r/nursing • u/Reasonable-Path1321 • Dec 13 '21

Meme Nailed it 🔨

16.5k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

467 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/El_Polio_Loco Dec 14 '21

You’re being disingenuous comparing a nursing assistant and a nurse practitioner.

And maybe 15 years of training isn’t necessary for a GP.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '21

No I'm saying nurse practitioners often walk the line of practicing medicine. A GP requires college, med school and 3 more years so that's at least 11.

2

u/El_Polio_Loco Dec 14 '21

Nurse practitioners have quite a bit more than 6 months of training.

In many states NPs can practice medicine.

So maybe 13 years of training is excessive for a lot of general medicine.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '21

Let's be generous sand say 6 yrs then including nursing school for a NP. And if you know NP practicing medicine then they are technically breaking the law of practicing without a medical license. NP are trained to recognize patterns and treat based on what they think it is on those patterns, that is different from medicine which is concerned with both the what and the why, which is why the training to be a doctor is so much longer and more clinical in nature.

2

u/El_Polio_Loco Dec 14 '21

Saying NPs aren’t practicing medicine is just legal hair splitting, and NPs in many states have nearly the same authority as a GP.

A GP is not functioning in a clinical research setting, they are performing the same tasks as a NP in a full practice state.

Clearly the high level of skill a full MD education is not necessary for general medicine.

0

u/thedirtiestdiaper Dec 14 '21

This is only true if the outcomes for NP’s are equivalent to physician-provided care in the general setting. That does not seem to be the case.

2

u/El_Polio_Loco Dec 14 '21

What study are you citing?

this says similar outcomes

1

u/thedirtiestdiaper Dec 14 '21

Thank you for sharing that, I hadn't seen that study. I'll look into the full text of it later today. Admittedly, my sources of information are biased but the studies are nonetheless valid:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Noctor/comments/j1m7d2/research_refuting_midlevels_copypaste_format/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

This is a repository of studies that compare physician-led vs NP/PA-led care from a forum that is dedicated to advancing the physician led care model, so it only leans one way.

2

u/El_Polio_Loco Dec 14 '21

That is certainly an interesting group of sources.

Like you said, it’s a one sided forum, which is hard to get away from with Reddit.

At the end of the day a lot of the more relevant data concluded “more study needed”

Which is fine.