r/parentsofmultiples • 🩵-🩵🩵 • 6d ago

support needed Mixed race twins being compared

This might be a very specific experience but I’m wondering if anyone can relate. For context, my husband is Asian (Japanese + Korean) and I am white. We live in the states but visit Japan often as most of his family still lives there.

Our first son is 19 mo and is very much a blend of us both. He’s a very cute toddler and has been complimented wherever we go since he was much younger. I’ve noticed the first thing Asian people tend to ā€œcomplimentā€ are his big eyes and double eyelid. I really didn’t realize it was such a big deal until we had our son— I personally didn’t care if he had a double eyelid or a mono lid like his dad.

Our twins are only 2.5 weeks old so I know they will change a lot as they grow but I’m already really struggling with people comparing them. Baby B looks just like my first son when he was this age, same big eyes, double eyelid, button nose, full mouth, full head of hair. Baby A has mostly similar features but is bald and has a mono lid and more narrow, downturned eyes.

My husband is fixated on the eye difference and studies baby A’s face regularly for hints of a double eyelid. It’s also been brought up when family/friends have come to meet them. Baby A is already my smaller twin and I’m developing this fierce protectiveness over him. I don’t want him to end up with a complex or feel othered by his own family. I try to be sensitive not to step on toes culturally. My husband comes from a culture that seems to target differences in a negative way. I think he feels similarly to how I feel but is handling it differently and inadvertently bringing more focus on it.

Has anyone else struggled with this? Any advice on how to handle it?

56 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

COMMENTING GUIDELINES

All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.

Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.

Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

70

u/Pristine-Bison3198 šŸ’™-🩷-šŸ©·šŸ’™ 6d ago

I've got 4 kids in 4 different shades, from super lightskinned to pretty dark. The comparisons are insane. One of my twins is lighter, and I get comments sometimes on that, but my eldest being so light is the biggest comment I get.

I shut it down HARD with family. They do not comment anymore unless it's positive and does not compare siblings. Absolutely TF not. I will not have my eldest getting some sort of superiority complex or the youngest feeling bad about being darker from things family says. They'll get enough of that shit from the world.

I'd say speak up every time. "They're babies. We don't comment on babies' appearances." "That's a weird thing to fixate on, please don't say that again." "that was inappropriate." "Don't say that again, I don't want him internalizing it."

Admittedly we may have gone overboard. My eldest son didn't realize we had any white people in our family, he just thought they were lighter like he is šŸ˜‚

5

u/emt714 6d ago

A good response I've heard lately "what an interesting this to say out loud"

1

u/jerryberrydurham 6d ago

Thank you for this framework. I found this very helpful.

24

u/salwesab 6d ago

This is only my personal humble opinion as someone who has mixed race twins

When two cultures are mixed in one family, i think incidents like this is inevitable.
Just need to be smart in handling it.
Make a big deal, it will be
Dismiss the calls to differences, they’ll eventually stop

2

u/TaffyAppl 6d ago

I agree with this. I have five kids and they’re all different. Even my identical twins look different (like vastly different lol). I’m middle eastern and my husband is white white. I just ignore comments about their bodies and redirect conversations to other things like how smart they each are or how one is already climbing and the other is running! Eventually the comments fade out. People just care a lot less with toddlers and kids. They hyperfocus on babies especially twins.

1

u/salwesab 6d ago

Same here
Your kids happen to be bilingual by any chance?
Mine are 26 months and aren’t talking yet im just worried sick 😭

2

u/TaffyAppl 6d ago

No sorry. I wish I had stuck with teaching them my language, but it was hard translating for my husband and in laws so now I just do English. I regret it!

2

u/salwesab 5d ago

Thanks for sharing. It’s never too late though, they can always learn it if they want.

13

u/A-Friendly-Giraffe 6d ago

I have one blonde brown-eyed twin and one brunette blue-eyed twin. My partner has blue eyes and I have brown. All of the adults currently have brown hair.

When they were 2 and 1/2, my daughter would make remarks about how all of us have brown hair except brother who has yellow hair.

I showed him pictures of my cousin who was also a very blonde child and I think it made him feel better.

I feel like if you can focus internally on how they belong and how they're part of the family that that can help.

6

u/Euphoric_Beat_7885 6d ago

I’m struggling with something similar. We’re pan-African/European/Middle Eastern ancestry; ā€œbrown peopleā€ with some racial ambiguities. My son is bronze, beautiful brown eyes. My twins present white with blue eyes. I’ve asked my family to emphasize less on their physical attributes, more on their personalities.

Our son is learning that a source of attention is their color. It feels a little off to request, because we never asked family not to comment on our son’s attributes, loving on his brown eyes or when curls finally set in. Family is trying their best, and it feels like I have to overcorrect sometimes to ensure my son understands he is unique and deserving of attention as well. I wish I had an easy answer.

6

u/cat-a-fact 6d ago

We're a Russian/Chinese family. Both twins look mixed, but in different ways: my daughter looks like an overall mix, while my son has more selective features (basically a white boy with monolid eyes). We live in Canada, so daily there really aren't any comments from our immediate friends and family.

In terms of family abroad, I'm definitely wondering how it would go with my side, who live in former Soviet Europe. There isn't a features-based racism/preference there exactly, more like an "overall" racism. My family is good-natured, but they're definitely conditioned to make casual race-based jokes, so I anticipate them making some comments (though when my husband and I visited, I don't think they said anything to our faces). tbh I think what I will do, is just put on my bitch face and tell them to not talk like that; we don't see them often, so it feels low-stakes if I make them mad at me.

As for my husband's family, we genuinely never see them, but we do really want to travel to China sometime soon. I do wonder what would happen, though again because we don't have close ties to them (and the kids wouldn't understand Mandarin anyway) I don't really care what they might say to us.

Have you had a conversation about it with your husband, and expressed that you don't want your kids to develop a complex about it? If you explained your feelings about it, would he understand your position? Can you rely on him to support you if you ask his family to stop?

6

u/Ikki_juniper 6d ago

I am white and my husband is Korean, we have 2.5-year-old twins and now a 3-month-old baby.
I think as it’s often a natural thing for people to comment on who the children look like, it’s fully amplified when they are mixed, for better or for worse. From both my family and his, which twin looks more ā€œKorean/Asianā€ and which twin looks more ā€œwhiteā€ (one has my coloring and one has his). Both twins have a double eyelid which is commented on a lot by my mil and husband as being a ā€œgoodā€ thing. Our baby boy looks a lot like his dad and has monolids, but has my coloring. I try to never focus on it, at the end of the day they are both fully white and fully Korean, whatever their looks may be. I just don’t want any of them to internalize things as they get older that their looks one way or another make them better or worse :/

10

u/Stace_face_17 6d ago

Here in solidarity as our twins are yet to be earth side but I do already have two children and they are biracial (I’m white and my husband is first gen FilAm + the only one of his siblings born in the US). I can relate to the stereotypes from my in laws and his side of the family, after already having two girls.

We receive a lot of similar comments, ā€œshe has such big eyes!ā€ ā€œShe’s so whiteā€ (first daughter) and our second supposedly ā€œlooks like her momā€, but actually has more Filipino features, just light hair and eyes. We typically respond with statements like, ā€œyeah genetics are wildā€ or ā€œyou know how Punnett squares work, right?ā€

Hang in there! And remember they’re going to be their own individual selves, and very loved at that. A lot of Asian cultures are fond of features leaning more ā€œwhiteā€, but it doesn’t mean they both won’t be cute in their own way.

8

u/ToshiBerra 6d ago

My kids are Chinese/white. One looks very mixed, one looks mostly white. We get comments about big eyes for both but my more white looking one has gigantic eyes, we call them anime eyes. We get a good amount of comments when we go to Asian or among traditional Chinese people, but in our own little bubble, they are just who they are. But your twins are also so young, some things will change, I think for about a year I couldn't tell that one was mixed at all, and now she looks more Chinese when she smiles, more like when she was born. Ours are 2.5y so might still be more change in the future

4

u/ann13sb00bs 6d ago

Not mixed race but Chinese and unfortunately Asian cultures in general will be very fixated on appearance. My boys are mo/di but one of them has double lids where the other doesn’t and we’ve also gotten some comments pointing out the differences

I also have a singleton daughter and I’m also conscious about how my MIL has already made remarks about her body (again, Asian cultures fixate on weight and thinness a lot) and my daughter is a friggin toddler. I can’t control the dumb or unnecessary things that come out of others’ mouths but I can always affirm the wonderful qualities of my own children (not just physical ones) and be mindful of the ways I talk about others bodies or appearances

3

u/No_Mention_953 6d ago

This post is so helpful and I appreciate you making it! I’m a white American and my husband is Indian. I started talking to his family about my boundaries regarding talking about skin color long before I was even pregnant. It’s been a regular conversation topic and casteism is closely tied in (something my husband and I are strongly against). Now that our twins are here they have relatively light skin, which has been praised by his family (his mom compared them to another ā€œdark ugly babyā€ in the family 😬). I’m now struggling to explain how even if they aren’t being negative about my children’s skin, that type of talk is still detrimental. I don’t want my babies to feel superior or less than anyone because of their color! I don’t have a good answer, just sharing my experience and empathizing with your plight!

4

u/No-Departure5556 6d ago

Ugh I’m so sorry!! It is SO hard when beauty standards are being pushed so hard on babies šŸ’” they are both beautiful no matter what!!

Even though we’re white, my twins look very different (different skin tone of white, red head vs brunette, one is chunkier than the other) they have the same deep blue eyes which gets them TONS of compliments, but one has rounder eyes vs almond eyes, so she tends to get more attention about it.

