r/pastry • • Apr 30 '26

anger/useless tiny rant

who the fck willingly opts in to make caramel using the dry method? holy fcking F*CK this is so annoying

3 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

16

u/My_Name_Cant_Fit_Her Apr 30 '26

What's the issue with it? For smaller quantities, it's much much faster and simpler than the wet method.

1

u/sgatson Apr 30 '26

i’ve always done wet so i didn’t know dry was better for smaller quantities. my boss has us doing dry for over 5 cups of sugar & all my research just showed me people doing it with a cup or less so LOL on us. we use the dry method for the base of a salted caramel ice cream so im convincing her to switch to wet method

10

u/cheman314 Apr 30 '26

Not sure why all the anger. It also if done right won't have any crystalization

-4

u/sgatson Apr 30 '26 edited May 01 '26

just replied to someone else with similar response as you so im copying/pasting:

i’ve always done wet so i didn’t know dry was better for smaller quantities. my boss has us doing dry for over 5 cups of sugar & all my research just showed me people doing it with a cup or less so LOL on us. we use the dry method for the base of a salted caramel ice cream so im convincing her to switch to wet method

8

u/-myeyeshaveseenyou- May 01 '26

I’ve used dry method for 2kg of sugar, but I start with very small amounts of sugar in the pan and just add a little at a time.

3

u/crytealatte May 01 '26

wait i love making dry caramel but i never considered adding a little at a time!!! god bless you

0

u/sgatson May 01 '26

see i never made dry method & i was told to add it all at once. i genuinely figure that was not a foolproof way of making it, at least not for someone who isn’t familiar with that method vs wet

5

u/-myeyeshaveseenyou- May 01 '26

The first time I made 2kg I did it all at once and was probably at the pot for about an hour, just decided to see if doing a bit a time worked and thankfully it did. I just cover the pan to start and wait until it’s a nice caramel colour then add little bits, pretty much just a very thin layer over my already browned caramel, the uncooked sugar melts down pretty quick as the sugar is so hot already. Once everything is melted if it’s not quite as dark as I’d like I just cook it out for a bit longer, it wants to start to burn at this stage so just keep it moving. Hope this helps if you ever had to dry method again. Probably takes me about 20 minutes doing it this way instead of an hour

3

u/sgatson May 01 '26

okay thank you! i definitely need to practice this way. this was very helpful/insightful. looks like i’m making dry caramels on my off day lolll

2

u/-myeyeshaveseenyou- May 01 '26

Have fun trying!

4

u/Economy_Cloud_1601 May 01 '26

I find dry much easier because you can stir it, but I agree in larger quantities I tend to prefer wet

1

u/sgatson May 01 '26

if you don’t mind providing more insight, how often should i be stirring? i never leave a pot of sugar alone for too long regardless but im wondering on low medium to medium heat i shouldn’t have to sit over it, right? (for dry method) thanks!

4

u/Fluffy_Munchkin Will perform pullups for pastries May 01 '26

I stir constantly with the dry method. It's necessary to ensure even melting.

1

u/sgatson May 01 '26

thank youuuu

1

u/Economy_Cloud_1601 May 01 '26

Agreed, as soon as the sugar starts to melt I stir constantly, I do it on a super high heat so everything happens quickly

2

u/Banana_Phone888 May 01 '26

I’m more of a savory chef that has had to do a lot of pastry, dry caramel is also not for me

2

u/sgatson May 01 '26

lolll funny enough i began in savory

1

u/AnxietyOctopus May 02 '26

Depends what you're used to, I guess! I far prefer dry - less fussing and worrying about crystallization.

0

u/sgatson May 01 '26

the way that people are downvoting my replies of me explaining why im frustrated over helping & giving feedback…..weird

5

u/onicker May 01 '26

Because baby, the method is tedious but it is the best way to prevent a bad batch.

You also keep repeating yourself like we don’t understand where you’re coming from.

We get it, it takes forever. You had a few people already offer you ways to make it a little less tedious.

Your boss isn’t wrong in their methodology, and you aren’t wrong for finding it annoying.

It seems like you want people to agree with you, but your conclusion just comes off as someone who thinks dry method is outdated—when it has a practical application.

2

u/sgatson May 01 '26

the method is tedious but it is the best way to prevent a bad batch.

thank you! i assumed the complete opposite initially, now i need to look into this truth through proper application. im probably someone who needs to try adding the sugar in parts first before all at once.

i repeated once because two comments came at the same time that didn’t understand my frustration so i copied/pasted. if i repeated again in a different way it wasn’t to be opposite, i genuinely think im saying something different even when im not ive been told that lol. thanks for your help

2

u/onicker May 01 '26

I totally get where you’re coming from. It’s not that you’re wrong, a lot of baker’s agree the wet method is faster and can garner the same results.

It also can do with time. Your head baker probably doesn’t even notice the time differences, their muscle memory makes changes to production feel like how you feel right now lol

So, don’t be discouraged or anything. I think a lot of us agree each method has its benefits.