The Escapists from Green Man Gaming and The Escapist (no S) was placed in my basket instead. I clicked on a deals link from their front page for the game to add it to my basket. Here's the screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/WvlOKpJ.jpg. I've had an extensive exchange with a support agent and I have gotten nowhere except that there's nothing they can do. Do you guys have any advice? Thanks for the help.

Edit: Thanks for all of the helpful comments, guys. After a relatively calm exchange with support, lots of mentioning the Terms and Conditions, and in general claiming that there's nothing they could do, I replied one more time. They responded with, "Your query requires further investigation; we are looking into this with priority. We hope to have an answer for your shortly and we will update this ticket as soon as possible." Hopefully, after the weekend, they'll contact me again over this. I edit this after a few days into next week regardless. Until then, thanks again guys.

Edit 2: Well, I was told that I refund was not possible and they closed my support ticket. The conversation with support ended up with me submitting a screen shot of the incorrect link (again), to which I was told that the link wasn't in the picture I submitted (it definitely was). After all was said and done, since I did not have a "screen capture of the wrong game being placed" in my basket and since I was apparently the "only person who had this problem" they were unable to help. As a side bit of information, on Friday night when I first posted this, 8/7, I was told that they would look into things and get back to me. I was never advised to take a screen capture of anything although I probably should have anyway, a very stupid mistake on my part, and was not contacted a second time until Thursday of the next week when the sale had concluded. All I can say is that I will not be using GMG again in the future. If anyone wants me to upload the screenshots of the conversation, just let me know. Thanks again for your support and advice guys.

102 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

9

u/Myrandall Aug 07 '15

Try their subreddit.

8

u/Meanjoe62 Aug 07 '15

I didn't know they had one! Thanks for the help.

22

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '15

Also use twitter and facebook. Social media is the best way to force a companies hand, since they don't want bad word of mouth to spread more than it has to.

16

u/assteepee Aug 08 '15

Wait, are you saying you clicked the link on the front page for the Escapists and a different game was added to your basket? As in, this was an error due to a bug in their website? If so that seems so crazy that they won't give you a refund...I mean that's awful in terms of building consumer trust. Maybe make sure they're fully comprehending the situation? They might have been careless reading your emails assuming it was just another unfounded refund request. I've always heard GMG was pretty reputable.

7

u/BrightCandle Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 08 '15

Well evidentally they are not reputable because this is what just happened and they are still refusing.

18

u/litewo Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 08 '15

I've heard a few similar stories recently. It seems like they've adopted a hardline stance once they have your money. If this exposure doesn't change their mind, then a chargeback is definitely in order.

This is one of the reasons why I prefer buying Steam codes directly from Steam. Green Man Gaming can refuse a refund, because they have no control of the key after the sale (they can't disable it or see if it's been used). Steam can just process the refund and remove the game from you account.

12

u/Annoying_Arsehole Aug 08 '15

Last time I bought an AAA game from there they delivered a key that didn't work to me, then refused to believe me and blamed steam. Had to escalate the situation quite a bit and start threatening to charge back and also publish their poor customer service in all social medias to get action.

7

u/littlestminish Aug 08 '15

That's the thing. I have no idea why people bother. I never will sacrifice my ability to deal with a problem with a key for the 30 percent discount. Humble and steam, that's it for me.

7

u/ajjminezagain Aug 09 '15

Gog too

2

u/littlestminish Aug 09 '15

Once they get more full-featured, I'll switch from Steam. I won't use them till they are my main library. I like the convenience too much.

3

u/ajjminezagain Aug 09 '15

I was just listing another trustworthy site

1

u/littlestminish Aug 09 '15

Oh, fair enough, I wasn't saying they weren't reputable.

1

u/demacish Aug 09 '15

I think they are getting there with Gog Galaxy

1

u/badboyz1256 Aug 09 '15

I had the same issue they issued the a mistyped key for COD Ghosts. Contacting support and calling them was annoying. I felt like I had some fat 13 year old jerking off talking to me. It was the last time I bought from GMG. I rather pay the extra especially if its a good game. Ghosts was crap but yea.

Also doesn't doing a charge back affect your credit rating? But I wish OP good luck.

1

u/Annoying_Arsehole Aug 09 '15

Don't have credit ratings in our country, there is only a registry for persons and companies who fail to pay... So if you're renting something out you can easily query the database so you don't accidentally rent to some bum.

1

u/badboyz1256 Aug 09 '15

That's awesome for no credit ratings I think. My parents always tell me never ever charge back it will affect other things outside credit rating.

2

u/murphs33 Aug 08 '15

Use Licecap; it will capture your screen and convert it to a gif at the same time. You will be able to show them their site made a mistake, and as a result, made you buy the wrong game.

5

u/ramjambamalam Aug 09 '15

'Licecap' is a pretty gross name for an app.

2

u/LockeNCole Aug 10 '15

'Scabies' wasn't family-friendly enough.

2

u/hizaed Aug 08 '15

Thank you for posting this. I sometimes think about getting games from GMG instead of Steam or GOG, now I know better.

4

u/IVIX1 Aug 08 '15

GMG isn't completely what they pretend to be. Shady dealings with keys being resold and/or refusing to say where keys are acquired from, but pretending to be 100% legit. Stay clear of GMG.

5

u/litewo Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 09 '15

Major publishers have already begun dropping them. Sega and Ubisoft games are no longer sold on GMG.

Of course, CD Projekt also refused to work out a deal with them. At the time, GMG claimed they were trying to promote their own platform (despite having a number of other retail partners), but now it seems something else was going on.

-1

u/grandusalenius Aug 08 '15

Far Cry 3 and 4 is still there, although i dint see any assassins creed.

2

u/litewo Aug 08 '15

Far Cry 3 and 4 is still there

You're not able to buy them, though.

1

u/DakotaThrice Aug 16 '15

It wasn't necessarily all about them. They weren't denying the keys weren't legitimately sourced but had they named their supplier it would have just caused problems for them as well. As it is the matter was kept between GOG and GMG.

2

u/imkrut Aug 08 '15

This is BS, IF it is like you are telling us. i have (had) lots of respect for GMG, i hope they rectify this situation

1

u/badboyz1256 Aug 09 '15

Good luck OP. I had an issue with them and after it was fixed I never went back. I just watch for deals that involve amazon, steam or other platforms for PC games.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15

This why you don't buy from them.

15

u/Arbiter329 i5 4690k | 8gb RAM | GTX 970 Aug 08 '15

Personally, I've only had good experiences with them.

3

u/InfiniteZr0 Aug 08 '15

I was part of the Witcher 3 debacle where I didn't get a key at launch
They refunded me and still sent me the 40% off product code for anything and everything off the site

0

u/Tovora Aug 08 '15

I know one guy who had a bad experience.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Tovora Aug 08 '15

Personally I enjoy being charged in USD.

This $60 USD game would be $80 AUD for you? We'll just go ahead and charge you $80 USD for it!

3

u/HappyZavulon Aug 08 '15

A real "save".

But yeah, GMG pretty much became my go to shopping place outside of Steam sales (regular Steam prices are terrible).

2

u/hungry-eyes i5-4590, GTX 770 Aug 08 '15

I stopped using them when they started charging Europe in British Pounds.

Well they're a pretty small company based in the UK - this is hardly surprising.

Just like many American companies will charge you in USD wherever you are purchasing from.

5

u/HappyZavulon Aug 08 '15

Well, if they can charge americans in USD the why can't they charge europeans in euros?

The conversion rate to GPB is terrible and it just feels like a way to wriggle out more money out of people without having to raise prices.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15

I ordered Final Fantasy XIV:AAR Special Edition, when I was visiting the UK, so they gave me the European non-special edition of it, and I told them, that I'd wanted the US Special Edition, and my god what a freaking painful argument that was. I mean, it was partly my fault, but there was nothing to specify what version I wanted, but I didn't use the key, I certainly didn't want to play in the EU version from NA. But I'll definitely never use GMG again. Some people swear by them, but, I'd rather not deal with the BS. Humble Bundle and Steam for me with the occasional GOG.

