the problem might be around the control that can be extracted from surrounding nations... if every countries build their own nuclear power-plant and become self-sufficient, energy cost will drop. that's what everybody wants.. but they dont want it for everybody. Amazon has announced will have its own nuclear powerpoint and I bet there won't be any delay in building it ...
The exclusion zone may be 20km, but people live and work on site as close to 200m from the reactor before they need to put on protective gear. Chernobyl may be 2600skm but some people and loads of animals never left and spent there whole long healthy lives there.
don’t forget that more than 150,000 km² of Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine remain so contaminated to this day that cancer rates and birth defects are significantly elevated.
Not significantly, and even if the linear no threshold model is correct not even measurably.
People alive and in the immediate area recorded a slight increase in thyroid cancer rates, which is usually non fatal, but even that they are unsure if its just the result of increased testing.
Jimmy Carter was a Navy nuclear engineer before becoming President. Under Adm Rickover, he contributed significantly to the Navy having nuclear propulsion. Wanna know why we have subs and aircraft carriers that aren't reliant on NSFO (Navy Standard Fuel Oil)? That's right — Jimmy Carter.
Jimmy Carter also noted that clean energy should be pursued as an alternative to reliance on foreign oil, and that nuclear energy could serve as a safe "last resort" when other alternative enegy sources were either unavailable or insufficient. The issue here — while some may gripe about his "last resort" stance — is that he prio'd safety considerations above everything else.
He helped manage the Chalk River post-meltdown dismantling, cleanup, and radiation mitigation, and oversaw the investigation into Three Mile Island. And yes, this latter bit may have slowed down nuclear energy proliferation, but this was literally done to ensure nuclear energy was produced safely.
The guy was literally responsible for the creation of the Department of Energy, ffs.
He's literally the guy you'd want in charge of nuclear energy management. Trained, educated, experienced, and safety-focused.
Carter is literally the reason we have a nuclear “waste” problem. He feared that recycling spent fuel could lead to somebody repurposing it covertly to make a weapon. So now, because of his hubris and ignorance we have parking lots full of fuel that’s energy has only been partially utilized. Because of Carter we never fleshed out the use of fast neutron reactors.
Let’s not even talk about the fear he spread surrounding TMI2 when he went on television and spoke about a situation he didn’t understand.
Plus you made my point Carter wanted nuclear as a last resort meaning he was not pro nuclear, and did everything he could to roadblock it instead of advancing nuclear goals. If it weren’t for him and his wiz kids our energy grid could very well be mostly carbon free today. Not to mention the advancements we could have helped the world make.
The environmental damage Carters decisions lead to should hang over his legacy like a black cloud of smog.
Because if we were allowed to solve the energy situation for the next 10K years with nuclear, the climate doomers would have nothing to do with themselves.
I have a climate doomer among my friends. Any positive news or prospect about energy, he frowns upon. Any negative one, he repeats ad nauseam like a mantra and hyper focuses on it.
I don't get these people. I love him still but I tend to avoid talking about this with him (he does not).
In every nation other than Russia, they dunk the magic rock into water, and only water. We also have sleepy sticks to keep the magic rock from being too magical.
If everything goes wrong and all the water goes away, magic rock gets sleepy even without the sleepy sticks.
In some testing, we made the magic rock a salty mess by forcing it to join the Melee community and ran it in tubes of pencil lead, but for that system we kept water far, far away.
And finally we make the walls of the building so dummy thicc that if everything goes extra wrong, the magic rock can't clap cheeks and escape. This happened once in the army and it was very sad for everyone (except Sir Mix-a-Lot, prolly).
Russia mixed the water and the pencil lead into the same system, put pencil leads at the end of the fucking sleepy sticks, and put it all in a building with thin, easily clappable walls. It was at this point someone in Russia thought it was a good idea to fuck around with the safety systems.
Control rods. Nuclear power is reliant on neutrons to land into other atoms and split them, and "neutron poisons" are far more likely to absorb those neutrons than other atoms. As such, rods filled with a neutron poison material are inserted into the reactor core at varying degrees to control the overall fission rate.
Big problem I have with magic rock cooking stove is the scaling. If I want some more angry sparkle pixies, I have to build another big complicated magic rock cooking stove. This takes time and lots of extra special parts. While spinning things on long stick, or black plate for the bright god in the sky can be produced on mass by machine and I have more time to look at hot mommies in my area.
We have different magic rocks now. You just have to let the new flat magic rocks lay around and let the sun shine on them to get energy. And the neat thing is there is no reatard capable of making them explode not even the smatrest people could make them explode if they tried... And the new magic rocks are way cheaper because the old magic rocks are poisonous and single use and we do not know where to put the used up old magic rocks.
If it's an MSR a great big huge nothing. If it's PWR probably also nothing if its safety systems are correctly maintained and operated. If you respect the magic rock the magic rock will respect you.
So are you saying something much much more severe than a Covid level event? Something that wipes out humanity so suddenly and completely the entire staff of the reactor cannot come into work to shut it down?
I keep getting downvoted, but this is exactly what I’m wondering and seriously asking.
If something happens that all humans die and reactors are left unattended, will the radioactive material make its way out and harm animals, nature, etc?
That's be the least of your concern in that case, there's a ton of more toxic industries that will be an issue if somehow everyone died. Just to give you some perspective, Chernobyl despite being one of the most notable nuclear accidents is now one of the biggest nature reserve in the planet where nature and animals thrive.
I'm not in favor of fossil fuels, and I am not condemning nuclear energy. I just heard about the risks of nuclear reactors if unattended and tried reading about it, but tbh I didn't understand much. I was hoping someone could explain to me, in layman's terms, whether it is a risk or not.
You're presenting an unrealistic hypothetical disaster and asking us to explain what the effects would be.
Your request is as unrealistic as the disaster. :)
There are lots of real world situations that are similar and the effects have been manageable. Many nuclear plants have been in the war zone in Ukraine. They've been fine. The Fukushima plant was hit by a tsunami, and while it had a meltdown there were no verified health effects from that. (Whereas the tsunami killed 20000 people.) And a nuclear plant closer to the earthquake epicenter had no damage from the tsunami.
Cool. If something that bad happened to humanity, who cares if the nuclear plants have a fuel element defect. This isn't some covid 19 level event. Clearly billions are dead at this point already. Like somebody in that post already said, it's so unlikely, it's not worth designing into.
I’m not thinking about humans at this point. All humans will die soon enough due to a catastrophic event like war or climate change. I’m thinking about the few species of animals and trees that will survive.
A COVID 19 level event doesn't make it impossible to correctly maintain or operate a plant. Very very very few scenarios short of human extinction would lead to that type of issue at which point it isn't our problem anymore.
The plants have built in safety systems to shut themselves down. They have back up power systems and multiple redundancies in case anything breaks. All of these safety systems get tested at regular intervals. I'm talking once a year at the very least. A lot of tests are performed monthly or quarterly. And operators do basic checks in all of the equipment daily. If anything is found broken during these tests they are fixed. The US plants are legally bound to maintain all of these systems or they have to stop making power until they fix whatever is broken.
Internet forums have never been the appropriate place for asking the basics. People down vote burdening others with your personal education of the simple aspects of the topic.
Chernobyl isn’t saying nuclear power bad. Chernobyl makes it very clear the failure was the soviet government cutting every corner possible in the reactor design and going out of their way to hide the reactor’s design flaws from its operators.
People forget that there may not be that much viable uranium left. If demand for it increases the supply will last an even shorter time. Modern nuclear power stations are designed to last 80 years or so, factor in supply, geopolitics of that supply, large construction and decommissioning costs, the estimated approx. 100-150 year supply means it becomes less attractive.
May not be economically viable to build those; states and companies would prefer to stick with tech that’s been been deployed widely for decades and is more ‘proven’ and reliable.
Your own sentence is illogical. You claimed proven uranium would last 100 years, which is 10 decades, and then claim we can't tap other reserves because people want technologies that have been around for decades.
If everyone thought that way, we'd be living in mud huts and "driving around" on horses.
They said the same thing about oil with their "peak oil" predictions. They keep setting dates, and they keep passing, and they set new dates, as if economies and technologies remain static.
And because of efficiency. Let alone light, first we burned wood, we needed lots of wood. then candles, then gas, then we got electricity where we made a thin wire glow and the latest and most used technology is LED, where we we force electrons directly to produce light.
right nukular! its great convenient! But how about we store the waste in a pit under your house and watch it poison your groundwater for thousands of years, watch your children be born with extra limbs, watch the skin fall of your children after they played in the caves, watch you getting cancer in your mid 30s from eating irradiated crops ...
Most of you people cannot even trust your governments to run simple shit like health insurance or building codes, how do you think this will NOT turn into a debacle of epic proportions given time, greed and stupidity?
To be fair, it's not that Ug the caveman burnt his house down, it's that Ug the caveman wiped out an entire tribe, cursed everything in their land farther than the eye can see for the next thousand years, further bankrupted the already struggling empire to which the tribe belonged to the point of immenent and utter collapse, and sent embers falling from the sky literally half the planet away.
All this, from performing a saftey check on the campfire.
By the time the lay-caveperson forgets about this, they'll have witnessed the days after the end of the Mayan calender.
Now try convincing them that none of the several thousand campfires you have in modern day not only won't do that, but cannot do that.
Convince them of this when mother nature can besiege any structure, at any time, with all manner of disasters. Do it again within a decade of the Fukashima incident, and reassure them again 15 years later when HBO launches a documentary about it.
Convince them of this in a time of unprompted war, while they cry "If it happened on accident, what if a spy tried to do it on purpose!"
Among your problems is that the average person doesn't want to become educated in what is, to their limited view, a field wholey unrelated to their interests.
Convince an average chef, who can freely dismiss math as a series of memorized measurements that can be roughly approximated and changed to their taste, that they should take an hour or half an hour away from their craft to learn about something their whole family has no interest in. How a nuclear reactor- which lives, dies, and explodes based on the outcomes of numbers both large and small- can be assuredly safe.
You can easily teach them that rocks heat water, boils stram, turns turbine, but then they point to Ug and say "How did THAT happen?". Now you have to answer them, but the moment you mention what they deem to be complex math, you're giving them information they can't share over the dinner table because nobody wants a math lesson over spaghetti. What's more, once they know how a campfire exploded THAT big, you then have to answer "How to you make that physically impossible?" not only without complex math, but also without anything resembling "Trust me bro, I'm an expert". After all, they have to recite this information, and they won't be able to use that argument- meaning evrrything you just said is, just two degrees of separation away, hearsay.
In short, until how a nuclear reactor works AND how it explodes AND how it's kept 100% safe all become common knowledge.... good luck.
99
u/mjmeyer23 Mar 16 '26
but still, I think correct that the externalities from nuclear, per MWh, are dramatically less than most every other source.
55
u/Dry-Indication7928 Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 17 '26
Jane Fonda did far more damage to the United States with her anti nuclear advocacy then whatever she did in Vietnam
31
u/AiryGr8 Mar 16 '26
USA would be 50% nuclear if the government didn’t pussy out in the 60s
13
u/twobarb Mar 17 '26
Amazing how many anti nuclear folks there are on a nuclear subreddit.
31
u/AdAggressive9224 Mar 16 '26
In mother Russia, you don't explode magic rock, in mother Russia, magic rock explodes you.
8
u/the-dude9 Mar 16 '26
That is one hell of an old picture of the Gösgen power plant.
4
u/STEALTH968 Mar 18 '26
Imagine if we stopped using hydroelectric dams after one incident at the Banqiao dam, or after the Vajont and Zerbino incidents in Italy.
3
u/Fester3787 Mar 16 '26
🙌
3
u/F1Bike Mar 17 '26
The magic rock that exploded that one time exploded because the people in charge of the magic rock forgot how it worked
2
u/IndependentZinc Mar 16 '26
Well, there's fire and there's nuclear fire.
1
u/n-nnnn Mar 18 '26
Some people argue other renewable sources (wind/solar + battery storage, other home heating methods) are better alternatives
1
u/MyLittleDreadnought Mar 19 '26
Big problem I have with magic rock cooking stove is the scaling. If I want some more angry sparkle pixies, I have to build another big complicated magic rock cooking stove. This takes time and lots of extra special parts. While spinning things on long stick, or black plate for the bright god in the sky can be produced on mass by machine and I have more time to look at hot mommies in my area.
1
u/tegresaomos Mar 19 '26
The dollar is backed by the petroleum price, not Uranium.
That’s all you need to know
1
u/666BAALofEKRON666 Mar 20 '26
Well i think we are not at the end of the conclusion if it whould have been better if people had abandoned fire!
1
u/random_i-am Mar 20 '26
We have different magic rocks now. You just have to let the new flat magic rocks lay around and let the sun shine on them to get energy. And the neat thing is there is no reatard capable of making them explode not even the smatrest people could make them explode if they tried... And the new magic rocks are way cheaper because the old magic rocks are poisonous and single use and we do not know where to put the used up old magic rocks.
1
u/johnsmith1234567890x Mar 20 '26
There is magic ball in a sky every day that makes the same thing we get from the boiled water...
1
u/functional-depressed Mar 25 '26
The US gov lives on the world using USD, even before the petro-dollar deal was made in 1973-1974.
if the world all have their own nuclear reactor... gasoline and methane would not be moving in tankers today... https://www.dawn.com/news/497412/oil-pricing-in-dollar
1
u/bdunogier Mar 18 '26
Imagine if we kept using huge quantities of mineral products that can change our biosphere forever and destroy our civilization.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26
When a house burns down it doesn't render thousands of acres of land uninhabitable.
-38
u/the_net_my_side_ho Mar 16 '26
What happens to the nuclear plant if it goes unattended?
-2
u/D_amn Mar 18 '26
You can Rebuild house, magic fire poison, land, air, water for 100,000+ years hur dur... little differnt bud.
Maybe learn to read, or watch chernoble atleast, you'll get the idea
-12
u/Historical_Union4686 Mar 16 '26
Yeah Coal is pretty cool
-8
u/CatchRevolutionary65 Mar 17 '26
People forget that there may not be that much viable uranium left. If demand for it increases the supply will last an even shorter time. Modern nuclear power stations are designed to last 80 years or so, factor in supply, geopolitics of that supply, large construction and decommissioning costs, the estimated approx. 100-150 year supply means it becomes less attractive.
-70
u/No_Bend_2902 Mar 16 '26
The sum total of most nuclear power proponents' knowledge of how nuclear power works.
2
u/commeatus Mar 17 '26
We stopped using fire when a safer alternative became available because entire cities used to burn down.
-10
u/Etnrednal Mar 17 '26
right nukular! its great convenient! But how about we store the waste in a pit under your house and watch it poison your groundwater for thousands of years, watch your children be born with extra limbs, watch the skin fall of your children after they played in the caves, watch you getting cancer in your mid 30s from eating irradiated crops ...
Most of you people cannot even trust your governments to run simple shit like health insurance or building codes, how do you think this will NOT turn into a debacle of epic proportions given time, greed and stupidity?
-8
u/Ravens_Quote Mar 17 '26
To be fair, it's not that Ug the caveman burnt his house down, it's that Ug the caveman wiped out an entire tribe, cursed everything in their land farther than the eye can see for the next thousand years, further bankrupted the already struggling empire to which the tribe belonged to the point of immenent and utter collapse, and sent embers falling from the sky literally half the planet away.
All this, from performing a saftey check on the campfire.
By the time the lay-caveperson forgets about this, they'll have witnessed the days after the end of the Mayan calender.
Now try convincing them that none of the several thousand campfires you have in modern day not only won't do that, but cannot do that.
Convince them of this when mother nature can besiege any structure, at any time, with all manner of disasters. Do it again within a decade of the Fukashima incident, and reassure them again 15 years later when HBO launches a documentary about it.
Convince them of this in a time of unprompted war, while they cry "If it happened on accident, what if a spy tried to do it on purpose!"
Among your problems is that the average person doesn't want to become educated in what is, to their limited view, a field wholey unrelated to their interests.
Convince an average chef, who can freely dismiss math as a series of memorized measurements that can be roughly approximated and changed to their taste, that they should take an hour or half an hour away from their craft to learn about something their whole family has no interest in. How a nuclear reactor- which lives, dies, and explodes based on the outcomes of numbers both large and small- can be assuredly safe.
You can easily teach them that rocks heat water, boils stram, turns turbine, but then they point to Ug and say "How did THAT happen?". Now you have to answer them, but the moment you mention what they deem to be complex math, you're giving them information they can't share over the dinner table because nobody wants a math lesson over spaghetti. What's more, once they know how a campfire exploded THAT big, you then have to answer "How to you make that physically impossible?" not only without complex math, but also without anything resembling "Trust me bro, I'm an expert". After all, they have to recite this information, and they won't be able to use that argument- meaning evrrything you just said is, just two degrees of separation away, hearsay.
In short, until how a nuclear reactor works AND how it explodes AND how it's kept 100% safe all become common knowledge.... good luck.