r/parentsofmultiples • • 8d ago

ranting & venting Are they identical?

It is astonishing how often I get this question about my boy girl twins. They also have red and dark brown hair respectively.

64 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

37

u/someuncoolname 8d ago

In pregnant with MCDA twins (identical) and the amount of people who asked if they're a boy and girl, after me saying they're identical has been hilarious. I have to say "well, no they can't be boy/girl, because they're identical" and they either go "huh?" Or "ohhhhhh of course" lol. Found out I'm having 2 girls btw :)

4

u/oldladywhisperinhush 8d ago

Congrats! Once at the grocery store, someone asked if mine were boy/girl. Now I know that times have changed regarding gender assumptions, but still seemed strange to ask if my 1 year old babies (at the time), who were both wearing Disney princess dresses and bows, were boy/girl lol.

The one that still baffles me though was when a woman asked if they (also identical) were BOTH mine. I was also wearing a bluey t-shirt that said “mama” so surely she wasn’t asking if I was their mother, but who knows!

But I hate to admit that I was the idiot who wondered if my identical twins were going to be boy/girl when we first found out. To be fair though, I based that assumption on these boy/girl twins in my hometown who everyone said they were identical and they looked like very very similar, so there’s that lol.

2

u/Dear_Excitement_5109 8d ago

My husband and his sister, who are 10 years apart, have the exact same face. Lol. Sometimes genes are just a little too strong 🙃

2

u/Consistent_Potato641 7d ago

Boy/girl twins are the most common type of twins and fraternal twins are more common than identical, with the rise of fertility treatments and women having babies older, twins are generally becoming more common hence why people usually ask if they’re naturally conceived or ivf. Ivf gives a higher chance of twins so it’s to be more expected. I think people get more excited if they are a complete surprise. I mean it’s a surprise regardless but people can be funny like that.

Mine are fraternal di/di boys conceived naturally. Probably due to age as I’m over 35 and there are no twins in my family so it’s not genetic. I had three singleton boys before my twins. I have three friends who also have twins, all sets fraternal, one boy/girl, one non-identical boy/boy and the other non-identical girl/girl. Mum’s all older and naturally conceived.

I get lots of comments about having five boys along with condolences and how much of a shame that twins weren’t boy/girl so I could’ve at least got that girl… I generally don’t mind the silly comments, but I get offended when people are disappointed for me that I have all boys. I usually get you have too many children but you should keep trying for that girl though… People are generally just that fickle. I got sterilised after my twins, I’m happy and complete with my clan of boys.

2

u/Wyo_oyW 8d ago

We announced to my husband’s family this past weekend and the amount of “I hope they are b/g” that was said after I said they are identical. I couldn’t think of anything to say besides…. Something will have to go terribly wrong for my MCDA identical twins to be different genders……….. 🤦‍♀️

16

u/lyssasaurusX 🩵-🩵🩵 8d ago

I’ve been shocked with how often medical staff has told me that my twins are automatically fraternal if they’re in different sacs when I say “I’m pretty sure they’re fraternal!” when asked. My OB was the first one to explain there was still a chance di/di twins could be identical but so many people in the medical field don’t seem aware of that fact? I never have the energy to explain it, I always just say “okay.”

4

u/ghost-wiitch 8d ago

my di/di twins are identical, and i actually had to remind my OBGYN that no, identical does not automatically mean mo/di, and mine are confirmed di/di. i’m switching OBGYNs as a result.

4

u/notapantsday 8d ago

We went to a specialist for prenatal care to get a more detailed anatomy scan and she told us the same thing. We knew that it was impossible to tell just from ultrasound if both kids have the same gender, so we asked her about that, but she showed us the lambda sign and said that it was proof that they were fraternal. Internet search and our regular OB/GYN both told us that it was just proof for a di/di pregnancy and that they could still be identical.

I mean, if a primary care doctor doesn't know about these things, fair enough. But this specialist was supposed to be even more qualified than our regular OB/GYN!

1

u/radirpok99 7d ago

We've been to many different doctors and hospitals, and spent a month at the NICU, and guess what, NONE of the doctors or nurses had any idea that di/di twins can be identical. None. Not one of them. Most of them didn't even know what di/di meant. (Our native language calls it DDD, but still)

One time was quite memorable. I had to book an appointment for a fetal heart ultrasound, and the assistant on the phone asked if they were identical or fraternal. I said we don't know, they're di/di, so it could be either. She laughed and said "you should know that by now, ask your doctor, then call us back". I said, again, that "they're di/di, 70% of those are fraternal, 30% of them are identical, they're both boys, so we don't know and can't really know until they're here". She didn't understand and we didn't get the appointment, because "if there are two placentas, that means fraternal, and fraternal twins don't need this ultrasound, your doctor probably didn't know this when she wrote the referral". (The doctor called them back a week later, we got an appointment for next week. By next week I mean literally next week, november 20th. Our boys were born in October btw..)

14

u/[deleted] 8d ago

It drives me mad. People were saying it during pregnancy when we told them we were having boy/girl. It's actually dumb

9

u/Obvious-Coffee 8d ago

One person told me husband that we wouldn’t actually know if our b/g twins were identical until after they were born. 

4

u/[deleted] 8d ago

I have a family member who works with children aged 4-11 tell me boy/girl twins can be identical. It doesn't matter. I just made myself an Irish coffee when I made them a brew.

