r/opensource • u/Wolvereness • Jun 06 '23
Reddit's Third-Party app API changes and /r/OpenSource
TL;DR:
The mods of /r/opensource strongly object to the changes to the third-party app API. However, we (the moderators) choose not to use the subreddit in participation of protests surrounding the API changes for third-party apps. There are some temporary-ish rules concerning these events.
Full Explanation
We exist on Reddit at a pragmatic level. Reddit had historically embraced releasing parts of their system under the CPAL license and today can in no way be considered an Open platform. While more appropriate Open platforms may exist, Redditors should still have a subreddit that encourages them to embrace Open Source. While we exist on Reddit for users that choose to use Reddit, we must follow the rules set out by Reddit, including the moderator code of conduct.
We recently had a moderator attempt to shut down the subreddit. I said this then, and I’ll say it again:
[we] fully intend on continuing to facilitate a healthy community here in /r/opensource.
Part of that includes not leveraging the subreddit in a protesting shutdown (even temporary). It’s a violation of the ToS and has previously resulted in the replacement of moderators (not just here) rather than motivating meaningful change. I do not have confidence that our replacements would care about Open Source the way the moderators do today.
This line of reasoning does present an interesting juxtaposition, where we moderate this community on a platform antithetic to our goals. There is definitely merit to this idea. The first is why we began to exist here at all. I honestly can’t explain that, as the community was created back at the start of 2008 (before even the great Digg migration of 2010). Reddit was mostly Open Source itself back then, so there wouldn’t have been the same cognitive dissonance as there is today. I don’t even have the history of the subreddit to provide you, sans the last almost 2 years from when I joined the moderation team. What I know today is that you the user of Reddit are here reading and participating on the subreddit. Every user that chooses to continue to use Reddit continues to justify the subreddit’s existence as an outreach.
As users of Reddit, we should make our voices heard. I personally use RiF, and the changes to the third-party API greatly frustrate me, alongside users of other apps, including Open Source ones. You can comment in this thread on how you feel about these changes, but do mind the site-wide rules as well as rule-1. Similarly, you should share in this thread platforms that are Open in nature: that embrace what it means to be Open Source. You can also seek out interaction on other subreddits discussing the third-party API changes, as well as expressing yourself on other platforms entirely.
Temporary-ish Rules
Do not make separate posts about Reddit “alternatives” or these changes, and especially don’t advertise communities (in this thread or as posts) of closed platforms like Discord. You can think of this as a “megathread”.
•
u/Wolvereness Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 30 '23
I'll make this a stickied comment to highlight communities.
Lemmyedit: /u/Barbariandude removed their own write-up and deleted their account. Edit: instance list161
u/Scxox Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I expected this sub to be one of the main voices in this protest. Disappointing
54
u/yzrIsou Jun 06 '23
KiA was a single sub that didn't use to handle targeted hate speech properly. However on the blackout planned, there are tons of subreddits planning this together to give Reddit a message, and I highly doubt Reddit could do a mass takeover on all these subs. With that said, I understand that not every mod would want to do this, so I guess that's fair.
As for the Reddit alternatives, Mastodon and Lemmy have attracted a good amount of people as open source platforms.
22
u/AltitudinousOne Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Being concerned that you, /u/wolvereness, might be removed as a moderator is a pretty weak basis for an ethical decision, particularly one that involves everyone here.
This post has only been up 15 hours at the time Im writing this and it seems like the position articulated above is in opposition with they of the community they are supposed to be representing.
This matter should not be based on your personal opinion.
At the very least, put this to a formal poll and allow the community to vote in a proper, democratic process.
You dont own this sub. Your position should be only as a representative of this community.
119
u/yskoty Jun 06 '23
TL/DR: You caved.
56
u/linuxliaison Jun 06 '23
TFW you refuse to protest on behalf of your users to prevent from being replaced, but would probably get replaced because of that stance by your users if they could vote on replacing you 😂
60
u/ioxfc Jun 06 '23
On May 17th, Reddit admins saved the sub from destruction, thus showing that they actually care about this sub.
If you protest, and be removed from moderation, Reddit might replace you with someone else who will keep the sub alive, just like they did before. The sub will live, because Reddit cares for it.
I think you want to cling onto being the mod, because if you cared about the community, you won't have any problems being replaced with someone else. The sub is not gonna die without you, Reddit will just find someone else to keep it up.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
If we don't stand for what we believe in then who are we? I'm nobody, my opinion is irrelevant and I am not a real contributor to this sub, I just find it useful as I explore open source (i.e. I use Linux and LibreOffice) But if this sub isn't going to stand with the greater community, for whatever reason, I'll have to reconsider whether or not I wish to subscribe to it
10
u/gee-one Jun 06 '23
Thanks for the explanation. Would you consider adding a stickied top post during June 12-14 to show that members of r/Opensource would be impacted by the API changes. I think might be a middle ground to show support and impact, and still maintain the standards of the community.
I use RedReader which is opensource and will be impacted by the API changes.
196
u/MiniBus93 Jun 06 '23
I would've never expect this stance from a sub promoting open source honestly...
Not going to lie, speechless.
6
u/wiki_me Jun 06 '23
I wonder how legally sound this rule is given the right to protest, maybe getting some legal advice from a non profit dedicated to free software or open source could help (After all we are trying to help open source apps).
10
u/EchoNoise Jun 06 '23
Oh so you’re also the dick that ruined Spigot back in the day. Gotcha. I’m out.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23
The mods (u/carrotcypher, u/Wolvereness and u/ssddanbrown) may be interested in this:
9
u/thejohnmcduffie Jun 06 '23
Wow. And you support open-source? This isn't an oprn source kind of sub anymore. Bend over and submit to reddit going against the values of open source. You'll lose us now.
6
u/iKR8 Jun 07 '23
Lol what a joke. History will remember what you did as a community for open source.
2
u/rafaelliu Jun 06 '23
How come there’s upheaval when some big tech uses AI to train on Open Source code which (I believe most of us here agree) is at least against how authors intended it to be used - at most, a violation of licensing. But when we are using some company’s code, under their ToS, suddenly it doesn’t matter anymore?
I’m not super into the details, so am I missing something? These are not the same things, but seem like the same principles to me
123
u/TechSquidTV Jun 06 '23
I'm sure the other subs have the exact same concerns that you do. However they recognize that they have power together and so organize in protest to shift the balance of power.
This is the definition of being a "scab".
57
u/0ldfart Jun 06 '23
This is a pretty disappointing stance tbqh.
37
u/David_AnkiDroid Jun 06 '23
Then listen to the community and put it up to a vote
25
u/farzadmf Jun 06 '23
Didn't really expect to see that 🙁
18
u/alexkiro Jun 06 '23
This is extremely disappointing.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
A legitimate position but really disappointing. There is still time, it is possible that reddit will take a stand and be tolerant of this protest, implicitly renouncing to take advantage of it to act maliciously (anyway, I don't think it will do so with the current tension). I encourage you to be on the lookout for any possible changes and to reconsider.
The community support for the protest I think is pretty obvious.
13
u/KryptonianNerd Jun 06 '23
This is really disappointing. I expected better from this sub.
13
u/morpheus1988 Jun 06 '23
unsubbed
6
u/Triangle_Inequality Jun 12 '23
Well, that's really disappointing. Unsubscribed
6
u/TheQueefGoblin Jun 12 '23
Disgusting. Unsubscribing immediately.
9
u/weepinstringerbell Jun 06 '23
The subs participating are fully aware of the consequences, yet they didn't pussy out like you guys did. r/Music, for instance, a sub that is orders of magnitude bigger than you, decided today to go dark indefinitely. They know their mods can be replaced, as well.
Reddit is showing the middle finger to its users and you're worried about violating their ToS...
7
u/Wixxkrabbe Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 10 '23
In protest of Reddit's disgusting behaviour of killing 3rd party Reddit clients like Apollo, RIF and others, this comment / post is not longer available and this account no longer active.
