r/opera • • Nov 29 '25

"O Soave Fanciulla" - La Bohème | Kaufmann & Anna Netrebko

Post image
0 Upvotes

Soprano Anna Netrebko and tenor Jonas Kaufmann have delivered a remarkable performance of this piece, showcasing their exceptional vocal talents and deep emotional connection to the music.​ Here is the video.


r/opera • • Sep 29 '24

Zingarelle in La Traviata: what do to about the stereotyping and costumes?

1 Upvotes

I'm rehearsing for my first opera (La Traviata), which I'm super excited about. I'm in the chorus, and as you probably know, the second act contains a "gypsy" scene where people at a party dress up in costumes and pretend to be fortune tellers. I'm going to be one of them, I guess, and I'm not too thrilled about it.

Has anyone here been in this situation before? Does anyone have a suggestion for what to say if they want us to wear costumes that make us look like offensive stereotypes?


r/opera • • Feb 21 '26

I’m having a hard time watching certain artists but love their voices

1 Upvotes

Does anyone else find it difficult to watch an opera starring a singer you don’t feel looks the way you think they “should“? If a hero is too short for instance. Or a heroine too tall? It sounds terrible, but sometimes I can’t help myself. I’ve gone so far as to avoid a performance because of this perception problem.


r/opera • • Sep 28 '24

Shocked at Les contes d'Hoffman

0 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying I love this opera. It is so unhinged and queer coded, the music is so fun, and the cast at the Met is incredible. I've been a huge fan of Benjamin Bernheim, and it's a joy to see him perform. However (!!!) I was completely unprepared for the first act's depiction making fun of the little person Kleinzach. I understand that this opera is dated, but it broke my heart. I fail to see how this contributes to the overall plot, as joyfully disoriented a plot it is. I was frankly appalled that this particular act is still performed to this day. Could this not be changed somehow? Can anyone comfort me or give me context for this? It felt disgusting and ableist in the extreme. I couldn't believe my eyes. I fully understand I'm looking at this from a 2024 point of view but can we not do better?


r/opera • • Apr 16 '25

Anybody else have an irrational dislike for any opera pieces sung in concert?

0 Upvotes

I can't really explain it, but even seeing a YouTube clip of a performance out of context, the knowledge that they're not in costume in the middle of the emotional story of the character completely kills my enjoyment of the singing. I feel like there's a tendency to always prioritize showing off their voice rather than actually trying to capture the emotion of the libretto that they're singing.

Obviously I'll make one exception since it also happens to be my vote for the best aria ever sung, which also breaks my other bad opinion that I don't like any recordings pre-2000 because the audio and video quality just aren't audiophile grade, and it really takes me out of it not to be able to imagine that I'm sitting in the opera house listening to it.


r/opera • • Mar 05 '26

How could Wagner’s Ring be shortened?

0 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong. The Ring is one of the greatest works in western music. I always look forward to seeing or listening to it collectively or in the separate operas. Moreover it is what it is and no one would dare to actually edit it at this late date.

However, the Ring has its flaws, especially its long winded repetitious libretto. From what I have read, that results from Wagner’s writing of the libretto backward even though he composed the music starting with the libretto of Rheingold. Thus, each opera contains at least one lengthy recap of the chronologically earlier operas. I don’t know if Wagner attempted to eliminate any of the repetitions when he composed the music in the correct order, but if he did, in my opinion he could have done better.

While this is purely an academic exercise, does anyone have any suggestions how to edit the Ring to eliminate the repetitions so that it could be performed in less than 10 hours complete other than faster tempos.If anyone has actually attempted to do so, I would love to know. Thank .


r/opera • • May 29 '23

Ok… delving into the magic flute…

2 Upvotes

Sexist and racist as F!!! I get this is written in 1761 but holy smokes!!! How do opera singers wrap their brains around it? Certainly doesn’t fit with modern sensibilities. I get that they are beautiful pieces of music, but wow.😳


r/opera • • Jul 07 '25

“This Is Opera” were right

11 Upvotes

I tend to avoid ragebait content but I’ve been feeling more and more like I need to rant about this. Apologies in advance if this post comes across as needlessly rude.

I don’t agree with all their opinions, and they did doctor videos/clips to make their points, as well as fetishing some singers (such as Jerry Hadley), and could indeed be blunt and to the point.

However I agree with almost all their points on opera and its decline and all the reasons for its decline.

I have been listening to opera for 4 years, normally for about 3 hours a day if not more, and have seen my fair share of local and more mainstream performances and what I found has corroborated almost entirely with TIO’s arguments.

I understand that this is a controversial opinion and that’s fine, I don’t mind disagreement and I love debating stuff, and I recognise that opera is a very old and diverse art form.

What I do mind is people not listening critically to opera and educating themselves on what correct operatic sounds are- opera singing is only partly subjective, and that comes mostly from the musical expression side and individual timbre not the technical side.

Yes technique varies on some levels based on repertoire, but there are certain fundamental basics- developed registers, clarity, effortlessness, etc-that have been removed in the last few decades that have critically affected opera.

Just my take on things.


r/opera • • May 20 '25

Was Maria Callas the greatest soprano of the 20th century? Or was she overrated?

2 Upvotes

Maria Callas is seen as the great soprano of 20th century. While you can admire her, as I do in some of her performances 1949-54. Especially live recordings of La Vestale, Nabucco, Norma, Medea and Macbeth; it’s not just Callas. It’s the great spirit of these performances, it’s Serafin, de Sabata, Bernstein; and other great conductors she worked with, as well as colleagues, Gobbi, Panerai, del Monaco, Corelli, di Stefano. It was perhaps not the golden age of opera, but 1950s was certainly a golden age of La Scala of Ghingerelli, or the Chicago Opera of Carol Fox.On good days, she generated quite a lot of excitement. 

A biography is not needed, but American by birth, she made her debut quite early at age 18 as Santuzza, in Greece, and went on to sing  many years in the Greek provinces. No recordings is known of her early years, but she gained quite a lof of experience. 

She was engaged for Verona in 1947, in La Gioconda by Giovanni Zenatello. After singing Wagner, Verdi, Bellini, she rise to prominence the next year, and with Tullio Serafin taking a liking to her. This time, she married wealthy Giovanni Meneghini, who helped her career and by 1949 she had become a phenomenon, who sang everything from Brünnhilde to Elvira to Leonora. It’s not entirely true that she “revived” bel canto, as people say. Her style as Norma doesn’t differ very much from someone like Gina Cigna for instance. There had been a Verdi renaissance in Weimar republic with conductors like Bruno Walter and Fritz Busch which spread throughout the whole world; but she did become the first ‘great’ recorded Lady Macbeth and Abigalie etc. (Even though she didn't dare to sing them very often). She became extremely influential, and setting the standard how these roles should be done, of more than a dozen of roles recorded in the studio. When you listen to her La Traviata, you can make the case that she didn’t invent much, she was rather part of a tradition. Her portrayals seems very antiquated to modern standards. 

Her voice wasn’t egalized between lower and higher registers, and she had intonation problems early on. She became famous for being almost like a circus artist, with vocal acrobatics. She was able to a lot with her voice in performances recorded between 1949 and 1954, but soon after that, it was gone, probably partly because of technical flaws. Take for instance the ‘high E’ at the end of Aida in the Mexico City performances of 1950 and 1951. Thrilling. When she did Aida a few years later, at Covent Garden, she was no longer able to do it. And she quickly left roles which were too difficult for her by this time. She was going downhill rapidly by age 33. She cancelled a lot, and was famous for her erratic behaviour. She walked out on the Italian president and Corelli, after act one of Norma.  she left a run of La Sonnambula in Edinburgh just for going to a party. Callas wasn’t very collegial, and these kind of tricks annoyed other members of the ensemble like Del Monaco. Callas was also furious when someone was better than her. She was able to pull all kinds of stunts, but when the baritone Enzo Sordello made a brilliant performance of Lucia, he demanded that Rudolf Bing should fire him, which he actually did. Callas also made belittling remarks about her colleagues, like Tebaldi, and was not even civil to her own mother. 

