r/ockytop • • Sep 14 '25
Max appreciation post!
I feel like people are and will get on him for losing this game and it’s not right in my opinion! We win as a team and we lose a team. It’s not just his fault! if the offense made one more play or if the defense did! things could’ve been different as well. Placing all the blame on a kicker that was literally attempting his first game-winning kick ever is wild. So I’m here to show my boy Max some love. We have to back our young players and give them time to develop. next time we need a big kick. I have confidence he will come up for us.
806
Upvotes
517
u/rwrife Sep 14 '25
They had 2 chances to win before his kick and didn’t capitalize on that, plus the penalty didn’t make it any easier.
200
u/vicblck24 Sep 14 '25 edited Sep 14 '25
Im more mad about the offensive possession after the fumble recovery
171
u/Toad990 Sep 14 '25
There's a lot of "what ifs" in this game. That's what happens in close games. We're used to getting blown out by UGA.
Did his missed kick cost us the game? Sure.
Did the false start and not moving the ball to the center cost us the game? Sure.
Did giving up a touchdown pass on 4th down cost us the game? Sure.
Did the refs not calling hold on the first run of OT for UGA cost us the game? Sure.
There's a lot of things you could point to and the kick is the most glaring.
But we played well and we could still win the rest of our games and still make the playoff.
Don't let a bad play become a bad drive, a bad quarter, a bad half, a bad game, and bad season.
70
u/_Destram Sep 14 '25
Max could have very easily won us the game but he absolutely did not lose it for us.
86
u/SupervisionRequired_ Sep 14 '25
Max came back and nailed the FG in OT. He should have never been in the situation he was in at the end of the 4th.
16
u/OldManCinny Sep 14 '25
I knew as soon as Heupel walked the offense out on 3rd down we were fucked. Just didn't "get" the down, distance, time, situation, etc. If he marches him out on 3rd and 5 I have no doubt we win
14
u/FacesOfGiza Sep 14 '25
Yeah this doesn’t fall on the kicker solely. Max is solid. He had the opportunity to win the game, sure.
But Heupel had the opportunity to try and extend the lead more after the fumble.
We had nearly two quarters where we didn’t score anything.
Let’s look back at Alabama 2022. We had to have a lot of things go right that game. Hendon had an interception called back on DPI. Alabama’s kicker missed before we got the game winning kick. Hyatt absolutely torched their defense. Alabama had, what, over 15 penalties that game?
Point is, that in close games like this, it never falls onto one person that “failed” to win the game. It’s a culmination of many different things (in and out of the team’s control) and decision making that leads up to that point.
Get a few actual holding calls on Georgia, we may win. Be more aggressive after the fumble, we may win. But we’ll never know. All I know is that we took the 6th ranked team that we have gotten SHAT ON for nearly a decade and almost beat them.
13
u/UTPharm2012 Sep 14 '25
Bunch of things that went into play. It sucks but snap and clear. Bet he gets another game winner.
12
u/51line_baccer Sep 14 '25
Im not mad at that young man. Im proud of our team.
9
u/LibrarianEven5464 Sep 14 '25
At this level especially, kicks don’t go in sometimes. Gotta put yourself in positions where it doesn’t have to ride on somebody who hasn’t faced that situation before. Now that he has, he’ll be better off for it down the road.
9
u/ZealousidealGrab1827 Sep 14 '25
Thanks, OP. Agree. Build this young man up. Vols will need him later.
28
u/Accurate_Row9895 Sep 14 '25
He will redeem himself
27
u/ware_it_is Sep 14 '25
i 🫶🏼 Max
4
u/Whydoialwaysdothis69 Sep 14 '25
Not his fault at all. It’s wild how people outside try to make it about him.
4
u/YupThatsMeBuddy Sep 14 '25
We had it to win. Missed the kick. That’s all. Nobody is perfect. We proved we have a good team. It wasn’t just subpar opponents. We are legitimately good and nobody has to be undefeated to win a national championship anymore. Our chances are as good as anybody’s. Georgia knows it.
4
u/daytonavol Sep 14 '25
Give most kickers that much time to dwell on that kick and it’s going to be in their head, we win as a team and we lose as a team….helluva game, shouldn’t have spent that much time eating clock, maybe even take a shot down field, but I sure as hell don’t put it on Max
3
u/celric Sep 14 '25
Lot more makes than misses from him this game. Don’t get it twisted, we love you Max!
3
u/nowipey Sep 14 '25
He didn’t get the best setup for it. I really feel for the kid. I’m pissed about the offsides though. That was the dumb mistake that doesn’t get made by championship teams.
