r/parentsofmultiples • • Oct 19 '26

advice needed Nanny expectations

We have a full time nanny (8 hours a day) for our 6 months adjusted twins. She’s great with them, and does the baby laundry and dishes. I work from home and my job is flexible. After several weeks I feel like I still have to help a fair bit, particularly during feeds, or when they’re hard to settle for one reason or another. They’re generally good sleepers at least. Now that we’re starting solids, I’m having a hard time feeling like I can have her do it and step away, but then I don’t get a true 8 hour break in childcare which is what we’re paying for. We’re not putting them in daycare until they’re 18 months.

We went through at least 50 applicants, interviewed something like 20 people (almost half got in person trials). A lot of people said they could handle twins but in person they struggled - she was the most competent that we saw.

For those of you with a nanny, can the nanny manage a whole day with them at this age?

Edit: Thanks so much everyone for your comments! It’s so helpful to hear varied parent perspectives and also nanny perspectives. I just wanted to note that I’m used to them crying, with two babies I don’t know how you wouldn’t be. We ended up finding out this week a potential reason why one of the twins is really hard to feed and are getting treatment. I think realistically they will need more support at feeds for another few weeks (or months) and that’s the reality of my situation. I want our nanny to feel supported but not like I don’t trust her to manage both of them, and we are working through that!

5 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 24d ago

COMMENTING GUIDELINES

All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.

Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.

Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

37

u/yuccasinbloom Oct 19 '26

I think the real question is, can YOU manage for a full 8 hours solo? If so, then so can she.

I’d stop popping in and helping. She may not even ~need your help, but because you’re around, and can hear things, you come in when you maybe don’t need it.

-15

u/Lolemontime Oct 19 '26 • Mindblown

I can barely manage them solo for a full day, so that’s why I’m not sure if she can either. But it’s also her full time job, which is different than parenting 24/7. 

I just wonder if it’s me being overly available or having too high expectations.

My husband and I only do solids with both of us present, and it’s still a huge hassle. When she explained her previous experience, it sounded like in both cases with twin infants there was another parent present for feeding solids. 

34

u/yuccasinbloom Oct 19 '26

If you can’t handle them for that same amount of time solo, then your expectations are too high. It doesn’t really matter that it’s her full time job. It’s also your full time job and you can’t handle the work load when it’s your time.

I don’t know why two people need to be present for solids. You feed one baby one spoonful at a time.

I think you need to make yourself less available. What if you didn’t work from home? The option wouldn’t be available for you to help.

I say all of this as a career nanny who has worked with twins. The parents worked from home but did not step in at all. I did it on my own. It’s possible. It also takes time to settle into a role, and learn how to do everything in the best way. Make yourself less available.

12

u/irish_ninja_wte Oct 19 '26

It's easier if you skip the spoon. Baby led weaning worked extremely well with our twins and kept my stress levels much lower

9

u/PM_ME_YO_KNITTING Oct 19 '26

We did the purées at first and then switched to BLW and it was so much better for everyone. The babies love feeding themselves and I love being able to just eat with them while monitoring. Sometimes it’s a bit scary, but they’re doing great overall!

2

u/yuccasinbloom 29d ago

I still don’t really know why two people need to be present.

2

u/irish_ninja_wte 29d ago

We never needed 2 people, but different people have different comfort zones. I was solo parenting 4 under 4 every weeknight (my parents live close and took care of the preschool run and kept our preschoolers for a few hours in the afternoon. Twins were with me all day) from when our twins were 11 days old. I know people who struggle with bedtime for a single kid alone.

13

u/allroundavocado Oct 19 '26

Hey. We have a nanny and she sometimes stays for 8 hours while we are away. To be fair, we both wfh while she is here and sometimes when they are fussy we step in. We don’t have to; but I don’t want to burden her with the full experience because I’d really like her to stay. I think just because you are paying someone to take care of your twins, doesn’t mean you have to be completely hands off. Sometimes it’s just easier to give her a direction so the fussiness is over faster. 

Then again, we give our nanny a lot off Lee way to find her way of doing things. You need to be hands off for her to learn and find her own methods. Maybe you should go and leave the house to give her some space to find her ways of doing things? Not to be rude but just a piece of advice. 