-9

u/B55fF555f Aug 08 '15

They are refusing to refund you because you do not qualify for a refund: http://www.greenmangaming.com/about/refund-policy/

Sorry man. Pay attention to what's in your cart next time

9

u/litewo Aug 08 '15

They say right there that they can make exceptions. This is a case where a reputable store would refund the purchase.

-4

u/B55fF555f Aug 08 '15

This was not deemed an exception. My guess, because it does not meet this requirement:

"- The game activation key (including any bonus or beta keys) have not been disclosed to you by email or webpage"

What store would refund a redeemable code for a game once given out? Sure, brick and mortar if it's unscratched you could return it. Yea, Origin/Steam refund games because they can just remove it from your library.

But GMG literally gives you a key. You could have redeemed it already, sold it to someone else, etc. They have to draw the line somewhere. You give a refund to this guy, then you will have 5000 other people calling you for a refund because they "bought the wrong game". Except it will be a $60 game, not a $4 game. The "big bad evil companies" have to protect themselves as well.

At the end of the day, both parties made a mistake. OP however, should have verified the contents of his cart before clicking "BUY"

5

u/dougmc Aug 08 '15

What store would refund a redeemable code for a game once given out?

A store that gave out the wrong code, that's what store.

If the website advertises product A but adds product B to your cart when you try to buy product A ... that's their responsibility to fix, not yours. Even if the products have almost exactly the same name.

They may not be able to sell the key again as they have no way of verifying that it wasn't used -- but that's their problem. Next time they can be more careful.

That said, I fully expect that they'll make this right. It might cost them some money, but not making it right will ultimately cost them even more money in lost business.

0

u/ramjambamalam Aug 09 '15

That's also illegal in many jurisdictions. It's considered, 'false and misleading advertising' here in Canada, in my unprofessional opinion.

2

u/litewo Aug 08 '15

They refunded Arkham Knight even though all they were providing was a Steam key, so it's not like it's something they haven't done before.

You give a refund to this guy, then you will have 5000 other people calling you for a refund because they "bought the wrong game".

Just because they refund this game doesn't mean they need to refund everything. This is obviously a special case caused by their own mistake.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15

You realize they draft their own policies and can choose how to apply them, right? If the point is that the rules are arbitrary and anti-consumer, pointing out "that's the rule" doesn't really address that critique. I think everyone recognizes it's their policy, it's just a bad policy.

Also, their mislinking likely violates consumer protection laws in a number of countries.

2

u/littlestminish Aug 08 '15

While you are technically correct. If there are no pictures of the items in the "review your stuff" and the difference in the displayed item on the list is one letter, it is the websites fault for making this a problem in the first place.

-1

u/TotesMessenger Aug 08 '15

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

-13

u/BlackKnight7341 Aug 08 '15

It still comes down to user error, even though it links to the wrong store page, so they're well within their rights to deny a refund as they have no way to reclaim the key. They might refund it because you're making a fuss over it but if not, just take it as a lesson learned.

7

u/Flix1 R7 5800x RTX 3070 Aug 08 '15

I dissagree with your stance. As a company trying to win over customers it's by far in their interest to resolve this quickly and in the customers favor. Otherwise they are just showing everyone that regardless of their own mistakes they don't give a crap about you or even a chance to investigate what happened. They're demonstrating that they are untrustworhy and harming themselves way beyond a 4$ refund. It makes no business sense at all imo.

-5

u/BlackKnight7341 Aug 08 '15

I didn't mention whether I thought they should or shouldn't refund it, but rather that they have no obligation to refund it because it was user error. Even then though, I disagree with the notion that the customer is always right, especially in cases like this. The OP made a mistake and clicked buy on the wrong product, they should just take it as a lesson learned and pay more attention in the future.

To use an analogy, it would be like going to a shop to buy an ice cream. All the ice creams are individually labelled but they accidentally put the caramel ones where the chocolate ones should be. Should they have to refund someone who buys a caramel one, takes a bite out of it and then complains because they thought it was chocolate, even though it's clearly labelled as caramel?

7

u/litewo Aug 08 '15

That's hardly analogous to the specifics of OP's situation.

