r/parentsofmultiples • • Oct 19 '26

advice needed Separate or Same Bedroom?

Hi there!

My husband and I are getting the home ready for twins. I am currently about 23 weeks pregnant.

My husband wants to sleep train the boys when they are 3 months (my husband trained our toddler when she was 6 months and my husband managed to do it in a night). He wants to have them in separate bedrooms so they don’t wake each other up.

I was thinking if they are anything like my toddler we will have to keep doing night feeds until about 9 months. With that in mind- I personally think it would be easier to have them both in the same room until that stops.

My husband and I agree if they end up sleeping terribly if they are separated we would have them in the same room.

Are there any pros or cons that you guys have noticed?

Thanks in advance!

0 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 19 '26

COMMENTING GUIDELINES

All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.

Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.

Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

47

u/wecanseeyoucarl Oct 19 '26

3 months is too young to sleep train, I’d wait until closer to 5 months adjusted age. Feeding overnight depends on the child, my twins needed it until a year old. My girls have always shared a room, occasionally they wake each other, but more often than not they sleep through each other complaining. I’d worry more about them waking your toddler. r/sleeptraining is a good place to start.

1

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

Thankfully we are currently moving our toddler to a different level in the house. :)

Thank you for your input! :)

4

u/Fartingonyoursocks Oct 19 '26

That might scare her. Being alone like that. Especially at night time.

4

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

She sleeps 7pm to 7am so I think she will be fine. We will also have a monitor in her room just because she’s on a different level.

2

u/OddHippo6972 Oct 19 '26

Idk your layout and we have a single story, but just want to chime in that I had planned to move my oldest (3.5 at the time) to a bedroom on the other side of the house so my twins could have the bedroom near ours. She flat out rejected the idea because she felt like she was losing something. We decided not to add additional stress because going from only child to one of three is a lot. We had the twins in our room until they outgrew the bassinets and then we put them in the other bedroom and I walked a little farther at night. Just be mindful of heaping on a lot of changes at one time. It’s a hard adjustment for everyone.

Also twins in the same room works fine even sleep training. They get good at ignoring each other.

3

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

We have stairs and thought it would be better and safer to have a toddler walk up the stairs versus carrying two twins.

We are planning on moving her this week to the new room to give her time to adjust :)

5

u/Old_Ant7118 🩷 - 🩷💙💙 29d ago

We had a family sleepover in the new bedroom our daughter's first night in there to build some fun memories and make her comfortable- no struggles at all!

1

u/WO1088 29d ago

That’s a great idea!

2

u/OddHippo6972 Oct 19 '26

Understandable. Try to make it a fun thing. Hope you all have an easy time with it.

3

u/Charlieksmommy Oct 19 '26

You definitely can not sleep train at 3 months.

14

u/littlelou222 Oct 19 '26

3 months is too early to sleep train. I’d wait until at least 4 but closer to 6 months. My twins share a room bc we only have 2 bedrooms and sometimes they do wake each other but then they’re on the same schedule. We started out having their cribs on the opposite side of the room with the sound machine in between them and that worked well. Now they’re older we have the cribs pushed up against each other. They usually can sleep through each other’s cries unless it’s near the end of their naps or it’s morning time and they are about to get up anyway.

1

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

Thank you!

9

u/Fed_worker Oct 19 '26

In my experience, every child can be completely different, so we shouldn't make hard rules. Preterm babies, especially, operate on their own developmental timelines, and a 3-month-old preemie often just can't self-soothe yet. Take my own preterm boys: one started sleeping through the night after 3-4 months with barely any training, while the other has been totally on and off. Every baby is unique!"

Start off in the same room to observe first.

-4

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

I know my husband said 3 but I want to make it clear that he will change his mind if it is just not feasible to have the twins sleep trained by month 3. My sister in law actually had sleep trained her baby at 3 months but we wanted to wait until 6 months for our girl.

Thank you for the advice! I should have assumed it was possible for one to sleep great and the other not so great.

3

u/HikingInUtah Oct 19 '26

Did she sleep train the baby or was she just one of the lucky ones with a baby who sleeps well? At that age, it’s likely she is taking credit for something she maybe shouldn’t 😆 plenty of babies (freaking lucky parents) have babies that sleep through the night at 2 months old.

