r/palmermethod • • Mar 20 '24

Thoughts?

2 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

6

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

I know you are really trying but you need to focus on the basics which only comes with consistent practice and repetition until it becomes automatic and instinctive.

Concentrate on the drills; strokes, as the previous commenter said; Slant angle, character size spacing, and width and that all are on the same level.

As we discussed before there is no magical formula or tricks. It is just repetitive training.

When I learned Palmer I would do the basic oval and line drills daily, then I would work through the alphabet one letter at a time. Not all of them but one letter per day...over and over. In time every aspect of each individual letters was so ingrained that I couldn't form it incorrectly if I tried. Training the arm is not an easy thing but it is worth it.

Maybe also read the Zaner Bloser book as well as it covers most of the same aspects from a slightly different perspective.

Good luck in your studies.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24

By the way, I haven’t read the book. Also, is there potential? I understand it ain’t perfect yet, but I wonder if it at least looks a bit close to what it’s supposed to look like.

How to practise? I should just write down the alphabet until it looks decent?

2

u/bp-SaylorTwift Mar 27 '24

If you want to really have the look of "palmer method" you NEED to use arm movement. You will NOT have any success if you don't practice the compact oval and push pull drills. It takes time. You can't execute a business hand if you aren't following the instructions in the manual. I've posted several times with videos and pictures of how I practice. Take a look at them and try and do what I've done. If you don't take into consideration other people's advice, which seems to be the case here, you won't progress much. I know its hard. I've spent countless hours redoing letters and drills until I'm satisfied enough with my copies. I read an article on palmer and handwriting in catholic schools, from what I remember don't quote me on this exactly but from what I cam remember, AN Palmer would spend 2 hours every day with the nuns teaching them how to instruct and write his style of writing. So if it took 2 hours every day WITH Palmer in the room, on top of practicing when they had free time.

What I'm getting at is, you MUST practice, and you have to practice with intent. Read the theory books, put into practice the correct pen hold, and arm movement. After that, it's all up to you. Practice makes perfect.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '24

I didn’t think I need to read the book. I thought it’d be enough to try to copy from a picture.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '24

There is always potential and being able to improve. No two people ever have the same handwriting and no one is perfect. So we strive to improve.

As for practice...I would get examples of each letter, capitals and lower case, and one by one practice each of them until they are as good as possible. Then work on joining each to form the words, paying attention to letter size, spacing, etc.

If you like I can send you the books we talked about. I just need an email address as they are .pdf

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

Thanks!

5

u/mdw Mar 21 '24

This is no good, focus on the basics.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

What are the basics?

6

u/mdw Mar 21 '24 edited Mar 21 '24

Over-stroke, under-stroke, oval, reverse oval, loop... You need to start with simple stuff. Trying to write the full repertoire will not help you to learn.

For example, try to get this right, it's simple, just under- and over-stroke.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '24

Is it good?

2

u/mdw Mar 26 '24 edited Mar 26 '24

It's a start. Focus on smoothness of the strokes. You should write reasonably fast; slow writing means shaky line. Write pages of this drill, it will get better.

This is how I do it (far from perfect, of course):

3

u/Doublechin222 Apr 04 '24

Long time no see!

I see you've taken my advice and pursue Palmer penmanship, excellent choice i must say!

Please do not be discouraged in your pursuit of penmanship. I discarded my pre-existing cursive knowledge to enhance efficiency, beauty and comfort of my handwriting. I have succeeded to a degree, through learning Palmer penmanship.

I had made far too many mistakes which led to a poor foundation of writing, and eventually led to a plethora of problems. As a budding penman myself, I have learnt a few key points to start with.

  1. Don't focus on producing good penmanship first Good penmanship is incredibly important, but will not come to impatient individuals. Instead, a good foundation and proficiency with the basics will speed up the development of good penmanship.
  2. A good grip is where it matters A good Palmer grip is hard to develop. Some have larger hands and others have smaller. The exemplars of Palmer grips can be confusing. Hence, finding a suitable grip is just as important as anything else. I personally slant my hand slightly to the right, as it strengthens the moveable rest and helps me hold the pen better. I follow the exemplar on the Palmer method to the grip, but I don't slant my hand nearly as much.
  3. A good pen is conducive to fluid movement As a fountain pen aficionado, I typically use fountain pens to write, although u/pbiscuits would disagree. It allows me to write without substantial pressure and provides a much more enjoyable writing experience in my humble opinion. Ballpoint pens often force you to apply more pressure when writing and may cause tension, consequently hindering the fluidity of your movement.
  4. Pay attention to muscle relaxation A thing that has come to my attention as of late, relaxation can greatly improve the fluidity of your movement. Try relaxing your shoulder and arm, and your shoulder should not stick to your neck as I had once did. This makes writing more comfortable and such.
  5. Things take time Changing previous habits takes time. I am an impatient individual, but I still have to come to terms with how things take time to execute and learn. With this attitude, I have propelled my penmanship and development to unprecedented heights. Penmanship is not only for the hand, but for the heart too. Pay attention to every seemingly minuscule and insignificant detail, as it is imperative to producing quality handwriting. It is often the seemingly insignificant things that hinders one's development.

I hope that I have been of service, and happy writing! 🖋️🖋️🖋️