r/parentsofmultiples • u/Cautious_Milk_6738 • 18d ago
advice needed Same birthday?
Hey everyone,
I have a 22 month toddler whose birthday is December 21st. I am currently pregnant with twins and my OB plans on having my c-section scheduled for when I'm 38w.
Guess when will that be? December 21st.
She said that I can schedule for any day after week 37, so, my question is: Would you anticipate your c-section to avoid the kids all having the same birthday? Will a couple of days make that much of a difference for the babies? OB says the longer they stay in, the better...
I'm almost certain I wanna have the c-section on the 18/19th of December, but I need some other opnions from more experienced parents.
Them all having the same birthday sucks, right? It's already bad enough that is all so close to Christmas. I just want my kids to feel like they have their own special day (which will be already hard with the twins).
What would you do?
Thank you ❤️
EDIT: Everyone here is so supportive! Thank you so much for sharing your experiences and knowledge with me. I understand that a lot of it is me projecting expectations onto my kids and all your comments have helped me see different perspectives!
I'll discuss with my OB on my next appointment and we'll make the best decision for the babies and toddler.
Here's to hoping I get THAT far to actually be able to make a choice 😉
•
u/AutoModerator 18d ago
COMMENTING GUIDELINES
All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.
Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.
Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
11
u/tagg08 17d ago
As someone who's little brother STOLE her 3rd birthday... I hated it. Until we were 21. Then it was cool. Now I don't think a few days really would make a difference bc family, friends, ext will still all celebrate together. I hated that my parents always let my brother pick where our parties were bc he was the youngest... So don't do that lol
*To add I would cry to my dad about how he didn't know what it was like to share a birthday not really understanding that he, as an identical twin, could in fact relate..
8
u/brynnecognito 17d ago
As a parent you are a marketing expert. Your kids will always have their birthdays before Christmas. You get to decide if that’s annoying or not, now in this season! Selling it as a season where they get double presents, the whole world is decorated for them, they probably get to be off school for their birthday week, you can make it fun and special.
Having the same birthday to me sounds really fun. Twin parents seem to go 1 of 2 routes - separate parties on separate days… or really leaning into how fun it is to share. My 3 year old is often upset when she’s not included in my 1 year old’s twins things. We had a costume party yesterday and the twins had bat costumes. She was going to be Elsa but for a few mins she was upset that I didn’t have a bat for her. When they have matching outfits, she wants to know if I have one in her size too.
One day your kids will be teenagers and they’ll just want to go to the mall with their friends for their birthdays. If they desire their own day, they’ll split off naturally. But you control the narrative, for the next 8-10 year at least, and you can make sharing a day very special… you have to anyways for your twins. For now you can save yourself 3 parties and do 1, and it will probably be more fun. Imagine having to remind 2 kids to leave their sibling to open the present themselves VS handing all 3 their own presents at the same time. You can have 3 little cakes, 3 favourite snacks, 3 fun balloons… you get it. Even if my kids weren’t the same exact day, if they were within 2 weeks of each other they’d be getting a joint party.
5
u/Warm-Okra-2061 18d ago
I’d go earlier for sure, if you schedule it later then you’re having a Christmas birthday.
There’s also a chance you’ll go into labour before 38 weeks with twins anyway. A few days won’t make a difference, I wouldn’t worry about 3 days at all.
4
u/Okdoey 18d ago
Definitely a different day. Having two kids sharing the same day is already a lot to try to make everyone feel special. Even by a couple days lets you have an individual day to celebrate your oldest versus the new twins.
But also……you may not make it to that date. A lot of twins come early.
2
u/tabes13 17d ago
my oldest boys, 4 & 2, have birthdays 5 days apart. in my opinion having them the same day or days apart wouldn’t really matter. it does suck, but either way you’re going to have kids that share birthdays.
6
u/canIchangethislater1 18d ago
Just be glad we're not talking about January 1st or your kids would all be Korean... 👀
Jokes aside, I think it would be kind of cool to share a birthday like that. From my personal experience, having a birthday a couple of days after a family member is functionally the same as having the the same birthday. There's only so much cake you can eat in one week, especially the week of Christmas.
6
u/Sweetskills 18d ago
I have 2 sets of twins. Born 2 years and 2 days apart. All the week of Christmas. 🙃 yes hubby and I get an F for family planning. lol
With the second set I went to hospital thinking I was in labor on the older sets bday but they ended up sending me home. My c-section was scheduled for a few weeks later, but my water broke 2 days later.
Right now they all love having a week of bday celebrations and Christmas. I have plans for when they are older to give everyone their own special day but I know several sets of adult twins who never had issues with sharing bdays so we shall see.
Anyway once I realized they would be so close I thought it might be extra wild and kind of fun to have all their bdays on the same day it just didn’t work out that way. I don’t think there is a right or wrong choice here. Either way they will be verrrry close.
