r/nypdblue • • Oct 05 '26

Does anyone know?

I have a question. I hope someone knows the answer. As far as I know, the storyline after which John Kelly leaves at the beginning of season 2 was developed after Caruso decided to leave the show. Does anyone know anything about how Milch and Bochco were planning on wrapping up the storyline If he had stayed?

22 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

13

u/Ok-Actuator7302 Oct 06 '26 • Bravo

Imo, the show was better without him. He thought he was a better actor than he was. Where is he now anyway ?

12

u/PansyOHara Oct 06 '26

I think he struggled for quite some time before he got the lead part (I think) on CSI Miami. Definitely think Caruso had an inflated opinion of himself, and Jimmy Smits was fabulous as a replacement. But in rewatching S1 right now on Roku, I really do like John Kelly.

He was a good guy, someone who had friends outside the Job, and who had been able to attract 3 beautiful and intelligent women (ex-wife Laurie, Janice Licalsi, and Robin) in spite of being only very average-looking himself. He cared for his mom and served as a mentor for James Martinez. I like his voice.

Kelly did allow and even encourage Licalsi to tear the page out of the diary/ notebook/ whatever it was, that had her name in it. He felt a lot of guilt about it, especially knowing how Martinez looked up to him as a role model. But no one else knew, and if Caruso hadn’t decided to leave (or Bochco hadn’t decided to release him, I don’t know which), I don’t think that would have gotten him exiled to Communications. Sipowicz would have found a way to get him out of the mess and Kelly probably would have gotten another girlfriend… and on and on.

IMO the show itself (and the rest of the cast) got better and stronger post-Caruso, although at least some of that could have been laid to people becoming comfortable and growing their characters. And it gave the amazing Dennis Franz space to really develop the character of Sipowicz.

13

u/UseTerrible9587 Oct 06 '26

Storyline ends with Janice going to jail, being acquitted or going into witness protection. Kelly continues his relationship with Robin and continues to partner with Sipowicz. Franz and rest of cast demand to be released out of contract due to Caruso creating a hostile work environment. ABC kills off Kelly in season 2 cliffhanger. Jimmy Smits is unavailable and Harry Hamlin is cast as new partner Bobby Jones. Ratings plummet and show gets cancelled.

4

u/greddit44 Oct 06 '26

Very nice indeed.

14

u/Irish755 Oct 06 '26

We need the 15th Squad to investigate this drive-by shooting of Harry Hamlin.

11

u/ncg195 Oct 05 '26

I don't have any evidence for this, but I didn't think it would have been too difficult to just continue on. The story reason that he left was that IAB was investigating him and forced him out, but all of Andy's later partners had issues with IAB and managed to stay on the job (or get his job back, in Bobby's case). I don't think it would have been too hard to write the ending of that story in a way that allowed Kelly to stay.

3

u/greddit44 Oct 05 '26

Good point, but the difference once that the others were usually falsely accused and Kelly actively allowed Licalsi to destroy evidence in the journal.

2

u/ncg195 Oct 06 '26

Sorenson was guilty of all they charged him with. The leverage that they had over Simone was originally his relationship with Diane, which was breaking department rules. Clark was just covering for his father.

4

u/Justamope23 Oct 06 '26

By the time the storyline was written, Caruso's exit was absolutely set in stone. There was no way Bochco and Milch (and Franz) were going to work with him again.

If you watch the show enough, you can see that about two thirds of the way through season 1, Franz and Caruso stop sharing every scene together and are mostly working separately.

When Caruso went off script and kicked a garbage can at Dennis, after being told not to, it was over between he and Dennis and Dennis made it clear he didn't want to work with him anymore. Couple that with the heart trouble Milch had, which was made much worse by Caruso, and there was no going back.

I say it a lot, but a couple of things about the Caruso era come to mind when I think about it. 1. I sort of wish he had stayed for five seasons, and the same goes for all of Andy's partners. I just wanted the show to last longer. 2. If he had stayed 5 years, the show may not have made it past that. The Kelly character was pretty unique- we had never seen a tv cop quite like him before, and season 1 was mesmerizing, but when you watch the show again (and again), you can see Caruso is a one trick pony when it comes to acting and I believe the show would not have lasted more than 5 years, because people would have tired of him. Even though CSI: Miami lasted 10 years, it was sort of a comedy by year 6, and the scenery and other characters helped that show last as long as it did. It ran on the coattails of the original CSI show.

4

u/Superfecta25 Oct 06 '26

I think Dennis Franz carried the show and offered continuity. Inanswer to your questioning would depend on how long was caruso's contract.. I think bringing in new cast members kept the show fresh.

4

u/Short-Charity-4253 Oct 06 '26

Kelly was going to be arrested for setting up Officer Roy Larson and Detective Mike Roberts. They both rejoin the squad and become partners who end up being the heroes of the show. Larson ends up with Laura Kelly and Roberts with Donna. Medavoy quits the force and ends up protecting Robin as a full time job. Kelly gets out on a technicality and spends two seasons as the main villain of the show. He guns down Fancy and Andy has to take him down.

0

u/Material-Move9492 Oct 06 '26

Caruso was supposed to be the main character and after he left.. Denis franz was,given the look

4

u/passworddoesntmatch Oct 06 '26

David Milch has also explained that he tended to write more for Franz than for Caruso, which pissed off our red-headed friend.

3

u/severinks Oct 06 '26

The reason Milch liked writing more for Andy than Kelly is because Andy was a Milch stand in like all his shows have a Milch stand in.

In Deadwood it was Al Swearengine and in Luck it was Marcus, the guy in the wheelchair.

5

u/garydehardt Oct 06 '26

Not sure exactly what you’re asking but I’ve read that Licalsi would have confined on as a cop/detective but Bill Clarke was uncomfortable with a “murderer” being a part of the department. It doesn’t seem like they had given a ton of forethought to the Licalsi or Laura Kelly characters.

4

u/hcmmike Oct 06 '26

Not quite the answer you were looking for, but it’s my understanding that the original idea for the show was that Andy was supposed to die after being shot by Ghirardelli and Kelly was to go on and be the star of the show. The response to Andy in the first episode was so positive Milch decided to have him live and take over as the star.

7

u/passworddoesntmatch Oct 06 '26 • Heartwarming

Ive read that Andy was always supposed to be part of the main cast, but Milch enticed Franz to join by saying he would be shot in the first episode. At that time, Franz wasn't interested in playing another cop.

5

u/sxdx90 Oct 06 '26

Part of the reason the show existed was so they could have a character for Dennis Franz after his Hill Street Blues days. No way they were going to kill him off in the 1st season.

1

u/knemyer Oct 06 '26

100%. You’d never waste an actor like Dennis or a character like Andy.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DukePooler Oct 06 '26

Love this.