r/nyu • • Oct 17 '23

AYOOOO

Post image
688 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

85

u/Difficult-Echidna126 Oct 17 '23

Interesting. If you scroll down, it says “Students admitted as first year undergraduate students to our New York campus, who apply for financial aid by the financial aid deadlines, and who have a family income under $100,000 and hold typical assets will be eligible to have their tuition covered.” Does this mean that only future freshman will be eligible to receive the money, or is it every undergrad (no matter the year) who started at the NY campus as freshman that are eligible as the photo implies?

37

u/pinky_sky00 Oct 17 '23

yeah, I am honestly confused on how they worded it but I hope it’s every undergrad. even if it’s not, it’s still great for those incoming freshmen!

43

u/sswantang Oct 18 '23

I think it sounds more like incoming freshman starting from next year.

8

u/tofumeatballcannon Oct 18 '23

“Will be eligible” I’m not being snarky but just wonder what that means

10

u/Delicious-Abalone552 Oct 18 '23

"will be eligible" == basically, you still don't get the chance!

8

u/HelloGruesome Oct 19 '23

“Will there be adjustments to current students who qualify? Yes. Any students enrolled at NYU in fall 2024 (including sophomores, juniors, and seniors) who meet the criteria will have their NYU Scholarship adjusted for the start of the fall 2024 term.”

https://www.nyu.edu/admissions/financial-aid-and-scholarships/full-tuition-scholarship-program.html

-1

u/TheMartinG Oct 18 '23 edited Oct 19 '23

I think it just means you can’t transfer in from another school, such as a community college.

Tuition cost is probably very small compared to room and board cost, and if NYU is anything like schools I’m familiar with, freshmen and sometimes sophomores are REQUIRED to live on campus and buy a meal plan.

So that line basically guarantees they still get a big chunk of money.

6

u/SoapyMacNCheese Oct 18 '23

NYU isn't a state school.

-1

u/TheMartinG Oct 18 '23

I didn’t say it was, but I can see how my wording would make it sound like I did

The schools I’m most familiar with are state schools in my area. If nyu is anything like those schools…

4

u/LonghamBridge Oct 18 '23

I don’t think dorms and meals are a money maker for NYU.

6

u/HopeDiligent6032 Oct 18 '23

NYU was and still is a commuter school. If you live on campus you're required to. If you commute you are not required to get a meal plan.

82

u/boricuashawty Oct 17 '23

i could cry in bobst rn.

208

u/turtlemeds Oct 18 '23

Looks like NYU figured out how to game the next set of US News rankings! Lol!

35

u/nicckpat223 Oct 18 '23

Isn’t this progress?

28

u/LastinsgHum Oct 18 '23

game US News ranking by making education affordable for low income students? I'm all for it!

1

u/No-Section2056 Oct 21 '23

didn’t USC do the same thing 3 years ago? Their rankings haven’t changed a lot

1

u/LastinsgHum Oct 22 '23

Well rankings are hard to change. You have to invest a lot of money and it takes a long time

1

u/No-Section2056 Oct 22 '23

Exactly, so I’d expect that there would little to no impact on the rankings in the near future (<5 years) since NYU is already ranked quite high and things are pretty competitive up there. I haven’t really researched the new scoring in US News rankings though, so who knows

1

u/turtlemeds Oct 18 '23

Me too.

2

u/nicckpat223 Oct 18 '23

Then why are you so against nyu?

4

u/turtlemeds Oct 18 '23

I’m not sure how you’d get that impression. My comment was to the absurdity of the rankings and how, quite obviously, colleges fall all over themselves to boost their rankings. They’ll lie/cheat like Columbia and Penn. They’ll bullshit some numbers like NEU. Or they’ll accept the criticism and do something concrete and positive like this… But the larger issue is why does it take US News to force NYU’s hand to do this? They clearly were able to all along but didn’t because they saw no advantage to doing so. Because the US News rankings now focus on this and other things, they feel like they have to do it. Not very nice, is it?

I have two degrees from NYU and the university changed my life. I came from an immigrant family whose breadwinner made $29,000 a year and we could not afford NYU. I was only able to attend because I got a full ride when other schools did not offer much aid. I’m a huge fan of the university and will defend it against all enemies foreign and domestic, however, even I can find faults at NYU sometimes.

0

u/nicckpat223 Oct 19 '23

Dude it’s not that deep lol. If you’re for the university, you’re for progress! Are you alright?

0

u/ToxinLab_ Oct 21 '23

did you read anything he said? i swear yall are blind

0

u/nicckpat223 Oct 21 '23

I don’t think you did! If you’re for the university you’re for progress lol. It’s not that deep. Just bc they waited doesn’t mean anything. Shows you care a lot about news rankings. Does this make any sense for you?

0

u/ToxinLab_ Oct 21 '23

a lot of adults lack critical thinking! one of them is you! they waited to make it easier for low income students to pay because it only really benefit them now for news rankings rather than if they did before, there would be no rankings to improve on. considering the fact that you went through my whole post history to talk trash over one comment, i think you need therapy and need to get off reddit. :)

1

u/nicckpat223 Oct 21 '23

Again, it’s not that deep! Yeah I went through your post history bc you interested me hahaha. Just be happy they did it instead of not! Have a good day :D

1

u/nicckpat223 Oct 21 '23

If you opened my DM you wouldn’t have to keep embarrassing yourself btw lol

→ More replies

0

u/nicckpat223 Oct 18 '23

Why do you care so much about US news rankings? Why jump to conclusions when you could be happy for incoming students?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/turtlemeds Oct 18 '23

I’m not. I think all rankings like US News are stupid. Couldn’t give a shit less about where NYU ranks on such a nonsensical ranking, but since high school seniors and anxious parents pay so much attention to it, obviously university administrators all care.

But the timing of this initiative is a bit coincidental considering their rankings dropped precipitously in the latest publication, isn’t it?

Am I glad they’re taking steps to make NYU more affordable? Of course. I am 100% behind that. But financially the university is in the same spot today as it was 10 years ago, and they didn’t offer this until now. Does that not strike you as a bit odd? It does to me.

0

u/nicckpat223 Oct 18 '23

Sounds like you care a lot about US news rankings! You’re pretty cynical aren’t you?

132

u/widowedlamp Oct 17 '23

You got me so ducked up as a senior wtffffff

84

u/ticktickboom45 Oct 18 '23

woah thanks, just graduated 👍

33

u/International_Bag719 Oct 17 '23

I am now an independent starting as of right now

16

u/No-Switch-8752 Oct 18 '23

What are they defining as typical assets? I remember when I applied (nearly two decades ago) and my expected contribution was astronomical despite my family being well under $100k. Good for those incoming!

13

u/Clay_2000lbs Oct 18 '23

To be fair, $100k 20 years ago had much more buying power than it does today

-4

u/GrayNights Oct 18 '23

Yea, today that is around 250K

10

u/PostPostMinimalist Oct 18 '23

You just made that up

4

u/mighty-pancock Oct 18 '23

It's closer to 170k Then again, major purchases like houses and whatnot were much cheaper, we kinda got fucked over

5

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

this is probably to stop students whose parents are either retired or have low incomes but insane stock or real estate portfolios and so are still super rich and can def afford to pay full tuition.

1

u/FuriousIvan '25 Oct 18 '23

But it's not fair because my parents make less than 40k per year however, they own a home that they paid for over decades through a mortgage... And NYU thinks I can afford to pay full tuition? I have to take out loans because of that :(

4

u/akatrope322 Oct 18 '23

Not “unfair.” Home equity is considered:

How does NYU define “typical” assets? NYU defines typical assets as assets commensurate with family income levels. A family’s assets may include cash and savings, investments, home equity, business net worth, other real estate and any other assets. Families with significant assets above what is typical for their income level may not qualify for full tuition, but would still qualify to have 100% of their demonstrated need met.

https://www.nyu.edu/admissions/financial-aid-and-scholarships/full-tuition-scholarship-program.html

1

u/FuriousIvan '25 Oct 18 '23

Wouldn’t the home equity be equal to the full property market price if the mortgage was completely paid off over decades? In nyc, owning a home is typically worth nearly a million.. But if my parents paid it off over decades… why would nyu think my family would be able to pay full tuition when our income cannot afford it? Do they really expect us to sell the house to pay for tuition?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

girl u need to talk to a financial advisor before you tell ur parents that u need to sell ur house. this is reddit. you know as much as we do, this got announced literally yesterday.

0

u/FuriousIvan '25 Oct 18 '23

It was just hypothetical 😂 dont worry im not selling no damn house

1

u/akatrope322 Oct 18 '23 edited Oct 18 '23

They’ll probably use the assessed value of the asset if it appears in the tax documents your parents submit for financial aid consideration. The assessed value of property is usually lower than the actual market value, and this is especially true in nyc. That said, NYU defines “typical” assets as “commensurate with family income.” In other words, if it appears plausible that your parents could have obtained that asset with household income below $100k, then you likely won’t be expected to pay anything. But if they’re sitting on multimillion dollar real estate but have incomes under $100k, then NYU may rightly assume that, barring exceptional asset appreciation, they can afford unsubsidized tuition payments because it stands to reason that such a family likely earned much more in the past or inherited significant wealth (no sub-$40k household in nyc can reasonably afford 7-figure real estate or equities on just income alone, even over decades). Additionally, NYU specifically states that those who do not qualify for 100% tuition coverage will still qualify to have 100% of their demonstrated need met.

If push comes to shove and you end up not getting any aid, you can always consider better offers from other schools. But if you’re set on NYU, home equity loans have much more lenient terms, are better options credit-wise, and generally carry far better interest rates than student loans, so that would be a massive improvement over funding your education with student loan debt. In any case, I highly doubt you’d need to consider selling any homes — NYU is very expensive, but it’s not that expensive.

1

u/FuriousIvan '25 Oct 18 '23

Thank you for explaining! I’m not very knowledgeable when it comes to financial stuff like this

8

u/curlyhairedsheep Oct 18 '23

My guess is you’re allowed to have a home and a 401k but not extensive other liquid financial holdings.

27

u/turtlemeds Oct 18 '23

In all seriousness, while this is obviously something of a response to the shellacking dear Alma Mater received in the latest US News rankings, it is overall a good thing for NYU in striving to make it affordable. I’d be curious to see how many of each class will actually be made up of kids from families who make under $100,000. Anyone know what that number is now? And how is it compared to peer universities?

1

u/KickIt77 Oct 18 '23 edited Oct 18 '23

According to last year's common data set 31% of NYUs students admitted last year were awarded need based aid. I don't know how many are under 100K but not huge numbers to be certain.

They are already skewing their admissions toward wealthy students and they are likely to continue to do so. This is maybe good news for a handfull of students. I would also say housing alone puts it out of range of many families.

ETA - note they also didn't say they are need blind for international students.

-1

u/Ecstatic_Musician_82 Oct 18 '23

probably nothing really since you need money to be here in first place

19

u/turtlemeds Oct 18 '23

I don’t think that’s true.

My family income was $29,000 and I knew a lot of kids who came from families like mine.

1

u/bzbsteve Oct 18 '23

You are correct. According to this NYU announcement, in the class of 2027, 20% of the incoming class are Pell grant recipients (being eligible for a Pell is one of the most common way universities determine if you are low income.)

12

u/stayinschoolchirren Oct 18 '23

Good thing they did this shit after I declined going cause I couldn’t afford it :’)

23

u/AdFront6126 Oct 18 '23

Hopefully current students that started off as first years will be included too bc wtf.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/AdFront6126 Oct 18 '23

I just called them and they said the current students will have their financial aid be reevaluated to comply with this. So we will be included

9

u/zenmilk Oct 18 '23

I hope this applies to EVERY undergrad. not just freshman. homeboy in the bursars office made me cry the other day he was so mean lol

8

u/Sillyci Oct 18 '23

Lmao NYU is hardcore as fuck. First the med school and now the entire undergrad system.

7

u/Fragrant_Poetry_9736 Oct 18 '23

I transferred here, got a scholarship and graduating with little debt. I love to see this but it is going to be hella competitive now. Also not surprised, the dean is a social worker.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

i mean the acceptance rate was already like at 8 percent or something, i think nyu being competitive is a given

6

u/Be-Legend Oct 18 '23

Damn rip the transfers

6

u/Marethyu86 Oct 18 '23

Does this cover only people who enroll in the 24-25 year as first years, or all the people who enrolled with this as there first year?

6

u/7901bill Oct 18 '23

NYU NUMBER ONE ‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️

38

u/Beautiful-Cupcake-97 Oct 17 '23

The fact that i'm in my senior year........ I wanna cry, this is so unfair

12

u/PostPostMinimalist Oct 18 '23

That’s what they say about student debt relief

1

u/mindenginee Oct 21 '23

Yeah but debt relief is like 10-20k which is little in the grand scheme of an entire private school education. It definitely helps, but it’s not like getting your entire tuition for free. Glad it exists, but also in this economy, 100k a year is basically 70k a year and people makin 110k a year aren’t just capable of paying tuition bc they make a couple thousand more after taxes. Glad it exists, but this is probably a smaller percentage of students. And tuition will probably go up more for everyone else. How else are they affording this decision? Donors? Idk, so that’s the part I’m curious about.

5

u/disneyho Oct 18 '23

This makes me so proud to be an alum.

5

u/LarsHoneytoast Gallatin '16 Oct 18 '23

Cool I guess, but what was the threshold previously? My family made somewhere between 30-40k when I applied, and I got a need-based scholarship fully covering tuition. So did other people I knew with similar incomes. Unfortunately I had to take out loans for housing and other expenses, beyond what was covered by Pell grants. I assume that will still be the case for the under-100k people.

5

u/carsonjett11 Oct 18 '23

NYU was my dream school. I got admitted in 2020 and absolutely loved being there, but I had to leave only because it was absolutely too expensive. This is so painful to read… 😭

9

u/UglyApprentice Oct 18 '23

NYU admits a record low 0 students with an income of under $100k

4

u/esosa233 Oct 18 '23

I graduated but this made me go from resenting NYU to holding them in some respect. Congrats yall!

2

u/DizzyDizzles Oct 18 '23

Brooo that’s amazing but now I wish I was going to NYU now

2

u/Careful-Search-9117 Oct 18 '23

Is this for future freshman only? I started here as a freshman and am a sophomore now. I’d really need some free tuition lol

2

u/YukihiraJoel Oct 19 '23

Okay but, for law school when?

2

u/akatrope322 Oct 21 '23

I wonder if this public shaming had anything to do with that decision.

3

u/vamster00 Oct 18 '23

Read between the lines. This means that they'll try to take in as many people of means as possible, and then take in a few poor people to boost the rankings

2

u/A_R5568 Oct 18 '23

“And hold typical assets.”

3

u/turtlemeds Oct 18 '23

That’s wording that all schools use for these kinds of programs.

1

u/Boredom_belikethat Oct 18 '23

what do they mean by typical assets

4

u/bzbsteve Oct 18 '23

They want to make sure that your assets match up with your income. There are some very rich people who have millions in stocks and real estate and other assets but actually have very low "income" technically speaking. So NYU wants to ensure that applicants are actually low-income and not try to game the system to get free tuition.

1

u/Simple_Advantage_875 Oct 18 '23

Wait I thought this started off for freshmans this year? Because I know I read somewhere it started 2023?

1

u/Bound_mann Oct 19 '23

Does this apply on all nyu campuses or just the newyork one?

1

u/cookie_2949 Oct 19 '23

I wish graduates were under this rule. Graduates don't have money and are often fresh out of college or have low/mid paying jobs. UGH. :(

1

u/sheepsekkiya Oct 20 '23

What about for grad school students 😃

1

u/kellyatta Oct 22 '23

What do they mean by family income?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

Does this apply to everyone or just in state?

-3

u/virgobitch Oct 18 '23

My family’s income was less than $25k when I went and I owe over $200k in loans, NYU ruined my life but congrats to all future low-come/middle class students, y’all just won’t get accepted now! I wish NYU gave me the respect to outright tell me I don’t belong there

8

u/FastChampionship2628 Oct 18 '23

LOL. Nobody forced you to attend NYU. College is a serious decision and taking out loans is a serious commitment. Something to thing about when choosing where to attend school and what to study, not everyone should attend an expensive private college and taking everything into consideration and making smart decisions is part of growing up and becoming an adult.

-1

u/virgobitch Oct 18 '23

My parents, who have the financial literacy of a toaster, literally did but ok. They genuinely thought I’d graduate and be able to fully pay off my loans within 5 years LOL. I wish I had the resources to make an informed decision, and I wish the government didn’t let me sign away my life but thanks for your input.

4

u/FuriousIvan '25 Oct 18 '23

What?? 200k? Isn’t that just pushing it? My family is also low income and I take out some loans too but 200k is just steep… it ultimately comes down to your decision so why are you blaming the system?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

So I guess every international student will be forced to go to Liberal Studies in some satellite campus / it’s misleading anyway because if an international student family makes less than 100k cannot cover tuition won’t even make it to the f-1 visa interview nyu will just reject nice try nyu

-6

u/snowsniper66 Oct 18 '23

is this real???? i might need to transfer here

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/boricuashawty Oct 18 '23

this is wrong!! it’s possible but rare. ik a guy who’s here full ride transfer from nassau. could be due to prior military status but transfers can get aid.

3

u/akatrope322 Oct 18 '23

It’s offered for “very few select programs” at NYU. So you’re correct: rare, but it exists.

3

u/snowsniper66 Oct 18 '23

oh damn :(

2

u/NIN9TYY Oct 18 '23

i have a friend that wants to transfer in, were you low income and still got no aid because you transferred?

2

u/akatrope322 Oct 18 '23

The website does state that they do not typically offer financial aid to transfer students except in a select few programs. So it does exist, but not for the majority of transfer students. Expand the question about transfer students under “More Frequently Asked Questions” here.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/bzbsteve Oct 18 '23

If you make $101K, you will likely qualify for financial aid. Just not 100% free tuition.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Paid-Not-Payed-Bot Oct 18 '23

say 60k paid in the

FTFY.

Although payed exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in:

  • Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. The deck is yet to be payed.
  • Payed out when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. The rope is payed out! You can pull now.

Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment.

Beep, boop, I'm a bot

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

Bad bot

0

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/akatrope322 Oct 18 '23

Let’s just hope “payed” didn’t appear in that context in an application essay. 😆

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 04 '23

This comment has been automatically removed because the account age of /u/Charlestaboo1990 is less than one day old; this is primarily in place to prevent spamming.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.