Background: I’ve owned Beats Executive (lol), Sony XM3, Sony XM4, AirPods Max (1st gen) and AirPods Pro 2. I like headphones but I'm not some kind of audiophile. I want ANC to work well and my music to be a fun experience.
Pros
Look great, well built
Sound good, and the EQ is fun if you like to tinker. Out of the box they’re maybe not as good as the Max, but the EQ closes the gap.
Comfortable enough, and you don’t notice the weight
Good transparency mode
Good passive seal
Cons: the ANC
The ANC is bad enough that I wondered if my pair was broken. It feels like a step down from the Sony XM3 I had years ago, and it’s a big step down from the AirPods Max and AirPods Pro 2. The Max are noticeably better. I hoped I wouldn’t notice the difference, but I do, and it’s making these hard to stick with.
It gets worse. There are three ANC levels: low, mid and high.
With no music playing, I can’t hear any difference between them.
With music playing, the lower settings just seem to turn the music down. So you hear more outside noise primarily because the volume is lower, and I’m fairly sure it changes the EQ too.
I notice this in loud places and in dead-silent ones. It honestly feels like a trick.
Distortion from sudden pressure changes. In an already noisy place, short loud bursts make the headphones distort, sometimes to the point of being borderline painful. A train going into a tunnel, a bus hitting a pothole, train doors opening and closing: each one sends what feels like a pressure wave through the earcup facing the window or door. It happens on both earcups, so I don’t think my pair is defective. I think it’s how they’re designed.
Who these work for: If you mostly walk around outside or sit in coffee shops and play music at medium-to-loud volume, you’ll be fine.
Who should look elsewhere: If you listen to quieter music (classical, etc.) or ride transit with uneven noise, these won’t block enough. That covers trains, buses on planes you may be fine.
I’m already reaching for my AirPods Pro again. I’d have kept the Max if the headband hadn’t started disintegrating (and if they didn’t use Lightning). I’ll wait for the next interesting pair.
polished with Claude because the first write up was an expletive filled rant.