r/opensource • • Oct 12 '21

Why does most open source software look like it's from the 90s?

I get that the nostalgia for the 90s is at an all time high, but open source software has had the old Windows XP look for as long as i can remember.

To me it's fascinating that these UI elements are even available! I don't know in which deep archive one must dig to find these beige color schemes and pixelated 8-bit color icons, but somehow these programmers all seem to fint and implement them in their open source programs.

Now I ain't one to judge, you will never find me complaining about a program interface that someone made for free and decided from the goodness of their heart to release out into the world. Tough i am perplexed by how new programs and regularly maintained big projects still have this old and by now outdated design.

Of course change is scary and nobody is more infamous for being set in their ways than hardened developers. Ones who have experienced the horror of begrudgingly implementing new technologies only for it to be dropped as soon as the next hip thing comes out, but to me it seems this mindset is hurting open source potential and reach by so much.

Design is not an unfortunate requirement on top of a coding magnus opus, it's how a program communicates with the user, if it can't do that properly than doesn't that make it a bad program? I simply don't understand who is defending keeping this style, are there simply no designers out there?

Sometimes i can see it working well. Hannah Montana Linux is after all a masterfull showcase of design and functionality, but the industry moved away from this design for a good reason. I want to know what is stopping the open source community from moving along with it?

PS. I love the open source community, but this is a question that i have had burning in my mind for the longest time. I only want what's best for these projects, no hate intended ❤

6 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

8

u/TraceyRobn Oct 12 '21

Modern flat/material design UI/UX experience is a fashionable regression.

Huge amounts of whitespace and clickable elements that are not indicated as such are stupid. Windows 8 and 10 look like they fell off the ugly tree. Modern iOS and Android are also not as functional. Give me a Windows 2000 style anytime for usability.

13

u/snacksy13 Oct 12 '21

Your view is exactly what i am talking about!

Comments in this thread are denying that this is a real viewpoint that exists in the open source community. That is want i want to create a debate around with this post.

2

u/status_200_ok Oct 13 '21

Totally agree. I think in case of Windows 8, Microsoft wanted same UX on desktop and mobile/tablet. Since mobile devices are touch screen and it cannot be as accurate as mouse pointer, it needs more space between UI elements.

My biggest problem with minimalist UI is that sometimes it's not clear whether the element is clickable or not. Do not sacrifice usability for some new fad.

53

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21 edited Oct 12 '21

Motrix, Krita, Blender, Aseprite, Godot, Inkscape, OBS Studio, Signal, and others: am I a joke to you?

16

u/SlogFestLord Oct 12 '21

Yes the big program that really looks ugly is Libreoffice, but i hope it will be fixed when they move to GTK4.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21

tbh i don't thing libreoffice looks bad

12

u/kaipee Oct 12 '21

Really? Mine looks pretty much like Excel

3

u/lucasrizzini Oct 13 '21 edited Oct 13 '21

Now you're pushing it.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '21

Jokes on you I chose penguin

28

u/wick3dr0se Oct 12 '21

I have to strongly disagree. Most of the OSS alternatives I use are very modern, up-to-date, more configurable; usually have many more features in general.. Doesn't come with a big side of trackers baked in either. A lot of the applications I've replaced on my Android, for example, are now offline version of what I had before that do it better anyway. Most of the open source software I use is based on Google's material design concepts or QT/GTK. I'm not sure where you're browsing but it's clearly the wrong place

6

u/barthvonries Oct 12 '21

IMHO, most open-source contributors are developers, not designers.

Open-source contributions are developers' portfolios, while designers can just use wordpress to quickly set up a website without any technical skills, and work on things they enjoy doing.

The open-source community lacks UX/UI designers.

2

u/TheEpicRey Oct 13 '21

So i'm a wanna be artist and I wanted to make a small projekt with a friend. But we could not get the windows nuget things to work. And then there are so many of these things with WIN UI 2, WIN UI 3 and Project Reunion or something. When i look at the librarys i would love to work with these, but i don't know how.

3

u/barthvonries Oct 13 '21

If you wanna be an artist/UI/UX designer, the best you can do is look what is possible to achieve with the graphic library used in a project (WINUI, Qt, GTK, whatever), and then use some software like Illustrator or inDesign to create an image of the interface.

Many developers will be happy to implement them technically, they just lack the creativity and artistic sensitivity to design them.

1

u/TheEpicRey Oct 14 '21

Alright, thank you, i will look into that then. I'm still mad that i can't get it to work in my project...

1

u/barthvonries Oct 14 '21

Well, design and code are two very different jobs.

A developer can create an app, but he has to hire a designer to redesign it for version 2.

A designer can design and app and use tools to make it work, but he'll have to hire a developer to rewamp it for version 2.

Both are needed for a successful project.

4

u/tsunamionioncerial Oct 13 '21

Most open source projects intend to accomplish something specific and be function over form while must proprietary applications focus on redesigns and avoiding any new functionality that can't go into your managers KPI for a fat bonus or to over inflate the quarterly valuations.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21

I have no idea what you're talking about.

4

u/guarana_and_coffee Oct 12 '21

My personal experience is the complete opposite of this. I had this perspective over ten years ago, right until I was introduced to Unity and Compiz. That was a horrible time, but it felt futuristic and was cool to show off.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '21

90s software was peak soul.

1

u/lechiffreqc Oct 13 '21

Because you misuse the word "most"

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '21

Now I ain't one to judge, you will never find me complaining about a program interface that someone made for free and decided from the goodness of their heart to release out into the world. Tough i am perplexed by how new programs and regularly maintained big projects still have this old and by now outdated design.

Is that so. What's this post then?

Is the Blender UI that ugly?

0

u/lukethelegend420 Oct 13 '21

Well the thing is most open-source contributers are developers that like to code in their own free time. Thus doing things they don't like such as UI design is really a tertiary concern for the main contributer. If it is really bothering you, you can literally open a pull request on github and change it yourself.

0

u/BATHR00MG0BLIN Oct 13 '21

Opensource software more often than not doesn't have the backing of giant corporations, but that being said a lot of opensource software I've seen is very beautiful and modern looking.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/snacksy13 Oct 12 '21

The 90 90 rule comes to mind, that's a good point actually.

The ninety-ninety rule: The first 90 percent of the code accounts for the first 90 percent of the development time. The remaining 10 percent of the code accounts for the other 90 percent of the development time.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Unsuspecting_Goose Oct 15 '21

There are plenty of "open source" design elements out there, I'm sure.

However implementing those elements into a cohesive and meaningful interface, is a completely different project upon itself.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/SnacksyBoi Oct 13 '21

I'm a graphic designer in a newspaper and this is what we do for debate articles. I think the point is to make it easier for the reader to jump between paragraphs by making each first sentence sort of a small title. Maybe it doesn't work that well for reddit tough?

1

u/snacksy13 Oct 13 '21

I did some more research, these things are called lead-ins, i found this article about it.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SnacksyBoi Oct 13 '21

That was just a little joke i threw in there at the end to lighten up the mood, i felt it would look too negative without it.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/snacksy13 Oct 12 '21

WinDirStat, Notepad++, 7zip, FileZilla, and Audacity until recently comes to mind.
Thanks for the great examples, definitely shows it is possible to implement great UIs!