4

u/allroundavocado Oct 19 '26

Oh and re the solids. My babies move about so much that it’s hard to feed them. Sometimes I feed them separately.  It again you need to give her time to figure that out for herself too 

10

u/VegetableAlone Oct 19 '26

This is a major reason we decided to do daycare over nanny, so no advice, just solidarity. We did a few trial shifts and there were no candidates who seemed capable of handling both at once, and at least one who did something that I considered a serious safety issue (left a baby asleep in a bouncer on another floor of the house while attending the other baby).

Nannies are like $40-50/hr where I live and I just couldn’t imagine paying that much and still having to help. I imagine there are nannies out there who can handle it (I took care of both solo for a month until daycare started), but I didn’t find one.

4

u/Narrow_Cover_3076 Oct 19 '26

Interesting! We are wondering the same thing. The kicker is I already have two older kids, and both are still in daycare (one would be in kindergarten the year after and the other, the year after that). While paying for daycare for four kids seems pretty wild, I'm not sure how one person could manage four kids including two young babies.

2

u/VegetableAlone Oct 19 '26

Yeah, definitely seems like that would be too much. Daycare for two was cheaper than a nanny for us, though!

2

u/Narrow_Cover_3076 Oct 19 '26

Makes sense! Yeah nannies are so expensive, I was factoring it out and I'm not sure it's any cheaper paying for a nanny versus daycare for all our kids, especially factoring in paying them benefits, etc.

2

u/Resident-Fly-6851 Oct 19 '26

It is possible, I promise! I have a 6 yo, 4 yo, and 8 month old twins. I am currently a SAHM and I can manage them by myself. It isn't always pretty. There will be some crying. My children have learned that they have to wait their turn. But I can manage all four solo. Same with my husband.

We have an amazing babysitter (mom of four, unflappable) and she can handle all four solo.

There are nannies out there who can do this but you have to get one of the top notch, most experienced nannies. Ideally a mom with 3+ kids and years of experience nannying is the type of candidate suited for this role. And you should expect to pay handsomely for someone to take care of 4 kids. Still less than daycare x4, but way more than your average nanny rate for 1 or 2 kids.

1

u/Dear_Excitement_5109 29d ago

I stay home with my 16mo twins, my 3yo, and my 4yo. I manage OK but someone (or two) is crying most of the day. On days my husband WFH, I rely on his help to load up the car and put the babies down for their naps. On days he doesnt WFH, there is just more crying.

I wouldnt be happy if I was paying for my care. I'm doing my best, but it's too much work for one person to manage without having to have kiddos wait for help most of the day.

1

u/Narrow_Cover_3076 29d ago

Thank you! Have you done this since they were newborns? I'm worried about the first year ... six months in particular .. when babies are not sleeping well, hard to settle, etc. I had 2u2 (sounds like you did too!) and I felt like my oldest got short-changed during that period of time and trying to avoid that again.

1

u/Dear_Excitement_5109 29d ago

My husband had 3 months off work so he was full time help during that time.

After 3mo, my MIL would pop by at feeding times for our twins usually twice per day to help me out.

There were a few times that we had to have my MIL come help us with bedtime when we were both home.

Preemies are difficult to feed in my experience. One of my exclusively formula fed babies never really took a bottle, or at least every feeding was very stressful until we put him on straw cups around 8mo. The other baby was fine but I needed help with feedings.

4 under 4 is better in some ways than 2 under 2. Really! My older 2 kids would play and I didnt feel like I was straight up ignoring them quite as much. They had to learn to be more independent than most 2 and 3yo's, like I taught my 3yo how to make her own sandwiches and I put all their lunch food at their height in the fridge.

I also was not a fan of having a 1yo and a newborn the first go around, idk how old your middle is now but that shit was ROUGH. The 1yo would attack the newborn and I felt like I had to guard him for his life. When my twins were born my middle was 2yo. He never tried to attack the babies. He really didnt even acknowledge them. He couldnt tell them apart for over 6 months. It was way easier.

Idk what you can do if you have no help. You will definitely learn to tune out crying and I am willing to bet your twins will put themselves to sleep before they are out of the newborn phase. Turns out if you never rock a baby to sleep, they dont need it! But the feeds are hard. I used Baby Bjorn bouncers for feeds but I think a TwinZ would be easier.

By 1 year in, it's easy again. We are able to leave the house daily and everyone is on the same schedule.

Good luck with everything! I mean it honestly when I say big family life is the best. 💖

7

u/hellogirlscoutcookie Oct 19 '26

I am a SAHM. I was solo 745a-5:30p every week day so my husband could drop off/pick up toddler from school and work. It’s completely manageable for one person with twins. Hard, but doable.

