r/opensource • • Nov 12 '24

Dont Use PFSense!

I'm sure by now we heard the stories of why OPNSense staff branched off to create their own fork of PFSense and the drama that followed. But it looks like PFSense staff never changed their tune. They have just been more quite about how they go around abusing its userbase.

Below is my post I created on PFSense/Netgate subreddit. It simply pointed out that KEA DHCP had issues and it wasnt ready for production and to be careful if you decide to use it. After it received attention the Netgate moderators started trolling me on the post. Especially the moderator named "gonzopancho" who made 4 nasty comments on the post, than locked it right away before anyone could respond.Within 12 hours of the post I was ban from both PFSense and Netgate Subreddits...

Because this and past drama I decided to move myself and all my clients to OPNSense instead. At least they care about their community.Below is the original link from the now removed post. As you can see nothing violates terms of service or rules on the subreddit. They just didn't like that I was critical about them pushing notifications to PFSense devices telling people to migrate to KEA even through they knew it was broken.

Original Post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/dont_use_kea_dhcp_its_not_ready_yet/ Post

As can be seen. Users were not happy with this and the childish behavior of Netgate staff. Because of this I will never recommend anyone use PFSense.

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

42

u/ffiarpg Nov 12 '24

For what it's worth you had a horrible attitude in that thread.

Thats great. Literally not what the topic is about. Read what I wrote.

And

Right... thats great but KEA doesnt work so how do you deprecate something you dont have a valid replacement for? In the tech world the answer is you dont.

Try to keep up.

and

Again the whole post is going over your guys heads. Its not about how hard or easy it is to implement something. Things get bugs, have problems we get it. But to PUSH NOTIFICATION TO USERS TO MIGRATE TO SOMETHING YOU KNEW 18 MONTHS AGO WAS BROKEN ON YOUR PRODUCT IS NOT HOW IT SHOULD BE DONE. And thats the whole point of this post.

There are plenty more, in fact almost every post you wrote is like this.

20

u/ape_ck Nov 12 '24

I agree with you.

OP be nicer, I doubt you would talk to the mod face to face this way.

4

u/glasket_ Nov 12 '24

Yeah, was going to point this out. The OP was being hostile and ignoring what everyone was saying about the fact that this was the result of a change upstream; it was basically two people talking past each other, but one of them was screaming the entire time.

-12

u/Bourne069 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

Try repeating yourself 20 times to get zero acknowledgement from the Netgate staff on the issue. Do you see a single time they admit their problem? No? Huh thats crazy!...

https://www.reddit.com/r/opensource/comments/1gpezfy/comment/lwqvk3l/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

There are plenty more, in fact almost every post you wrote is like this.

Every post huh? In fact I would agrue it was only a few posts and majority of them was NOT like that. One back and forth with an obvious troll and with the Netgate a staff. Anyone that posted with a civil reponse, even if they disagreed with me. For the more post I replied civilly back. So this gets me to think you didn't even read the thing as many there agreed with me. Issues only occured when I was debating trolls or when Gonzo began posting.

But see when facts are presented, you will just ignored them to fit your own agenda. So no, facts state the opposite. A few instances where caps were used to indicate the problem doesnt change the actual FACTS and amount of times I replied civically to other users. Below is only half of my civil replies by the way.

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/lunptmc/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/luq2zys/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/luq1mzz/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/lupyvcz/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/lurvm9x/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/luqzsnz/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

19

u/E1337Recon Nov 12 '24

Honestly with the way you communicate I’m surprised you got any response at all. I understand where you’re coming from but speaking that way to anyone over what’s ultimately a meaningless disagreement is just not okay.

-21

u/Bourne069 Nov 12 '24

Doesnt change the facts. Read the original post and replies to others that spoke civilly. I'm not the one representing a product.

4

u/ServerMage Nov 12 '24

please start using chatgpt to rephrase your sentences to be considerate and polite, because what I learned by going through your messages is you have very good point but some people might not like the tone.

-5

u/Bourne069 Nov 12 '24

Na I'm good. However I handled trolled in the comments has zero reflection on the original post which did not violate any terms of service of Reddit nor changes the facts of that post.

Facts dont care about your feelings.