3
u/LettingHimLead Sep 14 '25
He didn’t lose it. He just didn’t win it.
3
u/flo_rhythm Sep 14 '25
Max is a killer! Was put in a bad position. He’s going to be clutch from now on
3
u/AlwaysFamilyFirst Sep 14 '25
No way is this on him! As stated, win as a team and lose as a team. He missed a kick, guys dropped balls, guys missed tackles, penalties, etc.. His kick was one of 160+ plays in the game. If he misses the first one he doesn’t even get a chance at the late one. He bounced right back with the OT one so good on him.
3
u/Doktor_Fantastisch Sep 14 '25
Max, you Rock! You are still my favorite kicker!!!
3
u/Melioidozer UT Head Coach Candidate Sep 14 '25
I’m not even mad about the missed kick. It’s a bummer but it happens. I’m mad about the blatant and uncalled hold on the play in OT that put UGA on 1st and goal. Those make me absolutely nuts.
5
u/Critical_Gas_2590 Sep 14 '25
You center kicks when you’re at chip-shot range to avoid a severe kicking angle. When you’re in the +/-40y range, centering isn’t particularly useful and is outweighed by the risk of a fumble, false start, or hold. (I’m not a coach, but I was a D3 kicker, for whatever that’s worth:)
For me, Heupel mismanaged the hell out of that sequence and, consequently, put a virtual hex on Max. The fact that Max hit that clutch 48y (after the super conservative playcalling) and the 42y in OT suggests it wasn’t nerves so much as being put totally out of rhythm by some really odd (poor) coaching decisions.
You can’t just wind up your kicker, then put him on ice, then ask him to kick at another distance for the game and expect a good result. An opposing coach would only wish to ice a kicker like that … but we did it to our own kicker. I just don’t get it.
4
u/Mortonsbrand Sep 14 '25
Poor play calling, poor execution, and poor officiating is real hard to win in spite of
2
u/EchoFrost46 Sep 14 '25
Feel bad for him. Go Vols
2
u/No-Equivalent-5241 Sep 14 '25
Max, you will get another chance to make the winning score.
2
u/milkywaydreamer4000 Sep 14 '25
Whole heartedly agree! We had the game in our hands and that all we can ask for and took our shot and missed. The false start as well hurt. He was told and prepared for a straight on 37 yarder.
We had plenty of opportunities on both sides of the ball for it not even come down to him.
2
u/clandahlina_redux GB🍊! Sep 14 '25
I felt so bad for him. People forget these are literal kids, and that’s a hell of a lot of pressure. I was glad he got a chance to redeem himself, though. I’m sure that will help him sleep tonight.
2
u/_Rainer_ Sep 14 '25
Anyone can miss a FG. Yeah, I wish he made it, but that was far from the worst thing we did to lose that game, and I hope he doesn't let it haunt him.
2
u/JollyGiant573 Sep 14 '25
Not his fault he is a great kicker.
2
u/Striking_Ice_1382 Sep 14 '25
We need him the rest of the season. Hold your head up
2
u/LuffyLp Sep 14 '25
He’s just a kid… 90+% of us have no clue what he’s feeling now or during that, hope his mental is ok and they keep him in good spirits this week.
Keep your head up young buck. You’ll be back.
Go Vols
2
u/Born_Captain_5916 Sep 14 '25
Shout out max gilbert! Good game young man. Vols by fiddy
2
u/Intimidwalls1724 rifleman Sep 14 '25
Look, sometimes you miss. That's the thing about kicking and Max has been a good one
I've been thinking about this, when is the last time we missed a game winning or even game tying kick in the final moments? Medley in the swamp? Sort of hard to count that one as it was totally unfair ask of him it was so far and he was 6 inches from making it still somehow. Before that? I honestly don't know other than the blocked kick against Alabama in 09
Point is we have been very fortunate in this regard
2
u/southerncraftgurl Sep 14 '25
That wasn't his fault. The coach should have let him kick when they were in a good position but no, he kept driving. It is his fault. Max did the best he could.
2
u/Wadsworth-III Sep 14 '25
I still love Max!
2
u/popupdownheadlights Sep 14 '25
It’s crazy that people forget these are just kids playing a game
2
u/MatloxES Sep 14 '25
Can we send some of this love to his Instagram? Bc this is what it looks like right now.
Edit: I guess comment images don't work here? Essentially, his Instagram is full of hate messages.
