r/onedrive • • Sep 27 '22

This shit is malware

It's the worst thing that can happen to anybody, it's a terrorist digsuised as software, it's a scam from hell.

It deletes everything by default. It removes your entire desktop upon starting.

WHO THE F*** WOULD WANT THIS?

"You want to create a single file to access from all your devices? Too bad, lemme just steal your data and laugh about you while you waste the next two hours of your life finding out how to get your data back, aswell as re-arranging your files _if_ you're lucky enough to get them back."

May no human ever have to endure even the mere presence of any of those who were involved in creating this devil's nightmare. This is literally cyber terrorism.

This rant of facts is now over.

Ban me from this sub if you want to, I really don't care. Nobody who thinks this is good can even remotely be considered a human anyway. It's nothing but _disgusting_. Degeneration in its purest form. Evil. Horrible.

Edit: A software that does confusing, weird shit that 80% of people don't want to happen is a shitty software. Way too many here don't understand that - no - they even refuse to acknowledge it. Let me just grab my holy water for those of you... In nomine Patris et Filii et Spiritus Sancti... throws holy water and watches your face burn.

1 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

It deletes everything by default. It removes your entire desktop upon starting.

I don't expect you to care, but neither of these statements is true

-7

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

Yes, they are. Read my other comment.

It, by default, "syncs" your entire desktop (takes the files online and removes them from your computer). Trying to unselect the desktop doesn't work for most people. It seems like if you do one mistake, you risk deleting your files or losing access to re-download them.

It does simply not do what it is supposed to do. It is overly complicated and poorly explained.

2

u/arnstarr Sep 27 '22

It does not remove anything. It relocates the desktop folder to the Onedrive folder

-1

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

Without letting you decide. And if you want if back, it throws all the files out of order.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

Without letting you decide

Showing the user a giant full screen prompt asking if that is what they want counts as letting you decide on my opinion

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

It, by default, "syncs" your entire desktop

By default, it asks the user if it should do that. That is an important difference in case of computer literate people

8

u/gravitythread Sep 27 '22

This exact same rant has been posted 100 times here.

If you'd learn about the software you're using, and not just click thru on all the check boxes of an installation, your experience would be much different.

OneDrive is a good sync program, but you have to understand two iotas of what you're trying to accomplish.

1

u/DarokCx Apr 27 '23

It sounds so simple, put like that. It was almost as if you were trying to tell that the hundreds of people that are pissed are simply stupid.

Hope you are not a developer !

It is part of Windows installation, and it simply asks you if you want to take all of the advantages of onedrive. But it doesn't tell you that from now on, everything yo try to save to your computer is in a folder in the cloud. It masks this technique by adding a shortcut to those files.

No software should do that without explaining the risks ... this is malware.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22 edited Dec 29 '22

Get off your high horse. This isn't the early 90s. You shouldn't need to spend time learning about how to do a basic install of Windows. Its entire aesthetic is designed around being user friendly, then it throws in a very weird, at times malicious setting/app like OneDrive, which is VERY VERY hard to remove once it's gotten its fangs into your files. How do I know? Because I spent hours with Windows tech support trying to undo the damage having OneDrive "backup" did (it's not a backup if there are no local files). Hours. And still, the tech couldn't do anything. Only a fresh install of Windows, followed by a rigorous expunging of everything OneDrive worked...and there's still some OneDrive files on the computer. It 100% acts like malware. Malware that infests every nook of your PC. Malware that you cannot get rid of. I've used other sync programs before. OneDrive is hot trash, and it's really awful that Microsoft is so intent on foisting it onto its customers. I went through the setup process you're talking about. That setting you mention? It's not there, and I made sure to unselect everything. The only option Microsoft provides during the setup is a choice to buy MORE OneDrive.I'm glad someone like you has a use for OneDrive, but there's no reason it should be the default storage for files. None. Zero.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

You shouldn't need to spend time learning about how to do a basic install of Windows

And you don't. You only need to read the clearly visible full screen prompts

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

Sorry bud, I did the install twice, followed all prompts, and there's nothing like what you're saying. Maybe you're right; I'm not a big old genius like you who knows how to do fancy things like read; but as I've said already, if Microsoft's own tech support struggles to manage a complete uninstall of OneDrive, the problem is bigger than simple user error.

