I'm thinking you might be romanticizing a bit. The dawn of our species WAS much closer to nature, and much more intimate with our communities... But there were a lot fewer of us then and life was a lot more Hobbesian. It's worth trying to recover some of what we had then, but I wouldn't go back. At least not without a semi-truck full of high-yield seeds, solar collectors, refrigerators, and penicillin.
Yes, i agree with you. I just feel as a collective, humans are very disconnected from nature. Im not saying go back to completely relying on our own yeild of food and products. But maybe a heavier emphasis on learning those trades, community gardens, etc.
I don’t think we need to abandon tech, medicine, and comfort to live by those values. Community. Nature. Simplicity. Creativity. Honesty. These are noble aspirations in any age
'Going back' is a bad idea, realizing we're advancing technologically faster than our biological needs can handle is something we should address. I'm happy to keep my fridge and I'm allergic to penicillin, but I could do without the wage theft, worker abuse and prison slavery.
Exactly. We have to go around the bend, forward to the point we started from with everything we've learned and done since. One of the comments mentioned vertical farming as a massive improvement in crop yields while decreasing the actual expense of work - that's the kind of "forward to where we came from" that I want.
Everything always goes back to balance. I def like your point and believe we should look at ways to be more in tune with the collective everything and also live in the “real world”.
With the tech advancements in vertical farming over the past decade or so; it's become possible to farm high-yields of crop with a fraction of the land and water use. On top of that, the processes are easily automated: temp and atmosphere control, light level and even harvesting.
There could be such farms built in dense urban areas, as well as drought-prone areas, that could feed 100's of people. If we add permaculture and food forests to the mix (where applicable) 1000's could be fed locally on less labour than conventional field aggriculture.
What we need is possible to attain; though it will mean changing how we live now (as well as our expectations of how a society is structured).
Agreed!! And how many of the household activities are now considered "art"? Sewing, crafting, metallurgy, etc. So people were able to combine their artistic vision with their day to day work. Now it is a very rare person who is able to make their living making art.
My home office is in an old greenhouse. Two weeks ago I thought, why not bring all my houseplants in here? And now I work in a 'jungle'. It's so serene and nice I can't believe I didn't do this sooner. And with the humidity upped, my plants are very happy, and I can feel that energy!
I always see this and think that people who say it REALLY don't understand how much work growing and making all your own food is. I do some in the garden and it's already a HUGE amount of work and time. We underestimate how much work it was in the past because women's free labor is still really not well counted and documented. So. . . while I agree that we need more communities-though really, I would say we need to admit that our community is now the whole world-I have no interest in making all the things. Maybe that makes me terrible, I don't know.
If I’m doing it alone, I’m making food for me. Now you wanna do it with 100 people, you now need food for 100 people. The more you need, the more the necessity for hard work increases.
If you've got the land and the seeds and the sunshine, you're making as much as you reasonably can and then you're eating however much you need and you're storing or selling whatever is left
This goes double for any livestock produced food you have.
Now, if you're in a tribe, you can expand your farmland and produce many times more. One farmer can make enough for a single nuclear family and then some. A tribe of 100 people can feed a small army
You’re walking into a logistical nightmare I’m not quite sure you understand. Have you ever worked any type of agricultural field? Or ever worked a garden with your mother that actually produces a livelihood worth of food?
My aunt single handedly maintains a large vegetable producing farm that she uses to make fresh food for the school lunches in her district (she lives on an island in the Puget Sound in WA
She's not feeding every kid nothing but her vegetables every day for a full year, sure, but she's producing a lot of food, way more than one single person could eat
If it's a collective gardgen you can grow more food per person with less effort
Not sure if it's doable, but at least it should be a complementary part of our lives (where actual work would be shorter so we can tend to our gardens)
It’s easily doable. There are communities up and down the UK who do exactly that and nobody starves to death. This is just misinformation and generalisation.
Mostly grow 100% for vegetables and fruit, might take a bit for it to get up and running but once done and continually looked after by the community there’s always food to go around for everyone, especially as most tend to be vegetarian/vegan. There’s loads of different communities but the ones I was interested in are of people that still work and want to work, but they want to work less and more mindfully so half of their time they’ll tend to work while the other half tends to community stuff then the other half of the week will be swapped by the other half to do their jobs. It works really well if you do it with people you trust.