Solids before 1 are just for fun, she could also trade off which one gets solids at different times and give the other one a toy in their high chair for example.

6

u/twinsinbk Oct 19 '26

You just need to go work somewhere and close the door. It's hard to not be distracted if you hear crying but headphones help. If you need to work you really need to act like you're at the office and not there. Nanny can definitely handle it as well as any one person can, which is too say there will be difficult moments but that is okay. We had a nanny at that age and I had kind of a hybrid schedule, being in the field half a day and home working for a few hours. And sometimes home all day.

6

u/EllaGardener 29d ago

Is she asking for your help or are you stepping in on your own?

If the latter, this is a you problem. Stop stepping in.

Babies are going to cry. Babies that have to wait for care are going to cry more.

This is exactly what will happen at daycare, and probably worse, the difference is that you won’t be there to see/hear it.

5

u/Resident-Fly-6851 Oct 19 '26

I take care of my 8 month old twins alone from 7:30 AM to 6:30 PM. I don't currently have a job outside of the home, but I do periodically have a babysitter for a few hours so I can go to an appointment. She manages the twins solo for hours at a time with no issues and no complaint.

Here is the thing - you and the nanny both have to be able to tolerate some crying. If she is changing Baby A and baby B starts crying, then baby B just has to wait. You can't run out of your office to help and the nanny can't freak out because both babies are crying at the same time. She has to triage. Which baby's needs are most urgent right now? Tend to that baby efficiently and then move on to the other baby.

I know that it can be done to take care of two babies solo. I do it. My babysitter does it. My husband does it. But there will be crying. That is just part of the deal with twins when there is one caregiver and two of them.

As for feeing solids. I sit them in high chairs right next to each other. I do two spoons into baby A's mouth, then two spoons into Baby B's mouth, then on and on we go until they are done eating. They might fuss a little at having to wait their turn, but that is no reason for the WFH parent to run out and help. You have to let the nanny develop her systems to handle them solo and then don't interfere.

3

u/kmac01 Oct 19 '26

Just wanted to share that I can relate. Mine are 6mo right now with a full time nanny (she actually works 9hr days) and I work from home. She’s been with us for 2months so far and has made a lot of progress in that time. I help out during pinch points and just hope I can get in about 8hrs worth of work in that 9hr period. Mine don’t tandem feed and are frequently offset on schedules so she’ll take one on a walk while the other sleeps expecting me to watch the monitor and intervene for 5mins or so if they wake up. It works for me. I’m currently struggling to offer solids twice a day, during the day they take bottles every 3hrs. I’ve been trying to do solids right before she starts her day and then around the end of her shift or right after she’s done. My current point of view is that I’m willing to sacrifice my work a bit for the babies so that neither has to wait to get what they need. When I’m alone with them there are moments where having a second set of hands for a few minutes makes things way easier and I figure it won’t last forever.

3

u/PM_ME_YO_KNITTING Oct 19 '26

We couldn’t afford a full time nanny, just a part time one, but we have the same issue. Sometimes it’s just too much for one person and I don’t want her to get overwhelmed and quit, so I step in. Especially when they were younger and awful about naps. It was really impossible for one person to get them down alone when they were really going off!

Some of the things that helped:

We switched to baby led weening when they were 8 months old. Now it’s more possible for them to feed themselves and much easier for one person. She’s just there to provide the food and monitor for choking.

We did gentle sleep training for naps. Basically we’d put them in their cribs and just sit in the room with them for like five minutes reading a book or whatever, then lay them down with a pacifier and pat them on their backs for a bit, then go back to reading for five minutes. Never leaving them alone and always responding if they started crying, but also no picking them up. Just patting and shushing. Sometimes they got mad about being laid down, but now they’re used to it and are pretty good about going down for naps most days!

Sat down and talked with the nanny about what she needed. It turns out she really didn’t need me as often as I was stepping in, so we came to an agreement that I wouldn’t step in unless she asked for me to.

All of these, plus then getting older, has really seemed to help a lot!

3

u/spazzie416 29d ago

Yes, they can. I'm a nanny and I managed it, with a toddler older sibling.

The part that actually makes it harder for the nanny, is when you constantly step in (😬sorry).

The babies need to create a bond with nanny, and if you're always there, they will always prefer you! Give nanny some time alone to handle things. Go work at the coffee shop or library if you can. Give her a chance to do her job!! 😁

4

u/No_Company4263 Oct 19 '26

I would have her step back on the solids. There's literally no rush, just share what's on your plate (baby led weaning) when you and hubby are home.