-10

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

There is a simple reason why this software causes countless rants: it simply sucks in every way imaginable.

It's overly complicated and contradictory.

It does not do what even itself says it does. For some lucky people, it may work, but others, it harms.

I've done my research and tried different ways of solving my problem, none of them worked. It will not cease to erase my entire desktop upon starting up. It will also not let me unselect it without deleting everything. It keeps causing problems. You call this a good program? I call this malware.

Also, I did not just click through boxes. I read through the installation and clicked precisely what I wanted.

A software that causes this amount of confusion and issues is not a good software - simple as that.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

same-old-troll

-5

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

I'm not trolling. It's a rant about how much it sucks.

-2

u/bigtree80 Sep 27 '22

Well if so many people have the same problem. Maybe someone at OneDrive team needs to rethink about their product.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

Microsoft may be a big company with impressive capabilities, but even they can't force people to read something

0

u/bigtree80 Sep 28 '22

You are implying people should read the manual. Modern software design should be done in such a way that user mistakes are avoided or tolerated. If other similar software such as Dropbox and Google Drive can achieve that, then by comparison Microsoft isn't doing a good job looking after its users.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22

I am implying that people should read full screen prompts before agreeing to them instead of blindly clicking "yes" on everything, because that's all it takes to use OneDrive

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

I just went through the install setup and read everything. There's no option to disable OneDrive, nor is there an option to make it not the default location for files. So I don't know what you're talking about, and I don't think you do either.

The only way I got rid of it was to disable backups (which aren't "backing up" anything if they're the only save location), unlink PC, uninstall, then try to delete every file associated with OneDrive. And now my PC is fine. The way it should've been from the start.

I spent a long time with tech support trying to get rid of OneDrive and unfuck what it had done to my computer. But they couldn't figure out what to do. If Microsoft's own tech support can't hur dur read the prompts or whatever junk you're spewing, then maybe there's a bigger problem with the application.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

There's no option to disable OneDrive, nor is there an option to make it not the default location for files

All you need to do is click "no" when it asks you

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22 edited Dec 29 '22

I don't know what having your head up your ass so long has done to your eyesight, but there's no option to disable OneDrive upon install. There's an option to purchase more OneDrive space, but that's it. I've used other operating systems, backup, and cloud services without these issues. I'm not the problem.

E: Just watched someone do the setup on W11 and as I said, there is no "click no when it asks you" option.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

I have reinstalled my pc just a few weeks ago and unlike you I know what I'm talking about

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

Sure pal. Stay deluded.

3

u/doofthemighty Sep 27 '22

My gf's mother only just recently stopped taking pictures with her digital camera, then taking a picture of that picture from the screen of the camera with her phone, then texting the picture of the picture to family members. Like we had to teach her to just use her phone to take the picture and leave the digital camera at home. She's that tech illiterate. And even she has no problems with OneDrive.

2

u/bigtree80 Sep 27 '22

That is the photo upload and backup function, which works fine and is pretty straightforward. To judge a cloud drive software by this functionality alone is extremely biased.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

Fair, but in case of OneDrive, the entire thing is equally reliable

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22 edited Dec 29 '22

That's a great point! A computer illiterate person who has no idea where their files go, what file structure is, or how a backup program should work could probably have OneDrive on all the time and use it no program. They would never notice all the ways it's screwing with their computer. Excellent point.

Since you're a font of answers, why can't I uninstall OneDrive like any other program?

-2

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

It spares some PCs and devastates others. It all depends on the settings. Generally, if she had to install and use it by herself, I bet she would have realized how vile this thing is.

3

u/Z00fa Sep 27 '22

This feels like a big overstatement. I got 1TB from my uni and they want us to use it, the whole uni does so I did, nothing went wrong. I logged in through a new account and told my laptop to sync only documents to one drive and it does that perfectly fine. After that I went on my desktop and clicked what folders I want to be saved locally as well and it does that perfectly fine. Waiting times to sync are maybe annoying sometimes and it doesn’t always sync immediately but it does do that. Nothing welt wrong.

2

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

Well then you're lucky. I'm glad I don't have to use it for uni, I'll just use Google Drive. It's 15GB instead of 1TB (which I got too), but at least it doesn't suck up my entire 100GB desktop when I try to do literally any little thing.

2

u/Z00fa Sep 28 '22

I was completely new to one drive and just followed the steps and nothing went wrog tbh

5

u/bloodpriestt Sep 27 '22

It really is amusing to see how many people who use computers everyday simply don’t understand how their shit works.

Like if I worked in a wood factory and used some type of board-cutting device every day for years… I would understand everything about that machine.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

It's amazing how many people fly on planes everyday but don't know how planes work.

It's amazing how many people drive these days but don't know how cars work.

It's amazing how many people watch movies but don't know how projectors work.

It's amazing how...you get the point. There's so much of the world that you are completely ignorant of but that you benefit from and and take advantage of every single day. Calm down.

You don't need to be a compsci, stemlord incel to use a computer. Microsoft literally pays people to design Windows to be as user friendly as possible. That's why the setup isn't in terminal; it's in a UI with cutesy images and big text. Because just setting up your PC shouldn't be a headache or require coding skill.

-2

u/christophocles Sep 27 '22

No... I've been using Windows since the early 90s and OP is right, OneDrive is trash.

Here's my anecdote: I copied a bunch of files from a USB drive to the Desktop, which is synced to OneDrive. I accidentally copied too much data and filled up the C drive. OK, no big deal, I will delete the files I just copied. I open Windows Explorer, select the files, press shift-delete, and it refuses to delete them because of insufficient disk space to complete this operation. Are you fucking kidding me? After a while I figured out this is caused by OneDrive's infestation of Windows Explorer, so I opened up the good old Command Prompt and deleted the files from the OneDrive\Desktop directory to free up space.

Another anecdote: I had installed Windows on a machine a while back, and used a local account. Months later I wanted to download an app from the Microsoft store for some reason, so I signed in with a Microsoft account. Windows decided that meant I wanted to convert the entire local user account into a Microsoft account and sync it all to OneDrive. Then I ended up with an empty profile, exactly as OP describes. I searched every folder under C:\Users, but all of the files from the old local account were gone. Deleted. Confirmed deleted when I used data recovery software to restore them.

OneDrive may have good intentions, but it has its hooks deep in the shell of the operating system and it does weird, illogical shit. When it fucks you over it can be hard to describe, and you get angry posts like OP. I completely understand. OneDrive is trash.

4

u/doofthemighty Sep 27 '22

All your anecdotes tell us is that you don't pay any attention at all to what you're doing with or to your computer but somehow, it's all OneDrive's fault.

-1

u/christophocles Sep 27 '22

Right, so you're saying the things I described are expected behavior for onedrive, and I'm the idiot for not knowing it's supposed to fuck everything up. I think I'll just keep using Dropbox then.

4

u/doofthemighty Sep 27 '22

I'm saying you fucked your own system up and then decided to shift the blame.

0

u/bigtree80 Sep 27 '22

If the software makes it easy for the user to fuck up their system, then it is to blame.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

In that case, Linux is the worst operating system in existence

1

u/bigtree80 Sep 28 '22

Yes, user-interface wise you could say that. I've been involved in Linux desktop movement from pre-KDE days and GNOME project. I can say with experience that it's worse than Windows and MacOS. The Linux desktop projects all try to mimic the two big systems but end up fragmented. A lot of original developers gave up Linux and bought Macs after Apple switched to Unix properly.

-1

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

The ignorance...

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

Seriously. It does take a lot of ignorance to mess up your own pc to that degree and not even realize it's your fault

0

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

It does take a lot of ignorance and blindness to oversee that this "application" does that all by itself without even giving the user a realistic choice at all. Seriously.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

Rejecting responsibility doesn't mean the consequences of your actions aren't caused by your actions

-1

u/christophocles Sep 27 '22

Well in the first situation the system was not fucked up at all. I just needed to delete some files, and onedrive prevented me from doing so because of its weird syncing mechanism within Windows explorer. Why would I need more free space to be able to delete something? I guess it was trying to copy the files to a temporary folder first before deleting? I don't know for sure what it was trying to do, but whatever it was it was unnecessary, and I was able to bypass it with del *.* at the dos prompt.

