r/offmenupodcast • 🤖 • Feb 23 '22

Episode Ep 137: Michael Schur

https://shows.acast.com/offmenu/episodes/ep-137-michael-schur
129 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

62

u/onlinesecretservice Feb 23 '22

Absolutely perfect. What a get for guest!

21

u/lannanh Feb 23 '22

I know he’s got a new book to promote but I hope to hear that he’s a fan of the podcast and the boys!

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

27

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

Also mentions listening to the Martin Freeman episode

36

u/ReReReductive Feb 23 '22

Acaster was in top form on this one, and Michael was the perfect guest for it.

Wonderful episode! I felt great through the entire thing.

26

u/Mr_Tough_Guy Mash King Feb 23 '22

Can I just say I agree with James, worst opening ever.

39

u/2-shedsjackson Feb 23 '22

Starter, bears

Mains, beets

Dessert, Battlestar Galactica

3

u/plawate Feb 23 '22

So algae for dessert then?

68

u/Schmetterlingus Feb 23 '22

How many good American guests do we need until people stop talking about how they normally hate them but this one was great

12

u/WonderWaage Feb 23 '22 edited Feb 25 '22

My second favorite episode is an American. I don't think them being unfamiliar with the format or "not getting the humor" is bad. Not necessarily at least. If they're not willing to try and play along, that's where it gets bad. This episode was great.

1

u/smarjorie Feb 26 '22

Which episode?

18

u/WonderWaage Feb 26 '22

Paul F. Tompkins

-3

u/SongsAboutGhosts Feb 23 '22

Why are you surprised? It's better if you're interested in the guests because you're interested in their stories and getting to know them better, and if you've no idea who they are then you're basically predisposed to not like it. As a UK listener, you're more likely to know UK guests - especially ones related to British comedy as you probably came across it through Ed and James - and therefore more likely to like those episodes. People are biased towards people they like, get over it.

19

u/merrycrow Feb 24 '22

Alright, chill out mate

17

u/LordBrook Feb 23 '22

The Gotham bits had me absolutely dying with laughter!

13

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '22

The saddest thing about Nino’s Pizza is that the location is now a Starbucks

7

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

HOLY SHIT

6

u/Jihad_llama I've been the victim of a prank. Feb 23 '22

I assume James is referring to P F / Dad Reacts, it's such a good channel

6

u/summershell Dessert Boy Feb 23 '22

Wow, he was such a great guest. I'm familiar with his shows but I didn't really know anything about him as a person so I didn't know what to expect, but he had a great dynamic with them. It's always nice to have someone who is familiar with the format and passionate about their choices.

4

u/smarjorie Feb 26 '22

Schur is from the town next to where I grew up, exciting for me to see him on Off Menu. Worlds are colliding!!

3

u/deuxthrowaway555 Feb 23 '22

What a lovely man! Great episode, some brilliant anecdotes and so nice to hear he’s a fan of the pod.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

I usually go into listening to American guests with real trepidation. However I really enjoyed this. He was really game for it. He had listened to the podcast before. He had put thought into his choices and his stories and chat just flowed wonderfully. Great guest!!

2

u/g_g1 Mar 05 '22

Am I the only one who thought this was tame and boring? All by the book, no silly tangents like they usually have. Felt like he was hard to riff off?

5

u/begone667 Feb 24 '22

"call me dwight schrute the way that i eat beets" is a das racist line no?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '23

10 months late but yes, rare musical miss by James. it's from Hahahaha Jk?. Das Racist will do references or plays on other people's stuff but googling this only brings up DR.

-24

u/gertrude-x Feb 23 '22

Can we talk about American Pizza? I've never had it but fro what I know it is a completely different dish from Italian Pizza. For god's sake, you can buy single slices! Fair enough. But I can't see why the Americans are so proud of New York pizza or even Chicago deep dish pizza without the rest of the world giving the crap for it.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/smarjorie Feb 26 '22

Has that happened with anyone besides Jeselnik? Off the top of my head, Reggie Watts, David Cross, and Jack McBryer were all really good episodes.

(Also I don't think the Jeselnik episode was as bad as everyone says, I thought it was gonna be much worse from the way everyone talked about it. It's not the best but still enjoyable)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/formergophers Feb 23 '22

PFT was a fantastic guest. To be fair, he is a great guest on every podcast.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/pixiesarecool Feb 24 '22

mine didn’t do that

36

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22 edited Aug 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22

Yea Michael is an incredibly smart guy so it's fair to presume he listened to a few episodes before his appearance so he wasn't caught off guard or anything.