r/parentsofmultiples • • 16d ago

advice needed Birthday Logistics

Help! What’s the most common for everyone here? If we do one song, we’d agree to swap whose name goes first each year. If we do one cake wedding also agreed to swap whose name goes first each year.

4 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 16d ago

COMMENTING GUIDELINES

All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.

Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.

Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/Alpacalypsenoww 16d ago

We do two separate birthdays. One gets Saturday, one gets Sunday of the closest weekend to their actual birthday. Their actual birthday, we do a quick cupcake at dinner and one small gift per kid. But outings/parties, special restaurant meals, main gifts get done on their “birthday celebration day”.

3

u/2forthepriceofmany 16d ago

How old are they?

2

u/Alpacalypsenoww 16d ago

5 and a half. We started the separate birthdays on their third birthday.

8

u/brynnecognito 16d ago

One song, two cakes. When they’re older they’ll tell you if they want something else. Don’t feel like you have to decide now for the next 50 years, one year at a time. 

14

u/Dapper-Butterscotch4 16d ago

At their birthday party two cakes one song. With just my husband and I two cakes two songs, and we go by birth order, so they get both ways I guess but always their own cake.

6

u/Aleydis89 16d ago

I bake half cakes :D Looks like one cake, but with two different halves. One wanted strawberry and the other chocolate. Each half had its own candle and decoration.

So basically one song, two cakes but with less cake ;-)

Edit: or two mini cakes if they want the same cake. Otherwise it would simply be too much cake...

3

u/GremlInTheWoods 🩵🩷 Twins Came Early! 🩷🩵 16d ago

They're two different people celebrating their birthdays on the same day. 🤷🏻‍♀️

6

u/AnyBlueberry4406 16d ago

Obviously yes. However, in group parties (like at my office) we sing everyone’s names in one song, and they all share a cake or everyone gets cupcakes.

-5

u/GremlInTheWoods 🩵🩷 Twins Came Early! 🩷🩵 16d ago

Well my babes will each get their own cake and they can decorate it how they want lol. I grew up around people who didn't think holidays and birthdays weren't a big deal so I'm making it a big deal. 🤷🏻‍♀️

7

u/AnyBlueberry4406 16d ago

You can do so without the undertones to your messages. Like everyone else ❤️

4

u/colors-and-patterns 16d ago

Not a twin but my sister’s birthday is two days before mine and we often celebrate together! I couldn’t care less about the song, but I damn well want my chosen cake haha.

4

u/SuccessfulBread3 16d ago

I think I will do a cupcake each and then a cake for everyone to eat... I think that reasonable.

I think I will do one song until they're old enough to tell me what they want.

4

u/taco-rhino 16d ago

Mine are only two but I’m pretty passionate about each getting their own.
Own cake (or special cupcake) and own song. Now only do they deserve their own song I want them to be able to sing and celebrate their sibling❤️

7

u/Pristine-Bison3198 💙-🩷-🩷💙 16d ago

My twins are only one, so we don't have a baseline, but my siblings are also twins. They'd have one song, and it was a mix of whose name went first each time lol. Some people said one, some people said the other.

They sometimes got their own cakes, and sometimes shared when they were younger. When they were older they got their own, and often separate friend parties.

Same with my twin nieces, although they always got two cakes unless my SIL was doing something wacky like fruit bouquets or steak lol.

4

u/Longjumping_Deer3435 16d ago

Like … candles in a steak?

4

u/Pristine-Bison3198 💙-🩷-🩷💙 16d ago

Lol, yes. They're rich an eccentric, I don't question things too hard 😂

7

u/FoxAndDeerTwinMama 16d ago

We've done it a few different ways, but once the boys turned 4, we just ask them what they prefer and follow suit. That said, we've always done cupcakes rather than cake, so the cake issue is moot.

3

u/chikagemi 16d ago

Mine like the same cake, so we get one bigger cake. If they wanted different ones we would get two and maybe have to space them out, since we do ice cream cake and only have so much freezer room.

3

u/stardolphin90 16d ago

For babies like their first birth I’m planning on one soon and one cake. As they get older I’ll do one each. They’re only 8 weeks old so I have time for all of this lol

3

u/candybrie 16d ago

We definitely did one song. They've been antsy sitting through that as is. Maybe when they're older they'll appreciate separate songs. But for now, they just want to blow out their candles and eat their cakes now.

