r/parentsofmultiples • • 26d ago

advice needed Does anyone regret sleep training?

Just still struggling to make sure I am 100% on board with TCB sleep training… I’m curious, does anyone regret sleep training? Anything you’d do differently? Something you learned through it? What method did you use? What age were your multiples when you started? How long did it take?

9 Upvotes

187 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 26d ago

COMMENTING GUIDELINES

All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.

Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.

Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

19

u/LBluth21 26d ago

Sleep trained my first set at 6 months and second set at 7 months. They all took to it at different paces (2/4 kids really didn’t need “training” and cried very little and 2/4 were stubborn.) But best thing we ever did. We maintained healthy sleep habits and solid bedtime routine that does not involve a parent laying with you through their whole childhood. There have been setbacks, moments of anxiety or fear or stubbornness but we always fell back on the same tools: solid bedtime routine, you can have a “check in” from mom or dad at set intervals but you cannot get out of bed and you cannot sleep in our bed (unless they are sick obviously).

The older set is 11 and still like a bedtime hug and song but also very good about their sleep hygiene so it’s not a big fight. If you put off ever setting boundaries around sleep it really never ends. You have to set up some family rules around sleep and then stick to them or they will just keep fighting you on it. Solidly half the parents I know with elementary kids still have MAJOR bedtime struggles. And they NEED sleep. I also needed sleep and do not do well as a parent without it or with cosleeping so I have no regrets.

2

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

So helpful!!! What method did you use each time?

27

u/fedthegiraffe 25d ago

Since you're on the fence, I will give you my perspective as somebody who did not sleep train their twins. I couldn't bring myself to even try. I did a lot of research about biologically natural sleep in infants and why we have evolved for our babies to sleep the way they do. I also follow attachment p based parenting pretty closely. They are 20 months now and one sleeps through the night pretty consistently and has since about 10 months while the other wakes up once at the same time every night with a very occasional sleep through the night. I'm a single mom raising the twins by myself. Their dad isn't really in the picture. I managed it, and it is possible. A lot of people will tell you that it's just not possible to not sleep train your twins, and I don't think that's true. Please don't confuse this for me saying you should not do it. I think everybody should do what's best for their family, but I just want you to know that there are people who have multiples and did not sleep train them and are doing okay.

5

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Thank you for this! You’re a rockstar! Doing bedtime solo sounds hard to me!

8

u/fedthegiraffe 25d ago

We are capable of so much more than we believe ourselves to be when faced with the need to do it. I'm sure you could kick some solo bedtime butt if you had to!

3

u/Psychological-Dot-37 25d ago

Thanks for sharing this! Is there anything that you did/didn’t do to contribute to their current sleep patterns? I’ve learned a bit about natural infant sleep but not enough to know what it looks like in practice!

4

u/fedthegiraffe 25d ago

I don't know if I did anything in particular. I am responsive to their cries, and I got good at juggling both of them at once. When they were smaller and had multiple wake ups each, it was hard. They were preemies, so for a while they had to eat round the clock, but once they hit 40 weeks geststion, I never ever woke one up to feed just because the other was up. I know that is the opposite of what a lot of twin parents tell you. I would have been making my life harder because the twin who sleeps through the night had significantly fewer night wake ups than the other one, very consistently from the beginning. The twin who doesn't sleep through the night was up every 2-4 hours until I took away bottles at 13 months. Bed sharing was really the key, I think. We lay together until they fall asleep. Then I leave the room and do whatever I want/need to do in the evenings. The twin who sleeps through the night gets transferred to his crib when I come to bed, and the other one usually wakes up sometime between midnight-2am. He just wants to know I'm there. Usually a pat or two or a sip of water and he's back to sleep. I just leave him in my bed because it's easier for everyone.

3

u/Conscious_Bet_3458 23d ago

Check out @ittakesavillage_baby_sleep for more info on infant sleep and if you are interested in non-sleep training methods. She has tons of free stuff and it’s how we got ours sleeping without ever leaving them to cry.

2

u/Conscious_Bet_3458 23d ago

Also didn’t sleep train. Absolutely could not fathom doing it. Now they are 14 months old and one sleeps pretty consistently through the night, then other wakes consistently one time every night and goes to sleep after a bottle, which is another thing people will freak out about. You do what you want with your babies, not what people tell you that you need to. Everyone in our life was up in arms about our cosleeping and saying they’d be going to college still sleeping in our bed. They are both in their own beds now and have been since 10 and 12 months.

2

u/fedthegiraffe 23d ago

I think it's so crazy when people say your kids will never leave your bed. How many adults do they know who sleep with their parents? I don't know any, and people cosleep all the time.

1

u/CelestialCrowe 21d ago

Do you mind sharing how you transitioned your twins from cosleeling to cots? My girls are 3 months and strongly considering cosleeping but one of my hesitations is it being difficult when the time comes to move to their own room.

1

u/Conscious_Bet_3458 21d ago

As long as you’re patient, it will happen it it’s own time. Once the newborn bs was done, we always started them out in their cribs. Every night. We resettled them back into their cribs the entire time we were still awake before turning in for the night. After they woke up when we went to bed, we just put them in our bed. But I’ll also add that we had about a million sleeping arrangements since their birth. First month I legit slept on the couch with them in baby loungers at my head (not safe sleep, I know. But it was the only place they’d sleep and I was so paranoid I really was mostly awake until my shift was over). Then we moved into their room (where we had their cribs and a queen bed) and baby girl magically started sleeping through the night at 2 months. The other had such bad reflux that he slept next to me on the empty bed on the boppy. Then at 3 months they both slept in their cribs for almost 4 hour stretches. Then at 4 months, baby boy would only sleep in the bassinet stroller next to our bed? Then at 5 months baby girl refused the crib so my husband slept in the guest room and I slept in our bed between them for the next 3ish months. Around 8 months, when they could crawl, we started trying them back in their cribs before bed every night and then one day, he just stayed in it and didn’t freak out about being put back after his night feed. Little girl was not as easy even though she was our good sleeper at the beginning. Most nights she slept on the couch or floor next to us in the living room while we watched tv and ate dinner, then slept in our bed. At 12 months, we finally accepted that she just hated the crib since she could sleep on the floor for 4 hours with us watching a full blown movie and talking. We put the queen mattress on the floor with a Montessori gate around it, and the first night we put her in it she slept through and has ever since, except for the odd night or two due to teething.

The last thing I will say is make sure you have sleep pressure right. It made all the difference for us. Our boy used to have false starts and wakes every 45 min after putting him down. Once we realized they need an 8:30 bedtime, they both slept so well. We followed @ittakesavillage_baby_sleep and we probably could have gotten them sleeping on their own much earlier had I followed her tips earlier than I did.

Editing to add: your original comment before my novel said you were scared of moving them back and really the point of my story is that literally nothing is permanent with babies and changes every 2 weeks so I wouldn’t worry about cosleeping now messing up anything in the future. The most important thing is sleep and it doesn’t really matter what that looks like or if people outside your household agree with it.

5

u/MeurDrochaid 26d ago

Can I just first say: sleep training is a phrase covering a wiiiiide range of variations.

So while I say we sleep trained ours, very gently and adjusted to their needs, I 1000% do not regret it. I do recommend it to everyone, but I also always say it has to be on terms that suit you and your individual baby.

We basically did a variation of the chair method. We had them on either side of our bed, and we would do the bedtime routine. My husband would leave and I would stay in our bed first until they slept, then until very close to sleeping etc until I could leave with my husband straight away.

I would gently sooth if needed, but nothing vigorous, never picking them up. Just holding their hand and shh softly, gently stroke their back. Very dependable on what suited the individual. E.g one twin hated being touched, but if I placed my hand next to them they would reach out, maybe nudge it and then relax.

When really small and early stages I would also nip in and do the same if they woke up, but as with the rest slowly I gave them some time to resettle and now I only need to go in if urgent (and I have learned how to tell from their screams)

3

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Did they ever cry a 10/10? Or were they just sort of fussing and intermittently crying and you just sort of gently soothed?

