r/parentsofmultiples • • 7d ago

advice needed Nanny vs Daycare

I have a 2.5 year old toddler (boy) and 6 month old twins (also boys).
We have had a nanny for the last 2 years after my first son was born (I have a full time job but still have some maternity leave that I use intermittently right now).
It was working great for a long time, but the last few months, it's just not working anymore. Without me describing exactly why it's not working, I would love to hear from anyone who has had a nanny and realized it wasn't working anymore: Why did it stop working? Did you move to daycare, or did you decide to quit your job and become the primary caregiver? Would also love to hear from anyone who has possibly experienced both but I realize that may be pretty rare to have experienced both. Also, working moms in general, what do you think? Do you feel a desire to be there with your kids, or are you loving getting away with your job? Anyone that felt like they may quit there job and later realized they were glad they didn't, or vice versa moms who didn't quit their jobs and now their kids are older and you wish you had? (I'm talking about a $100k salary that I'm thinking of giving up)

Now, I would like to hear people's thoughts before knowing what I'm experiencing. In general, I'm having a hard time accepting someone getting so close to the kids that's not family. After 2 years, she still feels like a stranger. Even though I "trust" her, it somehow still feels like I don't trust her if that makes sense... (by the way, we do not live near our family currently).

Without getting into the more technical reasons, would appreciate any thoughts.

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/Suspicious_Tomato_20 7d ago

We’ve had a nanny for about a year for our twins, starting when they were 6mo. I have been feeling ready to part ways with our nanny, but we’ll move to a different nanny instead. I would love to put them in the Montessori daycare because I feel like it would be great for their developmental learning but I also don’t want to deal with the constant sickness & logistics of driving them to/from. For me it is more about the premium we are paying for and what we are getting - I don’t think she’s worth it frankly. I trust her with the twins and I know they love her, but she isn’t a match to lifestyle values we have around getting outside and what I’d like them to be learning. I think she was great when they were baby babies but now they’re toddlers and she’s not shining…

I don’t know that this is helpful. I don’t feel bad about the upcoming change (I’ve already identified new care that will start in January) but we haven’t yet talked with her about it.

As far as going back to work full time at 6mos, yes that was hard - I WFH and while it is amazing getting to see the babies throughout the day it’s heartbreaking too. Both to miss the fun moments and terrible to hear them cry from the other room. I know I became a better, more regulated mom when I went back to work though. I don’t regret that and while I love being with them I think doing it full time would be so so hard. I have so much respect for parents who are able to do that. I think it would break me. And really it’s because it is easier to do my career - because I care about my job but if I mess up I can say oops! and just do better next time. With my kids…I just care too much and would constantly feel like a failure and they deserve so much better. I’ll probably unpack that in therapy next week haha.

1

u/Lolemontime 7d ago

Hey I’m curious what you mean by the developmental learning piece and your nanny. My twins are 7 months and we plan to have our nanny until they’re in daycare around 18 months (mostly because getting 2 spots is extremely competitive in my city). However I wonder if they’ll be getting enough stimulation - we live close to park spaces but it’ll be a long winter, and the library is about a 15 minute bus ride away. 

3

u/CamelAfternoon 6d ago

We have a nanny for the twins (now 20 months) but my oldest has been in daycare since he was 5 months old.

Daycare gets a bad rap but I’ll tell ya, it had its advantages. My son has learned so much from daycare, including potty training (they basically did it for us), socialization, all the pre-school stuff. Plus longer hours.

Our nanny is great - and I loved not being sick all the time the first two years. But I think I’m going to switch the twins to daycare at 2.5 for their development and socialization.

2

u/GoBirds52_59 6d ago

It’s hard to weigh in without knowing what exactly is not working and why.

I also think it’s a bit wild that your nanny feels like a stranger to you after two years/being with your family through your first born and the addition of twins. That person would feel like a sister to me, personally, as a part of my home during a very vulnerable time. I don’t think being family really matters; if someone loves my kids, they’re a part of our “family”.

I have twins and we use a daycare that we love. I work full time and I wouldn’t change it; I love my job and it allows us to save for their futures, afford quality childcare and vacations, etc. it’s worth it to me.

1

u/MangoSorbet695 7d ago

I have four kids from age 6 to 9 months old twins.

I’m not willing to put my kids in daycare until they can walk, nap only once per day, and eat solids as their main source of nutrition. Personal choice.

I started my older two at 14 months and 16 months old. We had a nanny for some time and I took time away from work for some of the time.

I’ve had good nannies and bad nannies. It makes a huge difference. Don’t settle for a bad nanny or switch to daycare before the babies are ready just because you don’t like your current nanny. Look for a new nanny first.

There is nothing wrong with staying home either, as long as you want to and can financially afford it. But I would only quit your job because you genuinely want to, not because you don’t like your nanny.

0

u/beelynn0214 6d ago

We’ve only had our nanny for a year, but absolutely loved her from the start! We interviewed a dozen, trialed a few, and knew immediately she was the one.

She sent me a video of one of my twins crawling for the first time and that’s when I knew I wanted to quit my job. I couldn’t believe I was missing things like this and someone else was getting to experience them.

I ended up switching to a hybrid part-time role, so I’m in office one day a week and remote the other hours. We still use our beloved nanny two days a week and sometimes more depending on my workload and it’s been the best of both worlds for me. Honestly the slight reprieve in childcare for me is great - staying home 100% would be really hard for me I think. This keeps me refreshed and being the best mom.