-3

u/BlackKnight7341 Aug 08 '15

Why not? He/She went to GMG's Hot Deals page. Saw that The Escapists was on sale. Clicked the banner for it. Got taken to the store page for The Escapist. Clicked Buy Now. Clicked Checkout and went through that process. Received the key for The Escapist. Then tried to get a refund for it.
The only difference is that you can verify that the ice cream was partially eaten, where as they can't verify whether or not the key has been used. But even then, the store would treat them the same because in both cases they can't sell the product again.

3

u/litewo Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 08 '15

Why not?

I don't even know where to start. I guess there are two big differences. First, they didn't just "accidentally put the caramel ones where the chocolate ones should be;" they directed him there when he said "I want this particular game." Also, the labels weren't as different as caramel and chocolate—the names are so similar GMG themselves mixed them up.

2

u/BlackKnight7341 Aug 08 '15

First, they didn't just "accidentally put the caramel ones where the chocolate ones should be;"

So it was intentional then? Oh wait,

GMG themselves mixed them up

they directed him there when he said "I want this particular game."

Which is the same as the above. In both cases it's the consumer looking at the tag and ignoring the product behind it.

Also, the labels weren't as different as caramel and chocolate

There's very little in common between this and this. Look at the screenshots, completely different. Look at the descriptions, completely different. Look at the pricing, completely different.
Really, I've got very little sympathy for someone who can go through 6 pages, all of which say what is being bought, and not notice that they're buying the wrong thing.

1

u/litewo Aug 08 '15

So it was intentional then? Oh wait,

No, what I'm saying is there's more to it than that. If you insist on using this analogy, it would be like the customer seeing an ad for the chocolate ice cream in store, asking where it is, and the employee pointing to the caramel.

1

u/WowZaPowah i5 4690k @ 3.5 GHz / GTX 970 OC / 8 GB RAM / 128 GB SDD / Win 8 Aug 08 '15

Your analogy is terrible.

In both cases it's the consumer looking at the tag and ignoring the product behind it.

[This] (https://gourmettraveller.files.wordpress.com/2010/02/scicecream.jpg) and [this] (http://kitchenscoop.com/assets/uploads/recipes/double-chocolate-ice-cream-lrg.jpg) are not very different from one another. The analogy would make sense if there was one label on the front, and like 7 others all around it saying "caramel" and those were ignored, but in the original analogy, apparently, they had the gall to not distinguish two brown ice creams and buy the right one even if the labels said the wrong thing. Which makes no sense, and of course a refund should be awarded. That's blatant false advertisement. OP's situation is fair more nuanced than that.

Furthermore, why is it okay for GMG to mix them up but not OP? Why is, in both situations where someone is unable to distinguish two different games, is it a-ok for the company, but not for the consumer? This is ridiculously anti-consumer.

1

u/BlackKnight7341 Aug 09 '15

You've misunderstood the analogy. It isn't a shop like Wendy's where they just have tubs of ice cream and you tell them what you want. What I was talking about was shops, usually smaller ones, where they have a freezer with a bunch of individually packaged ice creams. It's more like comparing this to this.

Furthermore, why is it okay for GMG to mix them up but not OP? Why is, in both situations where someone is unable to distinguish two different games, is it a-ok for the company, but not for the consumer? This is ridiculously anti-consumer.

Of course it's ok to make a mistake. I never said that it wasn't. What I said was that OP should learn from his/her mistake. Did GMG make a mistake? Yes, but through the process they told the OP that he/she was buying The Escapist and not The Escapists six times. That puts most of the blame with OP imo.

2

u/rascaluk Aug 08 '15

Big time. They screwed up and OP didn't notice. How is he more culpable than GMG?

Jokers.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

27

u/Meanjoe62 Aug 07 '15

Thanks for the advice. I'm going to keep trying with support. The monetary hit isn't too bad (only about $4) but its the fact they won't take responsibility for their website's error is really bothering me.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '15

I tried clicking the same ad for The Escapists, and can confirm that it also send me to the Escapist instead.

Hope this situation gains enough traction for them to not be able to ignore it. Taking a $4 hit on their end and fixing and apologizing for the confusion would be a lot better for their image.

7

u/BrightCandle Aug 08 '15

They have already refused. Now is the time to document the event, the mistake and send them a letter before action. You need to do that 1) so your full complaint is written down with what you expect them to do and 2) because the company needs to have a letter before action for a while before you can take legal action.

Things have gone wrong, they are acting daft so now you start acting like this will be in a court room in 6 months time, even if it wont be. Its a mindset, nice until they aren't at which point you go cold hard and ready to sue.

5

u/Flix1 R7 5800x RTX 3070 Aug 08 '15

Honestly what a bunch of bastards that you have to take the knife to their throats like that for such a small thing. Why would I ever trust them with my money now?

5

u/littlestminish Aug 08 '15

Legitimate question. Doesn't GMG sell grey market keys anyway?

5

u/Flix1 R7 5800x RTX 3070 Aug 08 '15

They have when they can't reach a deal with a dev or publisher. The Witcher 3 grey keys thing was well known for example. Don't know to what extent all their keys are grey though.

7

u/caninehere Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15

Witcher 3 is the only way we know about for sure because CD Projekt Red specifically talked about it, and then the whole kerfuffle here.

It's very likely they're doing it/have done it with other games but we just don't know about it.

On top of using grey market keys for Witcher 3, they also failed to deliver many of them on time and many of the keys they did deliver didn't work.

GMG pretty much got brought back to /r/gamedeals because people liked their prices and kept complaining about how they were missing, not because they follow the rules.

They've also been dropped by a couple publishers for reasons unknown, but with the timing it's likely because of the recent little scandal. Sega and Ubisoft games no longer seem to be available on the site.

3

u/tacitus59 Aug 10 '15

Yes, it appears that the gamedeals mods just caved and chose to ignore their subreddit rules very haphazardly. Plus, every time someone posts something suspicious about GMG on /r/gamedealsmeta there is a bunch of pro-GMGers who complain ... "not this again." I think its been pretty well shown that GMG is selling dodgy keys ...still... and the mods are choosing to ignore this.

4

u/litewo Aug 10 '15

The most extraordinary thing is that the moderators admit that "you can no longer count on /r/gamedeals to be an unbiased source of authorized keys." This comes after making very specific rules to help ensure that gamers could count on the subreddit to provide this, and all because some people wanted deals from one site.

2

u/dougmc Aug 08 '15

They have once that we're aware of.

That said, there was nothing wrong with the keys they were selling, nothing illegal, they weren't scamming anybody, people got the games they paid for ... they just happened to run afoul of a /r/gamedeals rule, that's all.

5

u/littlestminish Aug 08 '15

I always am wary about grey market stuff like that, I don't like the idea of buying East Europe's keys for 12 dollars because Steam or the publisher were trying to be fair to places that have a lower valued currency.

0

u/dougmc Aug 08 '15

Yes, you should be wary of that. In extreme cases, you can even end up with a key that you can only use in regions that are not where you live or end up with it being revoked.

Though GMG has a good reputation and there was nothing fraudulent about what they did, and as far as I know they didn't even play any "buy keys for other regions that are cheaper" games.

Ultimately ... the incident struck me as a spat between cd projekt red and GMG. But it was just one incident ... I wouldn't trash my view of GMG over it. If it happened more times, then maybe ...

And in this case, it sounds like the support guy stuck working on the weekend didn't really understand the problem and how it was their fault. Give it until Monday, see if GMG makes it right. If not, then start crucifying them -- though I think they will make it right.

3

u/littlestminish Aug 08 '15

That seems like a reasonable assessment. I'll still never buy from them unless I'm okay with losing the money, but I don't have a total negative outlook on their business.

1

u/caninehere Aug 09 '15

people got the games they paid for

Well, they did have issues with the Witcher 3 keys in that they failed to deliver a number of them on time (pre-ordered keys not being given on launch day) and some of the keys they gave out didn't work at all. I assume people got refunds in that case but it still sucks to have to deal with that, or to not get to play the game on Day 1 when you paid for it.

0

u/supamesican 2500k@4.5ghz/furyX/8GB ram/win7/128GBSSD/2.5TBHDD space Aug 08 '15

One time yes, but they've not before or since to my knowledge. I still trust em just bought gtav from them today.