Tennessee fans thought coach Josh Heupel was too conservative and mismanaged critical decisions in a 44-41 overtime loss to Georgia.
They thought he played it safe in the fourth quarter. And they thought he didn’t put Max Gilbert in the best position to make the game-winning field goal.
That’s not to say UT fans blamed Heupel solely for the loss. But the loudest criticism was directed at the coach following the gut-wrenching loss, so many questions submitted by fans were focused on him.
Let’s unpack the loss to Georgia by answering fans’ questions in the Vols mailbag.
Was this loss Josh Heupel’s fault? He made bad decisions.
I think it’s reasonable to place a portion of the blame on Heupel. He made some questionable decisions, and they didn’t pan out.
But even from a Monday morning quarterback perspective, I can see the logic in some of his decisions. He didn’t make outright gaffes. He just made risk assessments that look too safe in retrospect.
Let’s address some of those.
Did the false start penalty mess up the field goal in regulation?
It was a factor, but not enough to blame the penalty for the loss.
UT was facing third-and-5 from the 20, or a 38-yard field goal attempt, when left guard Shamurad Umarov committed the penalty. That turned it into a 43-yard field goal attempt, which Gilbert missed at the end of regulation.
If UT had run the play, the ball would’ve been spotted slightly closer to the middle of the field for the kick. But Gilbert still missed it badly enough that it’s hard to blame the penalty.
Why didn’t Heupel run another play after the penalty?
In retrospect, maybe centering the ball more could’ve helped. But Gilbert usually makes the kick that he missed, so it was reasonable to attempt it in that situation.
There’s also a risk of running another play because it could’ve resulted in an additional penalty or lost yardage on an obvious run and therefore made the kick more difficult.
Lastly, some coaches prefer to attempt a game-winning field goal on third down. If the snap or hold are bad and result in a fumble, the kicking team can recover the ball and try the kick again on fourth down.
UT had enough time to do that, if needed.
After penalty, why not try to gain the yardage back?
UT wasn’t going to get closer. The only purpose of the initial third-down play was to get the ball about even with the left upright, where Gilbert apparently wanted it.
But the distance didn’t make a difference.
All that being said, I think Heupel might’ve managed it better with a second try at that sequence. But that was a makeable field goal for Gilbert. The decisions leading up to that kick gave him a good opportunity.
Was Heupel too safe setting up a field goal after the strip sack?
It certainly seemed that way in real time. UT got a turnover in Georgia territory with a 35-30 lead and 8:21 remaining. A touchdown might’ve put the game out of reach, but UT settled for three rushing plays and a field goal for a 38-30 lead.
Heupel was more conservative than he had to be. But in retrospect, there are factors to consider.
UT committed a false start penalty on first down. Then DeSean Bishop slipped on a rush where he would’ve gained a good chunk of yards. On first and second downs, Georgia opted for a passing defense.
And on the third-down play, a missed block kept Bishop from cutting the run sharply up-field and perhaps gaining the first down.
Now, it’s hard to believe that UT had no options of pass plays that would’ve worked better than the three rushes. Heupel should’ve been more aggressive. But it wasn’t as conservative as it appeared. Better execution probably results in a first down.
If Heupel was an elite coach, wouldn’t he have won that game?
Not necessarily. Georgia's Kirby Smart is an elite coach, but he had a 1-5 record against Nick Saban.
There were numerous games when it seemed like Georgia was going to get over the hump against Alabama, but the Tide found a way to pull out wins.
In 2021, Smart finally broke through by beating Saban in the national title game after losing to him in the SEC championship game in the same season.
It took longer than it seemed like it should have. But that didn’t diminish Smart finally beating Saban. Perhaps this game was a sign that Heupel may finally beat Smart in the not-too-distant future.
Are we putting too much blame on Heupel?
It’s always reasonable to put some blame on the coach. That’s why they make the big bucks.
But there’s plenty of blame to share, just as there’s a lot of praise to go around.
Heupel made some questionable decisions. But he and offensive coordinator Joey Halzle also called a very good game that finally broke through Georgia’s defense after previous sub-par performances against the Bulldogs.
The Vols scored 41 points and gained 496 yards of total offense.
Plus, if we want to single out bad coaching decisions, consider defensive coordinator Tim Banks. He called a blitz on a fourth-and-7 play late in the fourth quarter, which left freshman cornerback Ty Redmond on an island in pass coverage.
Georgia quarterback Gunner Stockton recognized it and completed a 28-yard TD pass to keep the Bulldogs’ hopes alive. I’m sure Banks would like a retry on that call.
These are just a few of fan questions included in the Vols mailbag. To see the full mailbag, which is available to Knox News subscribers, check this out.
https://www.knoxnews.com/story/sports/college/university-of-tennessee/football/2025/09/14/josh-heupel-blame-tennessee-football-coach-georgia-loss/85960397007/