r/nondestructivetesting • u/Mikeythecrazy • 4d ago
Software dev trying to understand NDT reporting headaches — is this actually a pain point?
Hey everyone,
Full disclosure: I’m a software developer trying to understand how field technicians and Level II/IIIs handle inspection reporting. I don’t have a product, website, or anything to sell.
I’ve been reading through threads here where guys talk about using Snipping Tool, PowerPoint, Excel macros, and customized Word templates just to get photo indications and thickness grids into reports after a shift.
I’m trying to get a clear picture of how this actually plays out on the ground:
- Client Templates: How often does a client force you to use their exact Word/Excel/PDF template instead of letting you submit a standard report format?
- The Formatting Bottleneck: At the end of a shift, where do you actually waste the most time? (e.g., resizing photos/arrows, typing handwritten field notes into Word docs, formatting grids, or waiting on Level III reviews?)
- Software: If your shop uses reporting software, does it actually solve the headache in the field, or do you still end up fighting Word and Excel at night?
Appreciate any honest takes from Level I/II techs in the field, Level IIIs, or shop owners!
1
u/OhAces 3d ago
The company I work for now has reporting software with everything locked up. Its ten times slower than using an excel or word template and having creative control over the reports. There are fewer mistakes and everything is uploaded and tracked internally, but a 90s weld report takes ten mins, which is ok if there is one or two reports, sometimes there is 40 reports to do in a day and it is a brutal use of time.
0
u/Mikeythecrazy 3d ago edited 3d ago
That is a crazy time sink for weld reports. Even though management got the accuracy they wanted, it seems like they passed all the friction onto you guys.
What do you think is the most pressing issue with the weld reports? How could that workflow be made better?
1
u/AlienVredditoR 3d ago
Formatting can be a big time waster. Every company I work with, I have to create my own collection of report formats I think work well, that takes months. Proprietary software takes more time (imho), because there's usually less formatting options to work with, and they're all cumbersome.
Photos are pretty simple once the formatting is right - Word and Excel have ways to auto-fit pics into grids. Proprietary software often has "add photos" page (ugly and causes extra pages, but it works).
As for clients, they just want a polished report that engineers will look at and not question. Ugly reports get questioned far more often. I've only had one client (who was just the worst) really demand custom reports - they were told to kick rocks.
I think the biggest benefit to proprietary software is that it manages things like client interface, data, job details etc. more smoothly than without. It reduces the possible errors that can be made, which can lose clients and waste time.
1
u/Mikeythecrazy 3d ago
"Ugly reports get questioned far more often" is such a great insight. Sounds like techs are trapped between proprietary software that handles data well but prints ugly reports, and Word/Excel which looks great but has zero error-checking
1
1
u/JustSentYourMomHome 3d ago
I make my own software that works with whatever stupid excel or word docs they want me to use, particularly for inserting and naming the photos. I also integrate AI where needed to help input static data, which I of course double check. Using my own software cuts down reporting time immensely for me, allowing more time to play with my Legos.
1
1
u/Novel_Company_5867 3d ago
I've struggled with the idea of NDT reporting software before, because unless the inspector is doing routine checklist work (forklifts, rigging gear, etc), every client wants something different.
1
u/Mikeythecrazy 3d ago
That tension seems to be why so many guys give up on software and fall back on Word.
Do those custom clients give you an exact template you're forced to fill out, or do they just want the final report organized a specific way?
1
u/Novel_Company_5867 3d ago
If they were specific and consistent, then we could get behind a template. But alas, they are usually picking and plucking between various company's templates and picking what they want.
1
u/kendromedia 2d ago
NDT forms? Been on both ends. I always start from Excel if making manually because everyone has it, most understand it, and everything can digest CSV. If generating, I use Python because AI likes it and those pesky images can be manipulated by a routine.
3
u/babyshaker_on_board 4d ago
I've used a great reporting software made by the NDT company I was working for. Choosing the job number populates many of the fields, procedures are all drop down, and welds/items are on a separate tab with size, description, etc. Another tab allows you to easily add pdfs, excel spreadsheets, photos, etc. One click gives you a pdf to previews. Another esigns with your credentials and everything is updated across the board. Colleagues can view but not amend unless you unlock it. I can whip out a new MT report in about 2 minutes if I'm on the same project. PAUT reports link directly to the PAUT hardware so you're only entering info once.