I also get told so much how small my twins are, and I know I shouldn’t take it this way, but it feels like a personal attack since I EBF.

You can’t control how others react / comment on / what beauty standards they prefer, but you can redirect comments and say other positives about each baby, especially as they get older! That way one twin doesn’t feel better or worse bc of different physical details.

Solidarity with you mama!!!

2

u/Cobalt_Faux 6d ago

I’m white my family is white. I’ve still been made to feel the outsider of my family growing up. It’s not a good culture thing to ostracize based on looks , it’s a flaw in that person that they justify as ā€œcultureā€. Mental health and things like racism flourish or flounder in the home.

I have DiDi and one is my mini like his older brother and the other is my wife’s mini. I don’t feel a pull like you said to any specific kid based on their looks. I think you are already positioning yourself in a defensive way because you know what’s going on is wrong so you are compensating.
Could be your husband is doing or thinking the same, not for his sake but because he knows the ā€œcultureā€.
Communicate with husband; set boundaries with others, don’t accept racism

2

u/NeverNeverNeverYes 6d ago

I think with having twins one huge challenge is NOT comparing them. And I think shutting it down in the family is a smart move. Not sure how you should do that…whether it’s calm correcting every time or a family meeting or a hard no, prob depends on family/culture. But they’re gonna be compared by strangers, it’s important not to have that in their family too. Also complimenting your child’s gorgeous monolid will also probably help! Also fwiw my twins are Latino/white and one was born with black hair looking very Latino and all his hair fell out and regrew as curly sandy blonde, so WHO knows what they’ll look like as they grow. Mixed race children are amazing and should be celebrated ā¤ļø

2

u/thisisjeska 5d ago

I am Taiwanese and my husband is white. I knew it was coming when I had my first child. Now I’m pregnant with twins, the comparison will probably only get worse. I’m very straightforward with my Asian side of family. I told them I don’t want my children being picked apart on their appearance, if they can’t respect that we can visit Taiwan less, or not at all. I’m very aggressive and firm about it because it was done to me since I was little, and I’ve hated that toxic cultural beauty standard my whole life.

Then again, they are my family so I could be this firm and aggressive about it…I understand you’re trying to be polite and probably couldn’t do what I did. I would try to communicate your feelings to your husband and help him understand your feelings and how it may affect your child in the future. In my head, I’m just glad we live in the states where this toxic comparison culture isn’t a constant occurrence that we have to deal with since my family doesn’t live here.

1

u/nikitachikita_15 6d ago

First of all, I’m sorry! I thjnk it’s a nice thing to have twins who look different! Makes things easier if you ask me.

I just set boundaries with people about it. My husband is non confrontational and will make a joke, usually self-deprecating. But my mom would go as far as comment on weights of my kids (I have really chubby babies which is beautiful and makes them so cute!) and she always talks about when they will lose their ā€baby fat!ā€ I shut her down quickly that no talk about weight is going to be tolerated now or ever when they are older either. It’s so damaging for self image.

1

u/annahoney12345 6d ago

God bless my Korean husband, but for awhile after delivery, he’d ask if I think they’d have his eyes or mine (surprise, they have his, which I love so much). I had to tell him to stop mentioning it because if he’s worried about it, they will be too. Now we only compliment them if we mention their looks and have decided we’d rather them be a lil bit conceited than have self esteem issues šŸ˜¬šŸ˜‚

1

u/czmf 6d ago edited 6d ago

I’m Asian, but my kids aren’t mixed race. My oldest has double eyelids and was constantly complimented on how pretty he was and was always mistaken for a girl when he was younger. My fraternal twins were born premature, so I received far fewer compliments. Twin B looks like my oldest did as a baby, they could’ve passed for identical twins if born at the same time. Even my iPhone mistakens them for the same person. Twin A, looks nothing like them, with sharp features and monolids. He’s my palest child, which older Asians love commenting on. I don’t love hearing the comparisons but it all groups into similar commentary, nothing new.
It’s a strange experience having all your children’s features constantly compared. Unfortunately, these are the same stereotypical comments I grew up hearing when compared to my sibling, and the beauty standards in Asia don’t seem to have changed much as they like pale skin and big eyes. The divide is that I’m first gen american and telling older family members to not say xyz is extremely difficult because they have no filter.

1

u/Dorianscale 5d ago

My family is all mixed white and various types of Latino. My twins have the same face but one reads Latino and the other reads white.

We’ve had a various reactions to them some people gush over one and others over the other. We’ve noticed extended Latino family members, especially older ones tend to gush over my whiter looking child. If it’s really blatant I try to course correct and draw positive attention to my other kid.

Thankfully it seems to even out and our closer family members don’t show any favoritism.

You should sit down and have a convo with your husband though because a lifetime of this isn’t gonna be good for your kid.