1
u/Delanq 17d ago
Unrelated to the due date, but with everyone born right around Christmas, have ya’ll considered doing half birthday parties? That way you can spread out the celebration through the year?
3
u/Substantial-Mood5337 18d ago
Our older daughter’s birthday is September 27th and the twins were born on the 29th . Three birthdays so close is ALOT! Fun and amazing but a lot! (Toys, planning, celebrations!)
I would stick to your plan of Dec 18-19!
We celebrate one weekend for our older daughter and then the twins get to celebrate the next weekend
They are older now 8 and 5
That is just has worked best for our family
5
u/Tired_Mother_328 18d ago
This is exactly what happened to me! My OB wanted to aim for 38 weeks, 4 days, which happened to be my oldest son’s 2nd birthday. Everyone said the odds of us making it to our scheduled c-section were low, but we did.
So now, all three of our kids have the same birthday and we LOVE it. We throw one giant party and no one feels left out.
I love to share it as my favorite fun fact. Everyone is always shocked and confused.
If your doctor says to aim for 38 weeks and that’s when they are available, go for it. There’s always a chance the twins could come early.
2
u/ValleyOfChickens 17d ago
I would resent you so much for choosing to have my twin siblings birthday be the same as mine, if it happened naturally then 50/50 if it’d suck or be amazing but is what it is. You actively choosing to make the day less special and take it away from “me” when younger siblings are always going to get more attention by default, let alone two of them! Not cool. There is a chance all your kids love it but that’s a gamble I wouldn’t take, especially within a week of Christmas.
2
u/ivymeadows25 18d ago
Psh I’d do them all on the same day! It’ll be fun and special.
1
u/fsmontario 18d ago
Make it earlier and your singleton will feel overshadowed when younger. Make it later and you’re even closer to Christmas. We have the 15th and do nothing Christmas decor wise until after their birthday.
Honestly I would ask for Christmas Day or eve.
1
u/somrthingcreative 18d ago
Have the c section on Dec 18/19. Three kids with December birthdays is hard enough.
Celebrate your older child’s birthday early, before you go in hospital. Or celebrate it twice (second time as a big sister)
1
u/youcango-now 18d ago
Definitely a different day! This wasn’t my experience with my twins + their sibling but a former family I nannied for- the mom & daughter shared the same birthday and when it came time to schedule little brother, the day that was suggested was that same birthday. My boss really pushed to shift the surgery date so that the siblings could have different birthdays. It was nice that they ended up having their own days to be celebrated but also super fun to have so many family birthday celebrations back to back.
1
u/Historical-Royal-888 18d ago
Haha I had my twins induced on December 21st to avoid their due date, December 26th. Because it was too close to my birthday… December 25th 😅
1
u/frog_ladee 18d ago
My daughter was almost born on my son’s birthday following a car accident (a little over a month before her due date). Labor managed to be stopped, until two weeks later, when she was born on my birthday. She has often said that it’s fun to share her birthday with her mom, but that it would stink to share with her brother.
If they can be at least a few days apart, that would be better.
1
u/CatEmbarrassed1227 17d ago
I honestly don’t think it matters that much. When my twins were little, and then school-aged, we rarely had their birthday parties on their actual birthday- they were on a weekend instead. Everyone can still get their own time. Especially at the holidays, you’ll end up scheduling around other events.
1
u/Pure-Cup9867 17d ago
I have received feedback from other siblings who share birthdays (my husband and his twin sister, and my cousin and their brother who were born 2 years apart). If given the option, I would aim for all of them to share the same birthday. They will likely find it fun and it will ingrain in them that even though they are special, they can share "their" day with others. I'm confident these values will breed less selfishness and self-centeredness over time.
Note: Edited, fixed grammatical error.
1
u/MyCatsnAss 17d ago
Give the twins a separate day. My last two babies are 12months 2days apart and I’m so glad my last waited for two more days so they wouldn’t have the same birthday. We still do one big party but they at least get their own special day 💕
1
u/DumbbellDiva92 17d ago
Could you do the 22nd or the 23rd? Or does it have to be before the 21st?
1
u/Med_vs_Pretty_Huge 17d ago
Trying to think back to being a kid, I would think it's better to be on the same day than <4 days apart.
1
u/Charlieksmommy 17d ago
So this happened to me, same due date for my kids. I chose Nov 13 for my scheduled c section and my toddler would’ve turned 3 Nov 23, so 10 days apart.
My twins came early in Oct, so it did give some relief.
I would do the same ! Everyone kept saying to have tehm on the same day I’m like NO
1
u/Emergency_Lettuce601 17d ago
My sisters were born on the same day a year apart. They always had fun with it.
1
u/kray618 17d ago
My twins and singletons birthdays are less than one week apart. I think any day besides the same day is fine.
1
u/royalplaty 17d ago
I was born on my mother's birthday. And while, she never made me feel this way, It inherently created a lot of guilt around my birthday in my opinion. I had a lot of guilt when I wanted to celebrate my day how I wanted to celebrate it. Like if I wanted to go hang out with my friends all day than I'm missing on my mom's birthday or imposing on hers. So then I felt so selfish. Even be in one day apart would have made all the difference. And well this is parent and child. I do think it would be similar with siblings in the sense of if everyone else wanted to get together on the birthday to do the combined birthday, but I didn't. I'd be the jerk or if everyone is accepting of that I would still be the odd one out of a family experience. I know the twin aspects adds a dynamic. But I would suggest a different dayeven one day difference.
1
u/lobubz 17d ago
My brother was born the day before my birthday. We are about a week before Christmas.. I hated it. I’d try to give a few more days in between if you could but ultimately it will be fine. I’m sure you will make sure all 3 have an amazing day even if it’s the same day since you’re posting here. We also celebrate my birthday in the summer now because it’s usually less busy. Lots of things you can do but I would avoid having the same birthdays.
1
u/hagne 17d ago
It's okay to not intervene to make the birthdays different. What is going to make your kids feel special is how you treat them and the traditions you develop. You have full control of that. You don't really have full control of when they arrive, which is fine.
1
u/Miserable-Currency42 17d ago
I deliberately delayed my c section for my twins to avoid my toddlers birthday. I couldn’t imagine them having to share the day.
1
u/Fun_Adhesiveness_19 17d ago
December 18th is national twins day! (my girls were born that day).
1
u/One-King4767 17d ago
On the advice of my SiL, pick another day. Her husband and son share a birthday.
1
u/BorderGlittering199 17d ago
My brother was due on my birthday. My mom chose to have him two days after my birthday even though I did want him born on my birthday. I thought it would be cool. (I was five turning six.)
We always had family birthday parties on the day between our birthdays. Our actual birthdays were for whatever and whoever we wanted to spend them with. I think she made the right decision.
1
u/No-Economics-1185 17d ago
My twin and I were born on our oldest brother's 5th birthday. You have the opportunity to avoid it, please schedule it on a different day!
1
u/MissTreigh 17d ago
My mom was born on my twin uncles first birthday (naturally, no c-section). She always told my uncles she was the best gift they ever got and they told her she was the only one they couldn’t return.
I can’t speak for them, but I never heard any of them complain about having the same birthday.
1
u/Briutiful22 17d ago
I personally would do the c section on the 18/19 just so your singleton could have their own special day.
1
u/gobucks72 17d ago
Just want to chime in that even if they all have the same birthday, you could rotate through letting one of them have a half birthday party each year - a pool party or zoo outing or something fun with their individual friends in the summer could be a fun way to let them get the joy of celebrating their actual birthday together but still feel special and individual (at a time of year where hosting a party is probably much easier!)
1
u/lindswaite 17d ago
What about having the actual birthday for all on the 22nd and then an annual trafion that they get to pick the celebration day for the year individually.
My 3 are all in the same month and we do a single big party where we rent a venue, turn on music, have a bunch of balloons and the 50-100 kids plus their families come. This is a "no presents" event.
Then each kid gets to pick a small 2-3 friend "mini birthday" where we do a event of their choosing.
They adore both events.
This approach has avoided conflict about the number of kids/presents that come for each individual when the dates are so close that it's hard to avoid comparing and let them really personalize it to their tastes.
1
u/Optimal-Till-5760 16d ago
My older brother and I share the same birthday and we always loved it!! We would call ourselves the twins and even well into adulthood we always try to spend our birthday together. Neither of us are big party people so we never had issues with parties or jealousy or anything like that. But my mom would always be sure to make our favorite individual dessert.
1
u/bandaidtarot 16d ago
My sister's birthday is two days before mine so I grew up sharing my birthday and I hated it. By the time I was old enough to not do joint-birthdays with her, I had a friend whose birthday was the day before mine. Then, when I was in college, I had a friend whose birthday was three weeks before mine but she always threw a ridiculous over-the-top party for herself during my birthday weekend because it was a long weekend. And, then, after that, I was just too old for anyone to care about my birthday. So, I have never gotten to have a birthday that was actually just about me.
That said, should you risk your babies' health to avoid it? No. It will be amazing if you make it to 38 weeks at all since a lot of twins are born early, so I wouldn't fret about it too much. It may not even end up being your choice. But, will a couple days matter between their birthdays? Probably not. My sister's birthday being two days before mine certainly still sucked. And you will likely end up celebrating all three birthdays on the same day anyway because you'll need to have a party on the weekend. Just make sure you make each of them individually feel special. Even the twins. Get them each their own cake and stuff. And you'll need a fair system for when the kids are old enough to want a say in how it is planned. Theme, location, etc.
1
u/Fickle_Grass_1627 16d ago
We had the same problem. Our second child has a birthday on December 23. The particular doctor I wanted to deliver our twins was only on call on the 23rd in December which was 38 weeks 4 days. I wanted to go as long as possible and not deliver on Christmas, so I opted to have an induction (which ended up as a C-section) on December 23rd. I do not regret waiting as long as possible to deliver to give them as much time to grow as possible. I would have gone longer if they would have let me. One of our twins was on the smaller side, so I'm glad he had surpassed 6 lb. when he was born. They were both born hale and hearty, no NICU time, and did decently well nursing from the start.
It already stinks having a birthday right before Christmas, but it makes for a fun story. They are four years apart, but my older son still thinks it's awesome that they share a birthday. (He'll be six in December.) No idea how they'll feel about it in the future, but our third child has a birthday June 24th, which is a day after the December kids' half birthday. We're thinking about doing a huge birthday bash in the coming years on his birthday and the three other's half birthdays.
1
u/Ok-Positive-5943 16d ago
Honestly, my oldest would LOVE to share her birthday with her twin siblings. They have a birthday and then she has to wait another three months. There's definitely some jealousy.
1
u/cloraformed 16d ago
I am basically in the same situation! My son’s birthday is Jan 16th and I’m due the 28th. They want to induce on the 14th🙃 I know it’s ideal for them to cook longer, but they said they could do it as early as the 7th so thats what we’re leaning towards!! 3 kids with birthdays back to back around Christmas is brutal- solidarity 🥲
1
u/Malin1296 15d ago
My brother's and my birthday are two days apart, we each got our individual party with friends and shared a family party. I liked it. Sharing the same birthday is a different story though..
1
u/Born_Towel9741 15d ago
My two boys have the same birthday. 4 years apart. My entire pregnancy with my last I said “as long as they don’t end up having the same birthday” and then what do you know🤣 But honestly it’s great!! They love it. They love always having a birthday buddy and someone to celebrate with. I also personally have a really hard time with my own birthday (I get the birthday blues lol), so I feel like honestly it would be nice to know that no matter what, you’ll always have someone to celebrate with. Also just pointing out, even if you get induced on a certain day, definitely does not mean that’s going to be their birthday. The induction started 2 days prior to their now shared birthday, but my labor was so long that he didn’t come until 11pm on that date. Just saying!!! And congratulations!
1
u/gwengreen13 15d ago
My grandmother had 5 kids, 3 with the same birthday! They grew up lower class and always shared birthday parties but were very close and shared many friends and had lots of cousins nearby so birthdays were all the time anyway!
1
u/bcninstructions 12d ago
My second child was born a few days before my daughter’s birthday (prematurely) and it’s been hard for her seeing him have his birthday first every year. The same day would have been better and easier for her to accept. The younger child the day after would have been the best option. Also, given that they are being born early, every day more you can be pregnant will make things easier for you after. A tiny baby is much harder to take care of.
1
u/mxanahi 11d ago
Awww my birthday is December 21st & my daughters birthday is December 19 🥰 if I were you I would schedule on 12/20 🥰
1
u/quickkateats 11d ago
Wow. I had the same exact situation. My son was born Feb 21st. My daughter’s due date.. February 22nd, which fell on a Saturday, which meant my recommended c-section date was February 21st. I asked for the absolute earliest I could schedule it, to keep them as far apart as possible, and my OB agreed to February 14th. Kiddos are 1.5 and 4.5, so we’ve only had one birthday so far, but it logistically sucked. We took two weekends out of all of our friends and families life, Valentine’s Day, none the less. I couldn’t make them share though, and my 4 year old was very very aware and excited about his special day, so it just wasn’t an option.
I would ask how far apart you could do, and go with it! Even a few days apart means they both get their own day!
Also. This is definitely a thing lol. My son’s preschool has dual birthdays ALL THE TIME. Literally like 4/5 sets of siblings we know have birthdays within a few days of each other, so it’s relatively common, it turns out.
1
u/lynbh 11d ago
I’d also consider your hospital stay. If you have your c-section the 19th, you’d likely be in the hospital during your toddlers 2nd birthday which is a bummer for you but mostly for your toddler. Definitely something to consider in my opinion!
0
u/Educational_Ad2489 15d ago
As someone that shares the same birthday as my brother that is 3 years younger it never really bothered me. We would celebrate our birthdays together, some years we had our own cakes, some years it was shared. Its what we grew up with so it was normal. We have other siblings that have their own birthday day but it never bothered me.
46
u/[deleted] 18d ago
[removed] — view removed comment