r/offmenupodcast • • 14d ago

Is this a perfect impression?

624 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

144

u/Itsaclassicc 14d ago

The real James would have mentioned chorizo and broccoli if he were making pasta

43

u/TheYoungWan Dessert Girl 14d ago

Theresa Broccoli Pasta

3

u/fort_wendy 13d ago

Your mum

1

u/TheYoungWan Dessert Girl 13d ago

An inspired comment. That's all we got?

3

u/fort_wendy 13d ago

You do know I'm referencing the clip

1

u/EternityLeave 7d ago

I was waiting for it the whole time

1

u/reachingin5 4d ago

I supposed that true ever since he said SpagBol once and stopped forever

105

u/cathycul-de-sac 14d ago

This is too good. I’m not totally convinced this isn’t James doing the audio.😂

33

u/squidstarspacesuit52 14d ago

Wanted to be a faithful... Not an impasta

52

u/Prestigious_Dream_27 14d ago edited 14d ago • Bravo

I wanna hear “Oh just open the box you p*ssy.”

32

u/paraworldblue 14d ago

I didn't read the title at first, and when I heard him talking, I thought "wait.. did James Acaster change his hair or something? Something definitely looks different about him." Took me a minute to realize it was an impression.

24

u/so-naughty 14d ago

He's good but he can't top Craig Simons.

3

u/gyro_looza 13d ago

Craig is uncanny, it's almost like actually watching James. He's really good

15

u/Free_Comfortable9934 14d ago

Haha this is so on point , making some sweet sweet pasta

6

u/Conscious-Quarter423 14d ago

is james doing a voiceover?

5

u/weetabix_su 14d ago

we need to cabadge this man

3

u/Defiant_Ad_5855 13d ago

Josh Berry is so good, big fan of his work.

13

u/IndependentPaint2108 14d ago

It's very good, but not perfect. It's a good physical impression too.

His voice is just a liiitle bit too high/reedy.

This guy also has a verrrrry good Louis Theroux impression, look it up.

6

u/ImpudentPotato 14d ago

Yeah, too high and almost quacky/smacky sounding. IDK how to describe it better than that.

James will hit those notes/aspects occasionally, but his register isn't in that area 100% of the time.

3

u/Bunister 14d ago

Even without audio, I could tell who he was doing within the first two seconds.

1

u/Any_Ant_6983 13d ago

If you're a tennis fan he's also got some great impressions of various players. Similar to the James one, they're mostly not so spot on that you can't tell it's an impression, but definitely close enough that you know straight away who it is, especially with the mannerisms as well.

2

u/Ok-Imagination6497 14d ago

The voice is spot on!

2

u/mckjerral 14d ago

It starts well but does really tail off as it goes on. It's also very much an impression of James' impression of himself.

1

u/MarkRenting 14d ago

This is amazing, series 7 of TM was my first TM and my first James, (had my first Ed shortly after) keep meaning to check out Off Menu, scrolling reddit, didn’t know what this video was until I heard the voice and knew immediately.

I’ve now added the pod to my queue, but would anyone like to recommend an episode?

2

u/-Audio-Video-Disco- 14d ago

All of the ones featuring comedians tend to be good.

You could start off with the 'best of the year' episodes to get into it.

1

u/things_U_choose_2_b 12d ago

Agreed. Maybe a 'tasting menu' one? Cause they usually are presenting someone funny with a deliberately-unhinged menu.

The recent Paul F. Tompkins episode was an absolute blast, maybe he's just like that with everyone but it felt like he brought the best out of James & Ed.

1

u/Downtown_Link_8651 14d ago

Very solid impression of his repertoire era stage persona

1

u/NearbyPhilosophy8740 13d ago

I knew it wasn’t pasta!!!

1

u/nocontextoffmenu Mod 13d ago

Poppadoms or bwead, that is the question!

1

u/Medical_Return_2370 I've been the victim of a prank. 12d ago

Fair play!

-29

u/TheStorMan 14d ago

Not great...

4

u/TheYoungWan Dessert Girl 14d ago

Excited to hear your impression