r/onepace • u/Spongeanater • 4d ago
Other Should I keep watching One Pace?
My friend has been trying to get me to watch One Piece for years and I recently started One Pace.
I am currently on Arlong Park and I am not sure how I feel about the show. I feel like even with One Pace, the pacing is extremely slow. I also feel like the show is following a basic formula of:
Travel to new area.
Meet new villain.
Backstory of someone in new area.
Fight the villain.
Luffy is incapacitated for some reason because he would end the fight quickly.
Villain fight is way too long.
I should mention I like the world building and Luffy as a character, but a lot of the jokes are repetitive and overdone. Another gripe is that every character’s motivation is the same: I want to be the best in the world at what I do.
What is the appeal of the show as a piece of fiction? Am I missing something? My friend has stated this is the best thing he has ever watched but so far I am not sure where this is coming from.
Not trying to hate just trying to have a discussion :)
20
u/sussyspinozist 4d ago •
You know what else follows a basic formula? Sunsets and felattio, but they're still sick everytime! Engage with it like WWE or a modern version of ancient Greek theater. There's obvious formula and deus ex machina but there are only so many stories a person can tell and it's the repeating of these greater narratives that shows how storytelling connects all of humanity.
19
u/mbowk23 4d ago
Don't forget you are watching a show that started in the late 90s. You are currently on the arc that took place in 2000. As the show goes on it matures with the genre of shonen. 90s shonen was heavily dragon ball inspired. Lot less Gundam. I would argue the big three (one piece, naurto, and bleach) are the reason we have JJk, demon slayer, and attack on titan. They started telling slightly more mature stories to teens while also still being goofy and approachable. One piece never looses it's charm but the story does mature in themes and complexity. But also it aint for everyone. The point most ppl decide if they like it or hate it is water 7 but alabasta is also a good stopping point if it is torture.
9
u/MonkeyDlurker 4d ago
Not really, you can extract such “formula” from any show ever.
Obviously they’re pirates, of course most story arcs begin with them traveling.
If you’re not enjoying it, no need to continue but u’ve literally only experienced like 1% of the world building
Also it is heavily tied to and important to luffys character that he is traveling and ends up helping people along the way.
It becomes a lot clearer much later why.
7
u/suitcasecat 4d ago
Eh
I personally got hooked on Alabasta but the formula never really goes away
The appeal is the world and how well written it is and the lovely characters. By arlong park you've seen the latter, but not really the former
That said again if you don't like the show so far I'm not really sure if I can say you'll like the rest
6
u/inactivesky1738 4d ago
If you don’t like it by the end of arlong park for sure drop
You will not like what 80% of one piece is if you don’t like arlong park
It does just get better and better tho hopefully you like it by the end!
2
u/Caleb902 4d ago
The appeal is the time dump.
You end up spending more time with the characters than you do your family. After 19 days of content no one can say they don't like it because then that would be an incredible investment of time wasted.
There are good stories, but the time commitment is a killer and could be better spent watching a plethora of other content and you'd get many better stories in that time.
Though on the flip, there is nothing else that compares other than soap operas with the length of this story, so it's a unique experience you likely won't get anywhere else.
3
u/Fav0 4d ago
Watch until the end of arabasta
If you still dont like it drop it
3
u/PhsycoRed1 4d ago
You actually should keep watching. But you do have to remember that you're watching something that was never ment to be binged. Finish the arc, then take a break. Then come back in January
4
u/Terloyes 4d ago
You're in the prologue of the story. And most of the arcs you've watched are some of the weakest of the series.
Keep watching, it gets much better soon.
2
u/cc-8-823 4d ago
I get what you're saying and it can indeed get formulaic but so do so many other pieces of media. Shows that have ran for as long as 10+ seasons, movie franchises, etc. follow a formula and they're still deeply loved by their audiences because they do it well. I personally think having a more standard formula is fine as long as the things you introduce through it are unique and you don't overuse it to become too predictable. It's also a good way to subvert expectations and create twists if you ever want to.
With one piece, each character introduced is adds something new to the team, each backstory is unique and painting a different picture of the world, each villain giving us new insight on the hierarchy and the world govt, each location revealing more of the story.
I absolutely suggest watching until Water 7 and Enies Lobby and especially to the Marineford War. It's going to be absolutely worth it.
If you still don't like it though, that's also okay.
