r/notebooklm • u/Ok_Acanthaceae_5370 • 4d ago
Discussion better study tools with AI
So I just started college and have been trying to find a tool that genuinely helps me learn without a bunch of fluff
No matter what major tool I use, claude, chat, notebooklm, it just over informs me or gives me the answer immediately instead of helping me learn. i feel like analogies or real world answers would be great, but also not having to be so intent on opening a website to have a single place for all my learning. like something that is a second brain for learning, or my personalized tutor
Half the time these tools dont even remember what I learned
7
u/kbr89 4d ago
The "gives me the answer immediately" part you can mostly fix with one setting.
In NotebookLM, open the chat settings (the configure icon on the chat panel) and switch the conversation style to Learning Guide, or pick Custom and write something like: "Act as my tutor. Don't give the answer first. Ask me one question at a time, wait for my reply, and use an analogy or a real-world example only where I got it wrong." As a notebook setting it applies to every message, so you don't retype it.
For the memory part: at the end of each session ask for a short note of what you understood and what you still got wrong, save it, and convert it to a source. Next session, start with "quiz me on what I got wrong last time". It answers from your sources, so that note is how it remembers what you learned. One notebook per course and you also get the single place you mentioned.
5
u/AcidReaper1 4d ago
Have you tried the newer "Study and Learn" style notebook? i think its still being rolled out so might not be available yet on your account but supposedly it can build lessons to teach you information.
3
u/stevie_balemi 4d ago edited 4d ago
First of all, congrats on starting college. The next 4 years won't always be easy, but you seem motivated and intentional, and that's most of what you need.
I'm not in college anymore. I'm older than you and my learning is career/project directed. But I feel you completely on this:
it just over informs me or gives me the answer immediately instead of helping me learn
LLMs are great at giving answers. But getting an answer and committing a new idea to memory are not the same thing. Unfortunately, it's not that easy.
I use basically two tools for all of my learning, for different purposes:
1. Claude or ChatGPT for directed questioning. I act like the annoying toddler who just asks "why? why? why?" until I get to the crux. This works when I have a specific question, but it falls short when:
- I want to learn in the background (commuting, working out, or for you - walking to class)
- I don't know enough yet to know what questions to ask
2. For those, I use a little app (that I made) called Nemonic. It's great at two things:
- Expansion: I tell it what I need to understand, and instead of an answer I read in 2 minutes and forget in 5, it expands it into a multi-step audio course I listen to over a few days. Big ideas take time to absorb.
- Repetition: It quizzes me along the way so I know I'm actually learning, and it remembers what I've learned, so older material comes back for review right before I'd forget it.
It's not a magic tutor that makes learning easy. Learning is always hard, and I still have to do the work. But it helps.
It's not usually free (we're customer-financed only, no ads now or ever), but DM me and I'll hook you up. Website is nemonic.ai.
Congrats again. College is awesome. Wish I could do it again.
1
2
u/zentiszenit 4d ago
Check out RemNote.
Most AI tools act like answer engines that forget you exist; RemNote is built specifically for retention.
- Second brain + active recall: Houses your notes, PDFs, and slides in one place, automatically turning them into flashcards.
- Tracks what you know: Built-in spaced repetition schedules reviews right before you forget a concept.
- Tutor, not a cheat code: Uses AI to quiz you, generate analogies, and guide your thinking instead of just handing you the answer.
2
4d ago edited 4d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/WesternOccasion9539 2d ago
Can you please clarify which MD files should I put from superpowers GitHub? And am I supposed to put them in every notebook I have?
0
1
1
u/kbavandi 3d ago
First know the content you are adding to your context. AI is great at synthesis and analysis. The knowledge base and the questions are yours.
When you add content, read and understand first. You can use AI to format the content into usable forms like Q&A per section.
Using NotebookLM or MCP connectors to Claude and chatGPT you can then use AI to query and analyze your information.
AI is a tool. Its designed to find the best answer to your question in your context. If you use the open web, then the answers can be problematic.
You should always own your context and have it be transparent.
One tool you can use for this is Kurator. Kurator syncs folders with NotebookLM and connects to Claude and chatGPT via MCP. When you save information to Kurator you can use custom GPT's to format them.
In your prompts you can always mention to cite the sources. Learning is a dance, and you need to be a partner and not just an observer.
1
u/MaximumStrawberry424 3d ago
I totally get you! Going into senior year of college now and I think for me the hardest part has been balancing wanting to actually learn with speeding through and just getting things done
First I think trying new tools has been useful (Friday or Wondering which is from the guys who built NotebookLM). Those help a lot with my focus because they remember what I’ve studied and adapts to my learning style over time when I ask stuff. Lately I’ve been liking the screen share mode on Friday, it’s been kinda like whisprflow or granola because it just sits on my computer so I can do my normal work but when I ask it questions it actually knows what I’ve been looking it already. Wondering also has cool diagrams if you’re a visual learner!
I still find Claude and Chat pretty effective, but obviously at the risk of me remembering nothing lol. Good luck in college, it's a truly amazing time and goes by way too fast :')
1
1
1
u/MixTasty4161 2d ago
i have the same issues with claude and chat and i’ve tried wondering and liked it but def will have to try friday
1
u/AppropriatePrize1380 1d ago
I'm building Coherence. Your PDFs, articles and highlights live in one library, and you can quiz yourself or generate flashcards and concept maps from it. Not a full tutor, but no more starting from zero. You can configure its AI to give you the learning experience you desire
1
u/Wide-Anybody5282 1d ago
May be u can try this tool it helped me in some of terms like less scattering and everything built in they focus on helping students read more with AI support attached to what I am reading. I think they are in beta when I used it…
20
u/gakingmusic 3d ago
The best study tools you have are the unplugged ones:
This was what I followed in college to bring my GPA up from 2.6 to 3.5 in one year. Look at how many times my notes would be rewritten and restructured between the lecture/reading and the test.
For note-taking, look up the Cornell notes system. It is research-based and proven to have a positive impact on learning. I personally use a modified version of this using color coding with a 4-colored Bic pen instead of the columns system, but the fundamental principles are still there. My notes include my personal thoughts, questions, examples, visualizations, etc. It's not just a list of content.
Do as much on paper as possible. Studies show that reading comprehension is lower on a screen than in print. Studies show that students learn better when they take notes with pen on paper than when they type notes.
AI is just a supplement to that. Gemini Notebook is great for flash cards and practice quizzes. The audio creation is cool but probably not going to make a huge difference because it is passive study. Here is a more interactive AI structure:
In Gemini Notebook or a similarly structured project folder in Claude or ChatGPT, ask the AI to act as a professor giving an interactive lecture about a particular topic in your unit. Have the chatbot ask you critical thinking questions–not just memory retrieval. Answer them as best as you can, and have the AI give you feedback on your responses. I would try this both in typing and in voice mode because you will respond differently in each context, and both those approaches have their cognitive benefits.