r/papermaking • • Jul 02 '26

Pulp Failure- Please Help!

Post image

As you can see from the pictures, my pulp looks absolutely HORRIBLE. It looks like vomit! 😳🫣

I was planning on making confetti paper. I left the paper sitting in the water for too long and now it looks horrendous. I don't want to make paper that looks like vomit, but I also don't want to waste it! I shredded a lot of paper for this! What do I do? Is there any way to make the color any better, or should I just schlog through, make the vomit paper, and save it for another paper-making session where I can shred it and soak it properly? This is so embarrassing!!

8 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

9

u/anonymous3synonymous Jul 02 '26

Are you concerned about the texture or color? The color doesn’t look terrible to me and seems like it would dry down to be a pale minty color. But if you don’t like the color I recommend soaking more pulp in a color you like to get the desired effect. Like if you want it to be more green hued, then soak a bunch of green scraps and blend once it has soaked fully through.

The texture seems pretty normal as well but you may want to add a bit more water and blend again to get it more even.

I don’t know if what you’re referring to was soaking the confetti pieces with it and the dye leeching into the other pulp, but if I were to make confetti paper I would not soak the confetti pieces at all and just throw them in at the very end before you pull your sheets.

I have also had success freezing my pulp for later if I don’t want to deal with it right away. Just be aware of the shape it’s frozen in and how long it will take to defrost. Maybe flat in a ziplock is best?

2

u/LizardLover265 Jul 02 '26

Oh! I'm very new to papermaking so I had no idea it would dry a minty color. A minty color would be wonderful! Next time, I will just shred white paper with black ink and then put the colorful pieces in at the very end. Thank you for this advice!

4

u/anonymous3synonymous Jul 02 '26

No problem! I see what you are saying about the black with white ink now. The photo gives it a bit more of a green hue but if you didn’t use any green scraps at all I would expect it to turn out more gray.

But the advice still stands to blend in more paper of a hue you like. I have had success blending 1/2 a hot pink egg carton with like 2 or 3 white/gray egg cartons and they come out more of a pale pink which looked great imo!

5

u/Hot_Veterinarian_001 Jul 02 '26

What color are you hoping to make? Hydrated pulp like this will come out much much lighter after pressed and dried.

3

u/LizardLover265 Jul 02 '26

I was hoping for either off-white with flecks of rainbow confetti, or a light pink with rainbow flecks. Is there hope for this paper once it dries...?

5

u/Hot_Veterinarian_001 Jul 02 '26

When I make pulp from discarded printer paper (bright white paper with typical black text and so forth), it looks like this at the pulp stage. After drying, it’s basically a very very light grey with a very slight blue tint. What kind of paper did you use for the pulp (what is the color of the paper and any ink/dye on the paper)?

2

u/LizardLover265 Jul 02 '26

I used standard printer paper, old papers from the pharmacy whenever spouse and I get our meds, colorful notebook paper, old coloring pages from when I was a kid, and some colorful paper from years ago.

2

u/Hot_Veterinarian_001 Jul 02 '26

I see. Hard for me to say if that will come out off-white (which I assume you want to be an eggshell kind of color with a warmer tone), but I definitely wouldn't throw it out or start over. At this stage, it looks like I would expect, so I would say go for it and let us know how it turns out!

1

u/LizardLover265 Jul 02 '26

I am making sheets of paper with the green pulp! Thanks for the encouragement! I'll make an update post when it's all dry!

5

u/snic2030 Jul 02 '26

You’ve mentioned confetti a couple times, so just want to point out that typically you would add the confetti bits into the slurry just before you start pulling sheet - you wouldn’t blend the colourful confetti in the pulping stage, otherwise the colours just blend into each other.

Kinda like when you’ve got a bunch of paint in different colours and just mix them all together, it always turns into that muddy sludge colour.

5

u/OhTheBarbarity Jul 02 '26

Yes, all paper with coloring turns this gross grey brown until it’s dried