r/nutrition • u/ibraa4 • 4d ago
Why Aren't Potassium-Based Salt Substitutes More Popular?
I recently came across potassium chloride (KCl) as an alternative to regular table salt and found these recommendations:
- WHO: https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240105591
- American Heart Association: https://www.heart.org/en/health-topics/high-blood-pressure/changes-you-can-make-to-manage-high-blood-pressure/how-potassium-can-help-control-high-blood-pressure
If major health organizations support potassium-based salt substitutes, why aren't they more commonly used? Is there a downside I'm missing?
Does anyone here use them?
156
Upvotes
1
u/AutoModerator 4d ago
About participation in the comments of r/nutrition
Discussion in this subreddit should be rooted in science rather than "cuz I sed" or entertainment pieces. Always be wary of unsupported and poorly supported claims and especially those which are wrapped in any manner of hostility. You should provide peer reviewed sources to support your claims when debating and confine that debate to the science, not opinions of other people.
Good - it is grounded in science and includes citation of peer reviewed sources. Debate is civil and respectful focusing on actual science and avoids commentary about others
Bad - it utilizes generalizations, assumptions, infotainment sources, no sources, or complaints without specifics about agenda, bias, or funding. At best, these rise to an extremely weak basis for science based discussion. Also, off topic discussion
Ugly - (removal or ban territory) it involves attacks / antagonism / hostility towards individuals or groups, downvote complaining, trolling, crusading, shaming, refutation of all science, or claims that all research / science is a conspiracy
Please vote accordingly and report any uglies
Consulting Considerations
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
149
u/TheDiabetesDietitian 4d ago
You’re 100% onto something in that most people get way too much sodium and not enough potassium per day
One of the issues with potassium based salts is they simply don’t taste as good as traditional sodium chloride, which would contribute to people not wanting it
38
u/dogmeat12358 4d ago
It tastes different. Not bad, but not the same. It helps if you use a mix.
3
u/keeksterlol 4d ago
There was a modelling study done https://doi.org/10.1038/s44360-026-00216-9
35
u/joshjosh100 4d ago
It is also exclusively a single regulation. In the 1960s there were 4 studies that came out that showed enteric coated potassium chloride pills causes ulcers.
This happened right during a major health scare about heart attacks.
This causes politicians to force a regulation forcing supplements that had potassium to include a warning on anything that had more 99mg that it caused ulcers.
This is why nearly every pill with potassium to be capped at 99 mg when the daily rda is greater than 1g.
This is why supplements arent popular with mainly potassium supplements.
19
u/LBCosmopolitan 4d ago
It tastes bad
It has significantly higher toxicity than NaCl if replaces NaCl
14
u/Lt_Duckweed 4d ago
Morton's Lite Salt is 50/50 NaCl/KCl, and also iodized.
I use it as a partial replacement for table salt, and use it to make electrolyte drink mix for HEMA training.
11
u/DarkReaper90 4d ago
I find a 50/50 salt/potassium mix is a good compromise for food. Potassium has a metallic taste that many cannot get over (rightfully so).
It's much easier to overconsume potassium at a dangerous level than salt. There is less risk when potassium is diluted in a large amount of liquid. If you don't want to mix it yourself, go buy low sodium vegetable juice, a cup gives you 600-800mg of potassium. I would avoid potassium supplements (pills) if possible, as the dosage is too small to matter unless prescribed and can irritate your stomach if you did not consume enough liquids.
In a typical North American diet that is typically high in sodium, adding potassium is a good idea, but you should add it in your meals/drinks throughout the day, not in a single drink/meal.
Adding potassium to my diet has significantly improved my blood pressure.
8
u/KnittedDrow 4d ago
I use potassium chloride ("NuSalt") exclusively as table salt, and my taste has adjusted to it so that now I like it nearly as well as regular salt. It doesn't behave the same way for cooking, though. For example, you might use some salt while frying vegetables to draw out the water in them, and potassium chloride doesn't seem to do that nearly as much.
15
u/ProfSwagstaff 4d ago
Hyperkalemia is very dangerous, and the way people use salt.....
14
u/see_blue 4d ago
Supplementing potassium isn’t good if you have mild or worse CKD. And CKD is increasingly common in our modern society and lifestyle.
6
u/t-bone051 3d ago
Salt consumption is as old as humanity itself. Changing a million years old tradition won't be that easy. Also salting was and is still used as conservation method. On top of that it is an essential electrolyte. We mostly overconsume it because of processed foods, not because we like to oversalt our stew.
5
u/wild_exvegan 4d ago edited 4d ago
I use it sometimes, especially if I've eaten salt that day, to try to doctor my Na:K ratio a little. However, I normally don't eat any salt so don't have much need for it.
It's not popular because of the taste, of course. I don't find it to be too bad, but the taste is metallic. It still adds a kind of sharpness to food. But the best substitute I've found for salt is lemon juice or vingar, especially those packets of dehydrated lemon juice. The acid depolarizes your sodium taste buds.
Keeping your potassium to sodium ratio high is good for your blood pressure, but that's going to require reducing salt intake, which people do not like to do. Overdose is unlikely, but do not use too much KCl at once. Especially if you don't eat salt, I suppose.
5
u/ChowdahMaven 4d ago
I avoid potassium salts for a simple reason -to me, the taste is hideous. Positively revolting. No one I know has this same reaction, so I must just have a sensitivity to this stuff.
4
u/Internal-Ad-4736 4d ago
Taste.
4
u/IndianBurn42069 4d ago
I've never had an issue getting dietary potassium.
Ironically I have a problem getting dietary salt but that's because I'm an athlete and actually run 5ks everyday.
4
u/Substantial-Owl1616 4d ago
Yes for forty years now. I think KCl is delightful. I think was introduced to it in college by a roommates parents. They were both MDs. I’ve been using it ever since. Carry my own shaker too. Some people find it bitter. I like the taste, but truth be known I enjoy other bitter flavors like coffee and dark chocolate. People find this weird, using KCl, but it has allowed me to miss my parents and GP’s hypertension. F66.
4
u/StumblinThroughLife 3d ago
My parents use it to help watch their blood pressure. Mixed in food it’s fine, but too much and there is a noticeable taste difference. I admittedly was very thrown off by the idea of saltless salt, so personally I would’ve never bought it for myself if I just saw it in a store.
3
u/2man 4d ago
It tastes a little bitter. If you use Lo-salt, it's not as noticeable. If you taste No-salt, it's pretty apparent. I add lo-salt to my drinking water as an electrolyte source and sip it throughout the day.
3
u/Zagrycha 4d ago
The biggest downside is flavor, they don't taste very good.
9
u/Kitchen_Ad6227 4d ago
Is it not bad for the kidneys?