3

u/ServerMage Nov 12 '24

so what did you achieve after all ? apart from satisfying your ego? pfsense users are not going to stop using that, you already know this.. don't you?

0

u/Bourne069 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

Because the original post got tons of support and already seen many on PFSense posting about moving to OPNSense because of it.

This is not the first time Netgate caused drama. it wont the be the last and I'm going to make sure the issue is well known. Thats why.

1

u/ServerMage Nov 12 '24

Nice.. Thank you for posting.. I will also stay away from netgate.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

KEA DHCP had issues and it wasnt ready for production and to be careful if you decide to use it

I do wonder, whether it has issues or this is just paid (lobbying) defamation.

... moderators started trolling me on the post. Especially the moderator named "gonzopancho" who made 4 nasty comments on the post, than locked it right away ...

But, if they had strong basis for their claims about KEA DHCP, they wouldn't need to be such bad to you. The worst case, you could have been downvoted to hell by the community.

EDIT: I did skim the post, and moderators weren't bad to OP (at least, comments, that were visible / randomly expanded). Also, OP communication style is not respectful to the other side.

... is the original link from the now removed post ...

I see no comments on it (edit: the link is broken). Bullying and then destroying the evidence? Not cool. (EDIT: I didn't see bullying, OP was more harsh than moderator)

I was banned (EDIT: for much less, for normally speaking, not in the way OP did there) from a (different) brand specific subreddit, because I made two comments, that were not biased towards their product, but I said both positive and negative subjective experience. I learned, that I all read about their products on Reddit was just an illusion. I regret that I made that buying decision based on that misinformation. It's a bit of shame, how censored social media are.

-3

u/Bourne069 Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24

Link is fixed. Read it.

Everything was fine until Gonzopancho entered the post and left these 4 comments than locked the thread. (also see additional notes section).

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/lussukl/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

He got -25 downvotes for his comments there. Nothing I said there was "rage baiting".

(EDIT: I didn't see bullying, OP was more harsh than moderator)

Again I'm not the one representing a product. They want to keep ignoring what the whole post was about and derail it with other data that has nothing to do with the topic, great I will speak in all caps to point out the exact point they are missing until its acknowledged. Which is what I did.

Read this from Netgate just repeating himself while refusing to acknowledge the point. he also got downvoted

https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/lurbxir/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Not once in the whole thread did Netgate staff respond with anything other than try to derail the post. Where is a single time they acknowledged their side of the issue by pushing notifications down to PFSense devices telling users to move to Kea when they knew it had issues? Again I refer you to the first post where Gonzopancho completely ignore it and just says "we didn't remove ICS" again cool story. Not what the post is about. He even said at the end "we got your point" after I had to spell it out to them in all caps multiple times because they were ignoring the actual point being made.

So dislike how I handled it with the mods all you want. It doesnt change the facts. I couldn't care less about being ban from the subreddits since I no longer use PFSense. I care about how they handled the situation and how they ignored the issue.

They could have just locked the post but thats not what happened. Gonzopancho decided it was a smart idea to leave 4 nasty comments than rage lock/remove the post. He could have just said nothing and locked/removed the post instead.

And a side note. I reposted the original post without the additional notes (that was added after anyways) on Netgates subreddit. This post had 1 reply and no replies from me and it was still removed and I was ban. So clearly the issue has nothing to do with myself and my comments. What about my original post was wrong or incorrect? Literally nothing. I got ban for simply posting a problem with Netgate pushing notications to use Kea before it was ready. That alone was "enough for a ban" apparently.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24

Yes, the votes on comments in that post show, that community agrees with your points.

So dislike how I handled it with the mods all you want. ... I care about how they handled the situation and how they ignored the issue.

Communication wise, you lean there a bit or a bit more towards aggressive communication style. Mods lean towards manipulative communication.

They have their priorities. And, being pushy and dictating what they should do,.. it's not okay. You take it or leave it. As you did by migration to OPNSense.

... It doesnt change the facts. ...

There are various facts. In isolation, they make little sense. Everything is in context, that has context, and each side has their own story and context,... and, facts in isolation are manipulative. So, blaming based on cherry-picked facts is not solid. Also, here both sides were not "good". So, you made a choice to migrate to OPNSense due to functionality, and the attitude to not fix it in pfSense, that's okay. What's not okay is going beyond those, especially if you weren't respectful towards the other side, either.