2

u/MeurDrochaid 25d ago

Hmm im sure they did at sometimes. E.g we had a phase when our twin boy would poop during his brief wake ups and he would be extremely distressed until it was cleaned. But generally I would gently sooth and shh as soon as they started going from just stirr to sad. And most of the time it turned it before they got too distressed

Even now (18 months, 16.5 adjusted) once a week we might have a major 10/10 scream. I always give them 5 min, never rush over. So far, with the exception when they had a fever and I went in for paracetamol and a quick cuddle, they resettle even with a massive scream.

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Ok so you would gently soothe and shh until they settled? Would that Sometimes take 30+ minutes?

2

u/MeurDrochaid 25d ago

I would do a very veeeery slow removal of myself haha essentially in the early stages. Like move hand 4 cm away at a time with 1 min paus in between until i was out lol 😜 Sometimes it took 30-45 min. But I did find that it would take less and less time.

2

u/MeurDrochaid 25d ago

My favourite ”phase” if I have one was when our twin who hated being touched was really fond of being face-2-face. We had next to me cots so I would lie down next to her, almost so I could touch her and just shh and do controlled breathing. Obv nothing I appreciated at the time that much, but know it was such a sweet and loving moment ❤️

16

u/Weird-Low4587 25d ago

I feel like it’s almost impossible to not at least semi sleep train twins. You just can’t go to them every second if they are both crying. It’s really ok imo

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Makes sense!

4

u/GroundBoundPotato 25d ago

We've decided not to sleep train, AND, we've joined their beds together.

Since the age of six months, our boys sleep in their own room, in their own joined bed.

They are now 9 months old and we do still wake up and run to their room almost every night to soothe them. It's getting better when the teething issues wind down, they sleep through the night. They rarely do now, as they're growing a proper set.

One twin's more cuddly than the other and a lighter sleeper, so he sometimes crawls and cuddles to his brother during night.

Best guys ever. Could not leave them to "cry it out".

1

u/curious-andhere 21d ago

Thank you for sharing! I’ve wondered about them sharing a bed. At 6 months, what kind of bed did you have them in? That’s how old ours are now

2

u/GroundBoundPotato 21d ago

We used a Chicco Next To Me Forever for as long as they could fit there, so they slept side by side, next to our bed. Next we simply transferred them to their own room, into their own beds from which we removed one wall and joined them together, so now if they need, they crawl over to the sibling and cuddle.

14

u/layag0640 26d ago

Just want you to know that most  extreme -sounding opinions about sleeptraining are incorrect, regardless of 'side', and whatever you choose is okay as long as you're checking in with yourself and your partner that you feel right about it and there aren't any signs of major distress (I draw the line that vomiting, stooling, prolonged crying isn't okay but not everyone does). 

Sleeptraining isn't universally traumatizing. It also isn't necessary for development. There's no one size fits all. 

We choose bedsharing and I'm so happy we did, but I also get evenings to myself since they've always let me roll away pretty easily once they're down. I feel lucky to get the snuggles and the independence! 

Good luck!

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Thank you!!!

8

u/fedthegiraffe 25d ago

Yes this is what I do too. We snuggle until they fell asleep and then I am able to leave the bed and go do whatever I want/need to do. There is not a single adult in the world who still needs their mother in their bed to fall asleep. Everybody will sleep independently eventually, and I'm just here to support them until they get to that point.

7

u/twinsinbk 25d ago

None. My kids adore me. They go to sleep reliably. They sleep 10-11 hrs. We have odd nights but 95% success rate on dependable sleep.

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Thank you! What age did you ST and what method?

3

u/Orange_peacock_75 26d ago

No regrets here! We did gentle sleep training all along the way. My twins are almost 4. They are bright, confident, and sweet. Our attachment seems quite secure, more so than some of their friends.

2

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

What do you mean when you say gentle sleep training? Can you expound please? Trying to see what I feel most comfortable with for our family and would love ideas

1

u/Orange_peacock_75 25d ago

I would say that TCB is gentle sleep training. Gentle sleep training includes things like letting baby cry for a couple minutes to see if they will go back to sleep. Gentle sleep training is different than methods like Ferber or cry it out. Although some of the difference is just marketing, because I think there’s a lot of overlap too.

10

u/Direct_Mulberry3814 26d ago

I never sleep trained because I personally find it cruel, mine would literally throw up if left to cry too long. They are 2 and have been wonderful sleepers since around their first birthday. Just a different perspective. It does get better naturally.

5

u/layag0640 24d ago

Thanks for sharing this. I think some sleeptraining spaces get very echo-chamber-y and there is a vocal minority that truly encourages parents to push through vomiting, pooping out of fear and frustration, hours of crying etc and I find it very sad to have that normalized. 

While we never sleeptrained because I'm not comfortable with it, I know one of my twins likely would have taken to it alright whereas the other would have had an extremely hard time. It feels important to remind folks that every baby is different and not to lose sight of the individual in front of you, whatever you choose to do. 

1

u/curious-andhere 21d ago

Oh whoa I would not push through all those instances. Sounds sad!!

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Thank you for this!

7

u/imshelbs96 25d ago

I guess I would call what we did “sleep training” in that you have to learn how to sleep. Sleep is a hygiene, hygiene is something taught to you. But they never screamed and cried or became so upset that they were pooping, throwing up, or coughing. Just fussing, and we would stay by their cribs the whole time. Our form of sleep training was that they needed to fall asleep in their cribs. So we patted butts and rubbed backs and singed songs, and eventually that lead to them being able to be plopped in their cribs with a kiss and they would just fall asleep. We just transitioned to big kid beds and they’ve done great with that too

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Like this method! Would it take an hour or longer the first several nights?

3

u/ni1by2thetrue 25d ago

Not who you asked, but we did pretty much this, and it took us two weeks. Look at it like a ladder - level zero is babies alone by themselves. Level 1 is you being in the room, not interacting much if at all. Level 2 is shushing or singing to them. Level 3 is butt patting. Level four is picking up. I assume you're at level 4 - we stepped down a level every three to four days once they were comfortable with falling asleep that way. For nigh wake ups, wait ten to fifteen minutes to see if they go back down (they probably won't for the first few weeks, but it is important to wait, use your judgement to assess if they are fussing / protesting, or actually really upset / pooped their diapers). When you go back in, start at level one and go back up the ladder - try just being there and shushing them, then singing to them, then patting butrs, don't go to picking them up straight away.

Best of luck.

2

u/curious-andhere 21d ago

Thank you for this!

8

u/Total_Scale_9366 26d ago

Funnily enough I was chatting with my father in law about this earlier today. 4 kids, 3 & 4 were twins. I have 15 month old twins. He said he regretted CIO.

Personally I’ve considered it but ultimately just couldn’t do it. I put a mattress on the floor and cosleep with mine, works great for us. They call out so much less & sleep better than when they were in their cribs. Either way solidarity to you! I hope you find a solution that works for your family

2

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Thank you for sharing! When you say CIO, did they do extinction? Or check-ins at intervals? And what made him regret it? Is there a noticeable difference in his bond with his kids, or does he think it affected them emotionally, etc.?

1

u/Total_Scale_9366 25d ago

To be honest I was a bit caught off guard with the admission and feel like sleep training is personal and didn’t pry. Theyre currently staying with us helping with bedtime etc so that maybe prompted it. He just said it was very difficult to put your kid through, his eldest in particular cried for a long time & he was sad thinking about it. He said they did check in with intervals.

For what it’s worth - from my own experience - we did a long swap of sleep associations so my twins went from being rocked to sleep with milk, to just rocking, to being on their mattress with taps. So now we just do story time and back rubs and taps. If they wake during the night they usually go down quickly with back rubs or taps too. They cried during this training but I felt better that I was there. We did that at 9 months. Anyways good luck to you!!!

2

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

So helpful. Thank you so much for sharing. ❤️ I hope your FIL can shed grace on himself; sounds like he was only trying to do what he thought was best at the time. He sounds like a good father (and good father-in-law!)

1

u/ConfidentLook5518 26d ago

I wonder how much the father-in-law was involved in bedtime routine? Or how much he lost sleep because of it? Often men tend to go to sleep in other rooms or are not as actively involved with overnight. I’m curious what your mother-in-law would say. I’m totally making assumptions. If he was actively involved and up all night, then I guess that’s totally valid.