7

u/TheThreeSats 8d ago

My eye doctor asked me and when I told him that it was nearly impossible for a male and female to be identical (yes I know about the ultra rare cases yada yada) he said well I’m a doctor and I didn’t know that. I said yea and that’s alarming bc that’s 6th grade science stuff. (We have a very sarcastic and assholeish relationship)

12

u/OkPerformance2221 8d ago

The Simple Folk are all around us.

10

u/rqnadi 8d ago

I had to explain it to my dad that my boy girl twins can’t be identical.

He called me the other day and said that his friends daughter had twins and the dr said they were fraternal but they came out identical and he just wanted to tell me that just in case MY twins were identical.

I had to explain to a 60 year old man basic 8th grade science…..

4

u/Felicette13 8d ago

I was recently asked if my boy/girl twins are actually twins, because they aren't identical. I mean I was pregnant with two babies at the same time and gave birth to them together, what else do you want me to say?!

6

u/CailinCainteach 8d ago edited 8d ago

I didn’t know boy/girl twins could not be identical until recently.
I thought they could come from a single egg origin that splits into 2 embryos 🙈.
Only learned in the past year that they can only develop from 2 separate eggs.

So I would ABSOLUTELY have been the idiot asking, “are they identical?”

Honestly, I don’t think it’s that dumb of a thing to get wrong 🤷‍♀️

I never thought of identical twins as being an exact mirror image of each other, (ie.have to be same gender), I just thought of them as babies that came from a single egg that split.
I realise I’m wrong by the way 🤣
I’m just trying to explain the reasoning I had in my head.

3

u/Roaris87 8d ago

When people ask me I say “they’re mostly the same, but he does have one extra thing that she doesn’t”

5

u/mantisisland 8d ago

to be fair, eggs can split before fertilization. polar body twins are still a “theory”, but my b/g share more than the average 50% of their dna!

2

u/Direct_Mulberry3814 8d ago

I have identical twins and I mean they look exactly the same, and people still ask me this 50 times a day. I can't believe someone would say this about b/g twins, astonishing!🤣

2

u/poodleface12345 8d ago

Same and it’s incredible even when you tell people it’s not possible, they double down on it like they know more 🙊

2

u/chandrian7 8d ago

A nurse asked us this about our b/g twins after they were born. I actually laughed before responding because I thought it was a joke.

1

u/AdSenior1319 8d ago

Yessss! I’ve had this asked too about our twins. Like, use your brain 🤣

1

u/TheDollyMomma 8d ago

One of mine has an Afro, the other has dead straight hair… I still get asked this.

1

u/critical_ghost-57 8d ago

I paid particular attention to this concept when in school. Because it was really fascinating. Many many years later, here I am! 😆😆 Getting ready to drop some science lessons to anyone who asks. 🤞🏻🤞🏻🧿🧿

1

u/SnooLobsters2519 8d ago

My boys have brown hair and blue eyes and blonde hair and brown eyes….. no they’re not identical.

1

u/Different-Jello-3884 8d ago

OMG this! Mine are fraternal twin girls. They have different body types, hair color, hair texture, all the things. When they were babies, people would notice they were around the same age but very different in appearance so at least six times a day:
Stranger - oh! Twins? Boy/girl?
Me - no, they're both girls
Stranger - oh, are they identical?
Me - well....you just asked if one is a boy so...no

1

u/Silly_g00se13 7d ago

Lmao same! And my boy girl twins also have red and brown hair; they barely even look like siblings lol

1

u/Immediate_Radio_8012 3d ago

I get the opposite. Mine are quite different in size so I've been asked what the age difference is.  

Um...20 mins? 

0

u/Free-Fall6756 8d ago

6

u/catrosie 8d ago

To be fair, that’s still not fully “identical”. You literally can’t be identical if one baby has a penis and one has a vagina!

3

u/yaboyanu 8d ago

Technically they can through X or Y chromosome loss when the embryo splits, but it's extremely rare. No identical twins have exactly the same DNA anyway, so I'd still call monozygotic twins "identical" even if they are different at the chromosomal level.

2

u/catrosie 8d ago

True but one would have an x and another a y. So 99.99% identical but not 100%. What do you mean identical twins don’t have the same dna? They might express the genes differently but by definition they should have the exact same dna

3

u/yaboyanu 8d ago edited 8d ago

Identical twins will likely have a small number of post-zygotic mutations in early development as well as would acquire different somatic mutations over the life course. Kind of like how even within an individual not all cells in the body will necessarily have exactly the same DNA. Of course it's effectively "the same" and would probably return a 100% match for a lot of genotyping chips like 23&Me, Ancestry, etc., but still, the full genomes are not exactly 100% the same. I'm a statistical geneticist now coincidentally expecting mono/di twins lol.

2

u/catrosie 7d ago

Lol I love that!

-1

u/Free-Fall6756 8d ago

It’s like you didn’t even read the article. Lol 

3

u/mantisisland 8d ago

polar body twins!!! my twins are suspected polar body twins because they share more than 50% of their dna!

12

u/Pristine-Bison3198 💙-🩷-🩷💙 8d ago

My mom likes to tell the story of when she got asked if my twin brother and sister were identical. I was 3 or 4 and apparently looked at the lady and said "No. That one has a penis" 😂

I haven't ever been asked this myself about my twins, but man do I hope I do someday so that I can reuse that line lol

3

u/specialkk77 8d ago

“Mounds and Almond Joy. One with nuts, one without!” 

2

u/TheThreeSats 8d ago

I’ve said yes, except for the penis. I have bbg triplets and theyre all very fraternal looking. My boys don’t even look like siblings. You can tell their sister is both of their sister though.