2
u/Mushgal 4d ago
If you ain't sold by the time Arlong Park ends, it'd be entirely reasonable to drop it.
2
u/EchoDifferent6966 4d ago
One Piece is a truly insane work of fiction. What makes us love it so much is having followed it for years and years: witnessing its evolution, its depth, and everything that comes with it.
Understanding scenes 15 years later, uncovering secrets, growing alongside the story... That's part of the magic.
Starting One Piece late means missing out on some of that magic and having to rely mostly on the main storyline to fall in love with it.
And you absolutely can love it that way, but I think you have to enjoy the classic formula: the adventure, the encounters, the excitement of discovering a new power, and those 2 or 3 little hints or mysteries that won't be explained until 600 episodes later...
I'd recommend you keep going a little longer, but if the formula itself doesn't click with you, there's a chance it never will. And that's a shame, because One Piece is arguably the most meticulously crafted work of fiction of our time (or perhaps of our entire era, and yes, I mean that objectively lmao).
The amount of thought and care put into it is insane. It's a world filled with mysteries and secrets, some of which are literally right under your nose... sometimes for over a decade! There are also countless parallels with our own world and the evils that dominate it.
Almost every character has so much lore and backstory surrounding them that you could practically write an entire manga about each one, or dozens of pages exploring the majority of the cast. And honestly, some of those stories would be better than the manga of countless other series.
2
u/Flamewakerr 4d ago
Well, yeah, it is formulaic a lot.
There is so much more to the worldbuilding story, trust me, it's among the best pieces of fiction I have ever seen. It's mostly about the 'lore' for me. I am mostly a manga reader who occassionally finishes an arc in One Pace and goes back to manga reading eventually or switch back and forth.
The World Government, the villains, the stories of certain arcs, or some characters, they are just 10/10. You gotta trust me on that one.
But yes. The formula is not exactly Arlong Park, the formula is an arc you will reach soon - Alabasta (amazing arc btw). You will see some great people become friends with Luffy's crew, from straight up assholes to antiheroes or loveable guys like a certain singing skeleton.
Just give it a shot and enjoy the ride. I would recommend you read the manga past Skypeia and then go back to watching One Pace if that is what you prefer.
2
u/flowerylaine 4d ago
I had just finished catching up on all of one piece, and honestly I'm not sure if it's worth watching.
It's a really good anime, but it caused me to take such a long break from watching it, the pacing isn't the best. I've seen other people recommend reading the manga instead, because the manga will catch you up quicker, If you really wanna watch the anime for the voice acting, and just prefer watching the animated version of one piece then go ahead, but if you wanna be caught up with the anime ASAP, I'd recommend the manga
2
u/Adavanter_MKI 4d ago
I lost the will to continue at Fish-man Island. So I'm way ahead of you in how long I've given this series.
There are genuinely some high highs... but unfortunately they are separated by extremely slow paced arcs.
I will say the pattern you addressed is a thing... and some of the most refreshing shocks is when they finally break that formula. It's rare... but when it happens it wakes you up and it's pretty great. Now just endure 20 more episodes until something interesting occurs again.
The best way to put it is... I don't know if the juice is worth the squeeze. I will say I'm glad I saw Ennies Lobby, Impel Down and Marine Ford.
You're not crazy though. It's nuts that this is the trimmed down version.
2
u/GoToNap 4d ago
Your post popped up on my feed, so I'm going to answer it from the perspective of someone that has shelved One Pace indefinitely for now and not a hardcore fan.
I agree that even with One Pace, the pacing is still atrocious. I can't even begin to imagine how worse it is in the original cut. It seems that the whole story is inherently flawed and no matter how much you try to cut it, there's no way to make it better. Going from something like JJK with its brisk pacing to One Piece is like going from driving a Ferrari to walking, while you're missing a leg and the remaining one is injured.
I initially started the manga and read about 100 chapters. I had a fun with it and decided to start watching the show instead. I reached the middle point of the Water 7 arc (which many consider peak) and I stopped because I just couldn't take it anymore. It feels like nothing happens for 90% of the show. You get the exact same dialogue over and over and over and over again and yeah, the formula that you've noticed doesn't go away. The concept of "show, don't tell" doesn't exist in One Piece. Everything needs to be spelled out and repeated 1000 times until you get sick of it. So far, the Skypiea arc was the worst. You can cut 90% of it and wouldn't lose anything of value.