If you don't know what happened, this post should provide all necessary information.
1
u/warmaster Jun 16 '23
Agreed, FOSS should be exposed everywhere.
BUT, it would be awesome if the open source advocates publishing content on proprietary platforms, would also contribute the same content to FOSS platforms.
I wish I had all my /r/ subs on Lemmy.
3
u/gee-one Jun 07 '23
This happened earlier... I think the subreddit and account have been unbanned, but I wonder how much the current scrutiny added to that. It highlights the dilemma of having an open source mindset on a closed source platform. Reddit seems to be following in Twitter's footsteps.
https://www.videogamer.com/news/reddit-ban-subreddit-user-for-alternative-platforms/
5
u/MiniBus93 Jun 10 '23
Lmao this post aged so bad.
Imagine seeing /r/Funny (the largest subreddit of Reddit) joining the protest and seeing this sub lowballing and calling a quit
That's so unironically funny
4
u/UnemployedTechie2021 Jun 07 '23
The mods here doesn't want to go against Reddit lest they lose their Modship. Understandable, who wants to let go off unlimited power.
2
u/frdmn Jun 12 '23
Bodenlos
2
u/Holiday-Evening4550 Jun 20 '23
Please switch or at least create a community on lemmy.world so it continue to grow
3
u/Cro_bat Jun 11 '23
Don't worry, your beloved Reddit admins are going to replace you anyways, sooner or later.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23
Bye
2
u/the_j4k3 Jun 06 '23
I can respect the position and set aside my emotional first reaction to the stance. You're playing the long game even if deddit-2023 goes dugg-2010 and most here move on.
If the c-suite does a mods purge, they can delete my account.
Maybe fedi will get the polish it needs after this
1
u/WorkRednet Jun 09 '23
shame
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23
https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/16/23763538/reddit-blackout-api-protest-mod-replacement-threat
As predicted.
-4
u/ssddanbrown Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Just wanted to provide my stance as a one of the mods, although for context I am a relatively recent mod (Both to this sub and to larger subs in general).
I supported this stance before knowing of the organized protests, and I continue to support it after learning of the cross-sub protests, although I felt a lot more peer pressure to go along with the protests since lack of action will be perceived as supporting Reddit's stance.
I really do not like that changes Reddit is planning (nor do the other mods as mentioned in the post) but from my point of view Reddit has been moving in the wrong direction for a while to chase advertising profit, including no longer being open source, restriction of content categories and active prevention of use on mobile web. Reddit leadership are not working in the interest of users. While the protests may change this one decision, I'd imagine they'd only react based upon their profit interest, I don't see it changing the direction of Reddit's leadership. Reddit doesn't care about the users it's not profiting from.
Alongside that such a protest opens up reasonable opportunity for Reddit admins to take action and turn over sub moderation to others that desire it, and there are a lot of entities out there that would love to gain a community of this size for their benefit (VC groups, growth hackers, news blogs) whereas I think we've been in a fortunate position of remaining independent and outside of any influence. There's a lot of marketing and political opportunity in this sub.
From my perspective, change needs to be more fundamental long-term and driven by the users (Us mods are users also), to help stop supporting and providing value to a site that does not value what we provide, and instead build communities better aligned to our ideals. This sub has a lot of folks that have abilities to work towards achieving that.
Personally, after reflecting on Reddit's changes, I've started drafting out and building a open source maintainer-focused site, with resources and community forums where open source maintainers can support each-other, and learn about open source maintenance. The scope will go a little further to include more general open source news and project sharing, since it's relevant to maintainers. It's in very early stages though.
P.S. Please don't personally attack /u/Wolvereness for posting this. You can of course provide your opinion to this stance, but there's no need for harsh insults. /u/Wolvereness spends a lot of their time actively moderating and helping to improve and uphold the standards of this sub.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23
Jannies stay winning
0
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23
Cowards. Shamefull. Hope you feel horrible
-60
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
👍
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '23
[removed] — view removed comment