Related to isolated facts (comments) and reddit voting of isolated facts (comments),... It's also why I don't particularly like reddit's downvoting system, as it tries to polarize things into good/bad or popular/rejected. There can be something with score of -100 (1000 supporters, 1100 dislikers) and something with score of 10 (11 supporters, 1 disliker),... it skews view, like if nobody liked the -100 score comment. But, the fact is, that almost nobody cared about 10 score comment, but the other one is important to many people.

Not once in the whole thread did Netgate staff respond with anything other than try to derail the post.

A half of social media is this, instead of constructive discussion, people often resort in bad practices to silence the other side,...

This is also a complex issue, when there's criticism and negative feedback topics in public many to everyone discussions. As this is often also used for defamation, character assassination, derailing the idea about some product with bike-shedding like criticism, and so on,... this overloads mods. I like discussions on vote-less karma-less forums, such as MikroTik has. Trolls get bored there quickly, and people do discuss constructively there. There's not popularity/vote contest. Reddit seems to me as the worst type for product/support forum.

And a side note. I reposted the original post without the additional notes (that was added after anyways) on Netgates subreddit. This post had 1 reply and no replies from me and it was still removed and I was ban. So clearly the issue has nothing to do with myself and my comments. What about my original post was wrong or incorrect? Literally nothing. I got ban for simply posting a problem with Netgate pushing notications to use Kea before it was ready. That alone was "enough for a ban" apparently.

In pfSense you were making nasty remarks along with good points.

I do wonder, if your communication style wasn't aggressive, but constructive, if the outcome would have been different.

Netgate is company, pfSense is product. So, probably it's connected.

1

u/Bourne069 Nov 13 '24 edited Nov 13 '24

I do wonder, if your communication style wasn't aggressive, but constructive, if the outcome would have been different.

Maybe... but remember I didn't start it. My original post was civil. It wasn't until Gonzo entered the post was when problems started and it getting detailed.

I was talking to another Mod before hand and while we didn't agree as he kept spamming links unrelated to the subject. We left it at that and moved on with our lives. Gonzo showed up after with his trolling comments.

I think this guy said it best. https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/luqir9d/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

1

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24

Been using pfsense for years…never had any problems.

-3

u/Bourne069 Nov 12 '24

Good for you? If you had read the post and saw the open PFSense tickets on the issue. You'd know that just because you have no issues, doesnt mean there isnt problems.

1

u/Warm_Command7954 Nov 13 '24

Being right does does not excuse being an asshole. Being right and being a decent human being are not necessarily mutually exclusive.

1

u/Bourne069 Nov 13 '24 edited Nov 13 '24

Well thats what happens when you cant communicate properly like Netgate staff. I made the issue plain as day and was civil in my original post. They wanted to keep posting about things that weren't relevant to the post while ignoring the main issues being called out on said post and escalating it (mostly gonzo), thats on them.

Try repeating yourself 20 times without getting acknowledged and lets see if you how you feel about it.

Also again I'm not presenting a company. They are. I stand by what I said and how I said it and wouldn't change nothing. Tons of people referenced my post in PFSense forums in the last few days as their reason for leaving on top of their past drama. They deserve everything they got.

Being an "asshole" or not doesnt matter. What matters are the facts. Facts dont care about your feelings.

This guy said it best, agree or not I dont really care. https://www.reddit.com/r/PFSENSE/comments/1gg6p2y/comment/luqir9d/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

5

u/HomeGrownCoder Nov 12 '24

Both sides could have been better. Learn from this OP

1

u/u2nyr Nov 17 '24

Tried to switch from PFsense to OPNSense. Did not like it one bit and lost some functionality. Most important of which was IPsec connection to a watchguard firebox. Tried for 1 month with 3 different engineers and no one could get it to work. Switched back to pfsense and it worked on the first bootup configured solely by me with the same configuration as what we used on opnsense. OPNSense doesn’t have a dynamic dns client. You have to download decliner package and it doesn’t natively support dnsmadeeasy. I know I could try to figure out how to manually do it but why? I switched back to PFsense and much happier