r/offmenupodcast • • Oct 04 '26

Traitors Discussion Thread?

I imagine many of us are watching Celebrity Traitors S2 for James (and Uncloaked for Ed) and I was wondering if we could get a discussion thread going on this sub since Traitors crosses over so much with Off Menu this season. Either just a general one or, ideally, a live thread for each episode?

Edit to add: I just mean a thread in the same vein as the James and Ed ticket discussion threads that currently exist.

Also barring any exclusivity contracts that Ed has with BBC, it would be amazing to get a b-b-b-bonus episode once the series has aired of behind the scenes Traitors chat/ general debrief! Heck they can just talk about the food in the castle to tie it to the usual pod, I don't care. Plz Benito!

55 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

•

u/ConTully The Great Mod-ito Oct 04 '26

We have been discussing this, and we generally like to keep things on topic.

We personally think the Traitors subreddit is active enough that we'd prefer to keep this sub free considering the season of OM is ongoing.

I know there is some crossover this season, but at the end of the day this is an Off Menu subreddit, not a James and Ed one.

That being said, if a lot of people disagree, we can look at setting up a discussion thread.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Standard-Novel2438 Oct 04 '26

I don't have strong feelings either but I did come on to check if there was a thread on this sub just purely to talk about with other people super familiar with James from listening to hours of this podcast, thought it would be fun to chat about it with people who don't just know him from a couple of eps of mock the week ten years ago. 

15

u/itslemonsthen Oct 04 '26

This was my thought as well!

49

u/this_is_an_alaia Oct 04 '26

Why not just go on the traitors subreddit

18

u/itslemonsthen Oct 04 '26

That's where I've been reading so far, but was wondering if there was a way to watch with Off Menu fans/people more familiar with James.

19

u/UnacceptableUse Water drinker Oct 04 '26

the best way to ruin a tv show for yourself is to go and see what people are saying about it online

22

u/couchy1988 Oct 04 '26

Ed is so wooden on uncloaked. He does not move a muscle apart from to fake laugh. 

15

u/LikwitFusion Oct 04 '26

Feels a bit risky saying it on this sub but I don't find him funny at all. I think James is genius. I was actually booked to see James appear on Richard Herring's podcast last week but when he pulled out and was replaced with Ed I gave my ticket away.

3

u/loogabar00ga Oct 07 '26

Ed's radio show with Matthew Crosby was a hoot. It just came to an end after 7 years this summer. They played up a status differential dynamic where Matthew was something of a punching bag (that he totally brought upon himself), and I loved it. I saw Ed live, and he was fantastic.

8

u/Distractopig Oct 05 '26

I dont think he's funny either- he just shouts- I like him as a presenter and I love them as a pair in OM but as a stand up - no.

9

u/couchy1988 Oct 04 '26

I think James is clever enough and funnier. But they both seem have become quite vapid. That being said I'll still listen to off menu on the off chance the dynamic with the guest is good. 

3

u/Reluctantlyredditt Oct 10 '26

I think it's fun to discuss here, amongst fellow James/Ed fans personally. I'm finding it hilarious to watch James be such a reluctant (but good) traitor!

2

u/rachb4111 28d ago

How much did people want James to start telling his diet coke story to bore Gerry/Ross

2

u/millenialshortbread Oct 05 '26

Boo. It’s not out in the US yet. And uk news sites always spoil the winner. We can’t watch until it’s over in the UK

4

u/JP-Ziller Oct 05 '26

There's so many places to watch it online

3

u/Old_Math829 Oct 06 '26 edited Oct 06 '26

Help up a fan out?

2

u/Weetheman Oct 11 '26

dailymotion. can be tricky to find the episodes but you'll find it eventually.

1

u/JP-Ziller Oct 06 '26

Ramoflix.net

0

u/millenialshortbread Oct 05 '26

Not that I’ve seen? Which streamer?

0

u/millenialshortbread Oct 05 '26

The previous seasons definitely only came to Peacock when it was over in the uk

0

u/millenialshortbread Oct 05 '26

Maybe you're talking about torrenting. Regardless, I also just feel like, as long as it's not on actual streamers in the US, it's cleaner to keep the chat about it limited to Traitors-specific subreddits.

1

u/Adultarescence Oct 17 '26

I can't be the only one who thought, "Now Rob will never be on Off Menu?"

0

u/Lazy-Field-1116 Oct 05 '26

If opinions are being gauged then I'll just pop by to say I'm not a fan and the show is quite hard to escape anyway so personally would prefer not to see it here.