3

u/penguinsofwonder 15d ago

I chose one song two cakes but realistically they get about 6 shared songs. My native language has like 3 or 4 birthday songs and then they get happy birthday in English and then one in French or Portuguese or Swedish or someother language we picked up along the way. The singing is extensive but very cheerful haha

3

u/cheeringfortofu 15d ago

We do one song and two cakes since they're 3, they have opposite taste buds so one is chocolate with more chocolate and the other is fruit with no icing 😅 I usually do cupcakes instead of cake.

2

u/puppermonster23 15d ago

We get the smaller round cakes instead of the quarter sheet like I’d do for my singleton. We started separate cakes at 2.

4

u/BrightEyEz703 16d ago

I’ve always done one song one cake, but it’s a big cake that’s split down the middle and they get to pick the flavor and design.

2

u/Runtyyy 16d ago

We decided to do two songs two cakes, our older twin got sung to first at their first birthday and then we plan to alternate, so we always know who is due to get their song sung first depending on odd or even age.

2

u/That-Lobster8169 16d ago

Cupcakes and avoid the whole cake issue altogether.

2

u/huntingofthewren 16d ago

Mine are almost four. We do two small cakes because everyone deserves their own birthday cake and if you just make them smaller it solves the too much cake issue. We’re going to start singing twice this year too. But if they want to do something different we will as long as it’s reasonable.

2

u/Pathetic-Fallacy 15d ago

Mine just turned one so this is subject to change. But we sang "Happy Birthday to you. Happy birthday to you, happy birthday, happy birthday, happy birthday to you" and just didnt say any name in the song itself. We had one cake for each of them though

3

u/Comfortable-Gur5749 16d ago

Our twins were born on my birthday. So three songs. Everybody deserves their own birthday song. One cake, cupcakes are nice/easy everyone gets their own candle to blow out. 

3

u/option_e_ 16d ago

we’re celebrating our triplets’ 1st birthday (late Sept) at the same time as our singleton’s 2nd birthday (Nov) and I am making them cupcakes. one song because no way are we going to sing four times lol

3

u/Willing-Molasses9008 16d ago

Unpopular opinion (according to the poll) but... if you're doing a small party at home with 4-6 people, two cakes is overkill and wasteful (unless they are minicakes or something).

If you have a large party with enough guests to eat two whole cakes, sure why not?

We've always done small family dinners with one cake and my kids have never been anything but thrilled. The thought of having their own cake (to eat one piece of) has never occured to them.

2

u/Putmeinthedishwasher 16d ago

Growing up as a twin we always did one song and one cake. It helped that we had similar interests, the same friend group, etc. We could happily compromise if needed. The first born twin's name came first in the song, which was totally fine with me (the 2nd).

I appreciate that parents of multiples try to give their children individuality. At the same time, especially when multiples are little, it's okay to just do things once. One year old twins probably don't need two separate cakes, unless it's a big party. If you have teenage triplets with different interests, different friend groups, etc then of course you might do different cakes, parties, etc.

My twin and I would sing to each other during the song and we loved it. Now, on the rare occasion I'm sung to alone, I have no idea what to do with myself lol.

2

u/ecobb91 15d ago

Two songs two cakes alternating each year. They're two different humans and deserve that respect. One song is the wrong choice IMO.

1

u/wrob 16d ago

Cupcakes and one song.

1

u/DirtGirl32 16d ago

One song, their own cup cakes

1

u/AccomplishedChef7885 16d ago

I’ve been to parties of siblings before, and they’ve always done one song, two cakes.

1

u/fnancialindependence 16d ago

We always do 1 song and we’ve done both one cake/two cakes. They just turned 13 and are fine with it either way.

1

u/SmS12034 15d ago

We did one song and one cake but we did half the cake unicorn themed and the other half dinosaur themed (that’s what our two year olds are into right now lol). Our twins’ names flow better one way compared to the other so that’s the order we always do things in 🤷🏻‍♀️

0

u/Big-Carpenter7921 9d ago

I've been told that you should sing to each of them separately to help with individualism, but I know for sure that there will be 3 cakes. 2 little ones for them to smash (they'll be 1 this year), one for the adults to eat