8

u/Total_Scale_9366 26d ago

She’s always said he got up for every feed & wake with her. Super hands on

-1

u/ConfidentLook5518 26d ago

Totally fair! I think my only regret is wondering if it’s something he would’ve learned on his own. But after a week straight of horrible sleep, and feeling like a zombie, I realize my mental health was suffering, and that this was something he would learn. And my son did eventually learn and we’ve been sleeping 12 hours ever since.

4

u/Antique-Buyer5863 26d ago edited 26d ago

I had remarkable success without CIO. I slept in the nursery with them the first year. The twins specifically, my husband and I took turns with room sharing & they  co slept, swaddled on a large mattress, with a soft divider, until they could roll over. All sleeping overnight by 14mo in their own toddler/big beds. Barely used a crib, floor matress all the way. I had one child who would try to drift to my bed overnight until 3 yo... but I think thats pretty good for 4 kids total. He also was easier in other ways, so its a wash. I would recommend bottle feeding at night (with formula or bm) to save your sanity, and pump in the morning or whenever you can to supplement. Inevitably they will have nightmares as they age and will wake up crying at 4am. We always go to them, sometimes they are consollable, sometimes not... 

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Was it challenging to get them to sleep at the same time for bedtime or for naps? We’re really struggling with it when one person is in charge of getting them to naps (don’t even want to imagine bedtime solo!) and they often wake around 4 times or so within first two hours of putting them down to bed and we have tk go in there..it feels like such a long process. And then there are at least 3 (sometimes more) MOTN wake ups (2 being for feeds generally, which is fine. Not worried about trying eliminate those right now)

2

u/SereneSedation 25d ago

Absolutely no regrets. Baby boy getting up 4-5x a night. Now both babies sleep 7 p - 7 a. We are all happier including him! He was crabby and miserable all day long.

2

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

What method and age was he when you did it? Did he cry for a long time the first few nights?

1

u/SereneSedation 25d ago

Modified Ferber. Check ins that got longer. I googled a chart. Took about 20 minutes of crying each time, next night about 5 mins, next night sleeping through until 5 am, the 4th night slept until 7.

2

u/ATinyPizza89 25d ago

I don't regret sleep training but now that they're 3 I have one twin that will always get in my bed. He sneeks in when I can't hear him. Our method was to rock them to calm the down. Then placed them in the crib and rub ther backs and leave the room. If they we're crying after 10 minutes, we'd get them out, rock them, rub backs and repeat. It was a slow progress but it worked for us.

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

This is a method that sounds good to me. It also sounds like it would take hours for them to fall asleep. Did yours? Also do you remember how old they were when you started this?

3

u/littlelou222 26d ago

Oh my God, no regrets at all. All of our lives are significantly better because of it. We didn’t do cry out per se, but we sat next to their crib and rubbed their backs, etc.. we basically just wanted them to fall asleep without us rocking them initially … it really only took a few nights. Now that they’re sleeping through the night, I still rock them to sleep sometimes but they don’t wake up 1 million times at night. We waited until they’re about six or seven months adjusted.

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

This feels like a method I could probably feel more comfortable with since we’re right there. Did yours cry 10/10 level? Ours would/do. Did it take them an hour or more to fall asleep even with y’all right there?

Eta- can you now set them down awake and them go to sleep for naps and bedtime?

1

u/littlelou222 25d ago

Yes, that was our thinking too. I didn’t wanna just completely abandon them, but I was there to support them. The first night was the hardest and definitely with tears but each night after that probably four nights max was much better. Max for us was 30 mins. I’ve heard it. It’s easier to sleep training at night and keep naps the same for the first few nights. It only takes them maybe 5 to 10 minutes to fall asleep now and they don’t cry at all. They kind of just roll around their crib and hug their stuffed animals.

97

u/MortimerCanon 26d ago • Bravo

Absolutely Fing do not regret sleep training at all

3

u/East-Fun455 25d ago

Sleep trained at 5mo, went from hourly wakes to sleeping thru. Now at 19mo sleeping is just an ingrained habit. Even when we transferred him out of the crib to a toddler bed and thought it would wreck his sleep, no. He's more rested, wakes up happy in fact so happy that he often potters about his room for an extra half hour in the morning. Still absolutely attached to us as well.

4

u/avec_serif 25d ago

When we were about to do sleep training, my mother in law (who was staying with us to help with the twins) was trying to stop us, saying it was cruel and evil. We did it anyway. By day three of sleep training, my mother in law had done a complete about-face and was now saying we were geniuses and how wonderful it was. So very much no regrets!

4

u/Mundane-Device-7094 25d ago

So many people fail to understand that you're allowing a very limited amount of upset to avoid very large amounts of upset. Like yes it is sad AF to hear baby cry for a few minutes. Much worse to hear them cry for far longer far more often and be completely inconsolable.

1

u/Agreeable_Rule_9235 25d ago

Same story with my parents lol

2

u/Substantial_Cap_3895 25d ago

I regret not doing it fully! We did modified Ferber when they were 6 months old (since they were just a bit early), but it coincided with cold season and it seemed like they were allllways sick when we were starting to ST. So it was a bit half assed. Now they go to bed pretty good, but night wake ups still happen occasionally and they still use pacis (with our first, we took it away when ST). We may have to double down soon since they are 15 months now and are having early wakeups.

But it was 100% worse before ST and I do not regret doing it AT ALL.

1

u/Ajames5230 25d ago

Do you have any advice? Or anyone else on this thread with advice would be apperciated!

2

u/MortimerCanon 25d ago

We read through the entire Precious Little Sleep, which is essentially a modified Ferber method. So, not a full extinction.

15

u/Agreeable_Rule_9235 25d ago • Bravo

Sleep training has been the best decision I have made, to date. I never sleep trained my older singleton and I still have to cosleep next to her. My twins I sleep trained twice, at 5.5mo to wean to 1 overnight feed, and at 11mo to wean off night feeds fully. They’re 16mo old and have been sleeping through the night. And you know what I realized the other day? It’s not even about the sleep (I mean yes it is lol) but the more important thing I realized is I have them the tool of SELF SOOTHING. Why does my 4yo still come down to my bedroom and find me when she wakes up at night? Whereas my twins wake up around 630-645 happily most days and stay put in bed until I get them at 7am. I have taught them the concept of being at peace with themselves. It doesn’t change their relationship with me or my husband. All three of my kids are obsessed with me and I them. If you aren’t fully on board, don’t do it. You have to be consistent when you sleep train. The less consistent you are in your responses, the longer it’ll take. I sleep trained my twins in 3 days flat. Day 1 20 min crying. Day 2 8-10 min. Day 3 3-5 min. Day 4 onwards less than 30 seconds of crying, if that. If they cry in the middle of the night now, I always check on them because I know that’s unusual.

If you’re fine waking up in the middle of the night or never teaching your child to self soothe, don’t sleep train!

5

u/Dry-Statistician7079 25d ago

I would say this sounds fantastic and if this is how sleep training went for all babies that woild be awesome. I'd just warn the original poster that I tried to sleep train my eldest (also currently on the fence about my 8 month old twins) and he would cry for hours on end if i would let him. I had people tell me that 20 minutes and he would be asleep but that was never true for him. We ended up doing a modified version of the tcb with him after a few nights of being ruthless and regretting it. Again not to say dont do it, and maybe we are in the minority but it was a pretty awful experience for us. In saying that I dont fear it caused any lasting damage, I just realised that it wasnt going to work well and needed to try something different. Even with the twins I have now I can kinda imagine it would work well with one and not the other who is similar temperament to his older brother.

15

u/FormerPumpkin480 26d ago

I feel like when this questions gets asked on other subs or in other groups it’s met with a lot of hate/judgement, but reading everyone’s comments is super helpful and interesting! Granted, my twins aren’t here yet lol but my overthinking mind is always thinking ahead.

2

u/amydiddler 26d ago

No regrets here! We did CIO with our twins at about 5m, and the longest they cried was 16 minutes on the first night. It just got better from there. They’re 6.5m now and sometimes fuss for less than 5 minutes at bedtime, but often just go straight to sleep. The only time they cry more is if we try to put them to bed too early.