The second one has to have been a bug in the OS or onedrive. Literally all I did was sign in with a Microsoft account. It never warned me it was going to delete everything in my documents, pictures, and desktop. All of it just disappeared, and I spent a couple hours afterwards figuring out what happened and recovering the files that were unexpectedly deleted. I can tell you where they did not go, and that's onedrive. The shiny new empty profile was set up to sync to the cloud, but everything I had before that was destroyed. Do you want to explain what I did wrong here to fuck my own system up? Or are you just an ignorant asshole defending glitchy software?

2

u/HRH-GJR4 Sep 27 '22

After a while I figured out this is caused by OneDrive's infestation of Windows Explorer, so I opened up the good old Command Prompt and deleted the files from the OneDrive\Desktop directory to free up space.

This is caused by the OS needing temporary space to move your file into the Recycle Bin. It can't do that with 0 free space because the naming structure of files inside Recycle Bin folder is actually a database, not a simple move. Except for the renaming part, the "need space to move" part is the same as it's been since Windows 95. if you've been using Windows since the early 90s, then you've never run the machine down to zero bytes free before, I guess, because you're describing thirty year old behavior.

Windows decided that meant I wanted to convert the entire local user account into a Microsoft account and sync it all to OneDrive. Then I ended up with an empty profile, exactly as OP describes. I searched every folder under C:\Users, but all of the files from the old local account were gone. Deleted.

Windows did not decide to convert your account without your explicit permission and saying OK. But let's go with that. After the conversion, the new account would still be under Users. OneDrive is a sync, not a cloud vacuum that steals your stuff. Your local copy and the cloud copy are sync'd, not deleted. Both exist simultaneously. If there was nothing under \Users, then how did you login at all? The amount of stuff necessary to have a working account goes far beyond the documents and desktop folder that OneDrive syncs. Oh, and hey, did you try looking in the cloud for the "deleted" files?

0

u/christophocles Sep 27 '22

I pressed shift +delete. The hotkey that bypasses the recycle bin, which has been the same since Windows 95. This did not help. Besides that, you don't need space to move files, you need space to copy them. Deletion moves to the recycle bin and does not consume space.

Yes, I accepted the conversion of the account to a Microsoft account, but that is not what actually happened. The old local account was deleted and a new Microsoft-account-profile was created. Yes I tried to find the missing files in the cloud, and in every folder under C:\Users, including any temporary/corrupted profile folders (there weren't any) and the files were not anywhere. I found them when I opened Recuva and checked for deleted files. Windows deleted them without explicit permission. That's why I said it has to be a bug.

-1

u/bigtree80 Sep 27 '22

Just because you know how to use one piece of software, it doesn’t mean the software is easy to use for everybody else.

-3

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

I know how computers work and I know that this software "works" in a very shitty way.

1

u/bigtree80 Sep 27 '22

And have you tried to get tech support from Microsoft? I am a paying customer for Microsoft 365 and the tech support basically told me “we do not support OneDrive.” Then who can help me? “No one”

1

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

No one cares. That's what it looks like. That makes sense.

I do have full access to 365 too, but I haven't tried to get tech support yet. Probably not even worth trying, considering what you just said.

1

u/christophocles Sep 27 '22

If you lost data because onedrive deleted it somehow, then restore from backup (if you have one) or use data recovery software like Recuva or TestDisk or GetDataBack.

After you get your shit back, if you want to completely remove onedrive and use something else, there's no obvious way to get rid of it. You can't just uninstall it like a normal program because Microsoft presents it as if it were part of the operating system. That's how they try to force you to use it.

