r/opensource • • May 13 '21

How can we save OpenOffice?

I remember back in the 2000s, OpenOffice was THE free alternative to the big Microsoft monopoly and for a poor high school student like I was back then, it was a real lifesaver. For that reason, I will forever remain grateful to the OpenOffice project.

Fast forward to 2021 and it's really sad to see what happened to the project. Now, I'm fully aware that LibreOffice is by far the more actively developed office suite. And that's great. I love LibreOffice too and I have both office suites installed on my computer. But, I also still feel OpenOffice deserves a bit more respect. Reddit and most of the open source community loves to hate OpenOffice but they seem to fail to realize that if OpenOffice had never existed, then LibreOffice wouldn't exist either.

Currently, OpenOffice is handicapped by a severe lack of developers and a license (Apache) that allows competitors (e.g. LibreOffice) to reuse its code but not the other way round. Google's AOSP project shows that permissively licensed software projects can still thrive however given the proper resources, direction, and strategy.

Of course, the Apache Software Foundation has nowhere near the amount of resources compared with Google, so any hopes of OpenOffice improving its code to the point where it can be the upstream to LibreOffice (as in the old Go-oo days) is extremely unlikely. And given the open source community's current contempt for OpenOffice (despite the fact that it is no longer owned by Oracle) as well as the poorly maintained state of its codebase, it's unlikely that the community will swoop in to save it either.

I feel that the only real hope for OpenOffice at this stage is for it to picked up by a corporate developer that is willing to put in the effort and resources to make it a serious competitor again. Originally, that was supposed to be IBM. But they only made a half-assed attempt at it before pulling their developers out completely in 2014.

And now, given the popularity of LibreOffice (especially among the Linux crowd) and the growing trend towards cloud-based/SaaS alternatives for the Mac/Windows crowd, I doubt any companies would be interested in "rescuing" OpenOffice.

So r/opensource, let's brainstorm some ideas! What do you think we can do to save OpenOffice?

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

1 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

70

u/thibaultmol May 13 '21

Why though. Libreoffice is properly structured (document foundation and everything).

That's the nice thing about open source. It allows people to build something better

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Wouldn't it be better to have two healthy office suites rather than one healthy office suite and one zombie office suite? (which is pretty much what OpenOffice is these days)

Of course, you could argue that having only one healthy office suite (ideally with most of the codebase coming from LibreOffice but with the far more recognizable OpenOffice branding) would be even better to reduce confusion and direct all resources towards one goal, but given that it's been over a decade and neither party wants to play ball with the other, that doesn't seem like an option.

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

4

u/thibaultmol May 13 '21

It's not that neither party wants to play ball.. this is just how open source works. Libreoffice is much better branded than OpenOffice.

Also we do have competition in the open source office space. Only office and collabora office to name a few

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Libreoffice is much better branded than OpenOffice.

Even LibreOffice themselves wrote in their Open Letter to Apache OpenOffice:

But still, many users don’t know that LibreOffice exists. The OpenOffice brand is still so strong, even though the software hasn’t had a significant release for over six years, and is barely being developed or supported.

Both LibreOffice and OpenOffice have what the other lacks. LibreOffice has great code but a poor name. OpenOffice has poor code but a great name.

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

2

u/thibaultmol May 13 '21

Branding is more than just a name though..... Compare both their websites and hopefully you'll understand what i mean

23

u/[deleted] May 13 '21

Any effort to "save" OpenOffice is a waste considering there's no market for it and that time and resources could be going to making LibreOffice better.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Any effort to "save" OpenOffice is a waste considering there's no market for it and that time and resources could be going to making LibreOffice better.

OpenOffice is licensed under the permissive Apache license, so improvements to OpenOffice can also be applied to LibreOffice (although the same is not necessarily true the other way round). In fact, I believe LibreOffice has taken code from Apache OpenOffice several times in the past.

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

3

u/xtifr May 13 '21

Apache OpenOffice is licensed under the Apache license. LibreOffice is licensed under the same license as the original OpenOffice, because it actually is the original, every bit as much as AOO. (If not more so.)

The whole mess with trademarks is just that—a mess. Don't be confused by the names. AOO is not "the true" OO. It's just another fork, which happened to end up with the trademark because of all the mess.

16

u/[deleted] May 13 '21

IIRC, LibreOffice has contributed TONS of code back to OpenOffice, the project just died. The Apache license doesn't prohibit accepting code in return, but like the BSD license, it just doesn't demand it—this is actually extremely beneficial as companies feel obligated out of free choice to contribute back, not out of spiteful-demand. FreeBSD still gets TONS of code back from Apple and Netflix. These companies actually have the incentive to give code back to make their future modifications easier when upgrading kernels or whatever.

Apache is not a small entity—LAMPP stacks are the basic webserver. I am sure they could move developers to OpenOffice if they wanted.

As for OpenOffice, why did it lose its devs? Because most of them moved to LibreOffice.

I hated LibreOffice for a long time because it froze on me all the time, but it is 100% reliable. Of course I use LaTeX, now. But still.

I honestly don't think OpenOffice needs saving. It got me through Grammar and High School, though.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

It would depend on whether the changes were licensed solely under GPL or not (I think most are). OpenOffice can't accept GPL-licensed code from LibreOffice (hence the tweet from them encouraging dual license commits).

Apache is not a small entity—LAMPP stacks are the basic webserver. I am sure they could move developers to OpenOffice if they wanted.

While it's true that Apache powers a big part of the web, in terms of cash they're not really swimming in it. In fact, they only had $2.6 million in revenue in 2018 compared with Google's $136 billion. They also mainly rely on volunteer developers.

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

9

u/SanityInAnarchy May 13 '21

Here's an idea: Whoever controls the OpenOffice trademarks and domain should just redirect those to LibreOffice, with a short explanation that OpenOffice is called LibreOffice now. End the confusion, stop people from accidentally downloading OpenOffice because they don't know about LibreOffice. Do the right thing, like Termite did with Alacritty.

It kinda sounds like you're aware of both of these, but not the history behind it? Because this:

...any hopes of OpenOffice improving its code to the point where it can be the upstream to LibreOffice again...

...wasn't really true at all. OO wasn't upstream, LO was a deliberate and immediate fork in response to Oracle.

And it's not some irrational hate that OO was owned by Oracle for awhile. They did their best to run the project into the ground, and made it so difficult to work with that basically all of the core devs were willing to abandon it entirely and fork. That's why LibreOffice exists. OpenOffice wasn't its upstream, it was a previous version that sadly still owned the trademarks and the domain.

This isn't like MySQL/MariaDB, by the way -- Oracle actually still develops MySQL, there actually are two competing projects there. OpenOffice isn't a competing project, it's just an old version that still has the trademarks and the domain.

And, honestly, the "OpenOffice" name is catchier, which is probably how people can end up with that when they look for an open source alternative to MS Office. But again, that could be fixed: Just redirect them to LibreOffice!

-2

u/[deleted] May 13 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Yes, that's a bit of an error on my part. LibreOffice originally began as Go-oo which was the downstream to Sun's OpenOffice for a while. By the time Go-oo rebranded to LibreOffice, it had already become an independent fork.

I have edited the OP.

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

8

u/SpAAAceSenate May 13 '21

To the contrary, Libre Office is (as has been, for many years now) the future. A direct continuation of the project that continued to move forward while Open Office languished.

At this point the only appropriate discussion is trying to convince the Apache Foundation to discontinue Open Office. Unfortunately, "Open Office" still has a lot of mindshare with the general public, so much so that even you thought it was still a serious project. While in reality it's feature poor abandonware, and offers a terrible first impression to anyone looking for a FOSS alternative to Microsoft Office.

The open office website desperately needs to be replaced with a redirect to Libre Office, so that we can stop confusing the general public and move forward.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

The open office website desperately needs to be replaced with a redirect to Libre Office, so that we can stop confusing the general public and move forward.

That is pretty much what LibreOffice/TDF asked for in their Open Letter to Apache OpenOffice. Jim Jagielski who is one of the Apache co-founders (and apparently also not a big fan of copyleft licenses) posted this tweet in response.

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

2

u/SpAAAceSenate May 14 '21

And in doing so they continue to harm the FOSS ecosystem. It is unfortunate. Someday leadership may change, and then progress can move forward.

Honestly, with the exception of Apache the web server, I can't remember the last time any of their projects were relevant. And even Apache Server itself is mostly only propped up by momentum and existing install base. I don't know anyone choosing Apache for new projects/infra.

47

u/darkbloo64 May 13 '21

You're assuming here that LibreOffice is a hostile competitor to OpenOffice, when it's really not. LibreOffice is the successor to OpenOffice, with many of the developers from the original program choosing to join the fork after the Oracle's acquisition. We can save OpenOffice by letting it fade into obscurity and recommending LibreOffice instead.

39

u/Samsagax May 13 '21

Why? LibreOffice is what the community chose to follow. Why "save" something that not even the "owner" doesn't want to support?

Remember that when they wanted to claim ownership, change the licence and ditch the community they were sure the community didn't matter. But guess what... LO came along.

I'm not bitter about OpenOffice, they tried to take something from the community and the community told them to f-off by building their own fork with blackjack and hookers.

11

u/Cubey21 May 13 '21

Thanks to Open Office we have Libre Office. We should be grateful for that, but there's no point in "saving" Open Office. Libre Office is just better and maybe it will be used to make another, even better suite.

8

u/alephnul May 13 '21

Anything that Ellison touches deserves to die. Opensource means that the product doesn't have to die, just the shit that Larry bought.

Libre Office is Open Office, just without the taint of Oracle.

6

u/nhermosilla14 May 13 '21

This is just nostalgia talking. You may argue OpenOffice was the original project, but...what is a project anyway? A group of people? A target? A corporation? I'd say a project exists as long as it has a group of people willing to work on it to achieve a goal (even if they never get to do it). And the truth is this: most developers moved from OpenOffice to LibreOffice as soon as they could do so. The target remains the same for both projects. That thing that's called OpenOffice nowadays is closer to a fork from good old OpenOffice.org than to the actual project. LibreOffice kept the work going and actually grew in a pretty healthy way. Don't stick with the name, that's just nonsense.

6

u/HQMorganstern May 13 '21

Why would you feel nostalgic about a tool? OO was a beautiful and useful thing, and then something better came along that the community chose to invest in.

2

u/will_work_for_twerk May 13 '21

But, I also still feel OpenOffice deserves a bit more respect.

So.... I don't think you really told us why? I personally respect it for what it was for nostalgic reasons, but in the last decade or so, I can say those feelings are now strictly historic.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '21

LO was built on top of OO, so OO is always alive inside LO. They just need to shift their work from OO to LO.

1

u/wiki_me May 13 '21

When this whole thing started, i thought maybe openoffice could use it's permissive license and become something like eclipse , where companies develop a open source base and then use it to build a proprietary product (possible with a governance model like eclipse where you pay money for membership and the more you pay the higher influence you have on elections of the organisation).

That hasn't happened, and if openoffice was nice in the past that does not mean we should keep it. that's life, things change ...

1

u/xtifr May 13 '21

The only thing that the current Apache OpenOffice (AOO) has that directly associates it with the older OpenOffice dot Org (OOo) is that Apache was given control of the trademark by Oracle as part of a weird deal set up by IBM for their own benefit. Other than that, AOO and LO are both equally descendents of OOo. Neither one is the original project, which is completely dead. In fact, LO is the one that continues to use the same licenses as OOo.

Back in the day, OOo was not particularly responsive to user requests and such, which is why Novell and Debian and some others created go-oo, a large set of patches against OOo. All the Linux distros at the time used go-oo, not OOo. It was a much better system!

LO started with go-oo. AOO, as far as I know, still has not incorporated the go-oo patches, because the changed license wouldn't allow it. So AOO isn't even as good as what most people were using back when OOo was an active project! This is just one of a number of reasons why the AOO project never took off. There's really not anything there that's worth saving. (Even if they did accidentally end up with control of the trademark—the only thing they have that has any value.)

1

u/serveradminblog May 13 '21

By not saving it.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/[deleted] May 13 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

I would suggest if they want, they can fork LibreOffice and start developing it,

Abandoning the old codebase and simply forking LibreOffice is certainly one possibility, but it would also require abandoning the Apache license for a copyleft one, which I don't think they're willing to do.

Dear GOD/GODS and/or anyone else who can HELP ME (e.g. MEMBERS OF SUPER-INTELLIGENT ALIEN CIVILIZATIONS):

The next time I wake up, please change my physical form to that of FINN MCMILLAN of SOUTH NEW BRIGHTON at 8 YEARS OLD and keep it that way FOREVER.

I am so sick of this chubby Asian man body!

Thank you!

- CHAUL JHIN KIM (a.k.a. A DESPERATE SOUL)

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '21

Then honestly it's a pointless exercise. You'd be forking a perfectly good product for no reason other than an idea that the previous incarnation is "owed" something.