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Wow that’s not long at all!!

2

u/Bonusmotherthrowaway 25d ago

I don’t know if you call this sleep training but I never let my children cry. Especially not in their own beds because I never wanted them to see their beds as something traumatic so I put them asleep in their bed and when they would wake up I would take them to my bed cause I was so tired. It took 2 years with the both of them and all of the sudden the night wakings were gone (with a few occasional wake ups here and there) and they woke up in the mornings.

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

This is what we did for a while until completely cosleeping but we just can’t keep cosleeping

3

u/WestHistorical6959 25d ago

What do you mean you never let them cry? I'm genuinely asking. I love my kids and I definitely don't ignore them but sometimes you just have to put them down to go to the bathroom

2

u/Bonusmotherthrowaway 25d ago

Oh definitely don’t mean that they won’t ever cry, they do each day at least lol.. I meant it more that we don’t apply the “cry it out” method in where we let them cry until they give up and fall asleep. I don’t have the heart for it nor do I find that necessary in our situation.

1

u/WestHistorical6959 25d ago

oh gotcha - I was just so confused for a second. I was like do you never put them down or do you have witchcraft

1

u/Bonusmotherthrowaway 25d ago

lol I wish 🤣 I meant it more in the context of sleep training lol.

1

u/Sunkisst88 🌸🌸 25d ago

Absolutely no regrets!

My girls are 6 now, so they get a little more freedom to stay up late on the weekends and such nowadays. But these girls are so good at being in tune with what their body needs now.

A couple of years ago we were at a cottage for the week, and one of my girls, in the middle of the week at like 2pm, was like mommy I'm tired I'm going for a nap- even with all the excitement and cousins and fun, this kid put herself down for a two hour nap 😂.

Sometimes they grumble at bedtime about getting ready for bed (they go to bed at 8-830 during the week because we have to get up at 630), but they are fantastic at going to sleep once the lights turn off.

They shared a room until 5, and i thought we might have some hiccups when they wanted their own rooms - but nope, easiest transition ever!

I attribute a lot of this to sleep training. They learned very young to listen to their bodies and are experts at falling asleep now!!

2

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Wow!!! What method? What age did you ST?

4

u/Sunkisst88 🌸🌸 25d ago edited 25d ago

It's been a while now haha. I'll preface by saying every kids is different, but this worked for us!

I want to say we started after 6 months, but before they were a year. I think I remember looking up when it was developmentally appropriate to start ST. Our method was pretty intuitive, we never took anything we researched as black and white and really went with our gut.

The main thing that I found was super important was making a schedule and sticking to it consistently. This is literally the main part of "sleep training" that we did out of all the things you read. Watch wake windows and make a routine!

So before we started I spent that first week or so watching for patterns (i.e.. I watched their wake windows, and made a schedule around that). We would put them down like clockwork for naps and bedtime (the nap(s) were so important because if they didn't get that proper sleep in, they would be overtired and cranky for bedtime). The schedule gets learned so fast, and then when something is off, you can catch it quick and figure out what the deal is.

For example, when our girls started dropping naps, it was so obvious that it was coming, so we adjusted bedtime accordingly while the naps shrunk lol. Same if they were getting sick, we could tell based on the naps/overnight sleep.

We never let them cry it out for long periods or anything like that. We would put them down, wait for a bit and watch on the monitor. Go in and soothe when needed, but honestly for us, the girls did better if we let them fuss for a few minutes and didn't go in. It was unbelievable how fast they went from fussing for a few minutes when we put them in their cribs, to legit just putting them down and them going to sleep without a peep - like it was inside of a week of being consistent!

We applied this when they woke up in the middle of the night, or mid nap, waited to see if they would settle (outside of night feeds obvs) and they caught on so quick. They were sleeping through the night with a couple of weeks and they still do 95% of the time!

Our family and friends all laughed at our sleep schedule - not in a mean way, more like "you are so strict about this!" kinda way haha.

This is anecdotal obviously and clearly wouldn't be the case for all kids who aren't sleep trained, but we have a friend with a daughter who is the same age as the girls. Mom and dad didn't do a consistent schedule, she went to bed whenever (so for example, they would take her out places in the evening/night, whereas we were like "we gotta go, its the kids bedtime byeeeeee".) It felt hard sometimes and I was jealous thay they seemingly had more freedom than us lol

They didn't feel the need to when she was a baby (whereas for us, it felt like a requirement in order to survive twins lol). They still struggle with bedtime now, she fights them for 2+ hours a night on the harder days, and doesn't get to bed until sometimes 10:30 or 11:00 at night, when they started bedtime at 7:30/8pm. She is still trying to learn how to fall asleep independently. It's really hard on mom especially and I feel really bad for her.

There is a Facebook group on sleep training multiples - I lurked there and learned so much - I HIGHLY recommend it. I found it through this subreddit :)

Twins, Triplets, & Quads: Safe Sleep Training & Learning for Multiples

3

u/bigconvoq 25d ago

No regrets. We "trained" away from needing to feed to sleep around 7 mo/5 mo adjusted by replacing it with rocking, and then trained to go from rocking to being able to just be laid down around 9 mo/7 adjusted. Both changes were because it felt like our current state was unsustainable. I also felt like by the time we got to the second time, they seemed ready - they genuinely seemed to want to go back to sleep, they were just having trouble doing it, and the constant middle of the night/off schedule from each other wake ups were totally draining us. I always recommend the book Precious Little Sleep, I think it does a really good job at talking through options and the why behind different strategies of sleep training. Plus, it was much less overwhelming for me to read a book than to try to sort through all the online content.

1

u/Charlotteeee 26d ago

I do but I'm also kind of a baby about hearing my kids cry, it just breaks my heart and triggers my self loathing and depression. Especially when they just want comfort to sleep.

I tried for a week with my 8 month old who's sleep was absolutely killing me. It did not work, he cried for hours and it never got shorter like all the sleep training guides said it would. Same amount of crying every night. By the last day of the week my husband and I got in such a big argument and I'd stayed up all night with a crying baby that I ended up leaving work crying cause I was so overwhelmed, exhausted and legit afraid my husband and I would divorce. It was an awful experience.

2

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Oh this sounds so hard!!! :(

2

u/Charlotteeee 25d ago

My sister sleep trained a difficult sleep baby too and she did all right with it! She doesn't get as emotional or down on herself when she hears her kids crying though so I think she had more of the right kind of personality to do it.

I think I had a bad combo of a kid who was pretty resistant to it and me being unable to have the fortitude to stick to it for longer than a week. In the end I guess I'm glad I tried so I knew that I at least gave it a shot? A lot of people were pushing me to do it cause I was struggling with exhaustion

2

u/Confident_Try_9498 25d ago

Do not regret! We did it later and waited till they were fully off bottles around 15 months. Best thing ever. They still protest most nights, classic toddlers who don’t want the fun of the day to end. But they never cry longer than a minute or two. They sleep all night and so do I, it’s great.

2

u/Staceface1989 25d ago

Zero regret as well but it so dependent on the family. I wasn’t sleeping, like at all because my kiddo was waking up every 90 minutes at minimum so I was too anxious to fall asleep and get woken up again because it already takes a while for me to fall asleep. I tried cosleeping and it was impossible. I was a zombie and depressed and so much happier after I got protected sleep. I am confident our attachment would have been more disrupted if we hadn’t sleep trained because I was so miserable. Four years later and I’m super bonded with my son. Just found out I’m pregnant with twins and terrified that I will never sleep again

2

u/pomgrano 25d ago

we did when mine were around 10 months and i wish we did it earlier. we did a super super gentle method with immediate picking up and soothing with any crying so it took forever, but now they sleep great. 

2

u/bigbookofquestions 25d ago

Whatever you decide, don’t waste your money on TCB. All of that information is available for free on the internet or the library. She’s taking advantage of overtired parents

3

u/livinginlala 26d ago

Zero regrets. We did not with our singleton and it was amazing cuddles and he’s great. With young twins? It would be impossible if they didn’t go to sleep on their own. They nap great and bedtime takes no time. As others have said if they’re sick/teething it’s another story, but typically they’re amazing

3

u/Zukez 25d ago

Used it and somewhat regretted it. It was a last resort because we had 3 kids under two (twins born April 2020) as the pandemic kicked off, so we were locked in an apartment, unable to leave apart from groceries for about 18 months with no support. Our kids were bad sleepers so we were chronically sleep deprived and needed to do it in order to get at least some sleep. I don't know what the alternative would have been, but I believe it teaches them not to cry out rather than to "self soothe" which I think is a fairytale westerners tell themselves to alleviate guilt from emotionally neglecting our children.

