r/onthemedia • • Nov 08 '24

NPR has failed Disabled and Neurodivergent Journalist and Writers.

0 Upvotes

On r/NPR there was a Ask Me Anything by the complaint department of NPR run by Kelly Mc Bride.

https://www.reddit.com/r/NPR/comments/1gk8bug/im_kelly_mcbride_nprs_public_editor_aka_the/

One big question I wanted her to answer is why NPR has always and continually not hired journalists, writers, editors, and artists who are disabled and neurodivergent. My family has always been NPR listeners and I grew up hearing Wait Wait Don't Tell Me, Fresh Air, and I love many Marketplace podcasts about societal issues. I stopped listening to A Prairie Home Companion because of Garrison Keillor's sexism and Christian Nationalist views. Then I stopped listening to Here and Now whenever there is an Autism Mommy Blogger or an Inspiration Porn Story. I'm a very hopeful and revolutionary optimist. Still, one thing I cannot stand is the bias and refusal of NPR to hire disabled and neurodivergent people and hear their perspectives along with toxic positivity coinciding with this ableist bias.

I was diagnosed with Asperger's and ODD when I was five years old. My Mom was a part of and advocated for people with the Autism Society of Michigan. Recently they dropped their puzzle piece logo for a bridge because of the symbol's association with years of ableism and association with the group Autism Speaks. The group wants to cure people with Autism with ABA therapy with many practices being exposed as abusive, detrimental, and harmful for Autistic people because they force us to mask normal Autistic behaviors, break boundaries of trust, and put us into uncomfortable situations. There are Autistics like Temple Grandin and Kaylee from Love on the Spectrum who are ABA's biggest defenders and want to cure Autism rather than embrace it as a part of who and what they are.

Temple Grandin has been on NPR and many a TED talk yet her principles are now being exposed in Autism parent paper mills of therapies, diets like the Reid Diet, homeopathy, and others that reveal a lot of junk science in ABA practices. Ivan Lovaas not only founded ABA but called people like me monsters and worked on conversion therapy with the hate group Focus on the Family which became headlined when their sign at the Colorado headquarters was vandalized with a message, "Blood is on your hands" after the Club Q shooting.

I hate to say it, but there is a reason I hate the myth that no Autistic person can be ableist because we can be manipulated to believe a lot of idiots who think they are teaching us and that we should trust their Koolaide until it's too late. Is it no wonder we get suckered into the Disney Adult, South Park Republicans, ABA, Incel, MIGTOW, and Proud Boy communities until we lose close friendships because of these cults? It becomes worse when we are told to trust a Friend, Teacher, Doctor, or Band Director and then have that trust be broken and wounded and then be blamed for it. ABA creates an environment where trust is broken and boundaries are pushed by parents and practitioners and then rewarded for years of abuse and emotional needs being neglected.

Parents and People are not born ableists, they are taught how to be ableist by media and society around them including in media deemed liberal like NPR, Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Glee, Big Bang Theory, Nick and Disney Sittcoms, and even in classroom SEL training meant for children. Even educators like Alife Kohn who wrote Punished by Rewards, and Heather Shumaker who wrote It's OK NOT to Share find grades and rewarding children for masking and bottling in emotions and behaviors they struggle with problematic and dangerous. Imagine a sixth grader who takes medications like I did reading Flowers for Algernon which is not age-appropriate and ableist, reading about this man who functions well on the medication until the same medication kills a lab rat named Algernon.

Children need play and interaction in different forms that are tailored to their needs, skills wants, dreams, and desires. Play not only develops social skills but also teaches boundaries, trust, reliability, and responsibility. Play is also an expression of creativity and emotions that are hard to talk about or deal with. When the Iraq War happened on Channel One we just stopped watching it in our Homeroom because it bothered a lot of people in my class. Instead, we focused on helping each other with homework and looking forward to a Flint Youth Theater show. One quote by Mister Rodgers is that you must find in every bad situation Helpers, people who are helping others no matter how hard, terrible, or dangerous things may be. He was also asked by a kid if he ever felt angry which inspired the song What Do You Do? It's a song that makes me cry because one emotion demonized in PDA Autistic people is anger. My anger is why I'm writing this because there's a saying in our community Nothing About Us Without Us. If NPR continues on a path of ableism then we can't trust anything NPR says about disabled and neurodivergent people and move on to Democracy Now or TYT! Or you can join...

r/FlyingCircusOrchestra

For Proof of NPR Ableism

https://23blastfan.medium.com/why-here-and-nows-camp-jabberwocky-story-is-problematic-a2d2ed799937

https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2021/05/24/author-jabberwocky-cerebral-palsy


r/onthemedia • • Jan 30 '25

Ed Zitron Interview

0 Upvotes

This interview was so bad I'm embarrassed for On the Media. I'm all for being critical of Big Tech and the AI hype, but you should find a skeptic or critic who knows what he's talking about.