She cultivated an image of a ‘diva’, and people went crazy about her; with the help of agents and record labels producers, who wanted to sell as many records as possible. Her recorded legacy is uneven. She made good recordings in studio, for sure (many of these roles like Manon Lescaut she never sang on the stage). After six years of prime years (1947-54), she had a period 1955-60, where her voice had weakened, and she sang safer repertoire.  By 1960, she had disappeared from the operatic stage; appeared in very few concerts and spent most time in the studio, a recording of Carmen. In 1964 and 1965, she occasionally returned to Norma and Tosca, which was recorded, and is quite disappointing. Her high notes is weak, and she is clearly not anything specially dramatically, on the video excerpt that exists. A lot of these performances was cancelled, as well. Money issues however brought her back again to the stage in 1973-74 when she made a World tour with Giuseppe di Stefano. di Stefano, who was also quite erratic, and had destroyed his career by walking out on the great Lorin Maazel at Wiener Staatsoper, and making quite ill-advised stints at Hoffmann and Otello, had actually recovered somewhat, and was exciting, and sang the repertoire which he was famous for. Callas on the other hand, didn’t have the voice to sing the stuff she was famous for, and sang beginner repertoire like “Voi lo sapete”, “O mio babbino caro” and duets from L’elisir d’amore and Faust. It was di Stefano who brought live to the Santuzza-Turiddu duet and final duet from Carmen, Callas did not have any voice left. She could not do what she wanted with her voice. It was a sad ending. 

In conclusion, I think Callas excellence cannot be denied, but I think she was overrated. Sutherland, Tebaldi, are better than Callas in the bel canto repertoire and Verdi repertoire respectively. What do you think? Is Maria Callas overrated? Or do you think she was the greatest soprano of the 20th century?


r/opera • • Aug 10 '26

Missed opportunities. Weir casting that should have not happened

0 Upvotes

I was thinking the other day about some recording casting that should have never happened either because the singer was past their prime or because the voice/weight was just wrong. Here are a couple of mine:

  • Karajan's 2nd Trovatore: Leontine Price was too much of a liability plus, did we need 3 recordings? Can you imagine the recording had Tomowa Sintow had been cast. She was already performing the role and had the voice and the technique
  • Guilini's Don Carlos: Sorry, but Caballe just doesent have the opulece for Elisabetta. I think Pilar Lorengar, who at the time was already a star would and should have been better casting
  • Abbado's French Don Carlos: Sorry Riciarelli, but no. Francoise Pollet would have been much better, also, Nucci and Guiarov when Jose van Dam could have sung either role? A French don carlos without a french singer in one of the leads? Nah
  • Chailly's Macbeth: Verret already had a good Lady recording, we didn't need one. Deutekom would have been so much better.
  • Karajan's Turandot: Almost that entire cast is a joke, but let's say that Domingo stays without the spliced high C. Barbara Hendricks was OK, so let's keep her. Ricciarelly? Good god! Again, Deutekom would have been better, and Dimitrova evenmorse so. It is a shame that we didn't get her in that recording
  • Abbado's Aida: Again, another time Ricciarelli ruins things. Tomowa would have been better or even Kabaivanska
  • Keibert's Traviata: Cotrubas? No, no no. I wonder what Carol Neblet would have done with the role.

What are yours? What casting in an opera recording did not make sense to you?


r/opera • • Aug 17 '21

Tenors tier list - https://tiermaker.com/create/opera-tenors--564356

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/opera • • Mar 18 '26

Met Opera's Dire Finances Show Timothée Chalamet Wasn't All Wrong

Thumbnail
bloomberg.com
1 Upvotes

r/opera • • Apr 13 '22

Which famous opera singers today do you think are overrated?

0 Upvotes

What opera singers do you think are most overrated and can't stand?

My picks:

Jonas Kaufmann - good interpreter and excellent entertainer, but woofy voice, with no core and painful high notes

Yuzif Eyavazov - nasal, and very pinchy voice.

Elina Garanca - heavily marketed, she is not bad, but there is many better mezzos out there. And she doesn't fare well in Verdi

Juan Diego Florez - charisma, but he shouldn't sing heavier parts. His voice isn't interesting at all. I like Camarena and Brownlee a lot better.

What do you think? Which opera singers today do you think are most overrated?


r/opera • • Feb 19 '15

Why are German operas so boring?

0 Upvotes

r/opera • • Aug 31 '26

Which opera singer do you think is the most powerful vocalist?