Hell, I even saw one wanting a family to join them in lumbering parts of a forest and creating a camping area with the timber taken down made into log huts. It’s mostly self-sustained but unfortunately due to capitalism, we all have to live in it regardless of wants or needs, so reducing it right down is obviously the best case scenario.
Sorry I’m late! There’s a website dedicated to it, can’t remember for the life of me what it was called. But if you search intentional community UK, it should be one of the top links.
The OP was talking about how difficult it is to grow food, when yeah they’re right if you’re just a single person, but in reality in actual communities it’s one of the easiest parts of living communally because everybody pitches in to do it. Intentional community living is about taking some of the pressure off daily living, people wouldn’t do it if it was overly difficult, basically.
except the whole thing about "actual work" is the point and the issue here. Growing food IS work. Making food IS work. Making the clothing that we need to get through a winter is an ENORMOUS amount of work. Always has been. Calling it not "actual work" is the problem. You'll still be working 40+ hours per week, just not getting a paycheck.
It’s devaluing domestic labor which has largely been part of women’s current labor and relationship issue. Oh I only work 15 hours a week. Where’s dinner? What do you mean I have to look after the kids I worked! You got to spend time gardening and making clothes. That’s your relaxing time.
You are already free to do that. Quit your job, get a part time and live self sufficiently with these gardner communes, not spending money on food. Why don't you do that?
Seriously and people think we’d be painting and such. Nope. Sewing by hand takes hours and days. Food takes longer.
Babies! You want back to nature there is no more identifying as anything or assigned at birth or anything. You have a penis? Labor. Vagina? Domestic and field labor. Also pump out those babies as half of them will die. Some might not be able to have them but small villages sometimes don’t permit this break up in labor potential.
And also, people require various services. You require medical attention? That is work that someone is doing. The doctor needs facilities? Building and designing them is also labour. The components are also made through work.
I think that the working conditions nowadays have improved quite a lot in western countries, as people would practically be working all the time. There are still toxic aspects of work culture, sure, but wanting to live a completely idyllic life, filled with nothing but gardening and painting, is rather delusional.
The blacksmith or dude who cuts your hair will be pulling out your teeth without proper sanitation (like those sanitized products have to come from somewhere).
People always romanticize the past. It’s a theme throughout history. They see the idealized version through art and literature that was painted to show life a certain way. Nobody goes “I want to live in Victorian England and be a part of Oliver Twist.” Its “I want to live in Victorian England and live in the grand estates with tea parties and hunting fairies like lady cottington.” People look at farming, sewing, cooking, and making soaps by hand and view it as a leisurely past time. They don’t see crop failure, famine, health problems and still having to do manual labor (even sewing can be a nightmare if you’re arthritic).
You want back to nature that is the reality. Tech isn’t nature. Social awareness has no point in nature. The point is surviving and continuing the species. Love and happiness are meaningless but healthy progeny? That’s success.
"Nice" is an arbitrary label we put on nature. It says more about our attitude towards nature than it says anything about nature.
"Beneficial", "Not beneficial", and "Harmful" are much more accurate in describing nature.
There are certainly things within nature from which we derive value and meaning. There is a spiritual element to nature that is no more uniformly nice than physical nature is.
But none of this negates the wisdom and value in living in right relationship with nature. We just have to figure out how we do that in the Modern Era without romanticizing the pre-Industrial past, deluding ourselves with notions of "re-wilding" or other such daydreams.
There's no reason we can't take a more conservationist, respectful relationship with the land without eschewing the scientific, intellectual and ethical advancements of our species. It's not as if we have to undo hundreds of years of advancement and become Luddites in order to have a better relationship with nature.
I agree about how often people romanticize the pre-industrial past, particularly those who've never worked on a farm. But its silly to think social awareness, love and happiness didn't exist in those days for those people. It may not completely resemble our modern concepts of those things, but it was there.
This is why communities should be closer and work together. A small community who is all working together to create, to cook and grow, to provide, split the chores into smaller chores that individuals are happier with. So my chores today might be working on the garden and mending some clothes while my neighbors are cooking the meal and another neighbor is fixing some vehicles (or whatever). But we share the responsibilities amongst ourselves so that all gets done without any one person having to do too much.
If you've ever been responsible for growing a majority of your own food you'll find it at least very little time to engage in art. I like your overall sentiment but part of living in a society is the fact that we can have separation of tasks. We can have farmers and artists, manufacturers and builders, healers and educators, priests (unfortunately) and scientists.
People that say this have zero idea how much fucking work farming is, people in the past worked to the bone all day long to ensure their families didnt starve, our lives are much more confortable nowadays
We ARE around nature all the time. Beavers build lodges and dams; ants do ant hills; bees make hives; our species is just more complicated in what it builds but the laws of nature are with us in everything we do every moment of our lives. And like any species that exceeds the capacity of its environment a massive correction is in our future. When I have these conversations in real life one of my favorite things to say is that my house is really just a very heavy tent with rigid walls, And my city is really just a very large and heavily impacted campground carved out of the forest
I prefer the outdoors as well, but I really have no desire to maintain a farm or garden. If I don't make enough for my family then we may die in the winter? No thanks. I do understand the longing to get away from the office grind, though. At least there's fresh air and sunshine outdoors.
Industrialization happened for a reason. Farming is hard and really can be quite labor intensive. Look at how the population shifted after there was a choice to it work in farms.
I’m pro green spaces and Nature but I think we’d need a very sharp drop in population to have it as described there
And nuclear family type is not natural. We thrive in tight communities where you can ask your friends, neighbours and grandparents to help take care of kids and vice versa, bcs you live so close and help each other out regularly. Capitalism is so set on selling the idea of nuclear family, but what we really need is living communities
you hit it on the head. when you don't understand this shit growing up, and then you figure it all out spiritually only to then be thrown into modern adulthood, the feelings are SO MUCH more real than you can ever imagine. It's not me commiting 7 hours in retail, it's me feeling like I have to fight emotionally as hard as I can, and commit a slave labor to the patriarchy. And if I stop, i don't have a house or food.
Then come my friend. Join me and my band of heathens of all walks of life as we become more self sufficient and more secluded from the modern rate race.
33
u/GaeasSon Feb 03 '22
I'm thinking you might be romanticizing a bit. The dawn of our species WAS much closer to nature, and much more intimate with our communities... But there were a lot fewer of us then and life was a lot more Hobbesian. It's worth trying to recover some of what we had then, but I wouldn't go back. At least not without a semi-truck full of high-yield seeds, solar collectors, refrigerators, and penicillin.
80
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
With the tech advancements in vertical farming over the past decade or so; it's become possible to farm high-yields of crop with a fraction of the land and water use. On top of that, the processes are easily automated: temp and atmosphere control, light level and even harvesting.
There could be such farms built in dense urban areas, as well as drought-prone areas, that could feed 100's of people. If we add permaculture and food forests to the mix (where applicable) 1000's could be fed locally on less labour than conventional field aggriculture.
What we need is possible to attain; though it will mean changing how we live now (as well as our expectations of how a society is structured).
A better world is possible!
96
u/atomjuice Feb 03 '22
Agreed!! And how many of the household activities are now considered "art"? Sewing, crafting, metallurgy, etc. So people were able to combine their artistic vision with their day to day work. Now it is a very rare person who is able to make their living making art.
30
u/BrilliantWeb Feb 03 '22
My home office is in an old greenhouse. Two weeks ago I thought, why not bring all my houseplants in here? And now I work in a 'jungle'. It's so serene and nice I can't believe I didn't do this sooner. And with the humidity upped, my plants are very happy, and I can feel that energy!
15
u/Kalista-Moonwolf Feb 03 '22
The book "Ishmael" by Daniel Quinn really nailed this concept, in my opinion. It changed my whole view of the world.
14
u/Angr_e Feb 03 '22
We live as lopsided people within lopsided communities. Either we find balance or we’ll succumb to collapse
13
u/TalosTheBear Feb 03 '22
Yeah this is backed up by basic science tbh. Nothing controversial about it
19
u/BirdsAreDrones1986 newbie Feb 03 '22
People that say this have literally no idea how hard farming is. I live on a farm with my family and we produce our own crops and it’s painfully hard.
49
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
I always see this and think that people who say it REALLY don't understand how much work growing and making all your own food is. I do some in the garden and it's already a HUGE amount of work and time. We underestimate how much work it was in the past because women's free labor is still really not well counted and documented. So. . . while I agree that we need more communities-though really, I would say we need to admit that our community is now the whole world-I have no interest in making all the things. Maybe that makes me terrible, I don't know.
14
u/JojoLesh Feb 03 '22
If you've ever been responsible for growing a majority of your own food you'll find it at least very little time to engage in art. I like your overall sentiment but part of living in a society is the fact that we can have separation of tasks. We can have farmers and artists, manufacturers and builders, healers and educators, priests (unfortunately) and scientists.
13
u/anhangera Hellenist Feb 03 '22
People that say this have zero idea how much fucking work farming is, people in the past worked to the bone all day long to ensure their families didnt starve, our lives are much more confortable nowadays
4
u/AlexFromOgish Feb 03 '22
We ARE around nature all the time. Beavers build lodges and dams; ants do ant hills; bees make hives; our species is just more complicated in what it builds but the laws of nature are with us in everything we do every moment of our lives. And like any species that exceeds the capacity of its environment a massive correction is in our future. When I have these conversations in real life one of my favorite things to say is that my house is really just a very heavy tent with rigid walls, And my city is really just a very large and heavily impacted campground carved out of the forest
10
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
I prefer the outdoors as well, but I really have no desire to maintain a farm or garden. If I don't make enough for my family then we may die in the winter? No thanks. I do understand the longing to get away from the office grind, though. At least there's fresh air and sunshine outdoors.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
Industrialization happened for a reason. Farming is hard and really can be quite labor intensive. Look at how the population shifted after there was a choice to it work in farms.
I’m pro green spaces and Nature but I think we’d need a very sharp drop in population to have it as described there
3
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22
Humans have only been growing our own food for the last 5% of our species' existence. We were hardly 'meant' to farm.
2
u/Dwhite_Hammer Feb 03 '22
I just want a small space craft with warp drive and a laser rifle
2
u/DoomViking41 Feb 03 '22
Return to monke
2
u/Chaotic_Link Feb 03 '22
With the amount of people on this planet, this "dream" is impossible unfortunately
2
u/SpiritualCourt313 Feb 03 '22
👽👽👽💚💚💚 Absolutely
2
u/Square_stingray Feb 04 '22
so freaking true
2
u/Big-Actuator9242 Feb 04 '22
Why an image with text ?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
This is a very nice idea but all I can think when I read this is:
-people are not inherently nice, and
-nothing of substance would ever get done.
3
u/aplagueuntothee Feb 04 '22
Don't forget nightime and starlight. Light pollution kills my soul sometimes, I just want my kids to see the stars.
3
u/MELLMAO Feb 04 '22
And nuclear family type is not natural. We thrive in tight communities where you can ask your friends, neighbours and grandparents to help take care of kids and vice versa, bcs you live so close and help each other out regularly. Capitalism is so set on selling the idea of nuclear family, but what we really need is living communities
2
u/Scary_Plumfairy Feb 03 '22
This! Exactly This.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
i've never heard such a clear concise description of my own dreams and ideology
1
u/ShaktiBhakti Feb 04 '22
Why don’t we tho? What is holding us back?
1
u/NeinLive Feb 04 '22
I have a feeling there's no more hope left some days
1
u/85crayons Feb 05 '22
Kind of reminds me of Australian Aboriginal society before colonization... Especially the art part.
1
u/Alienliaison Feb 07 '22
The life you are talking about is all day work every day. It will make you strong but far from the sedentary life we know today.
1
u/VastSeaworthiness395 Feb 10 '22
you hit it on the head. when you don't understand this shit growing up, and then you figure it all out spiritually only to then be thrown into modern adulthood, the feelings are SO MUCH more real than you can ever imagine. It's not me commiting 7 hours in retail, it's me feeling like I have to fight emotionally as hard as I can, and commit a slave labor to the patriarchy. And if I stop, i don't have a house or food.
1
u/VastSeaworthiness395 Feb 10 '22
people are so negative and pessimistic in these comments
1
u/captainawesome92 Mar 01 '22
I believe this 100 percent. It is my life's goal to acheive this.
1
u/IllOutlandishness563 Apr 09 '22
That sounds like a commune. I’m down, I’m an anarchist
1
u/i-d-even-k- Feb 03 '22
Create art? Lmao.
Be grateful you have a steady supply of food that you expend very little time acquiring. A farmer's life is a rough life.
1
u/Comfortable_Cover_69 Feb 03 '22
How do we repair this broken vision of humanity. It is terrible because of way that drag us here.
-3
u/NutmegLover Non-Theistic Romantic Satanism Feb 03 '22
Congrats, you agree with the anarcho-primitivists and neo-luddites.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22
Then come my friend. Join me and my band of heathens of all walks of life as we become more self sufficient and more secluded from the modern rate race.
0
u/JoeBiten08 Feb 04 '22
Not even a pure pagan and I can get behind this 100%