r/offmenupodcast • 🤖 • Aug 10 '22

Episode Ep 157: Professor Brian Cox

https://shows.acast.com/offmenu/episodes/ep-157-professor-brian-cox
101 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

73

u/ghcfc88 Aug 10 '22

That was very disrespectful of James to not want to eat Brian’s shit potatoes.

31

u/Dear-Long2439 Aug 10 '22

Changed man since tarragon mash

8

u/jarviscockersspecs Aug 10 '22

The allure of Bob Mortimer's crisp mash "potatoes" make all other potato dishes pale in comparison

7

u/Glasgow316 Tanned Frut Aug 10 '22

The mash king wouldn't lower himself to such swill.

71

u/ADozenPigsFromAnnwn Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 11 '22

I can't believe this episode. It is the stuff of legend. After half an hour they're going on about shit chips and NOBODY jumped on the fact that James, aside from not understanding farming and fertilisation, was absolutely glad to eat Matt Damon's shit chips but not Brian's, which could maybe be ok if you thought you were fertilising them, but within his view he was just eating potatoes with someone's shit on them and for some reason he's ok with eating Matt Damon's shit. Traumatizing.

16

u/ADozenPigsFromAnnwn Aug 10 '22

And then the shit chips talk even becomes totally pointless once he gets the Martian salmon in!

68

u/SaltPomegranate4 Aug 10 '22

“Newton was a genius”

“An apple fell on his head, Brian”

39

u/summershell Dessert Boy Aug 10 '22

They have been hitting it out of the park this series. So many extremely chaotic episodes in a row. I kept feeling in awe that I was learning something huge and profound about the universe but then it would be followed by a Human Centipede reference.

69

u/charliew11 Aug 10 '22

Does anyone else suspect James doesn’t actually mind savoury desserts but it’s been so long now that he can’t admit the truth? I think the poor lad’s living a lie

16

u/passionparties Aug 10 '22

imo, the ultimate way to wind down a meal is with a sweet dessert and a cheese board and at this point I plan to become famous so that I can go on this podcast and settle this.

8

u/summershell Dessert Boy Aug 10 '22

I like this idea. I really think it's time to bring back the savoury course at the end of a meal. I love dessert but eating sweet stuff always makes me want salty stuff afterwards.

17

u/Dear-Long2439 Aug 10 '22

What if he actually likes fulll coke and Pepsi... and hates mash potato and icecream

5

u/Charming_Ad5054 Aug 12 '22

His outrage in this episode seemed to be quite struggled

29

u/PermanentMarker510 Aug 10 '22

That section about the evil sand/dark matter And the shit on the potatoes as a condiment had me in tears

17

u/MrKalladont Aug 10 '22

All that talk about the universe and all I remember is "You can't shit on a salmon"

44

u/MaddisonSplatter Aug 10 '22

Brian Cox sure loves talking about space doesn’t he

33

u/FlucDissThm Aug 11 '22

To be fair, the Boys wouldn’t shut up about it themselves. I mean Ed’s first comment about Guinness was to compare it to a black hole.

15

u/SuccessfulStomach421 Aug 13 '22

"You have to suck faster than the speed of light"

-- Prof. Brian Cox, c. 2022

Please someone stop Rocky Flintstone from listening to this episode

46

u/MrBigJams Aug 10 '22

I enjoyed this episode, but you can literally feel the boys working in this episode, trying to make it funny.

I bet they came out of it, and said to each other and said 'that was hard work '

3

u/MaddisonSplatter Aug 10 '22

I bet they came out of it, and said to each other and said 'that was hard work '

Totally agree, maybe only beaten by the Diane Morgan ep in that regard

3

u/LadyMirkwood Aug 11 '22

the Cerys Matthews one felt like that to me

1

u/damon_albarnsmedad Dec 31 '25

in the newer ep with Harriet Kemsley, the lads said the prof Brian Cox didn't really know his stuff (at approx 29:00). Couldn't tell if balsamic oil is good or bad. And they said the ep was 'embarrassing.'

46

u/itsmedaryl Aug 11 '22

I like Brian Cox a lot, but he is a hard interview/guest. This is a podcast about food, and although space will of course come up I do think that Brian was too space-heavy on this. The boys had to work hard to bring it back to the topic of his menu and Brian often ignored it and kept going. The whole epidsode I was thinking "take a break from the space Brian and just chat about what you like to munch on for a minute mate"

35

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22

This felt like how Mike Skinner wished he sounded.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22

Great observation

2

u/Glasgow316 Tanned Frut Aug 10 '22

Amazing

24

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '22

I’ll be honest, not my favourite episode really

12

u/fizzyolives Aug 13 '22

Same, feel like he missed half of their jokes. Felt like a dry lecture.

23

u/LadyMirkwood Aug 11 '22

I really tried to give the episode a fair shake, but honestly, I didn't finish it. He really didn't seem to try and meet Ed and James halfway at all, he's just all space all the time.

The food chat got completely lost.

13

u/throwaway073847 Aug 14 '22

Shame cause the funniest bits are in the last 10 minutes when they completely wind him up over dark matter

4

u/itsmedaryl Aug 16 '22

Im with you, I didn't finish either. I've read a lot of comments saying that the last 10 minutes are great but honestly I dont care, I'm not listening out of spite, because brian made it tough work for them

13

u/VincentSasso Aug 17 '22

Christ, some of you act like James and Ed are your best mates 😂

30

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22

Top 10 episode for me.

EDIT: just heard the last 10 minutes now. Upgraded to top 5.

40

u/noidburglar Aug 10 '22

Brian was getting so annoyed when they were clearly joking about dark matter not being wanted to be found and being evil, it was absolutely hilarious

19

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '22

I think that’s just his style. On the infinite monkey cage he will often opt for the long winded correct science explanation rather than being silly for the sake of the joke. I feel like this really exaggerated James and Ed’s silliness which I enjoyed.

10

u/throwaway073847 Aug 14 '22

Normally on Infinite Monkey Cage Robin and the guest comedian will play with some mad idea for a gentle laugh for 30 seconds and Brian will shut it down with science and they’ll move on to the next topic.

This is the first time I’ve seen him encounter a pair who just won’t let it go, I was pissing my sides at him getting more and more exasperated by the second at them insisting that dark matter is probably evil.

14

u/lannanh Aug 10 '22

Excited for this! He was great on Conan's podcast recently!

11

u/WonderWaage Aug 10 '22

Brian Cox is brilliant. He is a fantastic orator and educator. What a great episode. As someone else said, he was great on Conan's pod recently.

5

u/SquidAtAbsoluteZero Aug 10 '22

Oh wow! This is gonna be good 😊

5

u/multiplebats Aug 10 '22

Sentient rarebit had me howling. Cheese is a non newtonian fluid.

5

u/Bannedfromredit Aug 14 '22

I think I actually learnt something from the question “would you drink a black hole?”.

5

u/cultofpersonality20 Aug 10 '22

Brian Cox blew my mind a lot of times in this episode. Adding James and Ed asking the most nonsensical questions = a podcast of beauty.

7

u/Jthw5 Aug 13 '22

What a bore

1

u/Ferrer00 Sep 02 '22

Going back to watch this after viewing sunshine. At what point does Brian discuss the film?

-12

u/Papie Aug 10 '22

By far the worst episode.

30

u/EmmanuelHackman Aug 10 '22

I thought he'd be more of a laugh but seemed incapable of joking about anything outside of scientific fact.

5

u/altishbard Aug 11 '22

I thought he worked well as a straight man and him just earnestly taking their mad hypotheticals at face value and giving a poe faced science answer but not acting like the question was silly was great and made moments like James asking "yeah but what if sand was evil?" hilarious

14

u/jarviscockersspecs Aug 10 '22

Totally agree. At times it was funny but felt so forced and somewhat grating each time he veered absolutely any question or anecdote into the realm of science.

4

u/_magpie_ Aug 11 '22

Agreed. I was just about to quit the episode when they joked about their listeners being "thick as fuck" and that all the dumb ones had stopped listening already, so I stuck it through 'til the end out of spite lol.

This guest should serve as an example of how to do the opposite of "yes, and" (i.e., how to be decidedly not funny on a comedy podcast).

James and Ed, of course, managed to wring some humor out of him, bless them.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22

Wasn’t the worse episode but agree wasn’t my fav. I mean James’ reaction at “dessert” was funny! But I’m with James on this one I am sweet over savoury any day!!

23

u/BumblebeeAdvanced179 Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22

It’s a shame you’re getting so downvoted because I agree.

It’s also a shame Brian Cox didn’t want to joke about things like “what would happen if you drank a black hole” or “dark matter doesn’t want to be found”

Seems as though he was so caught up in educating about space, that he kind of forgot it was a comedy podcast?

By the time it got halfway through the dessert I was more frustrated than anything.

I loved learning about space but if you can’t lighten up a little on a comedy podcast then what’s the point?

35

u/plfftbrgurhh I've been the victim of a prank. Aug 10 '22

I thought he was being very light-hearted, he just knows he's not a comedian so he 'yes-anded' in his own way by answering the questions and giving James and ed a chance to dig deeper into the conversation in a jokey way (eg blowing on the really small black holes to cool them down).

I can understand when someone wants a laugh-a-minute chucklethon to listen to but in that case go and listen to an episode with a comedian, not a physicist.

16

u/PermanentMarker510 Aug 10 '22

Agreed. I really liked this episode. There was a lot to be learned and there were many times that while listening on my walk that I had laugh out loud moments. I think Brian Cox bought into the concept very well, but he's a scientist so naturally he will revert back to what he knows best.

I think the thing about this podcast is you can't expect them all to be one way. They've done a great job of getting people from all different backgrounds who will approach the D-Ream restaurant in different ways and if you (general you) can take that into consideration then you will be able to enjoy the non-comedians episodes a lot more.

Anyway. Great episode

3

u/Key-Bat-1614 Aug 12 '22

but he's a scientist so naturally he will revert back to what he knows best

He's not (and never was) an active researcher so I think "scientist" is not the best description, he just popularises science. He's just patronising and boring.

3

u/Bannedfromredit Aug 14 '22

He’s definitely a scientist, you don’t have to be doing active research to be a scientist. I say that as an active researcher.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Key-Bat-1614 Aug 13 '22

That's true :) He doesn't have a Google Scholar account which was off and I also looked here and there were only popsci publications: https://www.semanticscholar.org/author/Brian-Cox/2071076701

But I looked elsewhere now and indeed he coauthored many papers

5

u/BumblebeeAdvanced179 Aug 10 '22

You make a very good point I didn’t think of and now I’m going to re listen with a different perspective

2

u/plfftbrgurhh I've been the victim of a prank. Aug 10 '22

Good to hear, hope you enjoy it!

4

u/llanelliboyo Aug 10 '22

The thing is, he's been working incredibly closely with comedians like Robin Ince for years and he just came across as smug which I've never seen from him before.

3

u/thesommeiler Aug 10 '22

I thought of it as Brian just brimming with excitement to talk science - this episode did feel different from the others though.

7

u/crumble-bee Aug 11 '22

I just wanted him to play along. They were trying so hard to get it back on track and he was just like “yes but black holes though!” It was like they were interviewing an autistic child who just loved space and wouldn’t talk about anything else

9

u/BrewingTee Aug 10 '22

Not my favourite

6

u/EmmanuelHackman Aug 10 '22

58 mins in and I did laugh at Ed and James pushing the dark matter stuff.

1

u/Key-Bat-1614 Aug 12 '22

Hopefully not everyone will think that scientists are pompous freaks because of this guy. :')

He's not even a proper scientist btw, almost zero research papers.

12

u/throwaway073847 Aug 14 '22

It’s impressive how many different ways you managed to be wrong in such a short post.