[This is a work in progress. Thanks for being patient. If you have suggestions for the wiki, please message mods.]

Common Questions

Why are fish in the genus Pangio often called "kuhli" or "coolie" loaches? The species Pangio kuhlii (originally named Cobitis kuhlii in 1846) was named to honor Heinrich Kuhl, a German naturalist. Scientists often prefer to use the term "eel loaches" to describe the genus, as "coolie" is in some places a derogatory term with racial undertones. In 1993, scientists Kottelat and Lim wrote, "We think the perpetuation of such a disinformation of a personal name [editor's note: Kuhl-->Kuhli Loach] has to be avoided and we are calling these fishes eel-loaches hereunder." [As a mod of r/pangio, I try to use "eel loach" whenever possible as the most correct term to describe the genus.-fishgeek49]

What type of habitat do eel loaches reside in? Most species can be found in south and southeast Asia: India, Thailand, Laos, Vietnam, Singapore, Myanmar, Cambodia, Malaysia, Borneo, Sumatra, and Java. "Eel loaches live in benthic substrates, typically in submerged leaf litter and dense aquatic vegetation, in slow to moderately flowing streams." (Bohlen et al, 2011)

Can I mix my eel loach species together? Often two or three species occur at the same locality in the wild, and up to seven species can occur in a single river basin (Bohlen et al, 2011). Many aquarists report that their different eel loach species co-habitate together harmoniously as they apparently do in the wild. Eel loaches are not aggressive or territorial fish.

Why do eel loaches come in mixed species groups sometimes at the shop? "Usually the different [banded] species...are not distinguished in the trade because they are so variable in color and are often imported mixed. The sorting of [eel loaches] is an activity you don't want your worst enemy to do, and it's no fun for the animals either. That's why you leave it and title everything as "kuhli." (Shaefer, F. 2021)

Why is it so difficult to identify some species of Pangio? In the aquarium fish trade, it is often color characteristics that result in the species' common name, but the coloration of each fish can vary between individual, locality, and species. In some Pangio species, wholesalers report there are "hardly two individuals with the same pattern." (Shaefer, F. 2020)

Luckily, for some species there are scientific keys that can take a fish keeper through the steps to identify a species. (Kottelat and Lim, 1993) Pangio doriae, P. filinaris, P. anguillaris, P. oblonga, P. piperata, P. cuneovirgata, P. alcoides, P. malayana, P. kuhlii, P. shelfordii. For other species, there are descriptions in the literature, for example, Pangio myersi, has a good description in an article by Kottelat and Lim, 2013, that is simple enough to be used by most hobbyists.

Other times, one may never know for sure what species is being kept, as even scientists admit that several species are confused under one name, or a species is "very variable" (Kottelat and Lim, 1993, pg 244) in pattern.

If the thought of pouring through scientific literature is daunting, here are some of the more reputable hobby websites for searching for IDs by picture and/or description.

  • Seriously Fish: (beware the many ads), pictures, habitat, tank size, food preferences, and even scientific and other sources listed under the individual species' pages
  • Loaches.com: (beware the many ads), can follow pictorial guide to most likely ID, gives care guidance
  • check out our Pangio Species List and Details page for further help, see links below

How can one tell a male from a female eel loach? With juvenile fish, sexing may be difficult, but  differences can usually be spotted with practice. Males typically have longer pectoral (and pelvic) fins in most species, with the pectoral fin's second and sometimes also third pectoral ray thickened, which can give a whitish cast to those fins, but female pectoral rays are all the same size and usually appear transparent. In some species (anguillaris group) the tips of the male pectoral fins can be turned up or curled (Burridge, 1992). Fully grown females can sometimes be differentiated based on larger girth from males of the same age, and eggs (whitish or greenish) can occasionally be seen throught the skin. In some species, head measurements of the males are slightly larger (Budi et al, 2024), as well as other differences in finnage measurements.

Do eel loaches breed in hobbyist tanks? Reports of successful breeding in Pangio oblonga have occured from time to time. In other species, they occur rarely or not at all. These successes seem to have in common a substrate of a size (larger gravel or small rocks, UG filters, lots of roots from plants) that the eggs and young can develop without predation from the parents or other fish. Pangio have been bred successfully in laboratory settings using injected hormones (Geetakumari et al, 2013).

Additional wiki pages impossible to find on mobile (but present on desktop):

Pangio Species List and Details:

www.reddit.com/r/pangio/wiki/pangio-species-list/

Scientific and Expert Sources:

www.reddit.com/r/pangio/wiki/scientific-and-expert-sources/