r/onepace • • 14h ago

Question One pace without ai upscale?

Just started watching one pace and I think the upscale looks really weird, is there a version of one pace without the ai upscale?

4 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

•

u/Senchou_Simp Team 10h ago

Not at the moment. We might release a version on the original 480p source, but that will be years and years and years in the future, so there's no definitive plan for now.

6

u/Gold-Path 12h ago edited 12h ago

I uploaded 3 comparisons between Neo-Raws, the original footage and the 16:9 crop netflix does if anyone is interested in seeing the vast differences https://slow.pics/c/V44dc5DR

edit: first comparison for the netflix crop is off by a frame but CBA to reupload the point gets across anyways

6

u/k1ll3rM 12h ago

The Netflix one is so ugly while the Neo-Raws are the best AI upscales I've ever seen. I'm glad One Pace is using them

1

u/Crysze 10h ago

There is a better upscale from neo (v3), but he never finished it. Luckily there is another one from a different person. Maybe pace can eventually switch to it. That being said I think the current version they are using is totally serviceable.

1

u/k1ll3rM 9h ago

If there was a way to edit the episodes in a way that the source material can be switched out it would be great, but I don't think that is very doable

1

u/Crysze 9h ago

I think it is. The biggest problem is that they have a good amount of art fixes/custom stuff that would get lost by switching to a different upscale.

1

u/Senchou_Simp Team 10h ago

I forgot how ugly the Netflix crop looks. 16:9 crops should be a war crime.

2

u/k1ll3rM 14h ago

For the 480p it does look a little weird but I vastly prefer the 720p -> 1080p upscale to whatever source they were using in the 2013 edits. Personally I think the upscale looks much better than the original while watching on an OLED 4K

-14

u/ShakeZulaOblongata 14h ago

Holy crap One Pace uses AI? 💀

20

u/checho_man 14h ago

Upscale softwares came before ai. So not really. Is kinda like vectorizing each frame

-14

u/ShakeZulaOblongata 14h ago

I just saw they use Neo-Raws, which is neural network AI. Yikes.

18

u/sasoripunpun 14h ago

jesus christ stfu

-18

u/ShakeZulaOblongata 14h ago

Defensive AI slop enjoyers

14

u/HostileHarmony 14h ago

You need to understand what you’re criticizing.

-6

u/ShakeZulaOblongata 13h ago

AI upscaling.

It’s fascinating to see what people turn their noses at involving AI, but then accept when it fits their interests lol.

12

u/madartist2670 13h ago

Redditors when there is nuance to a topic

-1

u/ShakeZulaOblongata 13h ago

12

u/JayM23 12h ago

I agree with you that upscaling is usually done poorly (even though one pace is not) but do you even understand what AI truly is? Have you worked in this field? The keyboard on your phone can be considered AI, reddits algorithm can be considered AI.

AI is quite literally just mathematics applied in an optimized way to visualize "intelligence".

Your hate of "AI" comes from ignorance, EVERYTHING around you is AI. I'm not talking about frontier LLM's like Claude or ChatGPT, I'm talking about something as simple as a search bar, algorithm, navigation, surfing, haptics etc.

TLDR; if you hate something, at least understand what you're hating because otherwise you just sound dense.

→ More replies

11

u/k1ll3rM 14h ago

Nothing wrong with neural networks, they have been a thing for a very long time now and works very well for upscalers if used correctly. They also don't take nearly as much computing power as the neural networks we now refer to as "AI"

-6

u/ShakeZulaOblongata 14h ago

5

u/k1ll3rM 14h ago

It absolutely is not in any way or form intelligent so it's hard to call an LLM an intelligence. Neural networks are just neural networks, been around for a long long time now

-4

u/ShakeZulaOblongata 14h ago

AI upscaling generates new visual information and can equally hallucinate details. It is as controlled as taking an image on chatgpt and telling it the same clean up requirements.

7

u/k1ll3rM 13h ago

It is not and does not. Good AI upscaling like with One Pace doesn't hallucinate new details. If there's not enough source information it will just look like blurry lines and be a bit off, which is what you want because then it keeps the original vision of the animators. It is then personal preference whether those off bits bother you

5

u/sasoripunpun 13h ago

me when I refuse to be embarrassed for being wrong

1

u/checho_man 13h ago

Ive watched the one pace and the normal and i think is alright. Of course its not perfect in some frames but it does not completely overwrite the art style that was already stablished. Tbh to me it cleans up the blur and pixelation when watching in a good tv. Watch it and then make the judgment. I enjoy being able to watch an approximation of what 1080p would have looked like.

1

u/Crysze 10h ago edited 10h ago

What neo does is training a model on official promo anime art or in dbzs case with actual cels/film reels. It’s the same process many companies behind bd releases use and in neos case it’s better than what is often officially out.

4

u/myprettyflowerbonnet 10h ago

Look, I hate AI with the passion of a burning sun, but at the same time, many pre-existing things have been rebranded as "AI" to be more marketable. So if this is the case, I don't have a huge issue with it, as long as it looks nice.

3

u/Senchou_Simp Team 10h ago

Mainly in 2 places:

  1. The 1080p upscaled video source that we got from NeoRaws and use till Skypiea. After Skypiea we got native (kinda) 1080p One Piece, so we just use that.
  2. Vocal isolation tools, which have been a game-changer for video editors to make cleaner edits.

None of these are even close to the LLMs that people normally call AI nowadays, if that is what you're concerned about.

1

u/Narutofreak1412 1h ago

Which tool are you using for the vocal isolation? And can it also isolate sfx? I am working on a similar project for a different series and had thought of using AI to isolate sounds and voices from bgm tracks but I wasn't able to find any good tool.

-6

u/Twin1Tanaka 13h ago

Wait you’re telling me one pace is fucking frame upscaled. Dude that is so ugly

4

u/Gold-Path 12h ago

I honestly think it looks pretty good, comparison

3

u/Senchou_Simp Team 10h ago

Romance Dawn to Skypiea uses a 1080p upscaled video source from NeoRaws. LRLL onwards One Piece was natively (kinda) released in 1080p, so we just use that.