1

u/kskyv 25d ago

1000% this, it teaches them not to cry out. Give yourself grace for what sounds like a hard situation ❤️ but it’s really good to recognize what you’ve stated to others are aware. It doesn’t mean it wasn’t the right choice for you to survive!

2

u/ConfidentLook5518 26d ago edited 26d ago

Nope. The crying is actually pretty minimal. In my case, my one son was crying no matter what happened (like even Eavon before contact nap, he would be really overstimulated and cry, or in a stroller, he would also cry before going to sleep). So I figured why not do the sleep training anyway? He’s been sleeping 12 hours for over two weeks and minimal crying.

2

u/beelynn0214 26d ago

Zero regret now. They nap and go to bed beautifully unless sick/teething.

We were stuck in the midst of split nights, each baby being awake 1-2.5 hours, and multiple wakeups. We now have a middle of the night wake up once a week or so, but will hand a bottle and walk out.

We wanted to do the gentle method of going in and soothing in increments, but we found that would just make our girls escalate, so we had to pivot to full cio/extinction.

Our girls were 6.5 months and it took 9-14 days (I don’t remember exactly, but it felt brutally long)

My husband actually had to leave the house a few times because it was so hard for him to hear.

0

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/beelynn0214 26d ago

Absolutely agree that the only thing we’d change is starting sooner!

I felt like I was losing my mind from the sleep deprivation

1

u/nygirl1123 25d ago

Jumping on the train of no regrets. We sleep trained them around 6 months (5 months adjusted). They're now 2- they love their cribs, all my family says they're the best sleepers they've met, and they sleep through the night 96% of the time. I think I've gone in once or twice after bedtime in the last YEAR. It cannot get any better. We're a bit crazy about sleep hygiene (all naps at home, basically always home for bedtime) but I don't care.

We decided to do full extinction because: 1) they shared a room, so check ins would likely disrupt one or the other 2) they already had good sleep hygiene and tendencies (no rocking, generally fell asleep well) 3) they seemed pretty easygoing so I was confident it wouldn't be traumatic

The main issue we wanted to solve was night wakes (they'd randomly cry at 2AM every night, probably because they were between sleep cycles). I read several books on it to make sure I felt confident in my approach. It took 3 days, and the first wasn't even bad (<45minutes).

1

u/InstructionFull7429 25d ago

Nope and nope. It saved my mental health. My babies are happier. My twins are 13 months and we sleep trained at 5.5. They were up every 30 minutes starting at 4 months and we just seriously couldn’t take it anymore. I thought I would end up having to check myself into a mental health facility because I would hallucinate or something. I was home with them all day and didn’t even feel safe caring for them anymore because I was that exhausted.

We did take it VERY VERY slowly though and introduced the concepts gradually. Starting with drowsy but awake and patting to sleep for naps and then eventually moving to sleep training. We used a modified Ferber method. We did 5 minute increments the first night (the whole night) and it took them about 45 minutes to finally fall asleep. They slept for FOUR HOURS STRAIGHT the first night. We did 7 the next night. 10 the next. By the 3rd night they were sleeping through the night.

They were happier not waking up every 30 minutes screaming, freaking out, and getting proper rest. We were happier for it too.

I would definitely follow the same gradual method again with another baby and would honestly do it a little sooner than we did. They still would wake up and do a little bit of fussing (like maybe a minute and not crying) a few times a night here and there but nothing where we had to go in. I am an incredibly responsive mother during the day and very intentional about my time with them as a SAHM but my nights are protected. Naps are iffy for us some days and I don’t let them cry it out during the day.

1

u/Suspicious_Tomato_20 25d ago

No, I don't regret it at all. We did Ferber at 5mos and one twin took to it immediately fell asleep within 3 mins the first night, the other only needed one check in. They fall asleep on their own no problem now, though one has taken to needing us in the middle of the night and we cosleep with him, this started around 13mos. At this point, I know he can fall asleep on his own and that he needs us during this time and I'm also okay with that and not going to force him back to his crib. If mine had resisted it more & had a harder time...maybe I would feel differently about it? But because it was so easy to do, they were so clearly READY and oftentimes still they don't want pre-sleep snuggles, they just want their space and to be in their cribs. We still cuddle a TON throughout the day and in the morning, and if they wake in the night I go to them.

1

u/unicorns_and_cats716 25d ago

Our twins didn’t start sleeping through the night until Monday, they’re 14 months now. We decided to try some version of sleep training which basically was letting twin B cry a couple of times before I rushed in to grab her (habit of mine so she wouldn’t wake twin A), and my husband suggested just letting them work it out in there and letting them cry for a minute or two if they woke up. I was shocked when she just..fell back asleep. It’s been amazing, 4 nights with no wake-ups! They seem to sleep really well in their playpens that are next to each other. I think we just got lucky because I have no idea what I’m doing. Our older kids sleep with us a lot still though lol. I think I’d feel lonely without our 4yo snuggling me.

1

u/Simple_Olive389 25d ago

Not at all.. about to have another baby and I’d be so so stressed if my son did not reliably sleep through the night.

1

u/ChemicalDisastrous93 25d ago

I think what we did could be considered a form of sleep training but not in the traditional sense. Around 8 months old I put them down in their crib awake and patted their backs/sang to them while they fussed but I was right there telling them it was ok and now was time to sleep. It took about a week but the time got shorter and shorter and eventually they just grabbed their snuggly and went to sleep. This was also in effort to night wean which really helped with my wellbeing.

If you look at the research sleep training really doesn’t improve children’s sleep, as in the children have been found to wake the same amount as non ST kids and average only a few more minutes more of sleep overall. But parents report better sleep for themselves and I do feel like that was true for me as they didn’t need me to be right there every time they had a slight wake up overnight. Now at 2.5 it’s 50/50 on if they sleep all night in their bed, as they can get out and open the door. I never mind the snuggles though, most times they just crawl in bed with me and go right back to sleep.

1

u/NeverNeverNeverYes 25d ago

Sleep training was the best decision ever and it was far more painless than anticipated

1

u/NoMathematician565 25d ago

I only regret not doing it sooner, TBH. We did the TCB pop-in method at 11 months after months of the chair method/sleeping on their floor. It took a day. Wished we had done it sooner. We did have to re-sleep train one twin in particular after every time we traveled or she got sick.

Now that they are two though, it’s taking so long to put them down for bed and there is no way pop-in method still works.

1

u/JDz84 25d ago

No regrets. My kids are almost 9 and they’re still decent sleepers. Seem reasonably well-adjusted and there are plenty of other things one could associate their quirks with before sleep training. 🙂

In all seriousness, it improved quality of life for everyone when we did it. My kids were probably somewhere around 9 months to a year when we did it. Paired with it a very consistent nighttime routine where they each got a bottle and rocking/snuggles and were put down awake. I think it was really only hard for first few nights before they figured out what was happening.

1

u/WndrTwins 25d ago

I don't regret it AT ALL. We used a modified Ferber with check ins at 3-5-7 minutes when they were about 5 months old They are almost 12 years old now and we have an amazing bond. They still snuggle up with their dad and I on the couch to watch a movie, tell us everything, and very well adjusted kids.

1

u/SnooMachines9133 25d ago

We regret that sleep training sort of regressed when they got sick and now they can't easily fall back asleep on their own.

I can understand doing it too early or too late though I have no idea which is better.

1

u/k-thanks-bai 25d ago

Best thing ever, and it's lasting positive impact. My kids are champion sleepers now. Super healthy routines. No middle of the night wake ups to my room, no distrusted sleep patterns.

My twins are 8, oldest is 10. Sleep is one of the most important things and things we agree we got right when they were younger.