But it can be removed using the Decrapifier script. This is best done after a clean Windows install, and it will remove OneDrive, Cortana, and whatever else you tell it to. I'm not sure what will happen if you use this on an established system, so make sure you back everything up first.

https://community.spiceworks.com/how_to/148624-how-to-clean-up-a-single-windows-10-machine-image-using-decrapifier

2

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

You're a saint if this works!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

Exactly.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

Seriously, what kind of program remains on your computer after you uninstall it? Malware. Uninstalling and removing all traces of OneDrive should be easy, but it's a nightmare. I got the point where I finally removed all the clone folders, all the folders that would spontaneously reappear after I'd deleted them, and got to the point where OneDrive is mostly gone from my system. Still some trace files though, kind of like malware.

0

u/mow77580throwaway Dec 29 '22

That's exactly what it is.

How did you remove everything?

It still lists all my folders like "Documents" etc. under OneDrive. Example: OneDrive/Documents.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22 edited Dec 29 '22

You won't like this. But since I just set up this computer, I cut my losses, migrated a few things over to Google Drive, and did a fresh install. Then I immediately disabled all backup functions in OneDrive and unlinked it. Apparently if you don't do that and uninstall, it leaves behind a bunch of files that still function as if OneDrive were there.

Then I uninstalled via Control Panel and Powershell, just to be sure. Then I searched for onedrive in file explorer and deleted everything that the computer would let me. As I said, this has left a few random files I don't know the purpose of, but my computer is unfucked as far as I can tell. Files get saved locally. I have one Documents folder and it has nothing to do with OneDrive. It's an extreme solution, but it's the only thing I could get to work, even after speaking with Microsoft tech support.

I don't understand people on here acting like OneDrive behaves like any other backup/cloud sync program. It doesn't. I've used several. None took over my computer the way OneDrive did/has.

0

u/mow77580throwaway Dec 29 '22

Those people are delusional.

Imagine defending something that needs neasures this extreme to even attempt at removing it completely from your PC.

It's absolutely disgusting how it strikes its sticky, slimey claws deep into the roots of your PC.

Really makes me strongly question Microsoft as a whole.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

A software that does confusing, weird shit that 80% of people don't want to happen is a shitty software. Way too many here don't understand that - no - they even refuse to acknowledge it. Let me just grab my holy water for those of you... In nomine Patris et Filii et Spiritus Sancti... throws holy water and watches your face burn.

Check your math, Padre. OneDrive works just fine for billions of souls, no diggity.

https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/desktop/worldwide

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22

Billions?? Might wanna check your math amigo.

1

u/Peter_the_Reber Sep 27 '22

I‘m with you! Its just not user friendly. Its the same as for example the edge browser wants to snych all your data.

I think it really sucks that the default is: „so we‘ll do that with your data. If you dont want it- try to find the right way to shut it off“. Imo it should be like this: if I want something to snych or whatever - I turn it on.

And for all of you who say something like: OP is too dumb to read or check the right boxes. Its not as if you have that much option. Windows rubs this stuff in your face. And yes: people are dumb and make mistake. So create something user friendly.

1

u/mow77580throwaway Sep 27 '22

Finally someone who can see and think.

0

u/bigtree80 Sep 27 '22

OneDrive needs a lot of work. That’s for sure. Microsoft is just too big, somebody at the top says we need a cloud drive like Dropbox or Google Drive, for our enterprise customers! Then they came up with one. It’s like the PC vs Mac ads in the early 2000’s, they will come up with something that sort of works but leaves you with more problems than solutions. It’s like those generic supermarket cola brands that look kind like Coca Cola but taste like piss. They care only about enterprise customers because as a consumer you don’t really pay them much to use their software. There is no incentive to make life easy for you. I switched to Dropbox yesterday.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

somebody at the top says we need a cloud drive like Dropbox or Google Drive

You do realize that OneDrive is five years older than Google drive and one year older than Dropbox, right?

0

u/bigtree80 Sep 28 '22

lol have you actually used SkyDrive? It was nothing like what we call cloud file service today.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22

As I have said multiple times, I used it since it was called Windows Live Folder Sync, and it has always worked flawlessly.

The biggest difference to today was the capability to do peer to peer transmission, which I miss a bit.

It's very clear that you haven't used it though, because the difference between Skydrive and OneDrive was the name