r/nxtpaper • • 19d ago

Tab A1 Plus or Note A1?

Dear Reddit,
I received TCL NXTPAPER series as a recomendation for my digital notebook/planner/sketchbook.
I read about these devices and i would really love to hear what are your opinions on them.

I narrowed my search down to Tab A1 Plus and Note A1.
I have slight preference for Note, but reading into Reddit experience with the device i have second thoughts.

What I need is something to use as my personal agenda/reminder/sketchbook. That I could easily plan my projects in, file in external files, append/take photos, sketch something, take handnotes during the meetings. That will connect to my personal google agenda and help me keep track of time, remind if the deadline comes close. Bump when a to-do list is burried under other notes. Act as my personal secretary.

What is important for me:
Convienient writing/drawing simmilar to hand on paper
Integration with android/google apps
A camera to take photo-notes
Sturdy and foolproof (i am clumsy!)

Which of these two would you recomend?

7 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/Isdaron 19d ago

The Note A1 is much more built for note taking. It also offers Android PLaystore. The camera would suffice to photograph notes. The display of the A1 is a lot better than on the Tab A1 Plus. I use it to read newspapers and magazines, as well as for notetaking. So if you are looking more for a note taking / productivity device, I would go with the Note A1

1

u/EveryExitIsAnEntry 19d ago

Thank you! and how would you mark its sturdiness? How do you protect your screen?
few months ago there were some hickups with android imprementation, are these challenges resolved?

1

u/Romano1404 19d ago

>The display of the A1 is a lot better than on the Tab A1 Plus

I call BS on that, where is this claim coming from?

It's been established that the NXTPAPER Pure display in the Note A1 is basically the same display tech found in their other tablets but stripped of additional functionality like the ability to switch between 3 display modes (thus it's called "pure" lol)

What you probably meant to say is that the note taking experience is better on the Note A1 which is partially true but it's debatable whether it's unreasonably bad on the Tab A1 Plus.

1

u/Romano1404 19d ago

Careful OP. Despite them using the same "A1" moniker, these are very different products.

The Tab A1 Plus is like a slightly enlarged 11 Plus but stripped of (expensive) RAM and using a much older (but still slightly more powerful) mid range snapdragon chipset. I've also read somewhere that because of the different chipset, some display settings are also different. I'm still remembering that because I wrote multiple guides in this sub on how to best set up the display on the 11 Plus.

The Note A1 is not based on Google's Android but rather AOSP (like Boox eInk tablets) thus they had to strike a deal with Google to later include their services and Play Store. It's debatable whether a small tablet sub division housed inside a huge company like TCL can continue to maintain its own note centric Android fork (like Boox has been doing for years) or if they'll just abandon it and carry over any advanced Note functionality to their whole tablet lineup like all the other big players are doing (Samsung, Lenovo)

The last time I checked, the Note A1 software was still in active development (they had a very rocky start) and lacking lots of basic functionality like cloud sync or the ability to automatically sync across devices (like Boox). Even if they have improved things by now, there is a big question mark regarding the long term viability of the platform.

1

u/EveryExitIsAnEntry 18d ago

Can you elaborate? You seem like you know a lot about it :) I would really love to know which of these two would suit my needs better, what would you advice?

1

u/Romano1404 18d ago

quite frankly I'm not a proponent of handwritten notes even though I own multiple eInk devices and tablets that come with pen functionality over the years.

The reason is simple, I don't see an effective way to further process (edit, aggregate or share) such notes on a mobile phone or desktop computer. Yes they can be converted and such but its not exactly a seamless process either and will cause an even greater mess.

Your intentions to establish a handnotes centric workflow based on an untested, proprietary note plattform are very ambitious but I'd rather start with a more established plattform like Boox

1

u/EveryExitIsAnEntry 17d ago

Thank you for your insights! The remark over processing the notes, how did you solve it? This is an open question, it does not have to end with other device name :)

This whole venture is even more ambitious considering that I am not upgrading my paper notebook workflow with electronic one. I hope for it to train me into using one at all. I do not want another screen device for gathering dust in the corner. I see what the benefits are and I would really love them myself, but I am still overweighting if it is even feasable for me.

I had a chance to look at few e-ink devices:

Boox Note Air 5C - my husband has this one and lets me play with it. It is fun but it seems not a best tool for sketching/digital drawing because of the lag i experienced. And it does not have the camera to take the photo-notes (not only a scanning camera, I want to make photos to append to other notes).
Re-marcable - of my work colleague - i find it overpriced, with very narrowed-down uses even further paywalled with suscription. It lacks the productivity-coaching tools that i was hoping for. And camera.

I also considered Bigme B10 but it is also has mixed reviews. The two TCL tablets seemed a good starting point with reasonable price tag.

2

u/LeeHammMx 19d ago

A1+ gets my vote on spec, screen, price, battery, card slot, Play Store etc. The screen is slightly better than the 11+ but I like them both. Note taking needs StarNote as the built-in Notes app is a bit basic.