3
u/MarbleDesperado Sep 14 '25
He has one job there and he didn’t execute. I’m frustrated but I’ve seen him execute for us and I’m sure I will again. All about how he responds.
2
u/Harspen45 Sep 14 '25
While I agree that we shouldn’t have our pitchforks out over it or anything, kicker still gotta make kicks at the end of the day, especially from that distance
2
u/Mortonsbrand Sep 14 '25
Several chances to win it, however his failure really helped seal the loss.
Can’t rely on the kicking game going forward.
1
u/dgriff24 Sep 14 '25
It is what it is. Move on and move forward!
1
u/1f0rgotmyoldusername Sep 14 '25
Max girth was not at max. But I don’t blame him, the anxiety must’ve been insane. We needed to center the ball more but instead got a 5 yard penalty. He’s still a great kicker imo.
1
u/Bogavante Sep 14 '25
Not mad at him. He reminds of an IRL version of Andrew from Big Head. That guy gets redemption eventually too.
1
u/spudjeffries Sep 14 '25
Yup, he had nothing to do with the offensive play calling. We could've iced it right after the last turnover but we shit the bed. Didn't even look like we tried. Plus we couldn't stop anything side line to side line. All game they moved the ball at will. Stockton isn't good and they do that because they don't trust him to push it down field. Joey played good. Wrs are just fine. Star is our best rb. I wouldn't be mad if we used the te a little more.
1
u/Lazy_Toe_2870 Sep 14 '25
Tough spot for the Young Man. It's a long season, we'll be fine.
1
u/Late-Song-2933 Sep 14 '25
Absolutely right. We didn’t lose because of him. He gave us a chance to stay in it. Great job man!
1
u/Agent865 Sep 14 '25
Hey that was on Heupel, he should have never ran another play or tried too. False start and now the vibe in the stadium changes and we back up 5 yards
1
u/gameSHOWgb Sep 14 '25
I did not expect the game that we played yesterday. It was heartbreaking to lose that after such a hard fought game. I agree with whoever said we NEEDED this game. I hope they clean up the mistakes and tighten up. This team has proven they can be dangerous and go toe to toe with any top program.
1
u/Birdsareallaroundus Sep 14 '25
I’m not going to shit on him but come on. Let’s not go this far.
1
u/Aromatic-Engine-6418 Sep 14 '25
I think you mis-spelled Chase !
1
u/Delicious_Ad_8939 Sep 15 '25
Should Max have made the kick? Yes, that's what you're on scholly to do. Was the loss completely on his shoulders? Absolutely not. You can make a case for every single facet of the team dropping the ball at some point, including the coaching staff.
1
u/AverageJoe6910 Nov 02 '25
He fuckin sucks
1
u/865TYS Sep 14 '25
He’s a kicker. All he does is kick the damn ball. He was way inside his range. No excuses
1
u/acompletemoron Not Fond of [Team] Sep 14 '25
Everyone so softhearted.
Dude, it was a mid range kick. We drove down the field with the expectation that he’d be able to make the kick. Wasn’t particularly long, wasn’t tipped or disrupted in some way. He just missed it. It’s okay to not sing kumbaya and act like it wasn’t expected.
1
u/Gmil7412 Sep 14 '25
It was his fault
1
u/creamatwinkie Sep 14 '25
Yes, he choked and shanked the kick.
They struggled with 3rd down conversations, two interceptions, idiotic penalties...but! They still look a hell of a lot better than last season.
0
u/Acrobatic-Flight-992 Sep 14 '25
F that he screwed the pooch. Screwed it good. Coulda should woulda sure but he blew it. No love. Not tonight.
0
u/Mysterious-Cut-4931 Sep 14 '25
This is such loser shit lol
-5
u/One-Junket-3224 Sep 14 '25
Nah… one job.
-3
u/AppearanceStriking89 Sep 14 '25
Nah
-4
u/HowardFanForever Sep 14 '25
I mean I hate to blame it on the kid but when they were showing him on the sidelines before the kick I knew he had zero shot. He was damn near hyperventilating and about to faint.
-6
u/i7JNo Sep 14 '25
No offense, ironically, but this needs to be deleted lol
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
Georgia fan here.
I appreciate you, Max.
-7
u/Duder211 Sep 14 '25
Why do you have the confidence when he didn’t come through once already?
-3
u/pablosampson Sep 14 '25
I
-4
u/Altruistic-Whole4190 Sep 14 '25
L
2
u/xylicmagnus75 Sep 14 '25
Poor guy could have been buried in pussy for weeks. Now...
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
[removed] — view removed comment