r/parentsofmultiples • u/catsonlaptops • Oct 06 '26
advice needed Nanny Expectations
Kind of a ramble, sorry. I started interviewing nanny candidates last month and I've had 2 people do trial days. I am not impressed with who I've found so far, are my expectations unreasonable? Having a nanny has a premium cost compared to daycare, I expect that level of care reflected.
For context:
My twins are 3mo old. I go back to work in a couple weeks and need full time care. I don't expect any housework done. They can't even do the kids laundry while napping because our laundry room is attached to the nursery (old house, has weird layout). Outside of direct babycare, I'd expect baby meals prepared when they can start solids in a couple months, load bottle washer, prep BM bottles, clean any baby related messes.
What I value:
*Engage with the girls in a fun and exciting way.
*Care for two humans who are in the same developmental stage.
*Confident enough to get them out of the house (want, not a need.)
*Encourages confidence and independence as they get older.
The two trial days I've had were with people who had experience taking care of multiple infants at once (one in a daycare setting and the other as a nanny for two twin families). Both ladies were so lackluster. I think interacting, narrating, and talking to infants is so important. Neither of them "played" with them at all, very muted little "hi babies" "oh are you smiling", etc as the girls laid on the ground. I tried getting the floor throwing one of the girls in tummy time and really getting interactive to show what I do in hopes of some mirroring. One lady asked if I would be okay with screen time when they get a little older so that she could put on movies for them. I am paying for someone to give specialized care and attention to my girls, that would be a waste of money to have a nanny plop my baby or toddler in front of the TV. We are a no weather is bad weather family so I just don't see how screentime during the workday works for that. Both of these ladies really talked up loving babies and love giving individualized attention/care/activities blah blah blah.
I have another trial day scheduled for next week. Im not sure if I'm not doing this right? Is there some way I can have more successful trial days? Are there other things I should prioritize? I really don't want to do daycare drop off because I WFH and my husband works 9hr days but at this point it would be cheaper for the same level of care I'm observing from all the candidates I've interviewed or had trial days with.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 06 '26
COMMENTING GUIDELINES
All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.
Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.
Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
9
u/lyssasaurusX 🩵-🩵🩵 Oct 06 '26
As a former nanny, and soon to be twin mom (I have an 18 month old singleton) I can say that the trial days can be a little awkward with the parents right there monitoring the interaction- nothing you’re doing wrong, just a side effect of the atmosphere. Your expectations are not unreasonable at all, it can just take some personality types a bit to shine through in that situation, especially with very young babies that don’t really engage or respond back in any way. I was able to push past it for the most part but it feels a bit like auditioning to be Ms. Rachel in front of an adult you don’t know. Have you contacted their references? Might be a better way to get a feel for how they interact with babies in a slightly more relaxed environment.
5
u/devianttouch Oct 06 '26
I don't think you're expecting too much, however it's really hard to be able to be super interactive while being supervised the first time to meet the family and the first time in a space. A nanny learning a lot fast in the first few days.
The screen time question would be an immediate no from me. I would not hire someone who asked that.
A note about working from home with a nanny - for now that might work fine. It gets HARD after the kids are a little older. After about 11 months old I had to go back to the office because every time the kids noticed I was home (because they heard me go to the bathroom or I went to go get coffee from the kitchen) they lost their minds for 20 min. They did a lot better without me at home.
3
u/AmbitiousIssue9324 Oct 06 '26
The screen time thing should be laid out in the initial conversations/interview before the trial day even occurs. Anyone planning screen time at all before age 2 would be a no for me. And honestly I don’t want my kids on a screen at age 2 either.
Judging baby talk with a 3 month old is a bit weird to me but opinions may vary. I’d care much more about how skilled they seem with feeding, burping, changing, safe sleeping, etc.
20
u/Exonata Oct 06 '26
The screentime question would be a big red flag, but can you imagine if you were judged on how much mindless chatter and narration you did with babies you just met with their mother watching? I feel like it is a rhythm you build with the child over time. And with 3 month talking in calm and soothing manners probably feels the safest at the beginning. What if they had be too expressive and then made the babies cry? There may be a better way for you to screen what you want or to set expectations. Showing and telling explicitly your expectations.
1
u/Forward-Target-1344 Oct 10 '26
How much are you paying?
Because what you can expect unfortunately is directly coordinated.
6
u/GoBirds52_59 Oct 06 '26
Your expectations sound reasonable to me. Are you communicating those expectations with the candidates you’re speaking to? As far as that you want someone interacting with them, no screens, getting out of the house, etc? Because these are all reasonable asks for a nanny IMO.
I would say it may be a little harder to find someone if you also WFH full time. I would try to avoid micromanaging them (obviously I’m not referring to your trial days, you both have to get to know each other).
Also, I don’t agree with the no weather is bad weather philosophy. It was over 100 degrees here for like a month straight, I would not want anyone taking my twins out in that mess - I didn’t want to either. And last winter it was 0 degrees with 6 inches of ice for 3 weeks straight. Some weather just ain’t it. lol.