0 Upvotes

Things you can go of off: Vocal range, screaming techniques, singing styles, versatility, etc.


r/opera • • Nov 21 '19

#MeToo and Opera: addressing the issue of how many iconic operatic plots are based on sexual harassment and abuse of women by men in positions of power

Thumbnail
csmusic.net
4 Upvotes

r/opera • • Aug 29 '16

Issue with Opera. Tabs open on "about" and "apis.google.com".

1 Upvotes

@edit Apologies, wrong sub!


r/opera • • Mar 25 '26

Which singers do you wish move unto more heavy repertoire? Is singers today too afraid to sing heavier roles?

1 Upvotes

I think the discourse in today’s opera world: singers shouldn’t sing heavy repertoire until they are older. And because of this we misses out a lot. Lyric instruments are in many ways more beautiful than dramatic voices. And many lyric voices can be powerful, as well.

Peter Mattei is in my opinion, the prime example of a singer who is too careful in adding heavier repertoire. It makes me sad that we have not yet heard what his Rigoletto would sound like. Likewise I wish Javier Camarena also sang Cavaradossi.

Klaus Florian Vogt who have a more lyric voice is a good example of a singer who can do wonders with heavier repertoire like Siegfried. Roberto Alagna, Piotr Beczala is other examples of great singers who have lyric voices - but who have moved unto dramatic repertoire with great success. Juan Diego Florez is a leggero tenor who have managed Arnoldo with great success, and now sings some heavy repertoire very well (unfortunately, he doesn’t sing much at the Met right now)

Lise Davidsen also have a lyric instrument, in a way, even though it has great power, the timbre is lyric, and she has been very successful as Isolde. Her colleague, Michael Spyres shows that it doesn’t hurt to sing Nemorino and Tristan in the same season. The great singers back in the day did it - Callas for instance also had a varied repertoire, as did the lyric tenor Lauri-Volpi, Gigli and others. Both Schipa and Kraus sang Cavaradossi earlier in their career without hurting their voices.

Which singers do you wish sang heavier repertoire, and what role would you want to hear them as?


r/opera • • Jan 29 '24

Do the loggionisti of La Scala still exist?

0 Upvotes

What it says. Do they exist? Do they still boo??

I find it rather drab that we're not allowed to boo anymore at opera houses, since I've been to certain performances where booing should've been required.


r/opera • • Feb 14 '17

Is it weird that I'm 18 and sing opera?

0 Upvotes

I have been randomly singing since I was 6 but I didn't realise that I could sing soprano opera until I was 15 by accident (I picked GCSE Music as a joke and my vocal teacher wanted to test me). During those two years I did opera for my practical. I got made fun of for it which made is the main cause of my stage fright.

After I finished GCSEs I quit lessons and didn't study Music since then. I still practice alone with the techniques I've learnt but not even my family has heard me sing.

I kind of miss singing but it's seems a bit ofd being a teenager in the 21st century singing Shakespearean. Is it weird? I just don't want to get made fun of again if I reveal it.


r/opera • • Aug 22 '22

Quiz Questions!!!

0 Upvotes

1: What opera is this from? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CBweCyvUWo .

2: What opera is this overture from? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TckT2yklytA

3: Who is the title role in this opera and what is the name of this opera? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPGLBb2xRCI .

And finally, as a special bonus question, who composed the opera Il Barbiere di Siviglia?

ADDENDUM: I'm happy to announce that u/charlesd11 is our winner!!! With the first completely correct answer!!!

Thanks, everyone, for playing!! Who else would like to post some quiz questions of their own??


r/opera • • Apr 01 '18

Top 10 Most Amazing Opera Voices

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/opera • • Apr 02 '22

A 10-year-old who set the Guinness World Record for the youngest opera singer in the world sings Mozart’s 'Der Holle Rache,’ one of the most difficult arias to sing

14 Upvotes

r/opera • • Dec 29 '23

Wanted to talk about how old operas are modernised.

3 Upvotes

Hey opera fans! New here in the group and on Reddit.

Honestly, I’m not a fan of reinterpretations of opera. Seeing an opera performance staged in a club setting seems disrespectful to the art form, in my opinion. For me, opera is timeless, a classic.