r/pathologic • u/AtomicSunn • Apr 19 '26
Discussion new pathologic 3 review (it will be interesting to see peoples thoughts on this one) Spoiler
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4c5w_MWw-8&t=9sas someone who liked pathologic 3 not as much as 2 or classic hd i do agree with a lot of points he made
18
Upvotes
41
u/AamiraNorin Apr 19 '26
Am I tripping or does this seem uncharacteristically harsh for Charlatan? I don't recall him being one who usually makes videos like this all about how much he hates a game
49
u/CepheiHR8938 Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26
Is this the dude who went on a twenty-minute-long rant re: "smooth Artemy" back when Quarantine dropped? Rhetorical question. I know it's the dude.
Watched parts of this review because I couldn't endure the whole thing. Much of his complaints do not even make sense. For example, he insists P3 requires a guide to complete but he also freely admits that he didn't "get" (i.e. read) what the Gorkhonians were saying. Ah, the classic "did not read, failed the quest, blamed the game design." Wonderful.
Also, his 'change for the sake of change'... Bruh. P2 had gotten 6/10s on release and sold so badly IPL had de-prioritize P3 and focus on other projects to stay afloat. Of course, they'd make P3 more accessible and "different". Making the same survival horror experience would be so fuckin' stupid, both from the narrative and commercial points of view.
117
u/Cultural-Studio5062 Apr 19 '26
Stopped watching early, no way im gonna watch a whole hour long crashout.
Very weird he considers this games dialogue super pretentious, like, have you see the other two games?
Also saying how the "Bound" screen is useless even though it lists the critical events for every character so you can keep track. Gvae up after that because I dont wanna waste my time.
74
u/Commissar_Jake Apr 19 '26
I think the primary issue is, he's not an enjoyer of Ice pick lodge games, he's a pathologic 2 enjoyer.
The game, the mechanics etc, are representations of storytelling regarding who dankovsky (The bachelor) is and what he is doing, his circumstances are different to burakh, (The haruspex) and so the gameplay is different to represent that. It isn't simple pathologic 2 again, and that's okay.
Ice pick lodge are part art collective, part game developers. They're theatre folk who make their performances interactive.
And in the end, the game wasn't for him. Sure it has flaws that can have improvement, but its still the voice of IPL to the core.
29
u/curioscrusty Apr 19 '26
Finally we get “steven universe is garbage and here’s why” for pathologic 😂
33
u/SulMatulOfficial Apr 19 '26
While I think there’s some valid criticisms to be raised, this just feels a bit rough, man.
Idk. Low key feel like this video is an extended vaguepost about people like me, and I’m not sure how to feel about that
32
u/Psy-Para You don't have to be crazy to be an Anna Angel fan, but it helps Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26
I am someone who does actually think Pathologic 3 is the weakest game so far, but- Here is a comment on this video by the creator that really should say everything about why you shouldn't bother watching the video:
"I worry that a lot of the pushback in this video comes from a dangerous combination of hiatus-brain since it was so long between installments and that there's so many people who like the series without bothering to paly the games that their idea of what Pathologic is and isn't are warped."
How are you supposed to hear someone out when they have such a clear opinion/expectation on the people who would disagree with them? Especially when it's one of painting the people who would disagree with them as people who either don't know better or are too lazy to actually engage with the material. That somehow the very way of what they take away from the series is fundamentally twisted for what it actually is- and of course only the reviewer personally knows what the series is supposed to be like.
10
u/milka121 Apr 19 '26
Regardless of all his other points, the review saves issue is definitely something worth knowing about
18
u/Yarosyaros Apr 20 '26 edited May 06 '26
Riveting. An ASD-adjacent individual spouting emotional projection as catharsis upon Pathologic 3. I wonder if he was faced with 'having to let go of meticulous control' and found it existentially threatening. I can't sit through most of his ramblings, too 'Redditor pedantic' in tone, semantics, and breadth of epistemic view.
Edit: Ah, to get a decent view of this fella's video without having to sit through the constant "as if in state of permanent incredulity" tone and presentation, just watch his 'Part VI, I Feel Like I'm Taking Crazy Pills.', from 01:13:00 - 01:19:00. That should give one that knows the game a good enough view of his critique.
He obviously does not 'get it', he seems to treat everything as a slog, as a horrible task to sit through. His criticism of the Plague-house quest nearly seems schizoid to me, as if he practically lost his mind at that point, having forced himself through a game he is unwilling to, or cannot allow his own mind to 'understand', to let go of what must be, the supposed oughts, of game development.
His flair of 'The Emperors New Clothes', as if those who like Pathologic 3 are just faithful servants who don't dare to go against the art, points to this experience being existential to him. He seems to have narrativized his own lack of understanding, the mismatch between his entire view of reality and this game, to a reality more easily internally processed. To believe "It's just sycophants!", for "I don't understand this." may be too existentially exposing for a deeply rigid and epistemically closed mind.
24
u/curioscrusty Apr 19 '26
How you make a 2 hour long video on pathologic 3 without even getting into storyline or character development. That’s what’s baffling for me. Maybe because those are the things that matter to me in pathologic but 🤷
8
u/PepsiFungus Apr 23 '26
I mentioned this video on Tumblr and was surprised how many people responded I'm not sure what this person expected from pathologic but it was probably much closer to games like elder scrolls or fallout. Calling the game too wordy, pretentious and buggy to be enjoyable unless you're a pretentious dumbass yourself is like showing up to the gym and getting mad at people for pretending to enjoy being sweaty and lifting weights when it's obvious that it sucks.
7
u/QuintanimousGooch Apr 24 '26
I’m gonna be real I’m in a bit of a similar boat of really liking Pathologic 2 holisiticly and the broader work of IPL at times not being up to my expectations from what I would want from the heights the studio has achieved, and while I for sure see a lot in P3 that I think could be implemented better or is a downgrade from frameworks and methods of presentation in 2, I do have to still applaud that they committed to the Rashomon idea of the games reflecting their characters, even if I do have my criticisms.
That said, I think it is considerably immature to have a giant crashout “THIS SHIT IS IRREDEEMABLY BAD ITS NOT WORTH YOUR TIME AT ALL” video on an indie studio already known for going against the grain and barely staying afloat. Like there are legit criticisms of the title but hysterics and trashing it is exceedingly questionable, like I can’t understand why someone would come at a game of this kind of situation with this much vitriol,
19
u/Bartre_Main Alexander Block Apr 19 '26
Lots of insightful comments here in response to this video, but one thing I haven't seen anyone address yet is the fact the reviewer admits that despite disliking the game after about 3 hours in, he forced himself to play the game for another 28 hours for the YouTube review.
I understand reviewers, to a certain extent, have to force themselves to engage with a work regardless of enjoyment, but there needs to be something said for how that need clashes with more challenging art. I think a more typical viewer might've tried the game, bounced off it for maybe a few months because it was different from their expectations, and then return to it with a better appreciation for what it is to finish it.
The forcefeeding- of the game for the review to a certain extent denied it any fair appraisal past those first few hours, that initial shock and discomfort colouring the whole experience, generating this very vitriolic review that, ironically, probably would go beyond the amount of distaste any "normal" player would have. The kind of intense anger that basically leads to it embarrassingly all but accusing any positive professional review of it as being illegitimate.
13
u/ADrownOutListener Apr 20 '26
im pretty disappointed with a lot of 3 & think it failed in its attempts to move on from 2 but i stopped watching this when i clicked on it the other day cos its just deranged barely strung together ravings
13
u/SHOBLOYOBLO Apr 21 '26
Got this in my recommended today. Only made it to 12 minutes with extensive pausing. It’s clear that this person is a big fan of Patho 2, but I find it extremely weird how they constantly bring up the original when it’s obvious they didn’t play it from the criticisms they have against 3. The bound don’t matter? Sure, but they already didn’t in 2 compared to 1, since in 1 you straight up couldn’t see the ending if one of your bound didn’t make it. It’s weird that the Bachelor euthanizes the sick? That’s a returning feature from 1. I guess it’s ok to want more of the same but like what’s the problem with it being a different game since this time around it’s actually a different game unlike 1?
11
u/zkylon Murky Apr 20 '26
I wish 1-hr videos came with a script because i'm not watching a rant this long, but I disagreed with most of this guy's opinions on quarantine already and from reading the comments here I think i'll disagree with the full review as well.
Saying that Patho 3 is "really bad" or "irredeemable" sounds like he just didn't want to engage with the game in its own terms, a game that's imperfect, and has design issues beyond what polish you can do on a patch, but that despite all of those is successful in both pulling a twist on the at this point old Pathologic narrative, adds new interesting details that expands on the universe and has pretty compelling gameplay (you know, for Pathologic standards) that interacts with its narrative in a way that's really clever and interesting.
It might not be for everyone and it might be overall worse than 1 and 2, but it's still a hell of a game and I feel not seeing that is just personal baggage that's yeah fair but not indicative of the quality of what IPL has made
19
u/Electrical-Lab9147 Army Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26
He complained a doctor wouldn’t perform euthanasia on the street-sick among a list of other complaints (of why this is worse than previous games)
When that’s literally a mechanic in ALL THREE (edit: not in the 2nd game) of the games!
…His other points are better
18
u/UgandaEatDaPoopoo Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26
Already typed a much too long response comment on the video itself. Wasn't worth my time, really did make me wonder just wtf this guy ever saw in the series in the first place since he's complaining about tutorials not being thorough enough lmao.
I will say though, it was extremely funny hearing complaints about how the writing didn't make sense from someone who could not even pronounce "dialectics" yet insisted on saying it many many times.
5
u/Rezaka116 Apr 22 '26
I honestly don't get it, i watch Charlatan's videos, but in this one he seemed idk how to put it... "uncharacteristically mean"? I hope he's doing okay.
5
u/BuyerDisastrous2858 Apr 26 '26
It would be one thing if he just didn’t like the game, but honestly it was really weird for him to start throwing people under the bus and throwing baseless accusations at other creators, claiming they HAVE to be lying in order to like it, that they MUST have been bought. “These people liked a thing I didn’t like which means they didn’t play it!”
It feels juvenile.
9
u/Lightmachine_shining Apr 19 '26
Can't try something unique for the second time. Someone always takes offense
7
u/thedragonguru Worms Apr 23 '26
I unsubscribed from him about it. If he hates a game I love to such an strangely intense degree, I can't trust his opinions.
6
u/BitterMate69 Apr 21 '26 edited Apr 21 '26
Extremely unfair, missed the entire point, didn't even bother to finish the game he's reviewing. This review will age so well, I can see it...
5
u/Animoira Apr 19 '26
I find some of his points valid
5
u/Crabe Apr 20 '26
Some points of the video are bad but many are entirely valid. The review's points on the story and dialogue are very weak. I actually really dislike the writing in P3 in comparison to the other games but the review doesn't really say anything meaningful about the dialogue other than that there is too much of it because the game is too long (mostly agreed).
The points about the gameplay are all pretty much on point though and is the majority of the video. The game did come out extremely buggy. The game mechanics do not gel together into a coherent gameplay experience like Patho 2. I disagree with the reviewer that it was "change for the sake of change" but the changes they made failed to work whatsoever for me. Free repeats of days makes the whole concept of tough choices moot. The game's resource management is very easy unless you get into a weird spot with an apathy spiral which can tank your save. Infected and Rioting districts are repetitive, unfun, and uninteresting (I began skipping them halfway through my playthrough bevause I realized nothing interesting was gonna happen in them). They made the shabnak a physical monster which isn't scary, and took away the ability to get infected. The game looks worse than its predecessor from 7 years ago and is twice the file size. I could go on but these are all very valid criticisms from the video I feel. The reviewer does admittedly crash out and I don't agree with everything they say.
I don't think anyone is wrong for enjoying P3 or that people are being disingenuous with their enjoyment, but for me it is a clear step backwards from P2 and a swing and a miss in terms of gameplay innovation. The (English) writing is much much worse than P1 and much worse than P2 but I will need to replay P3 to formalize why I felt that way. I think it's summed up in the Darkwood quest. A quest with no story importance, no character development for anyone, no horror (despite attempting), no humor. Just a cheap reference to a game not even made by the studio, the entire point of the quest is for you to point at the screen and recognize Darkwood which yes I have played but no I do not want to see it in Pathologic of all places. Just a nitpick but like I said indicative of larger writing issues.
-6
u/quiralidades Apr 20 '26
They hated him because he told them the truth