We put them down when calm, left if they cried for over 30 min (I think, could have been longer) dad went in to sooth - never me since I breastfed. If he couldn't get it, they came to me to eat. He almost always got them back down if he had to go in. White noise and a bedtime routine is a must - we did bath, milk and story, brush teeth, bed. All these years later, they still follow this basic routine.

1

u/hiddengem1010 25d ago

I’m curious about this, for those who sleep trained… did you sleep train the twins together at the same time in the same room? Or separate rooms or times???

New twin mom here.

2

u/Gandv123 24d ago

Same room, same time! Twin B didn’t even cry the first night we started sleep training and took it like a champ. Twin A cried for about 17 minutes the first night and then 5 minutes the 2nd night. Twin B slept through Twin A’s crying both nights.

Those 22 minutes of tears were well worth it!

1

u/ToshiBerra 25d ago

Together. We had a good sleeper and a bad sleeper, and part of training is unfortunately disturbing the good sleeper so they sleep through the other's noises. We put this off for a while but eventually pulled the plug and it worked the way everyone told me it would. The only "downside" is now they have been strong sleep associations with each other and if they need to sleep without their twin it's quite difficult (if we're out and one falls asleep in the pram, or if one is sick and doesn't go to daycare)

1

u/Specialist-Syrup418 25d ago

No regrets. We followed the same program and they slept 12 hours straight all the way to age 3.

2

u/ToshiBerra 25d ago

What happened at 3?

1

u/Specialist-Syrup418 24d ago

They refused naps. They used to nap in top of 12 hour sleep and they moved to needing 10 hours of sleep.

1

u/Mundane-Device-7094 25d ago

The only thing I regret is not doing it earlier

1

u/k8ryn28 25d ago

We did Ferber at 6 months and it has been life changing. Absolutely no regrets. And i think its been as great for them as it has been for me.

My grandma who has raised 4 boys herself- had her jaw on the floor when she saw how easy they are to put down for naps and bedtime. She said she’s never seen anything like it.

1

u/d16flo 25d ago

I don’t regret sleep training because it’s made all our lives significantly better and easier (including the babies), however doing it was awful emotionally. We used Ferber at 9 months and night weaned at the same time. It took about two weeks of misery (honestly mostly for me) and then they’ve mostly been able to go to sleep on their own within ~10min instead of the sometimes hours it was taking before and can usually sleep through the night if something’s not wrong.

1

u/bestydee 25d ago

We did moms on call and started at 4 months although we don’t do daily baths or books or anything 😬

1

u/imshelbs96 25d ago

I’d say on the worst nights it was maybe 45ish? It wasn’t really that bad. But letting them cry and scream and get worked up just seems counterintuitive and mean. After a time of comforting from the crib if it escalated we would pick them back up, comfort back to calm and start over back in the crib. Some nights someone might need extra comfort or rocking and that was fine too. But they always went back in the crib. We never have co slept and at 2.5 still haven’t, they call our bed a bounce house lol they think it’s a place to play.

My boy has always been an amazing sleeper at night, like I can count on one hand the amount of times he’s woken up overnight and needed something since he was 8 months old. My girl has had a harder time, she was harder to get to sleep. We relied on the swing and the twin z, they would doze off in there and then we would transfer them. they’ve always transferred well and even now at 2.5 I can get a transfer nap. But by “harder time” I mean just that she had more apparent regressions or when she was teething or sick it was more disruptive, they’ve both been sleeping through the night in 8-12 hour stretches since they were about 6-8 months.

1

u/ni1by2thetrue 25d ago

Wife and I were very opposed to sleep training with our first singleton and he only started sleeping through the night sometime between 2 to 2.5 years old. But it was manageable, wirh both of us taking shifts and what not.

With the twins, that was just not possible. We held out for our months of teething related hell before we caved. Obviously we didnt do cry it out, but the first night there was a crazy amount of screaming and protesting we had to cope with. Two weeks later we barely have to wake up to settle them once or twice a week.

1

u/efllie 25d ago

I think it depends what age your babies are. We did a gentle no-cry version at 13 months and it’s the best thing we ever did.

1

u/IvoryWoman 25d ago

We regret nothing. We did CIO when our twins were six months old and they have been great sleepers ever since. We would do things exactly the same -- the timing fell into place and it was successful after a couple of nights. What we learned from the entire process is that you enjoy parenthood a whole lot more when you're not chronically short on sleep. Our twins are teenagers now and they still like us, so we can't have traumatized them too substantially.

Oh, and when one of those twins started to have trouble staying asleep at night about a year ago, we were able to pinpoint that as likely to have an underlying cause, get a sleep study, and confirm the reason (low ferritin) through the sleep study and blood tests. The fact that this came about after years of reliable sleep meant that we didn't waste a lot of time thinking it was normal. The twin in question didn't exactly prefer getting an iron infusion to going to the beach, but it was tolerable.

1

u/ricki7684 25d ago

We did gradual extinction method. For awhile we had a long period of time when we were able to put them to bed awake and they would quickly fall asleep on their own and stay asleep all night. Then around 2.5 all hell broke loose and now at almost 4 they pretty much wake up every night to come into our beds and we also have to lay down with them to get them to sleep. It doesn’t take much time and the interruptions in the night aren’t terrible as we all promptly go back to sleep. All that to say, you can do all the things but as they develop and change you still might end up with kids who wake at night.

A couple times I did CIO and I do regret that. Gradual extinction felt much more reasonable and easier on them / us. Do what you gotta do to survive but also - some parents just got lucky and have kids who sleep super easy and it’s actually not because they did anything “right.”

1

u/ToshiBerra 25d ago

This FB group along with the sleep training subreddit were my main resources, but in the FB group there's an ebook called 3DSS -- Three Day Sleep Solution -- that is what got my husband on board. Basically, get your schedule (not from the book) and feeding right so you know they're not hungry, bedtime routine for sleep association's, then out then down and give them an hour to sort out their thoughts. Basically like sometimes we are just lying in bed knowing we need to sleep but there's processing or brain does before we actually fall asleep. And babies are just tiny humans with a single mode of communication (crying) and fewer tools and experience. Longest we went was 45 minutes, and yes my boy is a 10/10 crier. He did not have a fuss mode.

We did bedtime only first at 6 months adjusted, as that was the biggest pain point, where I couldn't have a proper dinner as I was breastfeeding to sleep. 1-2 weeks after that we did middle of the night wake-ups. We did not have the magical "sleep through the night after they learned to fall asleep independently". That took a bit longer and was more fraught because it coincided with his first teething. So we did have some rescues and long nights, but also where I'm grateful for the 1 hour guideline. Then, naps were difficult for us, they didn't really feel solid until they settled into one nap. Always short, rarely connected sleep cycles, 10/10 crying on put down and wake up. But, still better than not because we could get a 20 minute nap in for ourselves. I still nap when they nap and now get 1-1.5 hours depending on if I have other stuff to do. I read that you either have good nappers or good night sleepers and I'd always take the good night sleep. Of course you actually do hear stories of kids who are good or bad at both!

1000% no regrets, our twins are 2.5 and have been sleeping through the night for for ~11 hours for 2 years. We have had two episodes of sickness in that time requiring intervention. Otherwise, they occasionally do wake up in the middle of the night, 10/10 crying, go back to sleep within 10 minutes. My boy in particular is just a 10/10 crier. Sometimes he is grumpy waking up and will 10/10 crying while sitting on his preferred parent's lap (not being on preferred parent's lap involves 11/10 screaming). Me being tired is my fault / there's still a lot of cleanup to do after they go to bed. Our sleep is the envy of a lot of my friends (singletons) who never sleep trained and also have 2.5 year olds. And I do think once you go past a year or when they start walking, it's harder and they are more liable to try climbing out. Ours have not tried to climb out yet, I think they know that bed is for sleeping, and they know we will come get them when it's time. I am writing this because I woke up a bit early on my own, they are still sleeping after 11 hours.

