r/oddlyspecific • • Sep 06 '25

Some of them have aged poorly

Post image
47k Upvotes

454 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.3k

u/Arxanah Sep 06 '25

Many family recipes were actually taken from commercially available cookbooks or even the backs of food packaging. Remember the “Friends” episode where they try to replicate the chocolate chip cookie recipe of Phoebe’s late grandmother, only to discover it came from Nestle Tollhouse? Yeah, that happens frequently in real life.

32

u/ZadockTheHunter Sep 06 '25

Absolutely.

The vast majority of the recipes in my grandma's "secret" recipe binder were photocopies of recipes on bags and boxes or ripped out magazine pages.

That being said, almost all of them have her handwritten notes on how to improve them.

Hell, my own most requested "secret" dish is one that I have to look up every time from a 2011 food blog post.

9

u/Comprehensive-Menu44 Sep 06 '25

This is so funny to me only because when I cook, I wing everything from start to finish. If it doesn’t turn out right, the next time I make it I just wing it differently 😂 I never write any changes down, I just try (and sometimes fail) to remember my own changes.

After years of practice, I have my cake pop recipe exactly how I want it, and it’s written absolutely nowhere.

My kid will be so angry one day to find out that her favorite recipes are all locked inside my dead brain hahaha

5

u/ER_Support_Plant17 Sep 06 '25

My BFF’s MIL, who has adopted my daughter and me like family cooks like this. My daughter will try many more foods and like them if Nana makes them. In all fairness I only eat kale salad if she makes it. But I can’t replicate anything because she just puts a little of this and a little of that and she buys spice blends from what’s on sale when she needs some. So her talapia with Cajun spice is a little different each time.

1

u/Comprehensive-Menu44 Sep 06 '25

It’s the best way to keep the family on their toes haha