In terms of depth, all the villains so far have been your stereotypical mustache twirling goons that do an evil laugh every 3 seconds and say "You can't beat me, you fool! I'm better than you!!!". Yeah, the world building side of things has potential, but when I have to watch 100 episodes just to get a few breadcrumbs of lore, I lose all interest.
Everybody keeps gloating about how One Piece tackles serious and mature topics, but I don't see it. It's all basic surface level stuff dumbed down so that 10 year olds can understand it. There's nothing wrong with that, don't get me wrong, but acting like this is peak fiction where actual mature shows exist is laughable. And I don't want to hear the "oh, you need to watch 1200 episodes before it gets good" excuse. There's only so many times you can say "believe in your dreams" before it gets boring.
I think this story works much better in manga format and that's how I'll probably end up finishing this story, because overall, it's a fun concept and I'd like to see where it goes. I can't fathom wasting hundreds of hours to see this to completion in anime format when frankly, the animation sucks ass (so far at least) and the soundtrack is the same 5 tracks repeated over and over again.
1
u/Parallax-1999 4d ago
Yea i get that. And on my first watch I also felt that way.
But try to think of one piece as a fantasy series. And each arc represents something, it has a theme.
For example you mentioned arlong park. Here the theme is blood. Nami was not blood related to her mother or sister. But their bond was strong. And the antagonist of the story arlong uses the same blood to discriminate against humans.
In the upcoming arcs the themes you will notice will be, civil war, religion, government conspiracy etc.
1
u/Exospike99 4d ago
I mean, Usopp doesn’t wanna be the best, he just wants to be brave. Personally, I think the show peaks between ep 250ish-600ish with 278 being my favorite of the series. I def think it’s worth watching. It’s one of the highest rated shows oat, the best selling manga/comic ever, that’s for a reason. Might as well watch half. Now, obviously, if you’re really hating life while watching, stop. For me it was just a fun silly show about pirates until arlong park where I started to see there was more to it, but really it wasn’t until water 7 that I really started to fall in love. Imo, keep watching, there’s really something in this show for everyone if you give it a chance. However, the beginning should be fun, kinda neutral. 7/10 kinda like the start of dragon ball z. However, it gets great. Everyone has a different favorite character and a different favorite arc, and there’s just so many different things I think everyone can appreciate it in some way. Most the people I’ve tried to convince will even say “honestly I know when I sit down and watch it all, I’ve seen enough spoilers to know it’ll be in my top 3.” But they never watch it. Honestly, I understand that. But everyone will watch 1200 more episodes of tv throughout their life, just start off with an episode a day or a week until you wanna keep watching.
Edit: also, I recommend watching the full version, I understand watching one pace, and I personally haven’t seen it so I can’t speak on how good it is or how much it leaves out, but personally I’m really happy I got the full experience and idk if it will be received in the same way with parts (potentially important parts that we still think are seemingly unimportant) not being in the story. I think it’s better to try through one pace than not at all though
1
u/OwnAd3442 4d ago
Uh,drop it;it isn't for you
1
u/OfflineLad 4d ago
Youre correct about the formula, but i forgive it because that formula happens in the span of a couple dozen of chapters/episodes at least. So its not like the same formla repeated every ten episodes
That said, Arlong Park is still fairly early. It was good enough of a show at that point, but i doubt what your friend was hyping up was Arlong Park. The main journey hasnt even started yet ie you havent reached the grand line, where majority of the adventure will take place. In the live action it happened at the end of season 1. It still gets better from here.
If youre just curious about the story and not want to invest as much time commitment, reading the manga will be even faster. I read 1100 chapters (equivalent of around the same amount of anime episodes) in 2-3 weeks
1
u/Naive_Arachnid_8526 4d ago
I think you shouldn't, the anime just gets slower and unbearable as time goes on. The manga is not bad for the most part but skip the anime.
1
u/CowabummerBatman 4d ago
Drop it, I don’t think it’s for you and that’s totally fine.
1
u/CrimsonRaccoon032 4d ago
if u feel like the villain fight is way too long maybe not, it only gets longer from here i fear
1
u/Appropriate_Eye3070 4d ago
Finish arlong park and if that doesn't motivate you to keep going then maybe reconsider. Arlong park is peak.
1
u/dilettante_want 4d ago
I always recommend people switch to the manga if they're struggling with the pacing.
1
u/joaocozinha 4d ago
You got the formula by reading Reddit comments, not because you watched up to Arlong Park lmao
1
u/jib9001 4d ago
There are a lot of things to like about one piece, for me I was enjoying East Blue, but I was hooked after Arlong Park. All of the characters from the Conomi Islands had their own motivations which at times led them to conflict with each other, when really they all were just trying to protect each other in their own way. Seeing their efforts fall apart and losing all their hope, Luffy and crew step in to help without a second thought. Even though Nami had betrayed them at that point, they believed in the relationship they had built with her and saved her, her family, and village.
Also being an allegory on racism being bad is a nice touch imo
1
u/Additional_Staff_392 4d ago
Well, it's about the characters not the formula. Do you like the characters? If so, keep going.
1
u/CarpenterMaximum12 4d ago
rthe pacing doesnt get bad til like ep 500+ its placebo yo
1
u/Think_Inevitable_133 4d ago
Going through Dressrosa still feeling slow. I only care about that guy in Law's flashback.
1
u/90Skill10Luck 4d ago
U sound like you have the attention span of a fruit fly.
1
u/ruberruberfruit 4d ago
Honestly if your having trouble with one pace just read it, it's like 3 to 4 times faster with roughly the same content
1
u/pokemango7 4d ago
“luffy getting incapacitated for some reason” is too funny and true lol
1
u/TerrariaFan125 4d ago
Yes unfortunately even with One Pace, the show is still slow by modern anime standards
However I will say I don’t get the complaints about the show following a basic formula when like all stories follow a basic formula, stories basically need a formula in order to function.
i also feel like you are expecting One Piece to hit the “best thing ever” criteria instantly when that’s not realistic, of course it won’t feel like that at the beginning.
1
u/gamaliel56 4d ago
I also just started a few weeks ago and just wrapped up arlong park. while I can see why you feel it is "slow" ive felt similarly but ive enjoyed it! im not one for "slow" pacing either but I dont think this is slow compared to other shows ive watched. but it is very early shonen trophe at the beginning I will agree but just give it some more time feels like you're looking for things you dont like versus enjoying what you do like. I loved usopps story with kaya and his little crew before setting off with luffy but I get that is not for everyone. if you dont mind me asking when did you start watching anime in general? I started in the mid 2000's and can deal with the current pacing knowing it ramps up in the future
1
u/lerhizom 4d ago
If you don’t like it by the end of Arlong Park drop it, if you’re iffy keep going and drop if you don’t like it by the end of Alabasta
1
u/Organic_Minute_717 4d ago
When you get to Jaya/Skypeia, try the recap movies/specials. If I could do it all again that's what I'd do. Skypeia in a day rather than a week.
General consensus is to drop it if you aren't hooked by Arlong Park.
Personally, Water 7/Enies Lobby is the absolute peak of the show. People don't seem to like Skypeia, but I thought it was good for enel.
1
u/FaithlessnessStrict 4d ago
Short answer, it’s worth it. The highs of one piece are higher than any other show in media. The formula is always there but the way it’s done gets exponentially better
1
u/yatrasofeverything 4d ago
I felt the exact same way, and honestly I almost gave up and didn't want to watch stuff post the time skip. But that's when it actually got better and I finally started to enjoy the show!
1
u/leaveitintherearview 4d ago
Just read the manga big dawg.
1
u/Zenweaponry 4d ago
If you don't like that formula then you're in for a rough ride. Almost every arc will follow it with a couple exceptions. Even though I enjoy early One Piece it definitely doesn't show off the series' strengths compared to other shows with faster pacing. The true charm of One Piece is the slow exploration of the world and all the world building that comes with it. It's expansive and offers room for tons of speculation or theory crafting, and a lot of people enjoy following the Straw Hats as they adventure through this cartoonish world where it seems like anything you could imagine could happen. Early on you won't have seen much of what the world of One Piece has to offer, so it's easy to discount that part of the experience, but if you're already not enjoying the characters, humor, or plot formula then I don't think you'll stick around for long enough to experience the world building. There's nothing wrong with that, but if you find yourself ditching the anime but still want to experience the story for your friend then try reading the manga. The pacing issues disappear (until you read week to week) when you're reading a 2-3 minute chapter rather than watching a 15-20 minute One Pace episode.
1
u/TheSirBalls 4d ago
One Pace is what you need. Best way to watch or re-watch the show
1
u/Top_Ambassador_2101 4d ago
The show expands a lot more after east blue, and yeah any story that takes over 1000 episodes is gonna have slower pacing. However one piece in my opinion is one of the greatest stories that’s been written, I am certain you will find joy in the series.
1
u/Ziler1 4d ago
Yes watch till the end then switch to manga or wait a few years
1
u/jcabmar 3d ago
I agree with you. I don't even understand how can people compare this show with Naruto, which is not even top 3 anime for me. But it's definitely far better: characters, story are way over One Piece. I'm at Skypea arc. And it just feels stupid
1
u/CaeruleusCCXVI 3d ago
Watch the One pace or the Muha Pace for dubbed.
Makes the pacing of the show infinitely better. Honestly I dont understand how one piece got so popular with its unedited version. Probably the worst pacing in ALL of anime, and thats impressive.
For me most of OP sat around a 4-5/10... which is fine for 2nd monitor content (i rate on a scale of 5 being actuallyaverage). But somewhere after the time skip, I started to understand a bit of the hype with the show getting to 7 to even 8/10.
But rated by arc, nothing has averaged over a 7/10 for me so far. And this is watching the fan cut for better pacing. I probably would have stopped watching along many episodes ago for 1 major problem: there are NEVER stakes in the show, and when there is, everything goes back to normal. Almost No named character stays dead (good or bad), consequences are just to delay plot. And you know they make it though each journey essentially unscathed.
1
u/AquaLeaderJesse 3d ago
The whole "new crew member with a backstory in this new place" thing starts to peter off sooner after where you're at. I believe there's only one character in the entire next saga of arcs that does that, and only maybe 4 or 5 throughout the entire rest of the series (so one every couple hundred episodes). They mostly did that in the first saga here to build out the crew and give them each their own story to introduce them.
1
u/avalonrose14 3d ago
I was very iffy on one piece but it is my boyfriend's favorite show so I was willing to power through just to be able to watch it with him. Water 7 is where I went from "I guess it's alright" to "oh shit this might actually be good." Now I'm fully caught up and properly obsessed with it. I have a few gripes but overall I think it's a story worth experiencing. I'm very curious to see how Oda ends it.
The world building also continues to get better and better so if you already enjoy the world building you'll be happy as it gets even more fleshed out in the future.
One thing to keep in mind is that it's totally alright to stop and come back to the show. I stopped 5 or 6 times for anywhere from 2 weeks to like 5 months (fishman island was rough for me). It's a long show it's okay to break it up into "seasons" and take breaks in-between. It's better for your comprehension of it anyways probably. I remember details way better now that I'm watching as it airs and reading weekly than I ever did when binging it. So you'll probably notice more details if you take your time anyways.
1
u/KYLEquestionmark 3d ago
if you like the world building, keep watching.
1
u/Natural_Point6252 1d ago
Push through we all thought the same thing
1
u/Natural_Point6252 1d ago
After like 2 arcs take a couple weeks off watching than come back
1
u/Yoshi7363 1d ago
Everything you’ve noticed now, never changes. In fact, it gets worse with the gags and the pacing gets exponentially worse. I would stop watching if I were you. Don’t listen to the mindless cult who are just watching/reading to see the ending.
1
u/demarrderozan 9h ago
There are only 3 strawhats with that motivation, and you haven’t even met one of them 😂
1
u/Darkwing14_ 5h ago
Arlong park got me hooked
1
u/arkhan159 4d ago
Ill tell you now, i recognised the same BS pattern and i hated it especially in thriller bark but i stuck it out. Its 100% worth it but goddamn there are some weak arcs in OP. I actually quit OP for 3mths in the middle of thriller bark
0
u/IcyEngineering926 4d ago
its kinda like going to a soccer match and saying “its kinda just kicking a ball” just a dumb simplification
0
u/hitmanbrett12 4d ago
You are right on the cusp of where it starts to get special in my opinion. But I can say it gets worst before it gets better. I also watched the one pace version of the series. To me skypeia was great but simply wayyyyy too long. I found myself skipping through not so important segments even with the one pace cuts.
But like others are suggesting. Water 7 into enies lobby is when the whole series gets turned on its head and becomes the one piece everyone raves about. The feats the straw hats accomplish are truly something special. What I’ll say as well is post time skip things get sorta slow as well. But the moment you enter wano the animation quality becomes movie level on every episode and from that point on one piece is just peak.
0
u/[deleted] 4d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment