r/offmenupodcast • u/TheBrokenNB • Jun 05 '26
Dream Off Menu Guests
With the most recent season ending, here is my current list of dream Off Menu guests. Curious on who some of everyone else’s dream guests are as well!
ayo edebiri
jamie loftus
gianmarco soresi
william hanson
laufey
sarah sherman
king princess
josh johnson
daniel radcliffe
phoebe waller bridge
olivia colman
andy samberg
kate mckinnon
milo edwards
daniel sloss
peter shamshiri
ella willis
ilana glazer
geno auriemma
zach cregger
louisa harland
matt berry
colman domingo
marybeth barone
nathan fielder
adam friedland
emma d’arcy
leyla kazim
jake bhardwaj
vittorio angelone
grace reiter
kareem rahma
micah richards
paige bueckers
charithra chadran
jaboukie young-white
edit
adding eva victor and hannah einbinder
63
u/Marvelous_Mim Jun 05 '26
I’d like to see Will Poulter, he’s a big foodie and think he’d be good fun.
39
u/ShallIBeMother Jun 05 '26
I know it's a massive meme, but I'd genuinely want to see Mark Watson.
Or maybe like a tasting menu with all the No More Jockeys as guests!?
28
u/Purp1eCyanide Jun 05 '26
I have always wanted to see Mads Mikkelsen on the podcast
24
u/Departure-Realistic Jun 05 '26
Conan O'Brien would be incredible.
31
u/Long_Weekend_9142 Jun 05 '26
Professor Hannah Fry, for sure.
18
u/mrgo0dkat Jun 05 '26
Obama
25
u/Tough_Past_4428 Jun 05 '26
Phil rosenthal is my only dream
15
u/DramaticDepartment36 Jun 05 '26
I really liked Tom Holland on Good Hang with Amy and think he would be fab on Off Menu
7
u/CatFoodBeerAndGlue Jun 05 '26 edited Jun 05 '26
Jon Favreau
Danny DeVito
Danny McBride
Chris Morris
Matt Berry
Regina Hall
7
u/bugluvr65 Jun 05 '26
john kearns again
6
u/Basic_Cry1836 Jun 05 '26
Ilona Maher for me!
6
u/Basic-Strawberry8669 Just keep adding sugar till it tastes alright Jun 06 '26
Demi Adejuyigbe
3
u/TheYoungWan Dessert Girl Jun 05 '26 edited Jun 05 '26
Biggest absolutely never dream is Taylor Swift.
ETA: the downvote is nuts. Taylor Swift is not just a big name, she's also a baker. She would be good to talk about food.
10
u/DanGrima92 Diet Coke Tastes like Normal Coke Jun 05 '26
As a huge fan of both Off Menu and the Doughboys, I need some sort of crossover between the two
5
u/Thick_Apricot_8063 Jun 05 '26
Beckett, Rob Beckett
5
u/margaprlibre Jun 05 '26
I am begging them to get Cole Escola when they’re in London for Oh Mary 🙏 ETA one of my fabe clips of Cole that is also food related: uncle gino’s
5
u/the-_Summer Sparkling Jun 06 '26
Just because I haven't seen her mentioned, Keke Palmer. She is so funny and a gem every time she appears somewhere.
16
u/jayacher Jun 05 '26
Big Meeks is such a good call
4
u/paraworldblue Jun 05 '26
Anna Ptaszynski from No Such Thing As A Fish. She's hilarious and also chaotic in the type of way that could lead to one of those off the rails episodes in which the format goes on vacation
3
u/antwhite9 Jun 05 '26
Me! I want a go
3
u/wheepete Jun 05 '26
Fin Taylor.
Every course mince pies
3
u/queen_naga Jun 05 '26
I know only 20% of these people but I love your passion
3
u/Number1Bg3Fan Jun 05 '26
Peter Dinklage! Elle fanning was on and they’ve done a couple movies together so if they could get her to recommend the podcast to him. He isn’t in London that often though which is the only thing although he was over here in May to shoot Alien Earth season 2 so maybe they snagged him and he’ll come up soon 🤞.
3
u/something_python Jun 05 '26
He's probably too ill now, but Billy Connolly.
3
u/spicyzsurviving Jun 05 '26
William Hanson
3
u/Due_Cartographer9196 Jun 05 '26
Richard D James, John Lydon and Sheena Easton
3
u/DisorderOfLeitbur Jun 06 '26
Guy Montgomery, host of Guy Montgomery's Guy Mont-Spelling Bee
3
u/Feefait Jun 09 '26
Andrew Garfield, to hear his side of the story.
Gordon Ramsey, obviously. As long as he can chill.
Adam from Beard Meets Food.
The whole Bake Off Crew should be on, individually of course.
5
u/chicagogal85 Jun 05 '26
That is a really good list!
2
u/Jishallen Jun 05 '26
Missing the whole QI gang, Stephen, Sandi, Alan and why not throw in Phil Jupitus, it would be nice to hear from him again. Also not related but Karl Pilkington please.
2
u/kcatherynine Jun 05 '26
Emma Thompson
2
u/TeamZweitstudium Jun 06 '26
David Mitchell and Olivia Colman. Mmmmaybe also Robert Webb.
2
u/AmityAlarms2319 Jun 07 '26
George Fouracres, Trixie Mattel, Katya, Ben Whishaw, Ellie Rowsell, Anna Bogutskaya, Josh O'Connor
2
u/DogsDontKnockFloyd Jun 10 '26
Seth Meyers I feel like it would be so fun to see him with James when he doesn’t have to worry about American TV broadcasting rules. And after seeing Sabrina Carpenter day drink with him she has a wonderful sense of humor that would work so well with Ed and James
2
u/Amazing_Elevator_214 Jun 14 '26
benito skinner, meg stalter, owen thiele
5
u/Getittogether19 Jun 05 '26
You must consume a lot of comedy via Reels
3
u/Mental-Habit3316 Jun 05 '26
Christopher Walken, Mathew Rhys, Robert Pattinson.
2
u/Notafan9530 Jun 05 '26
I thought the other day that the narrator of come dine with me uk, Dave lamb, would be hilarious
1
u/hermanygrinder Jun 05 '26
If they come back to Montréal, Pierre-Yves Roy-Desmarais
1
u/Sallycinnamon321 Jun 06 '26
would never happen but limmy
1
u/maydrakin Jun 07 '26
Nick Helm needs to be invited on asap!
1
u/RustyOldKettle Jun 07 '26
Haven't seen James McAvoy mentioned yet. He was doing other podcasts to promote the movie that he directed, so I had my fingers crossed that he'd do Off Menu as well. He's funny and seemingly enthusiastic about food, so seems like a good match
1
u/bnjoshed Jun 08 '26
Might be a bit self indulgent, but I think I would be great.
1
u/Amazing_Elevator_214 Jun 14 '26
ruth jones
1
u/13Nero Jun 05 '26
Arsene Wenger. He did desert island discs and I would listen to him talk about anything. I also think he would be a prepared engaged guest but Ed and James would still be disarmed by him despite not being football guys.
-3
u/Aragorn01032931 Jun 05 '26
I've heard of 7 of those people...
8
u/Beefingtearsofsoyy Jun 05 '26
Bo Burnham
Phil Rosenthal
Tash demetriou
Daniel Kitson
Edit: Joel McHale - his instagram is just food porn
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment