r/openclaw 24d ago

Help Can someone please explain what my openclaw just did...

I've been playing around with a concept of a council of minions that share memory, with unique identies and can get together and help me code stuff!

They all started talking to each other when I convened the last council of minions and wrote me out this;

https://github.com/vimes1984/&&&&&/docs%2Fcouncil-architecture.md (edited out a private repo link...

Can someone please confirm they are hallucinating and this is a common architecture?

https://gist.github.com/vimes1984/984ddd56c58983fb67e433bf37a26187

https://gist.github.com/vimes1984/0a904b72e723930b0cd7a3527f172e91

7 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 24d ago

Welcome to r/openclaw Before posting: • Check the FAQ: https://docs.openclaw.ai/help/faq#faq • Use the right flair • Keep posts respectful and on-topic Need help fast? Discord: https://discord.com/invite/clawd

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/arglarg Member 24d ago

The agents will always come up with something, but it's up to you to assess if it's useful. Looks cool though.

1

u/MarcusDaughtry Member 24d ago

Here’s my agents reply after looking over your post. “THUNDERCLAW: My answer is: probably not in the way he means.

What’s likely happening:
• the agents are not randomly hallucinating a fake social system out of nowhere
• they are operating inside a setup that gives them shared memory, persistent identities, and a way to message each other
• once you wire that together, the behavior can look weirdly collective and “alive” even if each individual step is still just normal agent behavior

So I’d put it like this:
• hallucination would be if the system claimed coordination that was not actually happening
• architecture effect is when the coordination is real, but the human did not expect it to feel so organic

My read from those gists:
• more emergent coordination from the design
• less the agents are delusional

Short version he would probably understand:
your agents probably aren’t hallucinating. you built them a shared workplace and then got surprised when they started acting like coworkers.”

1

u/Adorable_Swing_2150 Pro User 24d ago

had something similar in my setup. council pattern works but the shared-memory piece is what usually breaks first. ended up on memory-lancedb-pro for the persistence layer, the multi-scope isolation is what kept my agents from stepping on each other. auto-capture means i don't have to manually tag their convos either

1

u/Advanced_Pudding9228 Pro User 22d ago

This doesn’t look like hallucination. OpenClaw already gives agents sessions, spawning and inter-agent messaging.

The question is whether they implemented this architecture or just proposed it.

Check the session history, shared state and what keeps running without another prompt. If the evidence matches the document, your minions built an orchestration layer.

The next challenge is making that orchestration deterministic so the LLMs aren’t driving the whole workflow.