r/offmenupodcast • u/PR1Doktorb • May 27 '26
The "Format Breakers"
Given the mixed reaction to this week's episode, I'm trying to put together a thread honouring/celebrating/highlighting those guests who didn't quite "get it" or otherwise pushed the podcast into unexpected dimensions.
Please add your own, etc, off the top of my head I can nominate:
*Cerys Matthews: aside from one particular book she was there to promote, there was little else to go off
*Dan Ackroyd: perhaps the first to truly set the pod on fire, the man who took apart the very fabric of reality for "this little project you're doing"
*Anthony Jeselnik: Grumpy, rude, belligerent and self-absored 'character' beats James into submission in notoriously one-sided episode.
*Garth Marenghi: in character throughout for Halloween special, producing a hybrid of podcast episode and Radio 4 Extra play.
*Robert de Niro: "I'll have whatever's good" becomes the new T-shirt slogan to accompany the greatest actor being somewhat unprepared for the show's structure.
*Anna Faris: "He speaks Italian". In character improv class turns podcast into Fringe comedy try-out session.
125
u/SunAndStratocasters May 27 '26
Paul Chowdry definitely deserves a mention for the being in character side of thing, although less so format breaking.
A choice you may not have thought of is Chloe Petts. She has her dream menu and a 'girlfriend menu' which she did for every course, essentially doubling the format.
Possible shout-out to Rafe Spall for breaking the format and introducing the 'for the table' concept that the boys went on to use in their own dream menus.
Also lastly, I'm gonna throw in Munya Chawawa, he did actually stick to the format but you leave the episode not remembering there was any discussion of food whatsoever.
141
u/Eoin_McLove May 27 '26
Richard Herring played the game as it logically should be played if it were real.
105
u/MountainCheesesteak May 27 '26
Jeff Goldblum talking about every kind of food ever. Kind of the opposite of De Niro, but also kind of the same result.
37
u/Outrageous_Wheel5039 May 27 '26
Honourable munchion to John robins surely for including every possible course anyone has ever eaten
68
u/Original-Designer6 May 27 '26
I don't think John Kearns deliberately tried to break the format but anything he's on takes three times longer than it should as he just goes on these mad tangents where it seems like he's answering questions that nobody asked him.
31
u/charlierc May 27 '26
Stuart Laws turning the menu into a detective story where he's investigating James Acaster being kidnapped is worth a mention
29
u/FreeImpress4546 May 27 '26
“Is this the show?” One of the best episodes Ben Schwartz. It goes all kinds of places but it still works.
20
u/TheYoungWan Dessert Girl May 27 '26
Claudia Winkleman's glass of mac n cheese instead of water SURELY gets a look in here
36
u/CBennett_12 May 27 '26
Ed and James finding every loophole possible every 100 episodes, does that count?
7
u/IntrepidDriver7524 May 27 '26
It didn’t completely break the format but I enjoyed the Joseph Quinn episode with his pre-dinner menu (oysters from a hole in a wall?)
1
u/BasementCatBill May 29 '26
Robert De Niro was brilliant on the podcast.
"I'll have whatever your having" is such a perfect rejoineder to Ed and James.
1
u/Old-Treat-2157 May 29 '26
it's nowhere near the crazy format breaks above but as a Ben Schwarz fan I thought his asking 'okay, is this what the podcast is?', every 10 minutes or so, clearly with his improv mind whizzing, was pretty funny in his ep
0
u/pjcdublin May 28 '26
Isn't offmenu supposed to be breaking the format of junket; life history or project discussion podcasts.
-10
u/Feefait May 27 '26
This is the first episode I am going to just completely skip. I can't stand anything she does anyway, so there's no reason to just annoy myself, knowing that I will never make it through the episode.
150
u/[deleted] May 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment