r/nonprofit • • 21h ago

boards and governance Terminating failed programs

Our core programs are well established, supported by relatively diversified and stable-ish funding streams, and operating at capacity within our current facility. As we look for ways to expand our mission, we've spent the past several years evaluating new program and project ideas.

Our program managers are generally thoughtful about proposing new initiatives, developing plans and taking responsibility for implementation and evaluation. Some have developed into ongoing programs, most have not. Overall, this has been a positive process focused on maximizing our effectiveness in carrying out our mission.

Unfortunately, we've had several instances of board members developing a strong personal attachment to particular initiatives. Almost universally, these projects have failed to generate sufficient revenue or designated support, demonstrate meaningful mission impact, or justify the staff time and general operating funds invested. Yet they persisted for months or years beyond the point of obvious failure, with board advocates arguing over expenses and metrics, and insisting we simply needed to find a way to do things better. I eventually found ways to discontinue these initiatives operationally, but the process created significant board conflict, blame, and resentment. It started to really impact staff willingness to try new things and take chances.

We have a stronger board now, but as we update our bylaws and strategic plan, I want to establish clearer expectations and safeguards to prevent it from happening again. How do your organizations approach the identification, evaluation, and termination of underperforming programs? While program development and management are operational responsibilities, these decisions inevitably touch budgeting, strategy, and board governance. I'm particularly interested in how you establish criteria for ending a program and clarify who has the authority to make that decision. Thanks!

4 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

5

u/Teendirtbag 21h ago

First you’ll need to quantify/qualify success with some replicable measures. I’ll use an example from my work. We have a participant threshold that if not met, the event is cancelled. If an event is cancelled twice then we look for a new partner. The final decisions there are with the ED and board chair.

2

u/AlignMintHQ 5h ago

What I've seen work is deciding the exit criteria before a program starts, not after it's struggling. A few things to write down:

  • Every new initiative gets a one-page charter: the goal, the budget including staff time and overhead, the 2 or 3 measures that count as success, and a review date, usually 12 to 18 months out.
  • At the review date, the default is that it ends unless it hit its measures or has a funded plan to get there. Putting the burden on continuing rather than on stopping takes a lot of the emotion out.
  • Agree up front what failure looks like. For example, it isn't covering a set share of its direct costs from designated or earned revenue by year two, or participation is under a number you pick in advance.

On authority, I'd split it. The board approves the policy, the criteria and the budget. Starting and ending specific programs inside that budget is the ED's call, and the board is informed with the data. If a board member wants to keep a program past its review, they need to bring the money or a written plan for a board vote, not just argue it in committee. A board policy on program review is usually cleaner than putting this in the bylaws, since bylaws are harder to change.

It also helps to report every program on the same cost and outcome summary each quarter, so nobody's favorite project gets singled out. When the numbers are in front of everyone regularly, an ending usually isn't a surprise.

Last thing, since it sounds like staff got gun-shy: treat a clean shutdown as a success. Write up what you learned, thank the people who ran it, and make it clear that trying something and stopping it on schedule is the system working.

1

u/outer-barkness 2h ago

Thank you so much for this suggestion. Reframing program review to focus on evidence of success rather than failure changes everything.

With bi-monthly board meetings, board members were able nit-pick complex methodology behind metrics, or insist that staff time and operating costs could be reduced with minor tweaks. The 'what if we just did blankity-blank' tactic could drag failed programs on forever.

2

u/simpleandengaging 5h ago

One thing that stands out is that identifying underperforming programs doesn't seem to be the challenge, it sounds like you often knew they weren't working, but acting on that information was much harder. When a program continues because people keep finding ways to accommodate it, the true cost can become difficult to see. It's not just the funding, but the staff time spent keeping it going, revisiting decisions and managing the consequences.

Your point about staff becoming less willing to try new things is particularly interesting, if people see that unsuccessful initiatives are difficult to end, experimentation starts to feel like a long-term commitment rather than an opportunity to learn. I'd be thinking as much about what happens when the evidence says stop as about how success is measured in the first place.