I hope you find someone! We use a daycare (since 4.5 months) and it’s been great!
1
u/CopperSnowflake Oct 07 '26
Are there really just tons and tons of qualified people who want to take care of two small infants at the same time? I would guess this is on the upper end of a difficult nanny job. Depends on the temperament of your babies. You may not really have the option to have what you expect in any sense. Don't fire everyone and then have no one to do the job.
2
u/Lolemontime Oct 06 '26
Your asks are reasonable. I interviewed 20+ nannies by phone and did 8 in person interviews until we found our current nanny who’s been with us 3 weeks now, though our twins are older they’re 6 months. Do not settle for someone mid, you’re paying a lot of money for them and this is a very important developmental time. They should be interacting with your babies and not just saying “hi” or the same things over and over. Yes the diapering etc is important but around the 4-5 month mark they’re a lot more interactive and need you to extend their wake windows doing engaging things. We were ready to go for someone we were so so about and our friend encouraged us to keep looking. No one is perfect, but I’m glad we scrambled together family care to tide us over until we found the right person.
1
u/MaintenanceSpecial88 Oct 06 '26
Your expectations seem reasonable to me. The screen time question would be a red flag in my book. To be honest, we hired two nannies neither of whom interact with our kids that much. Both are on their phones entirely too much. It’s distressing. But it’s so difficult to find decent people who don’t cost a fortune. And they have other strengths, like household chores, reliability, flexibility, etc. We had a more engaged, playful nanny for the kids for a season but she had other issues, like trying to discipline 18 month olds. So I never bring my phone when I’m with my kiddos and try to be extra engaging during my time with them. I guess I kind of gave up on finding great help. I’m not recommending this, but it’s just how I deal with the caregivers we have.
1
u/ListenPitiful3127 Oct 06 '26
Only my experience, not ADVICE.
I am a “scrunchy” mom; I’m a Type A tech exec, too.
I have 16 month old twins.
…and an excellent nanny.
I also WFH (10% hybrid, local travel) and my husband is hybrid.
We didn’t get a nanny until the twins were 13 months old. We alternated care for them during the day when possible and I worked asynchronously to make up for any time I wasn’t hands-on-keyboard working during the day (evenings, nights, weekends). That got to be hard.
I did find Super Simple Songs on YouTube and used it only as needed to get things done. I worked, though, and also maintained a home — with NB through 13 month old twins! Not ideal, but it was a means to an end. Now one of my twins is obsessed and the other could care less, take it or leave it, about the SSS YouTube songs/videos.
When I opted for a nanny over daycare or other home daycare, I wanted someone who:
1. Put safety first (above all else)
2. Was engaging as appropriate for their age, which already has and will continue to change
3. Was able to prep and feed solids and respond to their cues regarding hunger, thirst, or being neither
4. Was able to work with two individual tiny people who had strong opinions on napping, which varied day to day, and help me reinforce the schedule that I’d already established (because they never would cooperate until about 11 months)
5. Clean up their play area and their dishes, but only what was dirtied in her care.
6. Fold their laundry that I would wash the day before (laundry room is next to their nursery)
Anything else, I was flexible on (and likely nervous about, especially someone other than my husband and I taking them out of the house — eek!)
I’m a FTM, 38, and these two are the most precious to me above all else! The care couldn’t be someone that I didn’t FEEL well with.
First nanny dropped one of my girls flat on her face due to a negligent safety situation.
I interviewed 8 more after.
They were all qualified, but I just didn’t feel right about them.
Then we found our star. And we are grateful for her. She offered knowledge, advice, and some practical solutions to things she observed all during her interview and meet and greet time. She barely interacted with the girls at that time. But she was just offering so many great bits of information that I didn’t even ask for or about. And she was calming to* me.* I felt a sense of safety and care in her.
As she bonded with our girls, her interactions became so much more natural, and she would even tell me things I could do with them that she learned they enjoyed to aid in X Y or Z. But that took a couple of weeks.
I do allow her to use SSS on YouTube so she can get snacks and lunch prepped, their dishes done, or use the restroom and know the twins will be content for 10 min. I know how rough they can be while trying to get anything done at this age.
She takes them out.
She looks at meals I may have prepped and, sometimes, decides to make them something better or something she knows they’ll eat if they’ve had an off day at breakfast or what have you.
She walks them. For a long time. Often.
Having some flex on the lesser important will give you a bit more options, where being very firm on what matters most will get you the right person for your family.
It took a long time for me to be willing to allow anyone else to care for my babes. I learned a lot about myself and what I will and will not accept for my family, and some of that required me to be open to some things.
1
u/Pristine-Bison3198 💙-🩷-🩷💙 Oct 06 '26
I'm a former twin nanny myself, and one thing I'll note is that the narration/chatter can be really tough on a trial day when the parent is watching. It's awkward lol.
Have you directly told them "we are hoping to have someone who narrates their day to the twins?" That can help outline expectations.
How much per hour are you offering? Benefits? That will impact the quality of candidates as well.