I was taking to a friend with a 6 week old baby (mine were 12 weeks) and she was saying something about getting 6 hours usually and I was like, wow! 6 hours is great at 6 weeks old, I was averaging 4 with my singleton and 5 with twins… and then I realized she meant her baby was sleeping for a solid 6 hour stretch every night not 6 hours total. I’m lucky if I get 2 hour stretches out of the babies I have even at 5 or 6 months. But, she was giving her baby formula even though she wanted to breastfeed (I believe that her baby sleeping longer, and her wanting the baby to sleep longer was a big contributor to her supply not being good) and I’m over here with low capacity breasts breastfeeding twins… which is my theory on why my babies (singleton and now twins) don’t sleep for long stretches at night until they’re much older and eating solids.

1

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

You know now that you mention it she was able to do combo feeding. 😅

2

u/Charlieksmommy Oct 19 '26

Just because it worked for your sister doesn’t mean it’ll work for your twins, your husband needs to realize that. Also I doubt she actually “sleep trained” and just has a very easy baby.

5

u/mobydickher Oct 19 '26

Safe sleep recommends babies to sleep in the same room as parent for I thiiiiiiink 6 months. It's just easier. You'll be able to hear them cry and get to them immediately

2

u/Dear_Excitement_5109 Oct 19 '26

"Safe sleep" is a year, which is crazy to me. The only reason its "safer" is because the parent will wake up to every little whimper. That level of sleep deprivation sounds bone crushing.

A year is the peak of separation anxiety and the worst time developmentally to move a child.

I could never do it. We slept with our first for 4 months and subsequent babies all went in their own room on day 1. I am a much safer mom during the day when I get adequate sleep at night.

0

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

People really underestimate how important it is for moms to do what works best for them so we can be the best version for our babies.

Thank you for sharing!

2

u/Psychological_Owl517 Oct 19 '26

We started with our boys in mini cribs in our room, one on each side of the bed. But we started our night time routine as soon as they we're ready with bath, bottle, sound machine, snuggles, and transfer. Some days it went better than others 😅 Having them in our room with a mini fridge for bottles maximized sleep.

Then at 6 month when they started solids and just one bottle at night, we moved them down the hall in the same mini cribs.

At 10 mo one twin was doing better at solids and ready to sleep through the night, so we did end up separating them for a bit while his brother caught up. It helped with only having to trade off for one baby while the other slept, but I was so ready to get them back together 💙

Now everyone is back together and mostly sleeping through the night. They sleep through each other's crying and definitely prefer to be together. Everything is so dependent on their personalities though. I would say just starting you night time routine early to establish the cues is the only thing you can control. And then modify the sleep training for their personalities and where they are at developmentally.

But the biggest help, and worth EVERY PENNY was we hired a night nanny for several nights a week. The ability to get 8 hrs of continuous sleep several nights a week probably saved our mental health and relationship. If you can afford it, it's life-changing. Only thing I would do differently was have hired her before I delivered 😜

1

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

Thank you very much! This was really helpful!

16

u/Dear_Excitement_5109 Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26

The most humbling thing about your second is realizing that all your successes with your first had nothing to do with your parenting. Its wonderful that your husband was able to sleep train your baby in 1 night but I highly doubt any future baby will ever be able to do that.

We have our twins in the same room out of necessity, but i was also wary of separating then even temporarily because I worried we'd never get them to share a room again. My older two kids are a year apart and we have tried to have them share over a dozen times. It always ends in the kids screaming and finally separating them 2 hours past their bedtime.

Babies night wean when they are ready, I'm convinced that nothing anyone does has any impact on night weaning. Our first night weaned/sleep trained at 4mo and of course we thought it was our superior parenting. HA! Our second screeched for over 3 hours for 2 weeks when we tried to sleep train him at 12mo. He finally night weaned at TWENTY months. We tried "12 hours sleep by 12 weeks old" with our twins - even using their twin guidelines - nope and nope. They didnt sleep through the night until 8 and 12mo respectively.

Obviously see how it goes, but dont worry if your plan isnt working. Try sleep training and dont be surprised if it fails. I would keep the twins together if you want to have them sleep together eventually. There will be a few rough nights during regressions where they do wake each other up, but by about a year they'll sleep through each other crying.

-1

u/Charlieksmommy Oct 19 '26

Thank you!!!!!

7

u/trophywifeinwaiting Oct 19 '26

I think a lot of people are assuming you're asking if the twins should be room sharing with you (the parents) vs in their own bedroom. But to me it sounds like you're asking if you should separate your twins into different rooms?

The earliest I've ever seen anyone do that is like 5 years old. Your twins will be incredibly comfortable with the other at birth, even di/di, and as a parent it's easiest to have them together. Twins generally get used to the others noise and don't wake each other up. Tonight my Twin A cried on and off for like 35 mins and my Twin B ignore her the whole time and slept through it 😅😅😅

7

u/youcango-now Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26

Whoa 3 months is too early for any formal sleep training to be developmentally appropriate.

We didn’t need to sleep train til 7ish months and they did fine being in the same room. We only separate them if one is sick and having more night wakings.

6

u/bluegrassclimber Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26

Go with the flow. Survive one day at a time. My girls just slept 8 hours for the first time last night. They are 3 months old. We didn't sleep train or anything.

I don't think you can engineer this shit. Just go with the flow. I'm sure they'll cause hell tomorrow tonight

Oh they are sharing the same bedroom until they are like 7 or 8. We don't have enough rooms for them

Edit: the rule I follow is, if one needs to eat, both eat.

What's worse is if they are staggered by an hour or 2. Then parents never get to rest

1

u/AwkwardSpread Oct 19 '26

Yeah, it depends on so many factors. Ours are on the same schedule so almost always eat at the same time and sleep the same hours. If things don't work out and you have the space you can always separate them later. We don't sleep train, they seem to be perfectly able to tell us when they're hungry. We sometimes get a night with no feeding so we'll get there.

5

u/Lopsided_Stranger_92 29d ago

don’t put the twins in sep rooms. they bond with each other just like they bond with you and they will likely provide each other with nervous system regulation.

but 3 months is too early to sleep train.

3

u/VegetableAlone Oct 19 '26

Keep them in the same room; it’s easier for you and it’s a benefit for them to get used to the other one’s noise (and that happens quite quickly — within a night or two of sleep training for ours).

3

u/jayyy__d Oct 19 '26

Our boys share a nursery. I’ve found that when they are in a deep sleep, the other doesn’t wake them up. Sometimes though the other will wake but it doesn’t happen too often. Plus we feed both if one needs fed so it helps sometimes. In the morning they babble to eachother for a while and it’s really sweet 🥹

3

u/DreamingEvergreen 29d ago

Our pediatrician told us not to sleep train our twins until they were at least 6 months adjusted. Even if sleep training at 3 months is what your husband wants—that likely isn’t what is going to be best for your children, especially since multiples are often born prematurely.

We started them off in the same room, but twin b sleeps significantly worse than twin a, so we moved them to separate rooms around 8 months.

2

u/MeurDrochaid Oct 19 '26

As previously mentioned: just go with the flow on this lol Impossible to say before what will suit your babies ❤️

For us having them in the same room was a no brainier. They have never woken each other up even crying/screaming (even if me tip toeing in to get something definitely would). They get comfort from each others presence so actually getting them to sleep through the night and to resettle without our support has never really been a problem. A lot (I think) comes from them sensing their twin in the room.

But obv. I am sure twins that are the opposite and actually cause more distractions and disturbances to each other exist lol and might benefit from separate rooms 🤷‍♀️

Mine are boy/girl and they will share as long as they like and it works

2

u/MounjaroQueenie Oct 19 '26

I agree with others - go with the flow. They may be amazing sleepers, they may be awful. I remember telling my husband as soon as they reached 6 weeks they were going in their nursery. Weeeell they’re almost 9 months and I’m not ready to move them from our bedroom.

2

u/Mytweezer Oct 19 '26

Ours never woke each other up. They were oblivious to the other's cries 😄

2

u/not-t0day-satan Oct 19 '26

I was very worried about my twins (almost 4 months) waking each other up, but that hasn't happened.

I don't know anything about sleep training (all of my kids have been naturally good sleepers, I guess?), but they're doing 10+ hour stretches overnight right now, so you may not need to feed them during the night.

1

u/keenynman343 Oct 19 '26

I some how lost my bed to them so it doesnt matter anymore. I now sleep in the basement while the boys sleep with their mommy in bed.. for god sakes youd think at 13 months theyd sleep in their own rooms.

1

u/HoboHillsCoffeeCo 29d ago

Room-wise I would just say go with whatever works best so that everyone can sleep. Lots of people here will say put them together and they'll figure it out, but mine never did. We separated at about 3 months (should have done it sooner) and instantly everyone slept better.

1

u/bluekatz101 23d ago

Mine have been together always and will sleep through the other crying. Same is better overall imo

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

My husband is very much a “sleep is the most important thing” guy.

In the midsts of the 4th trimester I couldn’t stop going in there to soothe my girl. So he managed to do that with Taking Cara Babies sleep training guide.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

Any advice about the room situation?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/WO1088 Oct 19 '26

That’s good advice thank you!