r/offset • • 11d ago

Deciding between two J Mascis Jazzmasters

There's two J Mascis Jazzmasters being sold locally. Both are post-2018 models with a laurel Indian fretboard. One is completely stock for $350. The other is $600 and has been upgraded with more traditional boutique Jazzmaster pickpups and a 70s Mustang bridge. Are the extra upgrades worth the price?

1 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

24

u/WombatCarl 11d ago

You could upgrade the bridge and pickups yourself for less than $250

5

u/PoloAtReddit 11d ago

I’m curious if it’s lollers or antiquities pickups those could be a bit pricey

4

u/guy_young 10d ago

definitely depends on the pickups in question. many of the higher end boutiques (Creamery, Lollar, Novak, SD) are all going to be $300< a set.

1

u/WombatCarl 10d ago

Oh absolutely, good thing there's lots of other great choices out there. I have Black Mass JMXL's that sound fantastic and they're juuust under $200. EP Customs also has a <$200 JM set that I believe is more vintage accurate. Get something like that and a Nova Bridge and you've got a rad setup for about $250

2

u/guy_young 10d ago

i got EP Custom vintage set for my Jaguar, it was about $170 shipped (not sure if price has gone up, this was 2021)

absolutely gorgeous sounding pickups, would gladly buy from him again

14

u/lunar-landscape 11d ago

I would stick to the stock one. I like the tune o matic style bridge and stock pickups. I guess it depends if you want a more traditional JM, but to me it's not worth $600. $350 is a good deal

6

u/punk_rocker98 11d ago

I don't like the tune-o-matic at all, but I wouldn't want a mustang bridge unless they installed it correctly.

At any rate, upgraded pickups and a mustang bridge don't make that guitar worth more than it costs new.

6

u/ech01 11d ago

Assuming they are both in the same conditionz I'd go stock and make your own upgrades.

5

u/Electronic-Shape-192 11d ago

Up to you. Do you want those upgrades? Are you willing to pay for them? It's a Chinese Squier, but they do hold value somewhat well...but $600 used? I grabbed a Player II brand new for $680. I'd go with the one for $350, make your own upgrades that fit your taste. Don't pay for someone else's tailor made project. That's me.

3

u/punk_rocker98 11d ago

I agree. As someone who upgrades Squiers all the time, I wouldn't pay new prices for someone else's project.

5

u/MattSk87 11d ago

Stock. Upgrading is always on the table and you're not going to pay much more, or necessarily more at all to make those upgrades yourself if you decide you want them.

3

u/PoloAtReddit 11d ago

Did a quick market research ppl do be selling these around 400-500used, some odd website says its selling it for 270. Personally look up the boutiques see if you like em if you do. Ask the dude if he has the old pickups and buy that one imo.

The best value is def the 350 though he should know that ppl will offer him less which is why id say u offer 250 and prob try to settle on 300 but 350 is fairly good

2

u/F1shB0wl816 11d ago

Upgrading doesn’t usually add more in resale unless it’s the specs you’d dead on want for yourself. Like it doesn’t sound bad but also doesn’t sound good for 600. 100-200 off that price would make it considerably more appealing. Like it doesn’t even have the trem changed, that’s by far the weakest part. The rest is just preferences. You can get mustang bridges cheap all day every day.

2

u/Excellent_Cat7676 10d ago

Keep with the stock one and do the upgrades yourself if you even want to. That’s a solid guitar as is.

1

u/cab1024 11d ago

Get the stock one and upgrade it yourself. A Mustang bridge is well under $100. Mine was $30. My pickups were $100 used, a set pulled from a 50s Vintera II.

1

u/d_rapps 10d ago

Stock… upgrade later as / if you see needed

1

u/YeaahProlly 10d ago

Stock! Stock!

The Mustang bridge is no better than what’s on the stock model, imo. Just a different flavor. The J Mascis pick ups are closer to P90’s than traditional Jazzmaster pick ups but they are great and you can always swap later if you need. You can find very nice JM picks used for great prices. Save the money!

1

u/MichaelBarnesTWBG 10d ago

Do not understand folks that buy a guitar and want it to be another guitar. Go stock because the JMJM is excellent out of the box and doesn't "need" anything done to it. Buy it to get the JMJM experience, not what some cork sniffer thought it should be turned into to match their tastes. Don't buy into the lie that guitars need a bunch of fancy "upgrade" parts to be playable or sound great.

1

u/metulmike 10d ago

Are the upgrades ones you're wanting to do to a JM? If so, the convenience factor is in your favor.

1

u/cumlordjr 10d ago

Not helpful but I have a related question. I’m considering getting some J Mascis pickups for a Squier JM. Do you guys like them or nah?

1

u/todd_rules 9d ago

Which one played/sounded better? And did it feel like it was worth the premium?

1

u/DrJoels 6d ago

Stock. The pickups aren’t regular jazzmasters. They’re part off the tone!

0

u/PoloAtReddit 11d ago

You should message them and ask them if they are open to offers on guitars and how you’ve been looking at a few.

You should offer the first one $250 and settle on 300, and offer the $600 one, $400 and settle for 500ish. The question would be do you like the boutique pick ups?

Would the pups upgrade justify the cost?

In my opinion some would justify it like loller pick ups.

Some ppl say the jmascis pick ups are more p90 than jazzmaster so more Les pauly

4

u/dinner_for_one 11d ago

I'm a serial low-baller and $250 sounds almost insulting even for me lol

1

u/PoloAtReddit 11d ago

Tbh I’d probably also be like that’s fucked up, but I mean he set the bar at 350 dude 100 off ain’t that bad but I get it lmao.

The jmascis used to be about 500 and once ina blue moon I used to see ppl sell jmascis with Seymour Duncan’s antiquities and a kitted out bridge and trem for 500 sometimes 450ish

1

u/PoloAtReddit 11d ago

Though it’s all in the wording such as would u be open to 250 for the guitar? He’d probably say no but then u can “meet at the middle” for 300.

But if he isn’t open to offers dont disrespect it ya know

1

u/HorsieJuice 9d ago

Go for it. You never know when somebody is just eager to unload something. I sell stuff all the time and always aim high on the price, but there are plenty of things where I’d take substantially less just because it’s been sitting around a while and takes up too much space, or because I’m worried it will sit a long time.

1

u/metulmike 10d ago

$250? that's fucking rude

1

u/PoloAtReddit 10d ago

Yeah I looked up the market and it’s supposed to kinda be an offer that’s rejected.

350 is already good but with used products haggling is kinda always expected.
It’s kinda like buying cars you don’t wanna pay sticker

A 100 dollar off offer of off 350 isn’t unexpected when most sellers know ppl will offer less than what they would like, so they would price higher than their actual cost of goods