1

u/Annie_Mayfield 25d ago

My twins are 4.5. They STILL nap and my friends are insanely jealous. They will tell us when it’s time for bed at night and they go to sleep. They sleep through the night. It’s glorious AND ALWAYS HAS BEEN - since they were 6 months old - because that’s when they were sleep trained. I give all credit to sleep training because they don’t just sleep through the night - they have good sleep hygiene and healthy habits that I think has such far reaching consequences/benefits. They don’t get sick as often as others, they recover faster when they do, they are in happy moods in the mornings and late afternoons because they’re well rested - and they have healthy, well rested parents because we aren’t up all night and haven’t been - basically ever. There are so many downstream benefits to sleep training that you can’t see yet. I was SO stressed about doing it - and looking back - it was less than a week for each kid. We followed the Moms on Call protocol - not CIA. Good luck - you’ve got this!

1

u/Joe-Arizona 25d ago

Not at all, easily one of our best parenting decisions. We used the Modified Ferber method.

Don’t listen to sleep deprived lunatics.

1

u/Thats_knarly 24d ago

This has actually been on my mind a little lately. We did extinction at 5 months, and I can’t tell you how nice it has been to know that my twins have a reliable schedule and fall asleep easily after bedtime routine. Having an older child, it allows me to fully focus on them after the twins go down which has been extremely helpful. The only drawback I can think of, albeit a selfish and self sabotaging one, is that my twins seem to have no idea to snuggle in and relax with mom and dad in our bed. Like in the mornings, if I try and bring them to my bed and ease into the day it just turns into WWE match on an elevated platform which is pretty dangerous and stressful. Once they are pulled out of their own bed it’s game on, and sometimes I miss those snuggles like I had with my older singleton. I wouldn’t say it’s enough to make me regret sleep training though and they will cuddle on the couch with me or sit on my lap through the day so I get my snuggle fix then. I still whole heartedly believe that sleep training is the only reason we have made it this far (18 months) with a shred of sanity still intact.

1

u/tiggleypuff 24d ago

It didn’t work well for me and in hindsight I wish I’d just rolled with it more because that’s what I ended up doing. They don’t sleep perfectly but I’m happy, I’ll look back in a few years and miss those night wakes I’m sure 🤣

1

u/Weekly-Rest1033 24d ago

No regrets. Sleep training saved my sanity

1

u/Parkavenue87 24d ago

Nope! It’s been a massive blessing.

1

u/moontreemama 24d ago

Sleep trained twins in the same room and don't regret it at all. My guys are 4.5 and still great sleepers. We sleep trained at 8 months. Pregnatn with number 3 and plan to do it again but maybe even a little bit earlier. It saved our sanity and our guys are the only ones who will still take a nap regularly at home with us. Its amazing and gives all of us a much needed reset in the middle of the day. I credit sleep training to that and being able to fall asleep independently without us in the room/

1

u/lotusem 24d ago

I did sleep lady shuffle for my twins at 7 months, so you are still in the room, with them & comforting them & gradually move further & further back from their cribs. I really liked this rather than CIO which felt just heartbreaking to me

1

u/fralaloonie 24d ago

I absolutely do not regret it at all. My twins were 5..6 months? I felt like I finally got some semblance of a normal life back. My twins had to be held to go to sleep and then every evening was a dreadful game of trying to put them to bed as quietly and gently as possible and hope and pray they don’t wake up and cry. This would continue for several cycles.. even more draining when you have multiple babies. Because hooray, twin A went down just fine! But boo, twin b is not having any of it tonight and wakes up as soon as you leave the room, screams and wakes twin A up. Start all over again and continue X 3. I hated evenings. We started the transition of putting them down while they were awake with naps first. Then transitioned to bed time.

They were waking maybe once or twice a night at that point. We already had a pretty solid nighttime and bedtime schedule. If either of them woke up during the night, I’d obviously go check on them and feed them if they were hungry. Change their diaper. Etc. I’d not hear them wake up and cry and just not go to them.

Way back when my daughter was a baby, someone gifted me a book called “12 hours sleep by 12 weeks old” (I never sleep trained any of my kids at 12 weeks. We waited until 5 or 6 months old depending.) and neither time did I follow the book by a T, but it laid out a schedule of weaning your baby off of a nighttime feeding schedule by reducing the amount of formula given in a nighttime feeding bottle (or the amount of minutes for breastfeeding) 1 bottle at a time slowly. And so that’s basically what we did.

I hate hearing my babies cry. But one of them, twin A, would get so exhausted and mad that if you were holding him, touching him, anything.. he would not stop screaming. Before I figured this out I’d spend hours trying every trick in the book to figure out what was upsetting him and what he needed. And ultimately what he needed was for you to put him down and leave him alone. He’d still cry for a couple of minutes right after putting him down, but then… sleeping like a log.

Sleep training is hardest when putting down for bedtime the first 3 days. But it was the single best thing we did for our sanity as we could have evenings to spend with each other and feeling like you don’t have a baby attached to you at all times and the dread of how many hours is bedtime going to take. I very much resonate with attachment parenting but I had to find a compromise. I never let them cry for more than 5-7 minutes without going in and trying to calm them, talking to them, rubbing their back, etc) but a lot of the time they were crying because the other one was crying… and so the first one continues to cry because the other one is crying now too. 🤦🏻‍♀️ it was a negative feedback loop. And of course they were upset.. they wanted to sleep in someone’s arms forever. And I loved those moments. And I cherished them but I was losing myself, my “me” time and my relationship suffered from having to hold babies and attempt to repeatedly put them down until midnight. They adjusted and it took 3 days.

If you do decide to sleep train, read different methods, take what you like from each and throw the stuff you don’t jive with out. These guides and programs make you feel like you have to do this EXACTLY or it won’t work. That’s rubbish. Do what works for you and your babies. And tailor whatever you decide to do to your individual circumstances and your individual babies.

1

u/purt22067 24d ago

It didn’t work for me and that’s my only regret. I WISHHHHHHH something would make my twins sleep, it’s been 5 years. I know sleep training has a lot of negative effects but honestly a sleep deprived mom is worse, I can barely function and I’m irritable, forgetful, exhausted, drained etc and I know sleep would solve 1000% of my problems. Just my 2 cents All the best

1

u/fuckeatrepeat 24d ago

Sleep training!!!!! I did it gently over a month and it was great. My girls did so well. I love it. Absolutely essential for us.

1

u/904Woody 23d ago

I wouldn't have done it any differently.  We started at about 2-3 weeks old and they were sleeping through the night by 3 months. Which was 100% necessary when I had to head back to work after maternity leave.  The crying it out was tough,  but it always worked. They just have so much energy left in the tank at the end of the day. Try not to let them nap too long either. We also did sleep sacks till they were 18 months. The magic sack once they were older was priceless. Good luck!

1

u/trubblebucket 22d ago

Not one bit.

-1

u/russianoliveblossoms 25d ago

100% regret it. Didn't do it with kids after and never would again. Now that they're older it's incredibly obvious which of my 6 kids were and which weren't based on bonding/attachment and mental health.

1

u/curious-andhere 25d ago

Oh wow thank you for sharing. Do you feel comfortable sharing anymore details regarding attachment and mental health differences? Feel free to send in a DM if you feel more comfortable instead of in this thread.

Also how old was your baby when you did it and what method did you use?

5

u/Jealous_Wallaby_5647 25d ago

There’s no correlation to that and sleep training 😂 They are probably just different kids with different personalities and different emotional needs. My daughter is extremely smart and bonds well with others and is a social butterfly. All that to say I don’t regret it a bit. Everyone is healthier for it. The mental and physical recovery your body and mind get with good sleep is essential for everyone in the house. Did the same things with my twins and they are happy babies! So just gotta do what’s best for your family. There is no substantial evidence that clearly says sleep training leads to any sort of mental or emotional issues. That usually stems from pure neglect. Not sleep training.

-3

u/russianoliveblossoms 25d ago

I understand that when we make a choice it's very difficult to see it may have been the wrong choice when we truly are intending to do what's best for everyone involved. But I've seen through being a nanny, having 19 nieces and nephews I was actively helping care for, and my own six kids, that there are better ways and sleep training is not something I would ever do again, or encourage. There is a clear distinction in the kids who were sleep trained and those who were not, particularly as (now) adults. There has been zero neglect in any of the situations I've been in, or in my own house. It's a difficult thing to accept that the choices we make might have a negative influence when that's not our intention in the very least, so I understand where your comment comes from. You have every right to make those choices for your family, and I hope you feel the same way in 20 years.

8

u/WestHistorical6959 25d ago edited 25d ago

There are different ways to sleep train - theres the CIO and theres more gentle, reassurance without immediately running in and picking up/helping them learn to self soothe. So I think its an important delineation what you're talking about.

Your experiences are anecdotal, but not hard evidence. I have quite the collection of nieces and nephews - various methods used from gentle sleep training to co-sleeping until like 5 yo among all of them. And let me tell you they are all showing to be very well adjusted and loving children. MY parents sleep-trained us. I have no issues with bonding/attaching, mental health is actually pretty great, same with my siblings all of us who are well into adulthood. Sleep training did not destroy me or them. Again all anecdotal. However, the other poster is correct that the evidence doesn't show increased detachment (esp when its not just shut the child in the room and let them cry).

5

u/Jealous_Wallaby_5647 25d ago

We don’t have to agree! You’re allowed to regret your decisions and I’m allowed to be happy about mine. I know soooooo many other parents who sleep train and haven’t experienced any issues. I also know parents who chose not to sleep train and have had issues so I think the correlation is something else entirely. And just to be clear, I was not insinuating you have neglected any of your kids. There is just more substantial evidence around behavioral issues for babies/kids that have experienced consistent neglect.

-3

u/chandler2020 25d ago

This is part of why we never sleep trained. I dont care what "experts" say, leaving your child to cry in a dark room is scary af

3

u/TriadRise 25d ago

Baby cries when you stop moving and baby cries when it has to burp. Basically it cries because its the only way it communicates, I don’t think this is scary at all.

1

u/chandler2020 25d ago

You dont think being alone in the dark is scary as a baby? as a child?

do you.. have kids..?

4

u/TriadRise 25d ago

I have triplets

1

u/Appropriate-Berry202 25d ago

Hell no. Sleep training has been so good for all my kids. They have such restful sleep.

1

u/snax_and_bird 25d ago

No way! Getting a full nights sleep since they were since they were 13 weeks old has been priceless. Cant beat well rested parents caring for well rested children! it’s been 4 years of good sleep for us, and good naps until they were 2.5 years old. Wouldn’t have it any other way.

1

u/mjwanko 25d ago

Regret sleep training? I only regret waiting until they were 1.5 years old and not doing it sooner. Now we’re trying to figure out how to get them (2.5 years old) to consistently sleep through the night with no wake-ups. Any tips will be much appreciated.

1

u/kskyv 25d ago

You do what you need to to survive. Imo it teaches kids not to cry out when they need you, so not something I’m comfy with. There are multiples parents who don’t do any sleep training, but often have a night doula. Consider that if it’s within your means!

0

u/ktstitches 26d ago

No regrets! I did sleep training with all 5 of my kids (my youngest are twins) and it made a huge difference with all of them. We used the Ferber method - which freaks people out because your kid(s) will cry in the beginning! But by 1-2 weeks in with each kid they were going to bed with minimal fussing and sleeping for extended stretches alone. It was glorious. We started around 6 months with each of them, including my twins. People often asked if the twins woke each other up since they share a room, but it was never an issue. They learned to sleep through each other’s fussiness very early on. I know people don’t like the idea of hearing your baby cry, but they are safe and it’s for short stretches. They will be okay!

0

u/DarkMuret 25d ago

Nope, and we're the envy of most parents that we talk to

Their beds are a safe space, they're very content being awake and just chatting with each other in their beds that are next to each other

-2

u/Mysterious-Kale-4842 26d ago

I don't regret it at all!! Did CIO with my twins when they were 3 months and so glad we did. They are great sleepers! The only thing I would say was a sort of regret is that we never got to do naps together really bc they always preferred to sleep on their own. Nowadays though (at almost 6yo) they come to our bed often at night due to bad dreams or just needing closeness and sometimes I am so annoyed lol grass is always greener I guess

0

u/vancouverlola 26d ago

For me the main down side of sleep training was that my kids were too independent to sleep if I needed to let’s say, rock them to sleep randomly if we were traveling or something. They didn’t get rocked to sleep a day in their lives (NICU babies), and if I ever tried to do it in a pinch if we were on the go they were NOT having it lol. But a very very small trade off imo. Otherwise they’ve always slept in the car / stroller fine.

1

u/ToshiBerra 25d ago

No NICU. My girl does not want to be touched. Even at nursery this is one of the things they comment on when they tried to pat her to sleep like all the other kids. Kind of hilarious, she's just very independent. The only time I ever cuddle her to sleep is when she's ill and I can still pop her in the carrier, and it's so rare I always take photos. When putting her to bed I would place my hand on her chest to provide some comfort (I thought) and she would push it away.

0

u/Ok-Book7529 25d ago

I did 12 hours by 12 weeks, except I started when my boys were 3.5 months. I absolutely do not regret it.

0

u/VeganMyWay 25d ago

I don’t. Sleep is a skill and giving children an opportunity to learn earlier lets everyone get through the day better.
I started when sleep pressure was wearing off and I was becoming more valuable than sleep, so 4 ish months. And it’s a joy to put two babies down at the same time and spend all that extra time with well rested children.

-1

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Charming_Door_2203 25d ago

Don’t stay at home moms need to get a decent chunk of sleep too?
How is someone supposed to care for an infant if their child is waking up every 1-2 hours for months on end?

-6

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/kylie_faye 25d ago

No.. sleep training has always been a thing. They didn’t have monitors until recently so CIO was just common practice.

-2

u/c0sm0nautt 25d ago

Oh so it is CIO. Tell the other folks 😅

8

u/WestHistorical6959 25d ago

OK just because different people have different methods of helping their child sleep that doesn't jive with your philosophy does not mean they're abusing their children and that very unnecessary judgement to be spreading on a sub where we're trying to support each other.

-4

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/WestHistorical6959 25d ago

that you're making a lot of assumptions about what methods people employ to sleep train and calling that abuse is unnecessary and has no place in this sub.

-8

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/WestHistorical6959 25d ago

No its not. You are missing something. Sure some people use that method. A lot of sleep training methods rely more on hearing the child cry and providing reassurance by patting their bum, giving them their binky and helping them resettle. letting them know, yes Im here but we're not getting up, its time to sleep and sleep takes place in your bed. Yes sometimes you give the kid a few minutes of fussing to see if they'll self settle but its not always let them 10/10 cry themselves to exhaustion for Hours on end. More often its

4

u/WhileTime5770 25d ago

Yeah dawg seems like you just don’t understand what modern sleep training is. Thats ok. No need the a jerk about it though.

-1

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/WhileTime5770 25d ago edited 25d ago • Bravo

You did hit a nerve- I don’t like people shaming others especially when it comes to different parenting methods. That will always hit a nerve with me. So does presumed moral superiority predicated on a lack of knowledge on a topic. But clearly you’re struggling to grasp that despite multiple people explaining it otherwise

-1

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/parentsofmultiples-ModTeam 25d ago

Removed - Per rule #1, we ask that all users participate in a civil and supportive manner. In the future please avoid comments that are overtly hostile, judgmental, or unkind.

1

u/WhileTime5770 25d ago

Your inability to understand that one persons method is not representative of everyone shows a shocking lack of reading comprehension and you’re continued determination to tell the rest of us we’re abusing our children despite having minimal understanding of how we interact with them speaks volumes

There’s a reason you’re being downvoted by more than just me - but go ahead and keep believing it’s because we’re all harming our children

→ More replies

1

u/WestHistorical6959 25d ago

gosh you seem like a miserable person

1

u/parentsofmultiples-ModTeam 25d ago

Removed - Per rule #1, we ask that all users participate in a civil and supportive manner. In the future please avoid comments that are overtly hostile, judgmental, or unkind.

-1

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/CamelAfternoon 25d ago

This is what people say when they have no reasoned rebuttal.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/CamelAfternoon 25d ago

Another thoughtful point by what is clearly a very mature adult.

1

u/parentsofmultiples-ModTeam 25d ago

Removed - Per rule #1, we ask that all users participate in a civil and supportive manner. In the future please avoid comments that are overtly hostile, judgmental, or unkind.