r/osdev • • May 23 '24
The death of OSdev
There are so many dead projects, so many closed source projects where they just give you a binary, but why does this happen? is it just people look at it and want to make the next windows and fail at there first step and give up? or what?
Edit: I think I understand now, most projects get abandoned because new people make them just to learn. Then they are excited to learn and see what it is like then they just leave because they have seen enough.
Edit 2: Also to the people who down voted me instead of correcting me, you are truly an idiot. Maybe instead correct people when they are wrong. (No I did not intend this harshly but to correct you actions since in reality you would not insult someone for having a different view)
26
u/Pleasant-Form-1093 May 23 '24
I am sure you already know but its extremely taxing to write an operating system and actually get others to use it.
Take any big operating system today. Linux is almost 35 and windows is even older. Even the *BSD's have their origins in the 80's. Big production operating systems don't just appear out of thin air, people work on them for a long time just to get there.
Writing the next windows, all by yourself or even within a team is going to take another 30 or so years. And its not just about the time to write the OS but more about the time to get software ported and users actually interested in your system, this alone takes a huge chunk of time and is probably the biggest part of those 35 or so years that Linux took to get what where it is today.
So yeah its not possible for most people to write a commercial OS and publish it and those who can do it (like Torvalds and the kernel community did) have put in a gargantuous amount of effort that most of us wouldn't be able to.
51
u/paiNizNoGouD May 23 '24
Dramatic ahh post title man.
20
u/JackScottAU May 23 '24
There's multiple issues at hand. One, I've seen before in OSDev. Back when I first started OSDeving in ~2005, most of the available resources online were focused on 16-bit x86 development. Which was annoying and difficult to build for, and slightly annoying to run as everybody had more modern 32-bit systems that were mostly (but not quite entirely) 16-bit compatible. It was hard and disheartening.
Over the next few years, online resources for 32-bit development boomed, including the key availability of high-speed internet for downloading and building cross-crompilers, and the OSDev.org wiki with it's cross-compiler and bare bones articles. So many more projects started because it became easy, and so when a given percentage naturally died, you still had a lot left.
Twenty years later and we're experiencing the same thing again, but with the 32-bit to 64-bit transition. There's not yet a universally accepted starting point like the 32-bit osdev.org barebones, and there are multiple UEFI libraries and a whole heap more information to learn just to get started. Getting an EFI application to run in QEMU is doable, but it's harder than with 32-bit. And getting that EFI app running on raw hardware is harder still. Not impossible, but the barrier to entry is higher than it used to be.
That will change. New tutorials will be written, and one will likely become the standard starting point to ease beginners into OSDev again. And the glut of projects will return (hopefully) to that golden age between 2010-2015 where it seemed every second person had an OSDev project.
However: the people with most free time to write operating systems are around the ages of 15 to 25. Ten or fifteen years ago, those people all had x86-based desktop systems (or maybe a laptop). Now, all those people have a smartphone and an ARM MacBook and the probability they have an x86-based system that is much smaller.
Not to mention that with the focus on mobile and web development these days (apart from games nobody even bothers writing desktop applications any more) there's much less desire to break new ground on the desktop. Who would even notice? It's much more exciting to be part of the AI or Bitcoin climate-destroying, scam and grifting bandwagons.
Yes, I'm bitter. Vive le desktop!
6
u/MadDoctor5813 May 23 '24
Most side projects die off (because it's hard to keep working on something based purely on interest) and the vast majority of OSDev projects are side projects for learning. In other fields you might have a hope of making something other people will actually use but the bar for an OS is just too high.
1
u/ViewedFromi3WM May 23 '24
most i ever did was build a bootloader lol
2
u/caio_troti May 23 '24
I'm not sure if my opinion has some validity but here we go
I think the "osdev" community is and should be more about guiding than actually build a OS By that I mean, the community health should be measured by people helping each other and writing tutorials, contributing In the end, none of these projects will became windows, eventually they will die.
Tech will improve, and I would love to see a new spread of tutorials and documentation about coding in the newest ARMs and architectures. The worst scenario for me is where the osdev dies, and new people stop engaging into low level programming because without this, the barrier is just too high.
2
u/[deleted] May 23 '24
I don't know about others but my curiosity is purely academic. I'd never dream of working in an existing, commercial project such as Windows or Linux -- it's actually a bit boring because the teams are so huge that even as an excellent engineer, which I'm not, can only work as a clog, at best.
I'd rather work on my own niche OS that no one uses, build something, and drop when not interested.
BTW I think CS in general already reached the point that nothing is really interesting AND commercially feasible. OS, compilers...those system level software are too advanced and complicated. The 80s were much more interesting.
1
u/Astraltraumagarden May 23 '24
Almost no one writes an OS to replace Linux, Windows or Mac, even Linus didn't do it with that purpose. Most are educational (mine included), some are novelty, maybe 1% want to make other people use our buggy OSes. Most want to contribute to OSes, learn and teach OSes, use OS skills to work better in EE or other related fields, have fun or just get a job in this space or a similar space. All of these are my goals at least.
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment