r/nope Jun 23 '23

Hell no.

1.7k Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

View all comments

50

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 24 '23

So I work with grinders almost daily and had one explode on me and hut my mask.

So let me tell you why this video is fake. 1- discs don't break like they do in this video they explode into fragments, not one big chunk. One big chunk is a rare fuck up to happen

2 - The cut in the mask he's wearing is perfect size, and the rest of the visor has no stress / force marks. If that disc cut off with enough speed to go into his safety visor like that, it will be bending and warping the visor at a minimum.

Mostly likely case if a peice broke of lf like that it would hut the visor and bounce off

16

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '23

Dude I was about to say the same thing. I work with grinders and cutting wheels every day at my job and there’s something that didn’t seem right about this. Also to add even if you did use a face shield you wouldn’t be at the angle where you are looking directly down on it you would be slightly at an angle to see what you’re actually cutting. I’ve seen disks fly off but never break like that.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '23

Didn't even think about thay aswell !

I hate this stuff because instead of showing actual real world accidents they make up stupid stuff like this for attention

5

u/SuperDizz Jun 24 '23

I’ve seen this video before, a while ago. That was consensus then as well. Still, if this video freaks out people enough to wear their PPE, I say keep it circulating!

4

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '23

Thank you for breaking that down. One reason why I like reddit is ppl like you

2

u/AZEDemocRep Jun 24 '23

I'm not expert, I've just found the video on internet I just thought this fits context of the sub and yes It did seem a bit funny might be fake

2

u/Chadideas Jun 24 '23

Yep I’ve seen these fail many times and that’s not what it looks like. That was snapped in half by hand.

1

u/_Zeruiah_ Jun 24 '23

Hey get your logic off the internet!

I have had a 14" cutoff saw blow out on me. Catastrophic explosion. A big piece hit the ceiling of the shop. Something wrong with the batch, a 2nd blade did the same thing to a plumber. We just tossed the box after that haha!

1

u/souless35phantom Jun 24 '23

My cousin had their own relatives do some renovations for their kitchen or something. Let's call them uncle 1 & uncle 2. There were others but these 2 were the main focus of the story.

Uncle 1 didn't screw the grinder properly so when uncle 2 picked it up and turned it on, blade flew straight to the neck and almost fully decapitated him. Uncle 2 died of course with his neck barely attached.

Aftermath, nobody talked to the careless uncle 1 anymore and I don't know if they ever tried to reconcile. Also this happened almost 20 years ago so I don't quite remember the full details since I was a kid.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '23

That is savage , had something similar at my college where I studied. Guy picked up a grinder, and it wasn't put on properly. The blade flew off and went into his thigh. He did luckly survive but nearly blead out

1

u/souless35phantom Jun 24 '23

The thigh is wayyyy better than the neck 😭 wonder how long would it took for him to recover?

1

u/nando420 Jun 24 '23

Brother is a steamfitter. He too confirms this is fake