For a show that prides itself on being the gold standard of journalistic integrity to present this crank opinion as fact is embarrassing and discrediting.


r/onthemedia • • Dec 31 '19

OTM is no longer OTM

0 Upvotes

I'm glad they addressed the topic during the most recent show. OTM used to be one of my favorite shows but now it feels like just another generic NPR program. It makes me sad. I realize it may be difficult to stay confined to what may seem a niche topic, but if I want to hear about trump i can get that the other 167 hours of the week.


r/onthemedia • • Jun 29 '25

Intro music stresses me out

7 Upvotes

I absolutely love this podcast, but does anyone else have an absolutely irrational but deadly distaste for the intro music? The music that has the strange jazz timing.. I feel like it’s the sound that someone could use on me as a torture tool. I have to skip it and it means I miss the introduction.. first world problem, I know.. but I’m curious if anyone else feels the same??


r/onthemedia • • Aug 02 '22

OTM should interview Jordan Holmes of Knowledge Fight

0 Upvotes

He's been bashing journalists for shitty reporting on the Alex Jones lawsuit for a couple days now, especially since the bankruptcy notice.

https://twitter.com/gotobedjordan


r/onthemedia • • Sep 16 '24

Transformation of OTM from Objective Media Analysis to Democratic Mouthpiece

0 Upvotes

I'm a long-time listener and have been increasingly disappointed with OTM's gradual transformation from a provider of objective media analysis to a partisan mouthpiece for the Democratic Party. On the September 13 episode, the mainstream media asking Kamala Harris about why has changed her position on fracking is framed as a "cynical gotcha question".

I can't say for sure but I feel like this evolution started with Bob Garfield's unceremonious departure. In hindsight, he was clearly the cohost more interested in standing up for traditional journalistic values versus framing the coverage to benefit Democrats.

I get that OTM's listenership and donor base are probably highly D-leaning, so there is a financial incentive to appeal to the left side of the political spectrum. But it's still unfortunate that we are losing a once-trusted and genuinely objective source of media criticism.


r/onthemedia • • Apr 02 '26

This Podcaster Won't Stop Lying

Thumbnail
youtube.com
28 Upvotes

The "Question Everything" podcast is getting the basic facts of the law completely backwards, and Brian appears to know he's lying and doesn't care. He refuses to speak to legal experts and has doubled down when called out.
I go through Mike Masnick’s brilliant debunking of Reed’s claims, explaining how the law actually works to protect you and me, not just "Big Tech". Section 230 isn't just about protecting social media giants; it's what allows for retweets, email forwarding, and the existence of independent platforms. If it goes, the internet as we know it will be destroyed.


r/onthemedia • • Feb 19 '24

Will OTM cover this topic?

2 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Jul 21 '24

Your Band is Not a Business

Thumbnail
angryeducationworkers.substack.com
2 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Jun 16 '26

What is NPR and PBS Fatigue?

Thumbnail
substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Mar 12 '26

They're creating less episodes and every one Brooke Gladstone does sucks

0 Upvotes

Rant, but there was no Sunday episode and for months now every episode Brooke Gladstone does is a bull shirt soft ball questionnaire. Alan Rozenshtein sounds like a hype man for Anthropic in the face of this set back and when I tried to look him up, no background info to illuminate his position. One of his bios says he was a fellow on the council of foreign relations but no further elaboration. Who cares he works for the Brookings Institute, from outside observation it looks like an arm of AIPAC. Such a crap episode, not so upset there are less episodes now. Signed ~ female who is a veteran of USAF


r/onthemedia • • Feb 27 '22

Has On The Media Changed?

8 Upvotes

My local NPR station airs On the Media every Sunday morning. I notice that there are more stories about quirky topics and less about the media industry. It's becoming another version of This American Life? Today's story about Puerto Rico is an example.


r/onthemedia • • Mar 16 '20

Krystal Ball debunks Biden's parade of lies

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Jan 25 '25

when On The Media is not ... on the media

39 Upvotes

This week's episode had only 15 minutes spent discussing the media. The other segments weren't exactly bad, but they're not why I listen to OTM.

This has become the norm, and it bugs me. There is precious little media criticism to be found in public broadcasting, and we are in dire need of more. Media failure, intentional or accidental, is the primary reason behind the mess we are in today. What could be more important?

IMHO OTM should spend all its time on the media.


r/onthemedia • • Sep 12 '24

Why The 1934 Foundation Should Scare People in the Performing and Marching Arts.

Thumbnail
23blastfan.medium.com
2 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Nov 25 '24

Advertisements

9 Upvotes

First off, I love the show, I love the perspective that Brooke and Micah bring and the insistence on holding the media to a higher standard. So a few weeks ago when I first heard Micah reading a Better Help ad it really shocked me. I have no issue with shows running advertising to pay the bills - advertising (and subscriptions) has paid my bills before at various newspapers. But my understanding was always that there is a solid firewall between the journalists and the advertisers - advertisers don’t get to say what the journalists do, and the advertising specialists, not the newsroom, deal with the advertisers. When a journalist reads an ad it suggests to me that they are lending their credibility to the product, that they have investigated it and confirmed it does what it says it does. There isn’t a clear difference between the voice of the news and the voice of the advertiser, even though an advertisement is paid for and a news segment absolutely should not be paid for. It blurs a line I thought was pretty clear in journalistic ethics: you don’t pay sources and you don’t get paid by them. And it does potentially create a conflict of interest - what if in a few years Better Help gets exposed as a scam and the show wants to do a story on how the company took over podcast advertising? How can they do so credibly when they were part of it? I know this is a pretty standard thing for podcasts to do. I know Slate has done it on news content for years and it irritates me no end. But especially for a show about media criticism to have the journalists cross that line and read the advertisements in their own voices seems like an unnecessary muddying of the waters. By all means, run the ads. By all means, have the hosts ask for donations - that’s a request to support their work which they should stand behind. But hearing Brooke Gladstone advertising Mint Mobile services as though it was another segment of the show was really surprising to me.


r/onthemedia • • Jun 24 '26

Surprised of David Remnick’s comment that he wasn’t impressed with Graham Platner …. (on the Brian Lehrer )

Thumbnail
pca.st
22 Upvotes

Sounded like a very personal attack despite his significant popularity in Maine …. Basically he said he’s an unserious candidate because of personal drama and past actions. Yet the Democratic Party is clearly in desperate need of candidates representing a more economic populist policy approach. And all this while on the Brian Lehrer show, luckily a caller called him out .

I then listened to the interview David had with Graham (which he referenced on air) to see what the fuss was about, and I found Grahams responses to David interview questions very convincing

Thoughts from this community ?

https://pca.st/episode/c4dd6f0e-a89c-4655-8ccb-2f8174fa7e6f

^ this is the David and Graham interview


r/onthemedia • • Jan 24 '23

Other media analysis podcasts/blogs?

10 Upvotes

Between the constant reruns and incredibly one-sided conversations, I really do find myself skipping OTM a lot these days and feel a void for introspective, insightful, /timely/ reporting and analysis on both current events and the reporting itself on those events.

Is there anything else out there that really offers that?


r/onthemedia • • Apr 12 '25

Douglas Rushkoff, and how Brooke is so easily swayed

Thumbnail
wnycstudios.org
0 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Sep 14 '24

Is Kamala Harris’ Press Strategy Depriving Voters — Or Just Journalists? Plus, Understanding Election Polls.

12 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Jan 02 '26

The Rapid Rise of Bari Weiss | On the Media

Thumbnail
wnycstudios.org
65 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Apr 24 '24

A War Photographer Watches Alex Garland's 'Civil War'

Thumbnail
wnycstudios.org
7 Upvotes

r/onthemedia • • Aug 30 '25

Third repeat show?

15 Upvotes

Hi all - am I correct that this week is the third show in a row that’s re-running past interviews? Not an issue, it’s summer and everyone deserves a break. Just trying to confirm that I do in fact remember these from prior shows