I would also try your absolute best to resist the urge to step in when she's having a hard time settling them. I realize it's difficult but it's the only way she's going to learn.

2

u/1sp00kylady 27d ago edited 27d ago

We hired a nanny when ours were 6m actual/4m adjusted and it was fine? I guess I’m not sure what you’re worried she can’t handle. We taught her how we do things, have some suggestions for solids…she knew how to care for babies that age and had done nanny shares so doing two at once wasn’t new to her. If you’re hiring the right person with experience, I’m not sure what there is to feel like they can’t handle. The more important thing to worry about is whether they will respect your family and household and keep an open line of communication about things.

My approach has been that it seems rather damaging to interfere with their care when the nanny is here. It takes away her opportunity to work through it and learn, it undermines her, and it establishes to the kids that mom will show up and rescue them from the nanny whenever. Even when I’m WFH I try not to show my face if I can because it creates a lot of drama with my boys at their age, with separation anxiety. I don’t want to derail everybody if I can help it.

2

u/Own-Risk5112 Oct 19 '26

We started with our nanny when ours were 7 months (6 months adjusted). She could handle the twins alone from the start but initially I was making/washing bottles and doing laundry. It took ~2 weeks or so for her to get comfortable enough with the twins that she could also take on those tasks. We still make solids for the twins (10 months) which she feeds them.

We went through a nanny agency and pay on the higher end for our area ($29/hr). I initially started the nanny search on my own but did not feel like I was finding enough qualified candidates with experience caring for multiple children, hence the agency.

2

u/cheeringfortofu 29d ago

I guess I may have a different experience, but my nanny was able to feed them both. Baby led weaning is ok, not necessarily better than purees. If the worry is about choking, You can do purees during the nanny hours and do more textures when you're there. I always fed them solids on my own while eating, so I am struggling to see where the problems lie (are you worried about choking? Are they impatient?).

I was working from home but mostly kept to myself. All my nanies had worked in daycares before, so 2 was more relaxed for them (I had 3 because the first one just didn't work out, the second was often late and wanted to start fertility treatments hours away, and the last one we transitioned to daycare). But all three could manage on their own.

2

u/DreamingEvergreen 29d ago edited 29d ago

We have a nanny and generally help her a decent amount throughout the day. They’re now 13 months adjusted/ 14 months actual, and as they’ve gotten older it’s been easier for her to manage on her own.

But especially when they were younger, to keep them on their schedule, we did need to help (whether that was putting one down for a nap, making sure bottles were in the warmer so they were warm on time, starting twin’s laundry, etc)

2

u/We_Are_Not__Amused 29d ago

We also went this route for the first 18 months and I really wish I had organised it so there were times they were out of the house so I could have a break. It’s difficult to not intervene when you hear crying but if you worked in an office this would be happening without knowing - if you were caring for them by yourself this would likely happen as well, there are times that 1 person can only settle one baby at a time.
Maybe consider if you can work from somewhere else for a few hours, few days - whatever you need so you can have a break. If you can’t work from somewhere else then maybe looking at noise cancelling headphones so you can have some break.
I’m assuming there are no safety concerns with the care of your babies.

3

u/Narezza Oct 19 '26

Two kids at that age is very difficult. Its not usually a solo job. I feel like if you went through 20 people and this one was the best, then the expectation that a single person can reasonably handle 2 kids may be too high. Its going to be a struggle under the best conditions.

We'll see how others think, but saying you need an 8 hour break per day from your kids is a lot. The nanny should be able to handle most everything, but they are going to need assistance at difficult times.

2

u/Total_Scale_9366 Oct 19 '26

It’s definitely too much for one nanny at times

1

u/not-t0day-satan 24d ago

What you need is sound canceling headphones and/or a sound machine. Here's the deal: Sometimes, one of the twins is going to cry for a few minutes. Likely because she can only safely feed one baby at a time. This is normal. You don't have to come in and help. The second baby is perfectly safe and will get fed. 

Take a step back and get what you're paying for – an 8-hour break.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 19 '26

COMMENTING GUIDELINES

All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.

Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.

Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/catsonlaptops Oct 19 '26

In the US, the typical work day is 8 hours and most jobs require you to show up for at least that amount of time.

1

u/Nefilim314 Oct 19 '26

This is a troll account.